Convicted
The Trial of Kouri Richins
Resolved
Guilty — All Counts 📍 Kamas, Utah
Verdict
Guilty
All counts
Timeline
839
Events tracked
People
79
Identified
Evidence
489
Items catalogued
Get Involved
Summary
Kouri Richins, a 35-year-old Utah real estate investor and self-published children's book author, is on trial in Summit County's Third District Court in Park City, Utah, charged with the aggravated murder of her husband, Eric Richins, 39, on March 4, 2022. Prosecutors allege she fatally poisoned him by lacing a Moscow mule cocktail with fentanyl, resulting in approximately five times the lethal dose of the opioid in his system. She has pleaded not guilty to all charges, which include aggravated murder, attempted aggravated murder, two counts of insurance fraud, and forgery.
According to prosecutors, Kouri had powerful financial and romantic motives. They allege she was approximately $4.5 million in debt from her struggling real estate business, held nearly $2 million in life insurance policies on Eric that she allegedly obtained without his knowledge, and believed she would inherit his estate — valued at more than $4 million. She was also allegedly having a romantic affair with a man identified as Robert Josh Grossman. Prosecutors presented text messages in which Kouri wrote to Grossman that she wished her husband would 'just go away' so their life could be 'perfect,' and sent a Caribbean resort link just 16 days after Eric's death. Phone records also showed internet searches for 'women Utah prison,' 'luxury prisons for the rich in America,' and 'what is a lethal dose of fentanyl,' which prosecutors argue demonstrate consciousness of guilt.
A separate alleged poisoning attempt on Valentine's Day 2022 is also charged. Prosecutors claim Kouri laced a sandwich she gave Eric with fentanyl; he reportedly broke out in hives, blacked out, used his son's EpiPen, and later told a friend 'I think my wife tried to poison me.' The defense characterizes this incident as an allergic reaction.
The prosecution's star witness is Carmen Lauber, 54, the family's former housekeeper. Lauber testified under four grants of immunity that she purchased drugs for Kouri on four occasions in early 2022 — starting with opioid pain pills, then escalating to fentanyl after Kouri requested something stronger for an alleged 'investor.' On the third purchase, Lauber testified Kouri asked for 'the Michael Jackson stuff,' a reference to propofol (the drug that caused Michael Jackson's death), though the drugs actually obtained were fentanyl pills. Three days after Eric's death, Kouri texted Lauber asking if she 'still had her hookup,' and a fourth drug purchase followed. A $1,300 check from Kouri's realty company with the memo 'construction clean Midway' was presented as payment for that purchase. Lauber testified she never cleaned a house for that amount.
The defense has vigorously challenged Lauber's credibility, playing recordings of investigators telling the jailed Lauber they needed 'details that will ensure Kouri gets convicted of murder' and presenting transcripts of seven jail interviews in which her account contained numerous inconsistencies. Attorney Wendy Lewis also highlighted that the man Lauber allegedly bought drugs from, Robert Crozier, recanted his story before trial and said he only sold her OxyContin, not fentanyl. Additionally, no fentanyl was ever found in the Richins home — 19 items were tested and all came back negative — and the Moscow mule cups from the night of Eric's death were never tested, having been placed in the dishwasher by a nanny the next morning.
Defense attorney Kathy Nester argues Eric Richins suffered from chronic pain, Lyme disease, and used substances including marijuana gummies and hydrocodone, suggesting he may have obtained and accidentally overdosed on fentanyl independently — noting he had recently traveled to Mexico. The defense maintains there is no direct evidence of how fentanyl entered Eric's body and that the circumstantial case falls short of the required burden of proof beyond a reasonable doubt. The manner of Eric's death remains officially 'undetermined' on his death certificate.
The trial began February 23, 2026 and is expected to conclude March 27, 2026. Kouri Richins has been held in the Summit County Jail without bail since her arrest on May 8, 2023. If convicted of aggravated murder, she faces 25 years to life in prison.
Key Developments
Latest Development
🆕 VERDICT: GUILTY ON ALL 5 COUNTS — Monday, March 16, 2026
🆕 KOURI RICHINS CONVICTED OF AGGRAVATED MURDER, ATTEMPTED AGGRAVATED MURDER, TWO COUNTS OF INSURANCE FRAUD, AND FORGERY.
• Jury deliberated approximately 3 hours before returning unanimous verdict
• Richins stared at the floor and took deep breaths as verdict was read; visibly trembling before jury entered
• Sentencing: MAY 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. — what would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday
• She faces 25 years to life in prison (aggravated murder alone)
• Defense attorneys left courthouse without commenting
• Relatives of Kouri Richins left without speaking to media
🆕 AMY RICHINS (Eric's sister) outside courthouse:
'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.'
🆕 JUROR FOREPERSON 'LAURA' (Juror No. 2) — ABC GMA exclusive interview:
• 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing'
• Cellphone data 'blew her out of the water'
• Kouri appeared 'like a statue' throughout trial
• Book revelation: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this?'
• 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty... it was really heartbreaking'
• 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom'
🆕 JUROR No. 3 'CHRISTIE' — EastIdahoNews exclusive interview:
• Knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before selection
• Most powerful testimony: undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell)
• 'Utter shock' when defense rested without calling witnesses
• 'I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything'
🆕 FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION (Day 15) — DENIED:
• Defense (Nester) argued Bloodworth 'dehumanized' Kouri with 'black widow' reference and improperly commented on demeanor
• Judge Mrazik denied; said 'black widow' refers to woman killing husband (not an insect); issued special instruction that jurors rely on their own observations
🆕 CLOSING ARGUMENT HIGHLIGHTS:
PROSECUTION (Bloodworth, ~2 hours):
• 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money'
• Argued October 2021 was 'beginning of the downward financial death spiral'
• NEW THEORY: Both Moscow mule AND lemon drop shot may have been used to deliver fentanyl: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.'
• Booked Caribbean trip in December 2021 'knowing [Eric] would not' be alive in April
• 911 call: 'Not the sound of a wife becoming a widow — it's the sound of a wife becoming a black widow'
• 6 minutes from dispatcher instruction to CPR attempt
• Called her 'intensely ambitious' but 'incompetent' businesswoman who projected affluence
• 'Do not let her get away with murder'
DEFENSE (Lewis):
• Investigation 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias'
• 'No evidence' fentanyl was put in Eric's drink; prosecution 'waited until closing to tell you that without any evidence'
• Attacked Lauber: investigators 'put the word fentanyl in her mouth'
• 'There is no wrong way to grieve'
• 'Eric was worth so much more to Kouri alive'
PROSECUTION REBUTTAL (Bloodworth):
• 'Circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence'
• 'There is no other rational explanation'
• 'Despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric'
═══════════════════════════════════════
WHAT'S NEXT
🔴 SENTENCING: May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. (Eric's 44th birthday)
• Pre-sentence investigation report ordered
• Victim impact statements from Eric's family
• Judge Mrazik will determine: life without parole OR sentence with possibility of parole
• Kouri may speak at sentencing (analysts say unlikely)
• After sentencing: transfer from Summit County Jail to Utah State Prison
⚠️ APPEALS PROCESS:
• Defense expected to begin appeal after sentencing
• Preparation can take up to a year
• Potential argument: venue (denied change of venue motions)
• Case likely to go to Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals
• Utah AG's Office will respond
⚠️ SEPARATE CASE: 26-count financial crimes case (filed June 27, 2025) — unclear if prosecutors will pursue
⚠️ CIVIL COURT: Eric's family pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute' (prohibits inheriting property from person one killed)
⚠️ LISA DARDEN: Defense had filed sealed motions seeking court-appointed counsel for Darden prior to trial; those remain sealed
⚠️ SLAYER STATUTE: Family pursuing civil claims against Kouri
📺 MEDIA: 'IMPACT x Nightline: Love, Money & Murder' streaming Disney+/Hulu (March 19); '20/20: Murder She Wrote' aired ABC March 20
Evidence & Forensics
Toxicology report — fentanyl level
15 nanograms/mL of fentanyl found in Eric Richins' blood; lethal threshold is approximately 3 nanograms/mL, making this approximately five times a lethal dose. Acetylfentanyl (indicating illicit, not pharmaceutical source) and norfentanyl also found in gastric fluid. Small amounts of ethanol and quetiapine also detected.
911 call recording
Kouri Richins called 911 at 3:21 a.m. on March 4, 2022. Recording played for jury. She was heard crying, saying her husband was not breathing. Prosecutors argued she delayed calling 911 for approximately 15-20 minutes after first accessing her phone at 3:06 a.m.
Text messages — Kouri and boyfriend Robert Josh Grossman
Prosecutors presented text messages including: 'If he could just go away ... life would be so perfect' (February 2022); 'If I was divorced right now and asked you to marry me tomorrow, you would?' (day before Eric's death); a Caribbean resort link with 'Are we there yet?' (16 days after death); 'I think I want you to be my husband one day' (approximately one month after death). Text messages from the two months leading up to Eric's death through two weeks after were deleted.
Internet search history
Searches recovered from Kouri's phone included: 'women Utah prison,' 'luxury prisons for the rich in America,' 'Can cops force you to do a lie detector test?,' 'If someone is poisoned what does it go down on the death certificate as,' 'Can cops uncover deleted messages iPhone?,' 'how long does life insurance companies take to pay,' and 'what is a lethal dose of fentanyl.' Also recovered: three money-themed memes accessed the morning Eric died, including one reading 'I'm rich!'
$1,300 check from K. Richins Realty to Carmen Lauber
Check dated March 6, 2022 (deposited March 9, 2022), memo line reads 'construction clean Midway.' Lauber testified she never cleaned a house for $1,300 and did not perform any such work. Prosecutors allege this was payment for a fourth drug purchase made after Eric's death.
Community service letters
Two letters written by Kouri Richins stating Carmen Lauber had volunteered at a horse rescue cleaning stalls. Lauber testified the community service described in the letters never actually occurred, and the letters were submitted to drug court.
Life insurance policies
Multiple life insurance policies totaling nearly $2 million taken out by Kouri on Eric's life. Prosecutors allege Eric did not know about them. Court documents state Kouri forged Eric's signature on at least one policy application. Eric had reportedly changed the beneficiary of his own $500,000 policy back to his business partner before his death.
Autopsy report
Performed by Dr. Pamela Ulmer on March 5, 2022. Found no natural cause of death. Fentanyl level described as toxic and fatal. Ribs fractured from CPR. Beginning stages of coronary artery disease (not significant). White lung nodules attributed to stone masonry work. No signs of allergic reaction. Manner of death listed as 'undetermined.' Cause of death: drug intoxication from fentanyl.
Carmen Lauber testimony and immunity grants
Lauber testified she purchased drugs for Kouri four times. She is testifying under four grants of immunity (Summit County, Wasatch County, Salt Lake County, federal). Defense presented transcripts of seven jail interviews from April-May 2023 and video of investigators telling Lauber they needed 'details that will ensure Kouri gets convicted of murder.'
THC gummies found in home
Multiple bags of THC gummies recovered from the Richins home in subsequent searches (not found during the initial March 4 search). Found in closets and jacket pockets in locations out of reach of children. Defense argues this corroborates Eric's use of THC for pain management.
Hydrocodone pills and empty pill bottle
Approximately 10 hydrocodone pills found in a laundry room cabinet during a later search. An empty hydrocodone bottle with a 2016 expiration date was found on/near Eric's nightstand. Defense raised the possibility the bottle could have contained illicit drugs. The empty bottle was never tested for fentanyl residue.
Quetiapine pills
Quetiapine (generic Seroquel) was prescribed to Kouri Richins but found in Eric's toxicology results at a sub-therapeutic level. Two pills that had been cut in half were found in the home.
Letter found at foot of bed
A letter was found at the foot of the bed on November 7, 2024, during a search prompted by a private investigator's tip. The letter was not present in the first seven searches of the home. Defense noted it appeared after a private investigator was involved. Defense attorney questioned whether it had been planted.
Hidden letter from jail cell
A six-page letter found hidden in a book in Kouri's Summit County jail cell, written to her mother. In it, Richins referred to Eric's death as an 'accidental overdose.' Prosecutors say the letter was an attempt to coach her brother to 'testify falsely' by suggesting Eric purchased drugs from Mexico.
Fentanyl testing of 19 home items
Brian Holden, forensic scientist at Utah State Crime Lab, tested 19 items submitted from the Richins home. Found no fentanyl on any of them. Did not test the empty hydrocodone bottle as it was not submitted to him.
Two iPhones from Robert Josh Grossman
Detective Frank Root collected two iPhones from Grossman. Both were inoperable at the time of collection; Grossman claimed he broke them by accident. Phones were later made operable. Data extracted by FBI digital analyst Cheney Eng-Tow.
Cock n' Bull ginger beer bottle
An empty Cock n' Bull ginger beer bottle (an ingredient used to make Moscow mules) was found in the kitchen trash at the Richins home. Kouri told police she made Eric a Moscow mule the night he died. Cups in the sink were never tested; a nanny put them in the dishwasher the next morning.
Body camera footage — Deputy Nguyen
Showed Kouri Richins in pajamas at the home, crying and rocking back and forth, head in hands. Played for jury. Kouri told Nguyen the couple had a drink together around 9 p.m. to celebrate a work milestone before Eric's death.
Prenuptial agreement
Prosecutors allege a prenuptial agreement meant Kouri would receive little in a divorce, providing financial motive for murder. Kouri allegedly mistakenly believed she would inherit Eric's full estate under the prenup terms if he died.
Financial records and debt
Kouri owed lenders more than $1.8 million (some sources cite $4.5 million total debt to 20+ lenders) at time of Eric's death. Had more than 200 overdraft transactions totaling $300,000+ in months before Eric's death. Was being sued by a creditor. Had a negative bank account balance.
Facebook Messenger message — Carmen to drug contact
Message sent Feb. 5, 2022 from Lauber to a Facebook contact reading 'Text me. I've got a question I can't say on here' — presented as evidence of the chain of events leading to the fentanyl purchase.
Selfie photos — Carmen Lauber and Nancy Peterson
Photos taken on the drive to meet drug dealer Robert Crozier at the Maverik gas station in Draper, Utah. Admitted into evidence as corroboration of Lauber's account.
Text message — Kouri to Lauber, 'Still have your hook up?' (March 6-7, 2022)
Text exchange between Kouri Richins and Carmen Lauber on March 6–7, 2022 — two to three days after Eric's death — in which Kouri asked if Lauber still had a drug 'hook up.' Lauber replied yes but expressed surprise, saying Kouri had enough to worry about. Admitted into evidence at trial. Combined with the $1,300 check, prosecutors argue this shows Kouri was seeking more drugs immediately after Eric's death.
Recorded jail interview — investigators tell Lauber to provide 'details that will ensure Kouri gets convicted of murder'
Audio recording played for jury on Day 5 of a conversation between two Summit County investigators and Carmen Lauber shortly after her April 2023 arrest. In the recording, one investigator tells Lauber she could face seven years in prison for drug charges, and the other says: 'Give us the details that will ensure Kouri gets convicted of murder.' Defense used the recording to argue investigators shaped Lauber's testimony. Prosecutor Bloodworth acknowledged the language but argued it didn't mean Lauber was coached to lie.
Hayden Jeffs text messages re: Kouri asking for fentanyl and propofol
Before his 2024 death, handyman Hayden Jeffs showed investigators text messages allegedly corroborating his claim that Kouri Richins asked him for fentanyl and propofol weeks before Eric's death. Jeffs provided copies to investigators. His phone was seized by Heber City Police for the investigation. Jeffs died before trial; his girlfriend Anna Isbell testified in his place about a related phone call on Jan. 22, 2022.
Lauber drug test results — methamphetamine positives during drug-buy period
Under cross-examination by Wendy Lewis on Day 5, Carmen Lauber confirmed she tested positive for methamphetamine in late January, mid-February, and early March 2022 — the precise period during which she was allegedly purchasing drugs for Kouri Richins. Defense used this to further challenge her reliability as a witness.
Kouri's statement to Lauber — 'Eric died of a brain aneurysm'
Carmen Lauber testified that when she called Kouri shortly after Eric's death and said 'Please tell me those pills were not for him,' Kouri responded: 'No, they were not — Eric passed away from a brain aneurysm.' This directly contradicts Kouri's other statements about Eric's cause of death and is consistent with Gene Richins' Day 1 testimony that Kouri told him the medical examiner said Eric died of a fungal lung infection.
Lauber's text messages confirming Kouri approved fentanyl purchase
Carmen Lauber testified on Day 4 that when she texted Kouri that her source could get fentanyl pills, Kouri replied 'OK, go ahead and get them.' This text exchange — in which Kouri explicitly approved a fentanyl purchase — was presented by prosecution as direct evidence of knowing drug procurement. Lauber stood by this account under cross-examination, though she admitted she did not personally know what type of pills she actually received.
Crozier testimony — no fentanyl access until late 2022
Robert Crozier testified under immunity on Day 5 that he did not have access to fentanyl in January, February, or March 2022, and did not begin selling fentanyl until late 2022. He said he was connected to Carmen Lauber through Nicole Cummings (a woman he lived with), and that Lauber asked him for 'Roxys' — which he understood to mean oxycodone. He confirmed he met Lauber at a Maverik in Draper and believes he met her twice.
Four iPhones — Garaycochea phone extractions
Marcos Garaycochea of the Salt Lake County DA's Special Investigations Unit testified he performed forensic downloads on four iPhones at the request of the Summit County Sheriff's Office. One phone required a cracked screen replacement before data could be extracted. Data extracted using a forensic tool that cannot modify or delete existing data.
Defense theory — Eric's Mexico trip as fentanyl source
In opening statements, defense attorney Kathy Nester argued that Eric Richins had recently returned from a trip to Mexico before his death, suffering from chronic back and knee pain and Lyme disease. Nester told jurors: 'Guess where the fentanyl comes into this country from — Mexico.' Defense theory is that Eric may have independently obtained fentanyl during or after that trip, and that the pills Lauber purchased for Kouri were oxycodone (purchased at Eric's request), not fentanyl — consistent with the absence of oxycodone in Eric's toxicology. Defense also did not contest Kouri signed a $100,000 life insurance policy.
Prosecution opening — Caribbean trip booking and 'How did that make you feel?' exchange
Prosecutor Bloodworth revealed in opening statements that Kouri had booked an all-inclusive Caribbean resort trip for herself and Robert Josh Grossman, with a check-in date approximately one month after Eric's death. Additionally, within days of Eric's death, Kouri drove to the mountains with Grossman and, after he said he had killed someone, asked him: 'How did that make you feel?' Prosecutors argued this reflected guilt after Eric's death.
Crozier testimony — met Lauber once or twice, not three times; specific reason pills were not fentanyl
Robert Crozier testified under immunity on Day 5 that he met Carmen Lauber at the Maverik in Draper only once or twice — contradicting Lauber's testimony that he met her three times. He said he knew the pills he sold were not fentanyl because in early 2022 'everybody was scared of fentanyl — it was hard to get and people were dying.' He said the pills were made to look like oxycodone. Crozier's testimony directly conflicts with Lauber's account of the number of meetings.
Lauber post-testimony status — not drug tested, allowed to move to Las Vegas, served 23 days in jail
Under cross-examination by Wendy Lewis on Day 5, Carmen Lauber confirmed she is not currently being drug tested and is waiting to see what happens following her testimony before any immunity conditions are finalized. She was allowed to move to Las Vegas (though she still lives in Utah). She served only 23 days in jail following her April 2023 arrest. Prosecutors noted she has been sober since that arrest.
Lauber redirect — memory improvement after sobriety; detectives stressed corroboration requirement
During prosecutor Bloodworth's redirect examination on Day 5/6, Lauber testified her memory became clearer after she stopped using drugs and had a chance to review materials like phone records. Bloodworth emphasized Lauber was an 'addict' who was 'behaving like an addict — using drugs and lying about it' until her April 2023 arrest. Lauber also admitted detectives stressed that they would need to corroborate information she gave them.
Safe containing firearms, ammunition, and cash — Richins home
CSI technician Chelsea Gipson testified during her Day 2–3 testimony that a safe was found in the Richins home containing firearms, ammunition, and a large amount of cash. The safe's contents were documented as part of the evidence collection from the home.
Orange notebook — collected from master bedroom May 8, 2023
An orange notebook described as Kouri Richins' firsthand account of the night Eric died was collected from the master bedroom during the May 8, 2023 search (the day of Kouri's arrest), along with a blue iPhone. The admissibility of the orange notebook was a subject of a pre-trial ruling. Its ultimate admissibility at trial is still to be resolved; prosecutors must meet an admissibility threshold for it to be shown to the jury.
Kouri's voluntary written statement to Deputy Nguyen — night of March 4, 2022
A voluntary witness statement filled out by Kouri Richins the night Eric died was presented to the court during Day 2 testimony. The statement was submitted voluntarily to Deputy Nguyen on the scene. Body camera footage also captured Kouri explaining Eric's medical history to first responders as they attempted to revive him, and telling Nguyen that Eric took THC gummies that evening.
3D scan of the Richins home — collected May 8, 2023
CSI technician Chelsea Gipson testified that a 3D scan of the Richins home was collected on May 8, 2023. The scan was presented to the court during trial testimony, showing the layout of the bedrooms and other rooms in the residence.
Medical examiner finding — fentanyl orally ingested
Dr. Pamela Ulmer's autopsy conclusion (per court documents and trial testimony) states that the fentanyl in Eric Richins' system was orally ingested — consistent with the prosecution's theory that it was placed in a drink. This finding was referenced in opening statements and is a key element of the prosecution's narrative connecting the fentanyl to the Moscow mule.
Green jacket with THC gummies — Richins home closet
A green jacket was found in the southeast corner of a closet at the Richins home during a post-arrest search, with THC gummies in a pocket. This is separate from the black Under Armour jacket collected during the November 2024 search. CSI technician Chelsea Gipson testified about this item on Day 4.
Eric Richins prescription history and substance use — defense cross-examination
During cross-examination of Katie Richins-Benson (Day 1-2), defense attorney Nester elicited that Eric had been previously prescribed hydrocodone, used THC occasionally, drank alcohol socially, and took testosterone. Defense used this to build the narrative that Eric had prior exposure to opioids and could have self-administered fentanyl.
Cody Wright hard drive — collected by investigators
A hard drive belonging to Cody Wright, Eric Richins' business partner at C&E Stone Masonry, was retrieved by investigators and turned over to CSI technician Chelsea Gipson. Gipson confirmed this on Day 4. The contents of the hard drive and whether it will be presented as evidence at trial have not been publicly disclosed.
Valentine's Day sandwich in Eric's truck — prosecution detail
Prosecutors alleged at trial that on Valentine's Day 2022, Kouri placed the allegedly fentanyl-laced sandwich in Eric's truck along with a Valentine's Day note, framing it as a gift. Eric ate one bite, fell ill (breaking out in hives, blacking out), and told a friend he believed his wife tried to poison him. This delivery method detail — the truck and the note — was presented at trial.
U.S. Postal Service agent — May 8, 2023 search participant
A U.S. Postal Service agent was among the law enforcement personnel involved in the May 8, 2023 search of the Richins home (the day of Kouri's arrest). The agent was investigating whether drugs or drug paraphernalia could have been mailed to the Richins residence. This was referenced in Park Record coverage of Day 3 testimony.
Kouri challenged Eric's living trust after his death
During cross-examination of Katie Richins-Benson (Day 1-2), defense attorney Nester elicited that Kouri Richins sued to challenge the living trust Eric had set up (which named Katie as trustee) after his death. This was acknowledged by Katie during cross-examination. The outcome of that legal challenge was not detailed in trial testimony reported publicly.
Pre-trial ruling — expert witness admissibility (Amman, Throckmorton, Vanino)
At a Feb. 1, 2026 pre-trial evidentiary hearing, Judge Mrazik ruled: (1) Molly Amman (FBI profiler/behavioral threat assessment) — partially admitted; may not testify as to guilt or rebut case-specific assertions, but qualified as blind expert on retrospective studies; (2) Matt Throckmorton (handwriting analysis) — fully admitted; concluded there is a strong probability Eric's signature on an insurance document was forged by Kouri; (3) Dr. Sheri Vanino (domestic violence expert) — conditionally excluded; may be admitted if prosecution can establish a foundation that Eric knew Kouri tried to hurt him on Feb. 14, 2022. Defense expert Dr. Bryanna Fox argued the 'pathway to violence' model is not a valid post-offense assessment tool.
Eric Richins estate valuation — prosecution opening statement
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated in opening arguments that Eric Richins' estate was worth over $4 million when he died, and that Kouri believed (per prosecution theory) she would inherit the full amount because the prenuptial agreement would block her in a divorce, but not if Eric died while they were married. Bloodworth also stated Kouri owed more than $4.5 million to over 20 different lenders on the day Eric died.
Lauber deleted drug-purchase texts to avoid drug court violation
Carmen Lauber testified on Day 4 that after each of her drug purchases on behalf of Kouri Richins, she deleted the text messages with her drug source so as not to create evidence that she violated drug court rules. She was in drug court in Wasatch County at the time of the purchases.
K9 officer testimony — gummies not found during drug-sniff search
A K9 officer testified during Week 1 that he did not find THC gummies at the Richins home during his drug-detection search, despite his training. Defense attorney Nester argued the gummies were stored in places out of reach of children, explaining why the dog may have missed them. THC gummies were subsequently found in later searches.
Handwriting expert Throckmorton — strong probability of forged insurance signature
Per the Feb. 1, 2026 pre-trial ruling, Matt Throckmorton (prosecution handwriting expert) concluded there is a strong probability that Eric Richins' signature on at least one insurance document was not authorized by Eric and was forged by Kouri Richins. His testimony was fully admitted over defense objection. This is directly relevant to the insurance fraud and forgery counts.
Three money-themed animated GIFs accessed on Kouri's phone morning of March 4, 2022
Prosecutor Bloodworth revealed in opening statements that after first responders left the Richins home the morning of Eric's death, Kouri accessed three animated GIFs on her phone. The GIFs included: (1) a caption reading 'Idiots. Idiots everywhere'; (2) a woman wiping away her tears with dollar bills; and (3) a caption reading 'I'm really rich.' Previously described in case records as 'money-themed memes' — multiple trial sources confirm these were animated GIFs. Presented by prosecution as evidence of Kouri's state of mind immediately after Eric's death.
Detective O'Driscoll 'catch pole' text to witness — full content confirmed
KSL obtained and published the full text of lead detective Jeff O'Driscoll's message to witness Anna Isbell (referred to as 'W1' in defense filings): 'You have received a subpoena to appear at the court as a witness. If you fail to do so, the judge will issue a warrant for your arrest. You will then have to sit in a holding cell until you are needed to testify. So make your life easier and answer our calls so we can prep you on what you will be asked. Otherwise, the next time I knock on your door, I'll have a warrant and a catch pole for the dog.' O'Driscoll also told her to appear at court every day of the trial rather than providing a specific date. The defense used this exchange at trial as evidence of witness intimidation.
Walk the Dog letter — full content and recipient details
The six-page handwritten letter found hidden in a book (an LSAT prep test book) in Kouri's jail cell is titled 'Walk the Dog!!' It was addressed to her mother Lisa Darden but never mailed. The letter instructs Darden to ask Kouri's brother Ronald Darden to testify that Eric told him he was getting drugs and pills from Mexico, and adds: 'The connection has to be made with Mexico and drugs.' It also contains the line: 'He always wanted Kouri to go down for him.' Prosecutors allege this constitutes attempted witness coaching and solicitation of false testimony. The letter was found Sept. 13, 2023, by Summit County Sheriff's Sgt. Jeremy Thomas during a jail cell search.
Carmen Lauber employment connection — worked for Kouri's aunt
Carmen Lauber testified that she worked as a housekeeper for Kouri Richins' aunt, and cleaning Kouri's home was part of that job. She cleaned the Richins home approximately every other Friday and had known Kouri for approximately nine years prior to the events in question.
Kouri Richins assault conviction — May 2024
On May 13, 2024, Kouri Richins was found guilty of assault (class B misdemeanor) after failing to meet the conditions of a plea-in-abeyance agreement within the required time period. The original charge arose from a June 9, 2022 altercation at her home involving her sister-in-law — approximately three months after Eric's death. This conviction is separate from the pending murder charges.
Prosecution affidavits from Bloodworth and Hopper — classified as private
In its Oct. 16, 2025 opposition to the defense's exculpatory evidence motion, the Summit County Attorney's Office filed affidavits from Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth and Chief Investigator Travis Hopper in support of its position that the April 2025 Starbucks meeting with Crozier produced no exculpatory evidence. The prosecution simultaneously filed a proposed order to Judge Mrazik titled 'Order Classifying Documents as Private,' seeking to seal the affidavits from public access. The prosecution's written position stated: 'The State possesses no exculpatory evidence from that meeting to provide to the defense.'
Crozier affidavit — Starbucks meeting and repeated assertion of OxyContin sale
In a signed affidavit filed by the defense in connection with its October 2, 2025 bail reconsideration and exculpatory evidence motion, Robert Crozier stated: he met with who he believed to be lead prosecutor Brad Bloodworth and another man at a Starbucks in downtown Salt Lake City in approximately April 2025; he told them multiple times he was certain he sold Carmen Lauber OxyContin 30 mg pills ('Roxy's or Roxy 30's'), not fentanyl; they asked him several times if he was sure, and each time he said yes. Defense attorneys argued this meeting and Crozier's statement constituted exculpatory evidence the prosecution was required to disclose but withheld.
Lisa Darden 2006 suspicious overdose connection — unsealed search warrant (May 2024)
A search warrant unsealed May 19, 2024 revealed that lead detective Jeff O'Driscoll investigated Kouri Richins' mother, Lisa Darden, in connection with a 2006 death. In April 2006, Darden's female romantic partner died unexpectedly from a drug poisoning overdose of oxycodone. The partner had prescriptions for oxycodone and reportedly struggled with medication abuse, but was 'not in a state of recovery from addiction at the time of her death.' Darden had been named beneficiary of her partner's estate shortly before the death. O'Driscoll wrote that this made an accidental overdose unlikely. Investigators also found conversations on Kouri's phone showing Darden 'expressed disdain' for Eric. The warrant to search Darden's electronic devices was executed May 4, 2023. O'Driscoll wrote: 'Based on Lisa Darden's proximity to her partner's suspicious overdose death... it is possible she was involved in planning and orchestrating Eric's death.' Darden has not been charged with any crime.
Crozier's 2023 sworn statement — read to him, not written by him; later amended
During Day 5 testimony, Robert Crozier stated that he did not write his 2023 sworn statement himself — it was read to him and he signed it. He later amended that statement. In his amended account (and trial testimony), he maintains he sold oxycodone, not fentanyl, to Carmen Lauber. This detail about the statement's origins was confirmed in KPCW live blog coverage of his testimony.
Carmen Lauber asked detectives to write her statement for her signature
During defense cross-examination on Day 5, Carmen Lauber confirmed she told detectives: 'Just write it all down and I'll sign it,' meaning she asked investigators to compose her statement, which she then signed. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis used this exchange to suggest investigators shaped Lauber's narrative. Lauber acknowledged her memory at the time was 'messed up and foggy' due to drug use.
Naltrexone found in Richins home bathroom — among three medications in medical log
Deputy David Pimentel testified that the three medications he found and logged in the Richins home bathroom on March 4, 2022 were naltrexone, hydrocodone, and doxycycline. Naltrexone is a drug used to curb the desire for opioids. Its presence is notable given Eric's alleged undisclosed opiate use. This detail was confirmed by Court TV's Day 2 summary.
Kouri Richins' home — last search was Feb. 9, 2026 (clarification)
CSI technician Chelsea Gipson confirmed during Day 4 cross-examination that the final search of the Richins home prior to trial was conducted on February 9, 2026. The existing record referenced 'Feb. 6, 2026' in some sources; ABC4's Day 4 coverage confirms Feb. 9, 2026 as the correct date. The black Under Armour jacket was collected from a downstairs bedroom closet at that time.
Lauber testified Kouri paid Nick Bonsavage via Venmo for cleaning work
During Carmen Lauber's Day 5 cross-examination, she confirmed that Kouri Richins paid Nick Bonsavage via Venmo for cleaning work at the Midway mansion. Lauber and Bonsavage were paid $25 per hour. This provides additional financial transaction detail linking Kouri to both Lauber and Bonsavage around the time of the drug purchases.
May 4, 2023 video interview of Robert Crozier — says he sold Lauber fentanyl and 'she knew what she was buying'
Body camera footage of a May 4, 2023 interview between Summit County investigators and Robert Crozier was played for jurors on Day 7. In it, Crozier tells investigators he sold Carmen Lauber fentanyl pills and that 'she knew what she was buying.' This directly contradicts Crozier's Day 5 trial testimony that he sold oxycodone and had no fentanyl access until late 2022. Crozier testified at trial he did not remember the May 2023 interview because he was in Davis County Jail detoxing. Judge Mrazik instructed jurors to consider only Crozier's side of the interview conversation.
Recorded phone call — Kouri Richins to Utah Office of the Medical Examiner (Dr. Erik Christensen)
Prosecutors played a recorded phone call in which Kouri Richins called the Utah Office of the Medical Examiner and spoke with then-chief medical examiner Dr. Erik Christensen. In the call, she asked about a report showing additional testing on Eric's stomach contents, asked specifically how much fentanyl was found (Christensen told her 'people die with half that or less in the system'), and asked about quetiapine — which she pronounced multiple ways, though it was a drug prescribed to her and found in Eric's system. Christensen also asked her during the call whether Eric appeared to be abusing fentanyl; she said no. The call was presented by prosecution as evidence of Kouri's knowledge of the toxicology and her focus on incriminating substances.
Phone movement map — Lauber and Crozier converging at Maverik (Draper) on three dates
Digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos presented a map of phone movement data for Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier showing their devices traveling toward and away from the Maverik convenience store in Draper, Utah on three specific dates: February 11, February 26, and March 9, 2022. Each time, Kouri Richins' phone was in frequent communication with Lauber's. Kotrodimos confirmed these were the only three times Lauber's phone appeared at that Maverik location. The data corroborates three drug purchase meetings, consistent with Lauber's testimony (though Lauber testified to four total purchases — the fourth being via a different arrangement). Notably, the dates also correlate with Lauber and Crozier's phone records presented to the jury.
Kouri Richins' replacement phone — iCloud deletion searches and additional internet searches
Digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos testified that Kouri's white iPhone (seized April 13, 2022) had many items deleted from early 2022 through mid-March 2022. A replacement phone she obtained later showed fewer deletions, but jurors were shown multiple searches from it including: how to remotely delete data from an iCloud account or a phone not in one's possession; what police and the FBI do with electronics; prisons; white collar crimes; 'luxury prisons for the rich'; whether life insurance companies pay when a death certificate is still pending; and Kouri Richins' own net worth. These supplement the existing internet search evidence already in the record.
Kouri Valentine's Day text to Grossman — 'I love you Wanna be one of my valentines' / Eric's Valentine's Day text about feeling ill
Digital forensics expert Kotrodimos testified about text messages on Valentine's Day 2022: Kouri texted Robert Josh Grossman 'I love you Wanna be one of my valentines,' indicating she was traveling to him that day — the same day prosecutors allege she attempted to poison Eric. Meanwhile, Eric texted Kouri that he was going to lie down and might need to go to the hospital if he did not get better. These messages were extracted from Kouri's phone data.
Allison Wright testimony — Kouri told her she felt 'trapped' in the marriage (Costa Rica, Feb. 2019)
Allison Wright (wife of business partner Cody Wright) testified she had a conversation with Kouri Richins in Costa Rica in February 2019, in which Kouri said she felt 'trapped' — frustrated in the marriage and unable to leave because the prenuptial agreement meant she would end up financially insecure while Eric would be financially secure. Wright said she observed Kouri's subsequent drive for financial independence as Kouri pursued a master's degree and a real estate license. Under cross-examination, Wright acknowledged Eric may have had intimate feelings for a female coworker around that time.
Molly Crosswhite testimony — Midway home key left outside; tenants did not move in until end of March 2022
Real estate professional Molly Crosswhite testified she purchased the small Midway home from Kouri Richins in January 2022. She confirmed she had not changed the locks on the home, that a key was left outside the property, and that her tenants did not move in until the end of March 2022. Prosecutors allege this home was the dead drop location where Kouri left cash for Lauber and Lauber left pills for Kouri.
Juror familiarity issue — juror recognized witness Molly Crosswhite
During Molly Crosswhite's testimony on Day 7, a seated juror disclosed to the court that they had previously done a business transaction with Crosswhite, apparently not recognizing her during jury selection because she had used a different name at that time. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis moved to dismiss the juror, arguing the juror would not have passed jury selection had this been known. Prosecution opposed the dismissal. Judge Mrazik said he would consider legal standards and precedent before ruling.
Three money-themed GIFs — Donald Trump meme identified
Digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos testified that the three animated GIFs accessed on Kouri Richins' phone around 8:30 a.m. the morning Eric died — right after emergency responders left the home — included one featuring Donald Trump with the caption 'I'm really rich,' one featuring a man captioned 'Idiots, Idiots everywhere,' and one featuring a woman wiping her eyes with money. Previously recorded in the case file as generic 'money-themed memes'; the Trump GIF identity is now specifically confirmed.
Kotrodimos reviewed five phones total — not four
Digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos testified he reviewed data from five phones in connection with the case. Previously, only four phones were referenced in connection with Marcos Garaycochea's forensic downloads; Kotrodimos' own testimony confirms a total of five devices were part of his review.
Jury selection pool — 449 original, ~250 summoned, 40 per day for voir dire
Court records and pre-trial hearing coverage confirm the original jury pool consisted of 449 Summit County residents. Approximately 250 were summoned after the Feb. 2 pre-trial hearing. Approximately 40 prospective jurors were called each day for voir dire, with jury selection beginning Feb. 10 and lasting up to six days. Jurors were asked questions from a court-approved list.
Separate financial crimes case — filed June 2025, specific charge counts
The Summit County Attorney's Office filed a separate felony case against Kouri Richins in June 2025 for financial crimes dating back to June 2021. That case includes: 5 counts of mortgage fraud, 5 counts of forgery, 7 counts of issuing a bad check, 7 counts of money laundering, 1 count of communications fraud, and 1 count of a pattern of unlawful activity. Those charges will be tried separately and are not before this jury.
Molly Crosswhite Midway home key — turned over to contractors, not simply left outside
KPCW's March 3, 2026 report clarifies that when Molly Crosswhite purchased the Midway home from Kouri Richins in January 2022, she turned the key over to contractors in the interim before tenants moved in at the end of March 2022 — rather than merely leaving a key unattended outside. This supplements prior reporting that described the key as 'left outside the property.'
Estate value discrepancy — NY Post cites $3.6 million vs. prosecution's $4 million
The NY Post's February 11, 2026 background article states prosecutors allege the estate was worth $3.6 million, while prosecution's opening statement (per other trial sources) stated the estate was worth over $4 million. The $3.6 million figure is attributed to the NY Post; the $4 million+ figure comes from the prosecution's own opening. The discrepancy may reflect different valuations or reporting periods and has not been resolved at trial.
Three money-themed GIFs — Kevin Spacey identity confirmed; 'orphaned' images from deleted text message
Digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos testified on Day 7 that the GIF previously described as featuring 'a man' with the caption 'Idiots. Idiots everywhere' actually features actor Kevin Spacey. More significantly, Kotrodimos testified that all three GIFs (including the Donald Trump 'I'm really rich' GIF and the woman-with-money GIF) were accessed as part of a text message thread — and that the source of these images was deleted from the phone. He described them as 'ghost' or 'orphaned' images: 'The source of these images was deleted from the phone. It no longer exists on the phone.' It remains unclear who sent or received the text message containing the GIFs.
Granular phone movement data — night of March 3 through 911 call on March 4, 2022
Kotrodimos testified to the following phone activity sequence: (1) Activity on both Kouri's and Eric's phones stopped by approximately 11 p.m. on March 3, 2022. (2) The last recorded activity for Kouri's phone that night was it moving 35 feet. (3) Eric's phone received an unread work text before going inactive — no activity recorded after that. (4) At 3:06 a.m. on March 4, Kouri's phone was unlocked. (5) Fourteen seconds later, the speaker was activated. (6) At 3:08 a.m., the phone moved 243 feet. (7) The phone was then unlocked several more times. (8) Kouri called 911 at 3:21 a.m. Prosecutors may use this data against Kouri's stated account that she had been asleep in her son's room before finding Eric.
Life insurance policy — effective date February 4, 2022; application signed late January 2022
Per the KSL pre-trial timeline, a life insurance policy for Eric Richins went into effect on February 4, 2022. Prosecutors allege Kouri Richins signed the application for this policy in late January 2022 — approximately two to three weeks before the alleged Valentine's Day poisoning attempt on February 14, 2022, and one month before Eric's death on March 4, 2022. This supplements existing evidence about the life insurance policies.
Defense cross-examination — 'white specks' on Eric's nightstand never tested
During Day 2 cross-examination of first responders, defense attorneys noted that 'white specks' visible on Eric Richins' nightstand in body camera footage were never tested by investigators. Defense attorneys pressed responders about whether these specks were examined, consistent with the broader defense argument that investigators failed to consider alternative explanations for Eric's death.
Kouri's bodycam statement — 'chest pain' and 'He was active, he didn't just die in his sleep'
In Deputy Nguyen's body camera footage played for the jury on Day 2, Kouri Richins told Nguyen that Eric had mentioned chest pain before bed. She also stated: 'He was active, he didn't just die in his sleep, this is insane.' She further said that although she was sleeping in another room with their son, she would have heard any yell and that Eric had not made a sound. These statements are part of Kouri's voluntary account to first responders on the night of Eric's death.
Jen Shah — defense alternative explanation for 'luxury prisons' search
During cross-examination of digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos on Day 7, defense attorney Alexander Ramos raised former Real Housewives of Salt Lake City cast member Jen Shah as a contextual explanation for why Kouri might have searched 'luxury prisons for the rich in America' in April 2022. Shah was facing federal fraud charges at that time (she changed her plea to guilty in July 2022 and went to prison). Ramos asked Kotrodimos if he was aware of Shah's high-profile case in Utah around that timeframe — implying Kouri's search may have been curiosity about Shah, not self-interest.
Forensic accountant financial summary — Kouri Richins' financial collapse (Karrington, Day 8)
Brooke Karrington testified that by March 2022, Kouri owed approximately $7.5 million in total debt, was paying $80,000/month to lenders, had four payday lenders she was paying $2,100/day to, had bounced 236 checks ($360,000+, $5,600 in overdraft fees) from January 2021 through March 2022, and had 77 NSF transactions in December 2021 alone. Her accounts were 'perpetually in the hole' by October 2021. Between 2019 and 2021 her business expanded rapidly: 1 property in 2019 ($215,000), 5 in 2020 ($2.2M), 15 in 2021 ($6.7M), and only the $2.9M Midway mansion in 2022. She lost more than $900,000 across properties sold due to contractor costs and fees. Despite claiming 147 employees and $1M+ in profits to investors and lenders, Karrington found no evidence of those earnings. Kouri's net worth after the Midway mansion closing: negative $1.6 million. She received $1.35–1.4M in insurance proceeds after Eric died and spent it all within 3 months. By September 2022, she had approximately $800 remaining.
Buy/sell life insurance policy beneficiary changes — January 1, 2022 (Rodgers/Freckleton, Day 9)
New York Life Insurance senior advisor Lashawnda Rodgers and agent Brian Freckleton testified on Day 9 that on January 1, 2022, the beneficiary on the Wright-Richins buy/sell policy was changed from Eric Richins to Kouri Richins — and then changed back — multiple times within minutes, all via Eric Richins' login but Kouri's email address. Defense cross-examination established no permanent change was ultimately made and that anyone with Eric's credentials could have accessed the account.
Kouri asked Grossman about killing someone in Iraq — confirmed testimony (Day 9)
Robert Josh Grossman confirmed in his Day 9 trial testimony that approximately 10–14 days after Eric's death, he and Kouri drove to the Uinta Mountains. During their conversation, Kouri asked him if he had ever killed anyone while serving in Iraq, and how it had made him feel. Grossman said he did not find the question suspicious at the time — he explained she was 'exhausted emotionally' and may have been switching the topic. He stated he had no inkling before Kouri's arrest that Eric had been intentionally killed.
Kouri Richins texts shown to jury via Grossman testimony — December 2021 'love triangle' and January 2022 drug inquiry
Prosecutors displayed text messages through Robert Josh Grossman's Day 9 testimony, including a December 2021 text from Kouri saying she knew the 'love triangle can't go on forever' and that she couldn't expect him 'to sit around for the day the trigger gets pulled'; a January 9, 2022 message asking Grossman if he had done drugs besides marijuana and how recently; and a February 19, 2022 message saying 'I want you today, every day.' A text from Kouri to Grossman also read 'I am in love with a man that's not my husband.'
Second mistrial motion — Carmen Lauber drug court violation + undisclosed Lauber-Mainord text messages
On Day 9 (March 4, 2026), defense attorney Wendy Lewis disclosed that attorney Kathy Nester received a text that morning from state officials disclosing Carmen Lauber had violated drug court rules after beginning to cooperate in the investigation — specifically regarding an alcoholic beverage. The defense also received text messages between Lauber and Summit County Detective Eric Mainord that they contended were Giglio material and had been requested prior to Lauber's testimony. Lewis moved for a mistrial; Judge Mrazik directed the defense to submit a written motion. Prosecutor Bloodworth said he was unaware of the detective-Lauber texts but maintained information about the drug court violation had been disclosed to defense three weeks before trial.
Kouri Richins closed on Midway mansion March 5, 2022 — one day after Eric died
Robert Josh Grossman's Day 9 testimony and Karrington's Day 8 testimony confirmed that the purchase contract for the Midway mansion required closing by March 4, 2022 (the day Eric died), and that Kouri actually closed on the $2.9 million property on March 5, 2022 — the day after his death. Kouri had been texting Grossman about celebrating the mansion closing in the days before Eric's death.
Kouri-Grossman relationship origin detail — confirmed in testimony
Robert Josh Grossman testified on Day 9 that he met Kouri approximately a decade ago in South Carolina when he responded to a help-wanted ad for a house-flipping project. He moved to Utah in 2020 to continue working with her on flipping homes; their romantic relationship started around that time. He initially lived in houses she was flipping and was paid occasionally. This confirms and supplements prior record entries about Grossman's background.
Eric Richins told estate attorney Kouri misused POA — 'She's the mother of my children'
Estate planning attorney Kristal Bowman-Carter testified on Day 9 (Day 9 cross-examination by Nester) that Eric Richins acknowledged Kouri had misused his power of attorney to take out $250,000 but said to her: 'She's the mother of my children, I know she's made mistakes and she needs more experience. For now I'm going to do what I'm doing.' This shows Eric was aware of the POA misuse but chose not to revoke it immediately.
Mirror Lake Diner Valentine's Day receipt — February 14, 2022
Gabriel Morin, owner of Mirror Lake Diner in Kamas, testified on Day 10 (March 5, 2026) and produced a receipt showing a phone order placed under the name 'Corey' on February 14, 2022, at 8:55 a.m., for a Greek omelet and bagel sandwich, picked up at 9:07 a.m. Prosecutors allege this corroborates their theory that Kouri purchased and poisoned the Valentine's Day breakfast sandwich before placing it in Eric's truck. The name 'Corey' was used because the diner tracks phone orders by name.
Jail phone call — Kouri Richins and Ronald Darden (redacted), played Day 10
A recorded jail phone call between Kouri Richins and her brother Ronnie Darden was played for the jury on Day 10 (March 5, 2026), with agreed redactions. In the played segments, Kouri refers to going 'in for a consultation' and asks 'Why is that so bad?'; Darden says authorities might try to hold something against her. Kouri says 'Eric did it first' and 'anything she did, Eric did as well, so they cancel each other out.' She expressed being 'annoyed' several times and references asking someone else to testify. Judge Mrazik instructed jurors they could use Kouri's statements as evidence, but could only consider other speakers' words for their effect on Kouri as a listener.
Recorded phone call — Kouri Richins, Chelsea Barney, and Bryce Knudsen (March 19, 2022)
A recorded three-way phone call from March 19, 2022 — between Kouri Richins, her friend Chelsea Barney, and Eric's best friend Bryce Knudsen — was played for the jury on Day 10 (March 5, 2026). In the call, Kouri tells Knudsen she understands he is '100% loyal' to the Richins family; states she wants life insurance money to go to her children's trust; insists the house is hers; and references the money she took from Eric, saying he never 'gave me a f— chance' after that. She becomes emotional discussing the trust taking her house. Knudsen said he knew 'things were going to get bad' and is choosing to remain neutral. Jurors may consider only Kouri's statements as substantive evidence.
Kouri Richins 'life story' written at Sedona retreat (2021) — denied admission
Prosecutors attempted to admit into evidence a document Kouri Richins wrote during a 'Finding True Self' retreat in Sedona, Arizona in February 2021, in which participants were assigned to write their life story in the third person. The document was shown to Kouri's childhood friend Ali Staking. After a sidebar on Day 10, Judge Mrazik denied the document's entry into evidence because Staking could not confirm the handwriting was Kouri's.
Marie Bramwell attorney-client contact records — May 2021 to January 2022
Domestic relations attorney Marie Bramwell testified on Day 10 (March 5, 2026) that she met with Kouri Richins in person on May 3, 2021. After that single meeting, they exchanged emails: Bramwell sent Kouri 5 emails and Kouri sent Bramwell 4 emails, spanning May 2021 through January 2022. A check from Gordon Law Group paid to Kouri was presented as evidence. The existence of this attorney contact beginning May 2021 places Kouri's consultation with a domestic relations attorney approximately 10 months before Eric's death.
Bowman-Carter quote — Kouri 'livid' and 'What is wrong with you people?' upon learning of the trust
Estate planning attorney Kristal Bowman-Carter testified (detail confirmed Day 10 KPCW coverage) that on March 5, 2022, when a Summit County sheriff's deputy put her on the phone with Kouri to explain Eric's trust, Kouri responded: 'She was livid. She was upset. And she said, "What is wrong with you people?" and handed the phone back to the officer.' Defense disputed this was when Kouri first learned of the trust. Bowman-Carter also acknowledged she accidentally sent an email meant for Katie Richins-Benson to Kouri on March 4, 2022.
Karrington testimony — Kouri forged Eric's signature on bank loan papers; $25K of insurance proceeds paid to Grossman
Court TV's Day 8 coverage headline (confirmed from Article 3) indicates that forensic accountant Brooke Karrington testified that Kouri Richins forged Eric's signature on bank loan papers — this is distinct from the insurance document forgery covered by handwriting expert Matt Throckmorton. Additionally, KPCW's Day 9 article confirms Karrington testified that approximately $600,000 of the $1.4 million insurance proceeds paid off some of Kouri's debts, and $25,000 went to Robert Josh Grossman.
Kouri assault conviction context — assault occurred the day AFTER Eric's death, upon learning of the trust
KPCW's March 4-5 article clarifies that Kouri Richins was convicted of assaulting Katie Richins-Benson on the day after Eric died — specifically after Richins-Benson allegedly told Kouri about the trust Eric had set up. Judge Mrazik ruled the assault conviction is NOT allowed as evidence in the murder trial, as it could cause unfair prejudice against Kouri. This confirms the assault charge was directly connected to Kouri learning about the trust.
Grossman text about drug use and TV show 'Dopesick' — January 2022
KPCW live blog coverage of Day 9 revealed an additional detail from the Grossman text messages shown to the jury: on January 9, 2022, when Kouri asked Grossman if he had done drugs besides marijuana, she explained that the TV show 'Dopesick' (about the prescription opioid epidemic) had reminded her. This provides context for why Kouri asked about Grossman's drug history at that time.
Bowman-Carter accidentally emailed Kouri on day Eric died — email meant for Katie Richins-Benson
Bowman-Carter testified under cross-examination by Nester that after speaking with Kouri on the phone (on March 4, 2022, the day Eric died, after a deputy put them in contact), she accidentally sent an email intended for Katie Richins-Benson to Kouri instead. Bowman-Carter said she was not aware whether Eric and Kouri shared an email account, but confirmed Eric had told her Kouri read his emails.
Text message — Kouri to Chelsea Barney: 'If I die, Eric did it'
During Chelsea Barney's Day 10 testimony, prosecutors displayed a text message in which Kouri Richins wrote to Barney: 'If I die, Eric did it.' The date of this message was not specified in reporting, but context places it during the period when Kouri was in financial distress and had discovered Eric's anger over the HELOC (approximately late 2020 through early 2022). Prosecution presented it as evidence of Kouri's state of mind and awareness of marital conflict. This is distinct from — and more explicit than — the other Kouri-Barney messages already in the record.
Text message — Kouri to Chelsea Barney: 'They will not take from me what is mine'
During Chelsea Barney's Day 10 testimony, prosecutors displayed a text message sent by Kouri Richins to Chelsea Barney after Eric's death in March 2022, reading: 'They will not take from me what is mine.' Prosecution presented this message as evidence of Kouri's intent and resolve to contest the estate, consistent with testimony about her rage at Eric's safe and the living trust.
Kouri Richins paid $5,000 retainer to domestic relations attorney Bramwell — bulk refunded after no divorce filed
Post-Day 10 Court TV coverage confirmed that when Kouri Richins consulted domestic relations attorney Marie Bramwell (Gordon Law Group) beginning May 3, 2021, she paid a $5,000 retainer. She did not ultimately file for divorce, and the bulk of that retainer was refunded. This detail was not reported in real-time Day 10 coverage and adds financial and intent context to the Bramwell consultation already in evidence.
Prosecution witness count — nearly 40 witnesses called as of Day 10
KPCW reported on March 5, 2026 that prosecutors had called 'almost 40 witnesses to testify already' as of Day 10. Chief Prosecutor Bloodworth confirmed that Det. Jeff O'Driscoll will be the final prosecution witness, anticipated early the week of March 9.
Jury questionnaire — 23 pages, 99 questions; selection completed in 2 days
TownLift reporting confirmed that prospective jurors in the Kouri Richins trial completed a 23-page questionnaire containing 99 questions in advance of voir dire. The questionnaire covered media consumption, prior knowledge of the case, interactions with law enforcement, civic involvement, marital history and other background. Jury selection, which had been allotted up to five days, was completed in two days, with the majority of prospective jurors passed by Judge Mrazik on the first day (February 10, 2026).
Robert Crozier admission — 'went along with investigators, telling him what he did' to avoid further trouble
KUTV's Article 3 (March 3, 2026 coverage of Week 2 opening) reported that Robert Crozier, in the context of his trial testimony, stated he could not recall the exact details of deals made approximately four years ago and acknowledged that 'he went along with the investigators, telling him what he did because he didn't want to get in more trouble.' This admission, distinct from the previously captured Day 5 testimony details, strengthens the defense's argument that Crozier's 2023 statements to investigators were shaped by external pressure rather than independent recollection.
Kouri Richins-Chelsea Barney text exchange — June 2022 accusations from Eric's family
KSL post-Day 10 reporting confirmed that Kouri Richins and Chelsea Barney exchanged text messages in June 2022 in which they discussed accusations from Eric Richins' family members that Kouri was involved in his death. This text exchange was referenced during Barney's Day 10 trial testimony. It adds to the existing record of Kouri-Barney communications already in evidence and establishes that the family's suspicions were communicated to Kouri's inner circle as early as three months after Eric's death.
Kouri Richins recorded call with Knudsen — additional detail: sisters-in-law 'attacking her' and withholding money pending autopsy report
KSL's post-Day 10 coverage of the March 19, 2022 recorded three-way call (Kouri, Chelsea Barney, Bryce Knudsen) includes an additional detail not captured in existing records: Kouri told Knudsen that her sisters-in-law were 'attacking her for no reason' and 'wouldn't agree to give her any money until they got the autopsy report.' This supplements the existing record of the call, which captured Kouri's statements about the house, the trust, and the insurance money.
Kouri-Barney 'If I die, Eric did it' text — date confirmed as October 14, 2020
The ABC4 Day 10 report confirms this text was part of an October 14, 2020 exchange in which Kouri told Chelsea Barney the HELOC loan was $250,000, that the disagreement with Eric was 'getting out of hand,' and that 'if I die, Eric did it.' This confirms the approximate date as shortly after Eric discovered the HELOC (consistent with October 2020 timeline) and is the same day the dispute escalated. Previously in evidence without a specific date.
Kouri-Barney text about death certificate — June 6, 2022
Admitted as evidence during Chelsea Barney's Day 10 testimony. On June 6, 2022, Kouri texted Barney that she was racing to get the death certificate before Eric's sister. She subsequently sent Barney a photo of the death certificate and wrote that the results showed 'there was a trace of fentanyl and his lungs were shot.' Prosecution presented this as evidence of Kouri's awareness of the toxicology findings and her competitive dynamic with the Richins family regarding the estate. This is a distinct June 2022 exchange from the previously-captured family-accusations texts.
Kouri's 'life story' document from Sedona retreat — admitted as evidence (CORRECTION to existing record)
Contrary to the existing record (which noted the judge denied its entry when presented through Ali Staking on Day 10), KPCW's live blog and post-day article both confirm the document WAS ultimately admitted as evidence. Judge Mrazik had previously ruled the document relevant to how Kouri felt about her marriage; prosecutors prepared a redacted version, but on Day 10 the defense asked the jury to see the entire unredacted document. Its contents included Kouri's difficult childhood, her father's imprisonment, her mother's gambling addiction, her marriage to Eric, discovery of his 'emotional affair' in 2018, and her subsequent counseling for anxiety and depression. The apparent reconciliation: ABC4 live coverage captured the sidebar/denial with Staking; the ultimate admission likely occurred through the document's own admissibility determination separately from Staking's authentication.
Kouri-Knudsen call — additional detail: 'so good the past two years' and Eric's anger management book
In the March 19, 2022 recorded three-way call (Kouri, Chelsea Barney, Bryce Knudsen) played for the jury on Day 10, Kouri told Knudsen that she and Eric had been 'so good the past two years' — presenting a conflicting narrative from the prosecution's account of a troubled marriage. She also said Eric had an anger management book he wrote in every few days, that she was going to counseling, and that they were going on double dates and weekly date nights before his death. Knudsen acknowledged Eric would call him and 'vent,' and told Eric he should 'just get divorced'; Eric responded that he loved Kouri and his three kids. This supplements the existing record of the call and adds the detail of Kouri's positive characterization of the marriage's final period.
Grossman bought trucks — Kouri gave him two trucks and gave money whenever he needed it
Robert Josh Grossman testified during Day 9 that Kouri let him live in a home she was flipping, bought him two trucks, and gave him money whenever he needed it. This supplements existing Day 9 testimony detail about the financial nature of their relationship. Note: approximately $25,000 of insurance proceeds went to Grossman per Karrington's Day 8 testimony.
Joshua Kaze — Cody Wright had a similar Valentine's Day 2022 call with Eric
Joshua Kaze testified that after Eric's death, he discussed the Valentine's Day 2022 phone call with Eric's business partner Cody Wright. Kaze confirmed that Wright had a similar call with Eric on that same day — suggesting Eric reached out to multiple close friends on Valentine's Day 2022, consistent with the prosecution's theory that Eric was distressed after being made ill. This was additional context from Kaze's testimony beyond what was captured in the existing Day 10 record.
Anne Coates — TruStage is the consumer brand for CMFG Life Insurance
KPCW's live blog identifies the insurance company witness Anne Coates as being from 'TruStage life insurance' — TruStage is the consumer-facing brand of CMFG Life Insurance Company. Previously captured only as CMFG Life. This is a minor clarification of the company's branding.
Chelsea Barney text to Kouri — 'What would you have put in the sandwich for him to break out in hives?'
In a June 2022 text exchange admitted as evidence during Chelsea Barney's Day 10 testimony, Barney asked Kouri: 'What would you have put in the sandwich for him to break out in hives?' Kouri's response was that she didn't make the sandwiches — a deflection without denying the premise. Prosecutors presented this exchange as significant. This is a distinct June 2022 exchange from the death certificate text and the family-accusations texts previously captured in evidence.
Kouri Richins wrote she was 'relieved' upon receiving Eric's death certificate — 'finally over'
Post-Day 10 coverage (Hidden Killers Substack summary of Chelsea Barney Day 10 testimony) confirmed that in addition to the fentanyl findings noted in the June 6, 2022 death certificate text, Kouri also wrote to Chelsea Barney that she thought it was 'finally over' and that she was 'relieved.' Prosecution presented the word 'relieved' — rather than devastated or shattered — as evidence of consciousness of guilt. This detail was within the June 6, 2022 Kouri-Barney exchange already in evidence, but the 'finally over'/'relieved' language was not previously captured in the case record.
Chelsea Barney financial victimization — full details from Day 10 testimony
Chelsea Barney testified she wired Kouri $45,000 in two separate wire transfers as a down payment on a home Kouri was flipping. She subsequently paid $2,900/month in mortgage payments. The deed was never properly recorded with the county. After Kouri's arrest, an unauthorized loan was taken out on the property without Barney's knowledge. Barney was evicted in September 2024 when the property was transferred to cover Kouri's debts. Barney, a restaurant manager, described the $45,000 as her life savings. Previously captured only as 'evicted from home Kouri allegedly gave to a lender.'
Celebration of Life video — to be shown to jury with minors' faces blurred; atmosphere described as 'party-like'
Park Record's March 6, 2026 post-Day 10 article confirmed that prosecutors planned to show the jury a video of the Celebration of Life held at the Richins home the night after Eric died, with minor children's faces blurred. Prosecutors characterized the atmosphere as 'more party-like than grief-stricken.' Attendees captured in a photo admitted by Lewis on Day 10 included Kouri, Bryce Knudsen, Ali Staking, Chelsea Barney, and Amy Richins. This supplements but does not duplicate existing entries about the Celebration of Life.
Allison Wright works at C&E Stone Masonry — does admin and bookkeeping; husband and Eric had temporary falling out over hunting violation
EastIdaho Day 7 live blog coverage (confirmed per Day 7 in-court events) reveals: (1) Allison Wright works at C&E Stone Masonry doing admin and bookkeeping (the company formerly owned by Eric and her husband Cody). (2) During cross-examination, Nester elicited that Cody Wright and Eric Richins had a temporary falling out because Cody had provided information to law enforcement about a hunting violation Eric may have committed — Nester used this to suggest the Wrights had complicated loyalty dynamics with the Richins family. Wright confirmed it was temporary. (3) Wright also confirmed she remained close with Kouri after Eric's death and that her husband accompanied Kouri to court hearings.
Kouri-Barney text — Kouri told Barney she 'isn't allowed to attend' Eric's Celebration of Life
From the EastIdaho Day 10 live blog, in the March 19, 2022 recorded Kouri-Barney-Knudsen three-way call played for the jury, Chelsea Barney told Bryce Knudsen that Kouri 'isn't allowed to attend' Eric's Celebration of Life because 'his family will make her look bad.' Kouri said she just can't go. This supplements the existing record entry about the Knudsen call.
Amy Richins physically stopped locksmith — and was victim of Kouri's assault
Post-Day 10 reporting and prior KSL coverage of the assault case confirmed that Amy Richins (Eric's sister, distinct from Katie Richins-Benson) was specifically the person who: (1) ran into the garage to stop the locksmith Kouri had called to open Eric's safe on March 6, 2022; and (2) was punched by Kouri in the face and neck in the assault that resulted in Kouri's class B misdemeanor conviction. Amy testified at the assault case: 'It took four people to pull her off me.' Previously the record referred only to 'a sister-in-law' stopping the locksmith; Amy's specific role is now confirmed.
Cody Wright Valentine's Day 2022 call with Eric — 'fear in his voice'
Cody Wright testified on Day 11 (March 9, 2026) that he received a call from Eric on Valentine's Day 2022 and described 'fear in his voice and a sense of urgency.' He said the only comparable times were when Eric's mother died and when Eric was in a serious car accident. This corroborates Joshua Kaze's testimony about Eric being 'somber' and 'sincere' on Valentine's Day 2022.
Eric Richins went to Mexico in February 2022 for hunting — confirmed by Cody Wright
Cody Wright confirmed under defense cross-examination on Day 11 that Eric Richins went to Mexico in February 2022 for hunting, because Eric was unable to hunt in the U.S. for a period due to wildlife violations. This directly supports the defense's opening theory that Eric may have obtained fentanyl during or after a trip to Mexico.
Eric and Cody had lunch at Mirror Lake Cafe on March 3, 2022 — the day before Eric died
Cody Wright confirmed under defense cross-examination on Day 11 that he and Eric Richins had lunch together at the Mirror Lake Cafe on March 3, 2022 — the day before Eric died. This places Cody as one of the last people to see Eric alive outside the Richins home.
Eric's red personal truck — at Ford dealership at time of death; picked up by C&E; currently at Katie Richins' home
Cody Wright testified on Day 11 that Eric's personal red truck (owned by C&E) was at the Ford dealership when Eric died. Cody received a call from the dealership and had it picked up. Instructions had been given that the truck should not be driven. The truck is currently at Katie Richins' home. Defense did not establish whether the truck was searched before being retrieved.
C&E computer — sent to private investigator Gabler before law enforcement reviewed it
Cody Wright testified on Day 11 that after Eric's death, he sent Becky Lloyd to pick up Eric's C&E computer from the Richins home. That computer was given to Katie Richins-Benson, who gave it to private investigator Todd Gabler. Cody authorized the computer to go to Gabler before law enforcement went through it. This means the C&E computer was in Gabler's possession before investigators reviewed it.
Gabler GPS tracking — placed on Kouri's car, her mother's car, and her brother's car
Private investigator Todd Gabler testified on Day 11 that he placed GPS tracking devices on Kouri Richins' car, her mother Lisa Darden's car, and her brother's car as part of his investigation. He tracked them and turned the data over to law enforcement. He also tracked Carmen Lauber's vehicle and removed the device when he learned it wasn't Carmen driving.
Gabler phone contact analysis — hundreds of Kouri-Lauber texts; Lauber ranked 3rd highest contact after Kouri's mother and Eric
Private investigator Todd Gabler testified on Day 11 that he analyzed billing records for Kouri and Eric's cell phones (paid for by C&E Masonry). He found hundreds of texts between Kouri Richins and Carmen Lauber between January and May 2022. The only two contacts with higher frequency than Lauber were Kouri's mother and Eric. Gabler said he was 'very concerned about the high number of contacts and the criminal history for Carmen' and alerted the sheriff's office.
Gabler email to Detective Woody — advised interviewing Lauber while she was 'on the ropes in drug court'
Private investigator Todd Gabler testified on Day 11 that he sent an email to Detective Woody advising that 'now would be a really good time to interview Carmen Lauber because she's on the ropes in drug court.' Defense attorney Nester presented this as evidence that the private investigator — hired and paid by the Richins family — was actively coordinating with law enforcement to secure testimony from Lauber at her most vulnerable point.
Gabler removed safe from Richins home without law enforcement; opened with rubber mallet
Private investigator Todd Gabler testified on Day 11 (confirmed under cross by Nester) that he removed a safe from the master closet of the Richins home at Clint Benson's request, took it to a locksmith, had it opened with a rubber mallet, and then returned it — without law enforcement present. Gabler said: 'I don't need law enforcement to babysit me.' This was a separate safe from the one Kouri attempted to open with a locksmith on March 6, 2022.
'Babycakes letter' — Eric to Kouri; found by Gabler in May 2023; photographed on bed August 2024
Private investigator Todd Gabler testified on Day 11 that on May 10, 2023, he found a letter written by Eric Richins to Kouri in the bottom drawer of Eric's side of the bed. He described it as the 'babycakes letter.' He did not consider it relevant and put it away. On August 9, 2024, he photographed the letter — though he could not recall whether it was on the bed or if he retrieved it from the vanity at that time. Defense attorney Nester suggested this is the same letter found at the foot of the bed in the November 7, 2024 search and used this to imply Gabler may have moved it.
Amy Richins told Detective Woody that Eric said Kouri threatened to kill him — two separate conversations
Detective Jayme Woody testified on Day 11 (outside the jury's presence) that Amy Richins told her, in the driveway on March 4, 2022, that Eric had said 'Kouri was going to kill him.' In a second conversation, Amy told Woody that Kouri was erratic when drinking, Eric and Kouri had been fighting a lot, and Eric specifically said Kouri had threatened to kill him. Judge Mrazik handled the disclosure outside the jury's presence and then questioned Woody with both parties present before deciding how to proceed.
Kouri told Detective Woody she could not remember housekeeper's name on March 4, 2022
Detective Jayme Woody testified on Day 11 that after noticing the garbage cans at the Richins home were empty on March 4, 2022, she asked Kouri why. Kouri said her housekeeper had emptied them. When Woody asked for the housekeeper's name, Kouri said she couldn't remember it. Prosecution may use this to suggest Kouri was concealing Carmen Lauber's identity.
Throckmorton handwriting testimony — 'simulated forgery' conclusion; internal affairs history disclosed
Handwriting expert Matt Throckmorton testified on Day 11. He concluded the questioned signature on an insurance document showed 'no evidence that Eric authored the signature and he probably did not — it appeared to be a simulated forgery written by somebody who had access to his writing.' He reviewed 86 signatures and 24 sets of initials across multiple document types. His conclusion was verified by a colleague in Colorado. Under cross, Nester revealed Throckmorton was subject to an internal affairs investigation at SLCPD for allegedly falsifying documents — he said he was cleared. Throckmorton acknowledged a 4-per-100 error rate in the field and that he cannot identify who wrote the questioned signature.
Celebration of Life video — admitted as evidence on Day 11; played for jury
The video of the Celebration of Life held at the Richins home the night after Eric died was formally admitted as evidence on Day 11 (March 9, 2026) and shown to the jury, with minors' faces blurred. Bloodworth noted it was admitted during Allie Staking's Day 10 testimony. The video shows adults drinking and laughing. Cody Wright's wife Allison (Alley) Wright was confirmed to not be in the photo/video.
C&E Masonry gave K. Richins Realty a $200,000 loan in October 2020 — fully repaid with interest
Cody Wright testified on Day 11 that C&E Masonry provided a $200,000 loan (not an investment) to K. Richins Realty in October 2020 to pay for projects. Wright confirmed C&E got all the money back plus interest. Kouri was also on C&E's payroll and continued to be paid for a couple of months after Eric's death.
Eric Richins 'Red Devils' drug use in high school — raised by defense in Cody Wright voir dire
During a voir dire of Cody Wright outside the jury's presence on Day 11, defense attorney Nester raised Eric's alleged use of 'Red Devils' — pain pills — in high school. Wright said he was told Eric used them in high school but believed they were Sudafed; he had no knowledge of illicit drug use after high school. Judge Mrazik ruled Wright had not said anything impeachable and declined to strike his testimony. The defense stated they have an expert who will testify about Red Devils and argued this is central to whether Eric voluntarily ingested fentanyl.
Judge's ruling — Eric's high school 'Red Devils' drug use evidence excluded from trial
After voir dire of Cody Wright on Day 11 (outside jury's presence), Judge Mrazik ruled that Wright's testimony regarding Eric's alleged high school 'Red Devils' pill use constituted inadmissible hearsay. Mrazik then asked prosecutors whether they wanted to proceed with the testimony anyway (to insulate the verdict from appeal). Chief Prosecutor Bloodworth conferred with his team and declined. As a result, evidence regarding Eric Richins' alleged high school drug use will stay out of the trial entirely. Wright had said he believed 'Red Devils' referred to pseudoephedrine/Sudafed and that he could not identify them as illicit drugs.
Third mistrial motion — filed Day 10 over 'charges' reference, withdrawn Day 11
At a sidebar on Day 10 (March 5, 2026), defense attorney Wendy Lewis filed a third motion for a mistrial after a recorded phone call entered into evidence contained Kouri Richins referring to 'charges.' Defense attorney Lewis disclosed on the morning of Day 11 (March 9) that the defense had now withdrawn this third motion. It was not ruled upon. The second mistrial motion (Lauber drug court violation + undisclosed Mainord texts) remains pending.
Cody Wright — confirmed beneficiary change alert in January 2022; never saw Eric make changes
Cody Wright testified on Day 11 that in January 2022, he was informed that the beneficiary on his life insurance policy had been changed. He confirmed he had never observed Eric Richins making those changes himself. Defense attorney Nester noted the change was made on Cody's policy (the one insuring Cody's life, with Eric as beneficiary) not on Eric's — raising the question of who made the change. This supplements the existing Day 9 testimony about the January 2022 beneficiary changes.
Kouri told Det. Woody that Eric was cold 'almost immediately' and that Eric was 'healthy'
During Woody's cross-examination on Day 11, Nester asked if Woody had ever asked Kouri how long she was in the bed with Eric before realizing he was cold. Woody said Kouri stated it was 'almost immediately.' Kouri also told Woody that Eric was 'healthy.' These statements from Kouri to the first-responding detective on March 4, 2022, add to the record of Kouri's account on the night of the death.
Kouri Richins jailhouse message — 'she thought she would be set for life if he died'
During Day 12 (March 10, 2026) pre-jury proceedings, Judge Mrazik ruled admissible a jailhouse message in which Kouri Richins stated she thought she would be 'set for life if he died.' Defense objected to admission of this message; the judge overruled the objection and allowed it in as evidence. This message had not been previously identified by name or quoted in trial coverage.
Carmen Lauber interview transcripts / video — approximately 1,000 pages / 7.5 hours; admissibility dispute Day 12
On Day 12 (March 10, 2026), it was disclosed that Carmen Lauber's recorded interviews with investigators constitute approximately 1,000 pages of transcript and approximately 7.5 hours of video. The prosecution sought to introduce specific portions through Det. O'Driscoll's testimony. Defense objected, arguing the statements should have been dealt with during Lauber's direct testimony. Judge Mrazik ruled specific clips may be published in court for the witness but the full transcript should not go to the jury room. The issue was continued to Day 13 following a defense continuance request. Defense stated Lauber was 'unduly influenced by law enforcement' throughout these interviews.
Det. O'Driscoll interview with Kouri Richins — transcript; self-serving statements disputed
On Day 12 (March 10, 2026), defense attorney Nester referenced a transcript of an interview Det. Jeff O'Driscoll conducted with Kouri Richins and sought to have several redacted pages admitted into evidence. Prosecutor Bloodworth opposed, characterizing the interview as 'peppered with Kouri's self-serving statements.' Judge Mrazik ruled that the information can come out through questioning during O'Driscoll's testimony but the interview will not be admitted as a standalone exhibit. Some pages were unredacted at defense request.
Walk the Dog letter — prosecution response to anticipated defense 'fictional manuscript' argument
On Day 12 (March 10, 2026), Prosecutor Bloodworth disclosed during pre-jury argument that he anticipates the defense will argue the six-page 'Walk the Dog!!' letter was part of a fictional 65-page manuscript and that its meaning must be understood in that context. Bloodworth stated: 'That is untrue and we can prove that by proving how it was recovered.' Bloodworth proposed using Det. O'Driscoll to introduce the letter with specific wording about how it was found. This is the first disclosure of the defense's anticipated 'fictional manuscript' argument about the Walk the Dog letter.
Kotrodimos UTC clarification — Valentine's Day 2022 text message timestamps
On Day 12 (March 10, 2026), digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos was briefly recalled to the stand. Prosecutor Chervenak showed him an exhibit of text messages from February 14, 2022 (Valentine's Day) and asked about time stamps. Kotrodimos clarified that the timestamps are provided in UTC; Utah is -7 UTC in normal standard time and -6 UTC in daylight saving time, with adjustments made by the forensic software to display local time. Defense had no questions. This clarification may affect interpretation of the timing of Kouri's Valentine's Day texts to Grossman and Eric's texts about feeling ill.
Eric Richins 'open relationship' joke text to Bryce Knudsen — defense theory via Gabler
During defense cross-examination of PI Todd Gabler on Day 11, Nester showed Gabler a text in which Eric Richins told Bryce Knudsen he and Kouri were 'starting an open relationship, so I'm taking you home tonight.' Gabler testified he considered it a joke between friends and not sexting. On redirect, prosecutors confirmed Gabler had no opinion Eric was having an affair with Knudsen and never saw any indication Eric was using illegal drugs. The defense presented this as part of a broader narrative about Eric's text behavior that they may use in their own case.
Letter from Eric to Kouri — 'my princess' alternate name confirmed; ABC4 identifies it as such
The letter found by PI Todd Gabler in May 2023 in Eric's side of the bed — previously recorded as the 'babycakes letter' — is referred to in ABC4's Day 11 coverage as the 'my princess' letter. Gabler testified he found it in May 2023, initially did not consider it relevant, and later photographed it in August 2024. The letter was formally collected from the foot of the bed in the November 7, 2024 search. Both names ('babycakes' per EastIdaho coverage, 'my princess' per ABC4 coverage) appear to refer to the same document.
Court TV ruling — Lauber prior consistent statements admissible through O'Driscoll (Day 12)
Following a short recess during Day 12 pre-jury argument, Judge Mrazik ruled that there is no legal authority barring prior consistent statements from being admitted through a witness other than the original declarant. This overruled the defense's objection that Lauber's interview statements could only be introduced when Lauber was on the stand. The prosecution may now introduce approximately 100 pages of Lauber interview material — and an edited video of those portions — through Det. O'Driscoll's testimony.
Walk the Dog letter — jury presentation framing: 'personal belongings,' not 'jail cell'
To avoid disclosing to the jury that Kouri Richins has been in jail, the prosecution and court agreed that Det. O'Driscoll will testify the Walk the Dog letter was recovered from a book found in Richins' personal belongings — without specifying that it was found in her jail cell. This was resolved during Day 12 pre-jury proceedings. Fox 13 reported the framing agreement.
Gabler iCloud clone of Eric's phone — basis for accessing Eric's text messages
PI Todd Gabler testified on Day 11 that he created a clone of Eric Richins' phone based on an Apple iCloud backup, which gave him access to Eric's text messages. This explains the mechanism by which Gabler was able to review Eric's texts, including those with Bryce Knudsen. This detail emerged in ABC4's Day 11 coverage of Gabler's testimony.
Investigation stalled by fall 2022 — Gabler's tip on Lauber was the break, per Woody testimony
Detective Jayme Woody testified on Day 11 that the investigation into Eric Richins' death had all but stalled by the fall of 2022, months after his fatal overdose in March 2022. The investigation accelerated near the end of 2022 based on information provided by private investigator Todd Gabler, who alerted the Sheriff's Office about Carmen Lauber. Deputies ultimately arrested Kouri Richins in May 2023.
Orange notebook — journal entries and investigation timeline; admitted as evidence Day 13
The orange notebook collected from Kouri Richins' nightstand during the May 8, 2023 search was admitted into evidence and published for the jury on Day 13 during Det. O'Driscoll's testimony. The notebook contained: (1) a journal entry in which Kouri described finding Eric's body and the immediate aftermath; and (2) a written timeline of events following Eric's death from Kouri's perspective, including her interactions with Eric's family and learning about the private investigator. Previously, the notebook's admissibility was described as unresolved. This confirms it was ultimately admitted.
Ghostwriter evidence — 'Book Writing Lane' wrote 'Are You With Me?'; Kouri paid $2,500
Det. O'Driscoll testified on Day 13 that investigators found evidence on Kouri Richins' cell phone showing a ghostwriting company — 'Book Writing Lane' — wrote her children's book 'Are You With Me?' Text messages showed Kouri told friends and family she paid $2,500 for the service. Kouri also texted her brother discussing hiring a ghostwriter for a larger manuscript: 130 pages for $5,000, or up to 250 pages for approximately $10,000. She noted she would need to change names and take precautions to avoid a defamation lawsuit. The subject of the larger manuscript was not stated in the messages shown.
Anonymous book package sent to SCSO — confirmed sent by Lisa Darden via Amazon subpoena
In March 2023, the Summit County Sheriff's Office received an anonymous Amazon package containing Kouri Richins' children's book and a note: 'There are two sides to every story. This is the true Kouri, a devoted wife and adoring mother. Thought you should know. From Anonymous.' Det. O'Driscoll testified on Day 13 that law enforcement subpoenaed Amazon and confirmed the package was sent from an account registered to Kouri's mother, Lisa Darden.
Phone call — Kouri Richins and Lisa Darden discussing the sandwich allegation
A recorded phone call between Kouri Richins and her mother Lisa Darden was played in court during Det. O'Driscoll's Day 13 testimony. In the call, the two discussed the allegation that Kouri had poisoned a sandwich given to Eric. Kouri said: 'They are nuts,' characterizing the accusation as a lie. This is the first recorded instance of Kouri directly denying the Valentine's Day sandwich allegation in a call played for the jury.
Kouri text to brother — asked if Eric ever talked about suicide (May 24, 2023)
A text message from Kouri Richins to her brother, dated May 24, 2023 — approximately two weeks after her arrest — was admitted into evidence and shown to the jury on Day 13. In the text, Kouri asked her brother if Eric had ever talked about suicide. Her brother responded that Eric had not.
Eric Richins Google search — distance from Utah to Sonora, Mexico; shortly before death
Det. O'Driscoll confirmed during cross-examination on Day 13 that a Google search was found on Eric Richins' phone made shortly before his death, searching for the driving distance from Utah to Sonora, Mexico. O'Driscoll testified he believed Eric had gone hunting in that region of Mexico. Defense attorney Nester raised this during cross-examination, consistent with the defense theory that Eric obtained fentanyl during or after his February 2022 Mexico hunting trip.
Lauber interview video clips played for jury — 'didn't deserve that' and context for 'ensure Kouri gets convicted of murder' statement
During Det. O'Driscoll's Day 13 testimony, approximately 100 pages worth of video clips from Lauber's interview sessions (from the total ~1,000-page/10-hour interview record) were played for the jury. In one clip, Lauber said Eric 'didn't deserve that,' though she also said she didn't know if what was done was intentional. Another clip showed O'Driscoll telling Lauber they needed details to 'ensure Kouri gets convicted of murder' — O'Driscoll testified on the stand this was 'a poor choice of words in hindsight' and was intended to convey the level of detail and seriousness required, not to coach false testimony.
Walk the Dog letter — read aloud in court by Det. O'Driscoll; key additional content confirmed
Det. O'Driscoll read the six-page Walk the Dog letter aloud in court during Day 13 testimony, after agreed redactions. Additional content confirmed: (1) the letter instructs Ronnie to say Eric always wanted Kouri to take the blame if caught and put drugs in her bag; (2) it states Eric kept drugs in his work truck but Cody emptied the truck a week after his death; (3) it states Ronnie would have messages on his phone about Eric getting high. On cross, O'Driscoll confirmed: the letter was never delivered to Kouri's mother or family; he never obtained a warrant for Ronnie Darden's phone; and at least one person confirmed knowledge of a fight in which Eric put drugs in Kouri's bag before a trip.
Kouri emails to 'Good Things Utah' executive producer — requesting TV appearance to promote book
Emails between Kouri Richins and the executive producer of 'Good Things Utah' were admitted into evidence on Day 13. The emails showed Kouri filled out a standardized form requesting to appear on the show to promote her book, claiming it was the first children's book about losing a parent. O'Driscoll confirmed he watched Kouri's April 2023 appearance on the show.
Carmen Lauber recalled Day 13 — drug court violation: seen holding alcohol at concert (November 2023)
Carmen Lauber was recalled to the stand on Day 13 (March 11, 2026) as part of Judge Mrazik's ruling denying the second mistrial motion. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis cross-examined Lauber specifically about a November 2023 drug court violation in which Lauber was observed holding an alcoholic drink at a concert. Lauber testified she had gone to a concert with a friend and agreed to buy food and drinks instead of being paid back; she confirmed a probation officer saw her holding a drink but said she did not personally drink. When told the officer stated she was drinking, Lauber said: 'If the officer said that, then it is true.' Lauber then left the stand again.
O'Driscoll confirmed — no fentanyl found on any tested item in the home; 'boatload in stomach'
During Day 14 cross-examination, Det. O'Driscoll confirmed that investigators found no fentanyl on any tested item in the Richins home across a four-year, 10-search-warrant investigation. When Nester asked 'we have no murder weapon, like you haven't found anything that was connected to Eric's death, no fentanyl, correct?' O'Driscoll replied: 'There was a boatload of fentanyl in his stomach that came out of the house with him.' He also confirmed a bag of loose hydrocodone pills found in the mudroom cabinet was tested and did not contain fentanyl.
Two additional GIFs accessed at 10:43 a.m. on March 4, 2022 — second set revealed in Day 14 cross-examination
During O'Driscoll's Day 14 cross-examination, defense attorney Nester admitted a second extraction report showing two additional GIFs accessed on Kouri Richins' phone at 10:43 a.m. on March 4, 2022 — distinct from and approximately two hours after the three GIFs accessed at 8:29 a.m. O'Driscoll confirmed he viewed both sets of GIFs during the investigation. The content of the 10:43 a.m. GIFs was not specifically reported. A photo of the Legacy House (Midway mansion) was also accessed at the 8:29 a.m. timeframe.
Eric Richins' photos sent March 3 also accessed on Kouri's phone morning of March 4 — defense context for GIFs
During Day 14 cross-examination, Det. O'Driscoll confirmed that on the morning of March 4, 2022, someone using Kouri's phone also viewed photos Eric Richins had sent her the day before (March 3, the day before he died), including a photo of the Midway mansion with the message 'I just dropped gravel at the Midway mansion.' Defense used this to suggest the 8:29 a.m. phone activity — which included the three money-themed GIFs — was routine message-viewing rather than celebratory, as the prosecution argued.
Kevin Spacey 'Idiots' GIF confirmed as from TV show 'House of Cards'
During Day 14 redirect examination, Prosecutor Bloodworth asked Det. O'Driscoll whether the Kevin Spacey 'Idiots. Idiots everywhere' GIF is from the TV show 'House of Cards.' O'Driscoll confirmed it is. This supplements the existing record that identified the GIF as featuring Kevin Spacey without specifying the source.
Nick Bonsavage jail call (March 4, 2022) — suppressed statement: Lauber 'made money selling fentanyl'
During Day 14 pre-jury argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth disclosed that a jail call from March 4, 2022 exists in which Nick Bonsavage stated that Carmen Lauber had 'just made money selling fentanyl.' This call had been referenced in prior testimony to the jury using the phrase 'illicit street drugs' rather than 'fentanyl.' The specific word 'fentanyl' in the Bonsavage call had been suppressed from the jury. Bloodworth stated that if the defense opened the door via the Norris information, this more explicit version of the Bonsavage statement would be admissible. The defense declined to open that door.
Orange notebook quote — Kouri's journal entry describing finding Eric's body
The specific text of Kouri's journal entry about finding Eric was published in Court TV's coverage of O'Driscoll's Day 13–14 testimony. The entry reads: 'He was cold, very cold so I pulled the blanket up on him, but his body just felt so strange to me, it was heavy is the only word I can think to describe it. He was pale/yellow, mouth open. An urge came over me that this wasn't good.' This is the first time the specific language of Kouri's account from the orange notebook was reported publicly.
O'Driscoll — Eric's Valentine's Day allergy/EpiPen: seasonal allergies confirmed; hospital visit uncertain
During Day 14 cross-examination, Det. O'Driscoll confirmed that Eric Richins was treated for allergies — specifically seasonal allergies (trees, grass) — and that EpiPens were found in the Richins home refrigerator. O'Driscoll confirmed Eric mentioned going to the hospital on Valentine's Day 2022 but said he was unsure whether Eric actually went. This is relevant to the defense argument that Eric's February 14, 2022 illness was an allergic reaction, not a poisoning attempt.
Directed verdict motion arguments — insurance fraud/forgery count; TruStage $100,000 policy specifically cited
During the Day 14 Rule 17 directed verdict motion, Judge Mrazik asked Bloodworth specifically to address 'lack of believable evidence regarding intent to defraud.' Bloodworth identified the TruStage (CMFG) $100,000 life insurance policy as the specific document at issue, arguing that at the time Kouri forged Eric's signature, she intended to defraud — noting nothing on the application indicates Eric was aware of it and everything routes back to Kouri's address. Ramos argued for the defense that prosecutors had not proved Kouri signed Eric's name without his knowledge or permission. Mrazik denied the motion, ruling even slight evidence of guilt requires submission to the jury.
Defense rests without witnesses — Kouri waives right to testify; no rebuttal case by prosecution
After a 90-minute lunch recess on Day 14 (March 12, 2026), defense attorney Wendy Lewis announced: 'After consulting with our client, the defense rests.' Kouri Richins formally waived her right to testify. The prosecution announced it will not present a rebuttal case. The defense had previously indicated it would call approximately three witnesses; the sudden decision to rest surprised observers. The only witness technically called by the defense during trial was Ali Staking, who testified during the state's case-in-chief due to travel difficulties. The jury was dismissed until Monday, March 16, 2026, for closing arguments and jury instructions.
Norris credibility disclosure — Norris called SCSO after hearsay ruling; told deputies defense counsel instructed him to call
Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth disclosed on Day 14 that David Norris contacted the Summit County Sheriff's Office only after Judge Mrazik had already ruled his testimony hearsay-inadmissible, and that when deputies interviewed Norris, he stated he was calling because defense counsel told him to. Bloodworth characterized Norris as not credible. This adds important context to the Norris exclusion already in the record — Norris did not independently come forward but was directed by the defense.
Jury note to Judge Mrazik — concern about gallery spectator drawing jurors (Day 5)
During Day 5 (February 27, 2026), the jury sent a written note to Judge Mrazik expressing concern about a person sitting in the gallery who appeared to be drawing them. This is consistent with the existing record noting a spectator was removed for sketching jurors and identifying them by number, but the mechanism — a jury note — was not previously captured.
Jury instruction rulings — motive instruction removed; domestic violence instruction removed; 'firmly convinced' objection overruled; Lauber immunity/snitch instruction debated
During the March 13, 2026 jury instruction conference, Judge Mrazik made several key rulings: (1) The motive instruction was removed — the jury will not be instructed on motive, by agreement of all parties. (2) The domestic violence/cohabitation instruction was removed — Nester argued domestic violence was not part of the trial; judge agreed to remove it. (3) Nester's objection to the 'firmly convinced' language in the reasonable doubt instruction was overruled by Judge Mrazik. (4) Prosecutor Burmester objected to a 'snitch' instruction as inapplicable to Lauber; Nester argued for a federal co-conspirator instruction; Mrazik said he would review it. (5) Nester requested a special instruction regarding Lauber's immunity grants. (6) A specific instruction was discussed for Det. O'Driscoll based on his presence throughout the trial. (7) The 404b and in-custody informant instructions were also discussed.
Hayden Jeffs suppressed statements — also at stake in Day 14 Norris 'high-stakes poker' ruling
Court TV's March 13 article clarifies that during the Day 14 Norris argument, the State's counter-position was that opening the door to Norris testimony through O'Driscoll would admit not only the Nick Bonsavage jail call ('making money from the sale of fentanyl') but also previously suppressed statements by Hayden Jeffs — in which Jeffs told investigators before his September 2024 death that Kouri Richins had asked him for fentanyl. The existing record captured only the Bonsavage call as the suppressed evidence at stake; Jeffs' suppressed statements were also part of the package the defense was protecting against by declining to pursue the Norris line.
Defense had 'several witnesses ready to testify' on Day 14 before deciding to rest
Court TV's March 13, 2026 article confirms that before the lunch break on Day 14, defense lawyers informed the court they had several witnesses ready to testify. After a roughly 90-minute lunch recess during which they conferred with Kouri Richins, they returned and announced the defense rests without calling any of them. This establishes the decision was an active, deliberate choice made during the lunch recess — not a situation in which the defense lacked available witnesses.
Lauber drug court violations — three total (firearm, alcohol, curfew) confirmed via Court TV
Court TV's coverage of Carmen Lauber's recalled Day 13 testimony confirmed she admitted to three drug court violations: (1) possessing a firearm she was prohibited from having due to her criminal history; (2) alcohol consumption (observed holding a drink at a concert in November 2023); and (3) not complying with her curfew. The existing case record had captured only the alcohol/drink violation from Day 13 testimony. The firearm was found in her home during the April 2023 search. The curfew violation is a newly confirmed distinct third violation.
Jury instruction — 'informant' instruction for Lauber and Crozier
Judge Mrazik resolved the contested 'snitch' vs. federal co-conspirator instruction at the March 13, 2026 jury instruction conference: Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier will fall under an 'informant' instruction. Previously the record showed only that the judge had taken the 'snitch' instruction debate under advisement. ABC4's post-conference coverage confirms the 'informant' instruction as the final resolution.
Defense law firm names — 'Nester Lewis' and 'Langford Ramos'
KPCW's March 15, 2026 trial cost article identifies the defense firms by name: Kathryn Nester and Wendy Lewis are from 'Nester Lewis,' while Alexander Ramos is from 'Langford Ramos.' Previously in the record only their individual names were listed without firm affiliations confirmed.
Eric joked about Kouri trying to poison him on Valentine's Day — O'Driscoll confirmed
ABC4's Day 14 coverage (confirmed from published article) notes that during O'Driscoll's cross-examination, it was established that Eric Richins joked about Kouri trying to poison him on Valentine's Day 2022. O'Driscoll confirmed this while Kouri maintained Eric only had an allergic reaction. Eric was confirmed to have an allergy doctor and to have received allergy shots.
Kouri's brother identified as 'DJ Khouri' — KPCW live blog confirmation
KPCW's live blog from Day 13 identified Kouri Richins' brother (referenced previously only as 'DJ' or 'Ronnie') as 'DJ Khouri' in the context of text messages about the children's book ghostwriter. This is distinct from 'Ronald Darden' — suggesting DJ and Ronnie may be two different brothers, or DJ is an alternate name/nickname. The KPCW blog refers specifically to 'DJ Khouri' as the person Kouri texted about the ghostwritten children's book and the larger manuscript.
Walk the Dog letter — additional content: allergy pill bottle in work truck; Lisa Darden instructed to meet in person; photos of Eric passed out; letter references 'Skye'; Katie's daughters photos scheme; 'Bring me home'
Additional Walk the Dog letter content confirmed via KSL, Deseret News, Court TV, and KPCW coverage of O'Driscoll's Day 13 testimony: (1) The letter instructs Kouri's mother to meet brother Ronnie IN PERSON — not by phone or text — because she feared her mother's home and phones were being monitored. (2) The scripted narrative has Eric saying he kept drugs hidden in an ALLERGY PILL BOTTLE in his work truck so Kouri wouldn't find them. (3) The letter says Kouri's phone contains photos of Eric 'passed out on the floor or in a chair' and that Ronnie 'should have texts' from Eric talking about getting high. (4) The letter references former defense attorney 'Skye' (Lazaro) planning to test gummies for fentanyl. (5) Page four instructs Lisa Darden to find photos of Katie Richins-Benson's daughters on her phone, print them, and mail them anonymously to media companies — with the goal of making Katie 'livid.' (6) The letter closes with the words: 'Tell him I need him to do this. Bring me home.' (7) The phrase 'Walk the Dog!!' is scrawled across the top with 'But take vague notes so you remember.' These details supplement but do not duplicate the existing Walk the Dog evidence entry.
Kouri Richins phone locked at 9:32 p.m. March 3, 2022 — exact timestamp clarified; moved 35 feet 'around 10:30 p.m.'
CNN's mid-trial recap article (March 9, 2026) confirmed via Kotrodimos' testimony that Kouri's phone was locked at 9:32 p.m. on March 3, 2022, and remained locked until 3:06 a.m. on March 4. The phone moved 35 feet 'around 10:30 p.m.' — a more specific timestamp than the existing record's 'approximately 11 p.m.' This clarifies the granular phone movement timeline entry already in evidence.
Grossman text to Kouri — 'love you' GIF (two people kissing) sent night before Eric died
CNN's March 9 article confirms via Grossman's testimony that the night before Eric died (March 3, 2022), Grossman sent Kouri a GIF of two people kissing with the caption 'love you.' This is the GIF referenced in the existing record entry about Kouri texting Grossman 'Love you' before making the Moscow mule, but the specific content of Grossman's GIF to her had not been identified.
Kouri Richins text to Grossman approximately 2 weeks before Eric's death — fuller quote including 'Figure life out together'
CNN's March 9 article confirmed the fuller version of the pre-death Kouri-to-Grossman text: 'I do want a future together. I do want you. Figure life out together... If he could just go away and you could just be here! Life would be so perfect!!! I love you.' The existing record captured only the 'If he could just go away' portion. This is the same message thread but includes the preceding sentences not previously captured.
Grossman cross-examination fuller quote — 'I can't tell one way from the other anymore. I've been confused for years.'
CNN's March 9 article provides a more complete version of Grossman's cross-examination response when defense attorney Lewis asked whether the Uinta Mountains conversation about killing seemed strange in retrospect. Grossman's fuller answer was: 'I can't tell one way from the other anymore. I've been confused for years.' The existing record captured his earlier answer that he was 'blown away' after the PI told him Kouri killed Eric; this captures his overall state of mind at trial.
Eric's limited prescription drug history confirmed by O'Driscoll — no fentanyl prescriptions found
Det. O'Driscoll testified during Day 13 that he reviewed Eric Richins' prescription drug history as part of his investigation and found it was 'limited.' No fentanyl was prescribed to Eric at any time. O'Driscoll also found texts between Eric and Kouri about THC gummy use from November 20, 2021. Confirmed via KSL, Deseret, and East Idaho News Day 13 coverage.
Defense zero-witness decision drew immediate divided reaction inside and outside courtroom
KUTV reported that the defense's decision to rest without calling witnesses 'quickly sparked debate both inside and outside the courtroom.' Some observers argued the move suggests prosecutors failed to prove their case beyond a reasonable doubt, while others said it could make the defendant appear guilty to jurors. Online reaction was similarly divided, with social media comments reflecting both perspectives.
Defense opening — photo of empty pill bottle on Eric's nightstand shown to jury
During defense opening statements on Day 1 (February 23, 2026), attorney Kathy Nester showed jurors a photo of the empty pill bottle sitting on Eric Richins' bedside table the night of his death, along with bags of THC gummies Eric was known to use regularly. Nester argued Eric had asked Kouri to procure opioids for him. This supplements the existing defense opening statement record — the photo of the pill bottle shown to jurors as a visual exhibit had not previously been captured.
Katie Richins-Benson testimony — mother was a drug and alcohol counselor; family raised to avoid drugs
Katie Richins-Benson testified on Day 1 that the Richins siblings' mother was a drug and alcohol counselor who had instilled in them from an early age the dangers of drug use. This was presented in response to the defense's opening narrative that Eric Richins was addicted to painkillers and may have overdosed. This detail was not previously captured in the existing Day 1 testimony record.
Prosecution closing argument — Bloodworth's 'black widow' framing and curative instruction
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth stated the 911 call was 'not the sound of a wife becoming a widow — it's the sound of a wife becoming a black widow,' referencing Chelsea Barney's description of Kouri from a recorded phone call. Defense attorney Nester moved for a mistrial on grounds this dehumanized the defendant; Judge Mrazik denied the mistrial but issued a curative instruction telling jurors they may consider their own observations of Kouri's demeanor but may NOT consider Bloodworth's characterization of her demeanor.
Prosecution closing — CPR delay countdown clock; '6 minutes' before CPR began
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth showed jurors a countdown clock while replaying the 911 call, visually demonstrating that approximately 6 minutes elapsed from when the dispatcher first asked Kouri to perform CPR to when she said she started. Bloodworth argued: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' He also argued Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the call ('I can't move it'), which he characterized as dehumanizing.
Prosecution closing — lemon drop shot; fentanyl ingestion mechanism theory
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth explicitly argued for the first time in front of the jury that Kouri used 'the Moscow mule and a shot' to get Eric to ingest the drugs. He stated: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He used this to explain why the Valentine's Day sandwich attempt failed but the night of March 3-4 succeeded: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric knew something was wrong, it was in his body.'
Prosecution closing — Kouri's debt 'nearing $8 million'; IRS calls two days before Eric died
In closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth cited Kouri's debt as 'nearing $8 million' at the time of Eric's death. He also disclosed that Kouri had called the IRS twice in the three days before the alleged attempt to murder Eric on Valentine's Day, and again 'two days before Eric Richins died.' He argued she 'needed cash immediately' to close on the Midway mansion on March 4.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's Orange Notebook inconsistency: drinks in bedroom vs. kitchen
In closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth pointed out a specific inconsistency in Kouri's orange notebook: she wrote that she and Eric had their celebratory drink 'in the bedroom,' but other accounts (and the prosecution's theory) indicate they were made in the kitchen. He also noted the notebook placed Eric as still being on the phone when she went to her son's room at 9:30-9:45 p.m., but Eric's phone activity records showed he was off the phone before 9 p.m.
Defense closing — Lewis's personal widowhood disclosure
During defense closing arguments, attorney Wendy Lewis disclosed that she herself had been unexpectedly widowed when she 'was not much older than Kouri' and had two young children. She used this personal disclosure to argue against judging Kouri's grief: 'If I learned one thing during this trial, I learned I didn't grieve right. They want you to look at a woman during the worst moment of her life and to judge her. There is no wrong way to grieve.'
Defense closing — 'if fentanyl accidentally obtained and Eric took voluntarily, not aggravated murder' argument
Defense attorney Wendy Lewis made a specific legal argument in closing: 'If after looking at all the evidence you believe Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric took those pills voluntarily and died, that is not aggravated murder, and you must find her not guilty.' She also argued: 'If Kouri was as motivated by money as they would have you think, would she really have killed her wealthy husband to run off with a handyman who lived for free in one of her houses? Eric was worth so much more to Kouri alive than dead.'
Jury composition clarification — 6 men and 2 women deliberated (not 6/6 split)
When Judge Mrazik excused the jury to deliberate on Day 15, he noted that 4 women were the alternates who left. The deliberating jury of 8 consisted of 6 men and 2 women. Previously the trial record noted the full 12-person jury as 6 men and 6 women — this clarifies that after alternates were removed, the 8-person deliberating panel was 6 men and 2 women.
Juror note — factual stipulation missing from jury room materials
As jurors were walking out to begin deliberations on Day 15, the bailiff received a note from Juror No. 2 stating they thought jurors were supposed to receive a hard copy containing a factual stipulation. Judge Mrazik went back on the record to address this, and the stipulation of fact was subsequently included with materials sent to the jury room.
Bloodworth closing — Kouri 'feigned ignorance' with Dr. Christensen; 'has a master's degree'
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth argued that when Kouri called the medical examiner's office and asked about quetiapine as if she didn't know what it was, she was 'feigning ignorance with Dr. Christensen' and 'fishing for information to craft her defense.' He stated: 'She has a master's degree' — using this to rebut any suggestion Kouri didn't understand the drug found in Eric's system that was prescribed to her.
Bloodworth closing — 'She's covering up' re: Kouri telling Gene Richins Eric died from COVID and lung fungus
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth referenced the testimony that Kouri told Eric's father Gene that Eric died from COVID and a fungal lung infection (the same condition Eric's mother had died from). Bloodworth stated: 'That is not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.'
Prosecution closing — Kouri's signature on Mirror Lake Diner receipt described as 'one pen stroke'
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth pointed to the receipt from Mirror Lake Diner (where prosecution alleges Kouri picked up the Valentine's Day sandwich) and highlighted that Kouri's signature on the receipt was 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' This was presented as identifying evidence connecting Kouri to the Valentine's Day food pickup.
Prosecution closing — Celebration of Life video shown again during rebuttal
During the prosecution's rebuttal closing, Prosecutor Bloodworth showed the Celebration of Life video (of adults joking and drinking at the Richins home the night after Eric died) alongside a photo of Kouri's book cover and a photo of Kouri on 'Good Things Utah.' He stated 'People grieve differently' sarcastically before showing these images — his argument being that Kouri's behavior after Eric's death was inconsistent with genuine grief.
Defense closing — 'Walk the Dog letter never went to anyone; nothing more than thoughts on paper'
Defense attorney Lewis addressed the Walk the Dog letter in closing arguments, stating: 'There were several things in the letter that were true and the letter never went to anyone. So it was nothing more than thoughts on paper.' This was the defense's closing characterization of the letter — not explicitly raising the 'fictional manuscript' theory that had been anticipated, but arguing the letter's non-delivery negated its significance as evidence of consciousness of guilt.
Both families received 24 wristbands each for closing arguments
Per the East Idaho News Day 15 live blog, Kouri Richins' family received 24 wristbands to attend closing arguments, and Eric Richins' family also received 24 wristbands. Ten journalists were in the front row, filling the courtroom. This supplements the existing record showing both families received two rows of seating under the amended decorum order.
Verdict — Guilty on all five counts; sentencing scheduled May 13, 2026
On March 16, 2026, after approximately three hours of deliberation, the jury returned a unanimous verdict finding Kouri Richins GUILTY on all five counts: aggravated murder, attempted aggravated murder, two counts of insurance fraud, and forgery. Kouri Richins lowered her head and remained still as the judge read each verdict. She was wearing a floral blouse. Sentencing was scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 11:30 a.m. The maximum sentence for aggravated murder is life in prison without parole; the charge carries 25 years to life.
Prosecution closing argument — lemon drop shot theory for fentanyl administration
In closing arguments on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth for the first time explicitly argued that Kouri administered fentanyl to Eric via a lemon drop shot (in addition to the Moscow mule). He said: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis pushed back: 'There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.' This is the prosecution's closing-argument theory on the method of administration — not new physical evidence, but a new explicit prosecutorial claim.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's orange notebook inconsistency: celebratory drink in bedroom, not kitchen
Bloodworth pointed out during closing arguments that Kouri's orange notebook journal entry states she and Eric had their celebratory drink in the bedroom — not the kitchen, as other accounts suggest. Bloodworth said: 'In Kouri Richins' mind, that's when the incident started — with the Moscow mules.' He also noted that in the notebook Kouri said Eric was on the phone when she went to their son's room around 9:30-9:45 p.m., but Eric's phone activity shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m. — an inconsistency Bloodworth argued proved Kouri's story was fabricated.
Prosecution closing — GIFs accessed 'exact minute deputies signed log out of house'
Bloodworth argued during closing that the three money-themed GIFs were accessed on Kouri's phone 'at 8:29 — the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house' — and that whoever accessed them 'turned the phone this way to view them better.' He also argued there was no evidence Eric sent those GIFs, distinguishing them from the Midway mansion photo Eric sent the night before which was also accessed at 8:29 a.m.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's signature on Mirror Lake Diner receipt: 'one pen stroke, doesn't lift the pen'
Bloodworth pointed to a distinctive characteristic of Kouri's signature on the Mirror Lake Diner receipt from Valentine's Day 2022: 'Her signature is one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' This was used to link Kouri to the Valentine's Day sandwich order placed under the name 'Corey.'
Prosecution closing — Kouri called IRS twice in three days before Valentine's Day attempted murder
Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that two days before Eric Richins died, Kouri spent time on the phone with the IRS. He also referenced that she called the IRS twice in three days before the Valentine's Day attempted murder. This was presented as context for her financial desperation and planning.
Fox News — Eric Richins' gastric fluid quetiapine level: 16,000 ng/ml
Fox News' verdict article disclosed a previously unreported specific figure: Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine (an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid that was prescribed to Kouri Richins). This specific gastric fluid quetiapine level had not been reported in prior trial coverage.
Defense closing — admitted opening statement claims that didn't materialize at trial
During closing arguments, defense attorney Lewis acknowledged: 'We said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial, but strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' This was an explicit concession that the defense's promised evidence (e.g., the expert witness on 'Red Devils') was not ultimately presented.
Courtroom attendance — each family received 24 wristbands for closing arguments/verdict
East Idaho News reported that both Kouri Richins' family and Eric Richins' family each received 24 wristbands to attend the Day 15 proceedings. Ten journalists were on the front row. The courtroom was described as packed.
Prosecution closing — lemon drop shot as second fentanyl delivery vehicle
In closing arguments on Day 15 (March 16, 2026), Prosecutor Bloodworth argued for the first time in full detail that Kouri used BOTH the Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot to administer fentanyl to Eric. He said: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Kouri's orange notebook writings about the night of March 3 had referenced both drinks; Bloodworth used those writings against her. Defense attorney Lewis responded that this was 'argument, not evidence' and that the prosecution waited until closing to assert this theory without evidentiary support.
Orange notebook — additional inconsistency identified in closing: Eric's phone activity vs. Kouri's written account
During prosecution closing arguments on Day 15, Bloodworth identified a specific inconsistency in the orange notebook: Kouri wrote that Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's bedroom around 9:30–9:45 p.m. on March 3, 2022. However, Eric's phone activity data shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m. Bloodworth used this to argue Kouri's account was fabricated. A separate inconsistency: Kouri wrote they had the celebratory drink in the bedroom, but other evidence indicates it was made in the kitchen.
TruStage insurance application — incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins
In closing arguments on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth stated that the $100,000 TruStage (CMFG) life insurance application contained errors including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins. This supplements prior evidence about the forgery count — previously the record only noted that Throckmorton concluded the signature was 'a simulated forgery'; the SSN error adds an additional indicator that Eric was not the applicant.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's phone accessed at 8:29 a.m. 'the exact minute deputies signed the log out of the house'
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated in closing arguments that the three money-themed GIFs were accessed on Kouri's phone at 8:29 a.m. on March 4, 2022 — 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.' Bloodworth argued: 'Whoever accessed them turned the phone this way to view them better.' He distinguished the Midway mansion photo accessed at that time from the photo Eric had sent the previous night, arguing it was a different image.
Verdict — Kouri Richins found guilty on all five counts
On March 16, 2026, the eight-member Summit County jury (six men, two women) unanimously found Kouri Richins guilty on all five felony counts: (1) Aggravated murder (1st degree felony); (2) Attempted aggravated murder (1st degree felony); (3) Insurance fraud (2nd degree felony); (4) Insurance fraud (2nd degree felony); (5) Forgery (3rd degree felony). The jury deliberated for approximately three hours before reaching the verdict. Sentencing is scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m.
Slayer statute civil case — Eric Richins' family pursuing claims against Kouri
KPCW reported after the verdict that Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri Richins in civil court under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which bars a person from inheriting property from someone they killed. This civil case runs parallel to the criminal conviction.
Prosecution closing argument — 'black widow' statement and CPR countdown clock
During prosecution closing arguments on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth replayed the first minute of Kouri's 911 call while displaying a countdown clock showing it took six minutes from when the dispatcher told Kouri to begin CPR to when she said she started. Bloodworth stated: 'It was not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It was the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' The 'black widow' phrase derived from Chelsea Barney's recorded phone call with Bryce Knudsen, per Bloodworth's clarification during the fourth mistrial motion. CPR clock stopped at 5 minutes 56 seconds. The defense filed a mistrial motion over this phrase; Judge Mrazik denied it and issued a special instruction for jurors to rely on their own observations of Kouri's demeanor rather than the prosecutor's characterization.
Prosecution closing — Kouri told Eric's father he died of 'COVID and a lung fungus'
During closing arguments, Bloodworth stated that Kouri told Eric's father (Gene Richins) that Eric died from COVID and a fungal lung infection — the same disease Eric's mother died from. Bloodworth called this 'not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.' This supplements the existing Day 1 testimony in which Gene Richins described Kouri telling him the medical examiner attributed the death to a fungal lung infection and COVID; the closing argument framing specifically identifies it as a cover-up tactic directed at the father.
Prosecution closing — Kouri called IRS twice in three days before Valentine's Day 2022 attempted poisoning
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that two days before Eric Richins died (i.e., approximately March 2, 2022), Kouri spent time on the phone with the IRS. He also disclosed she called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric on Valentine's Day. This suggests financial urgency in the days before both alleged poisoning attempts and had not been specifically highlighted in prior trial coverage.
Defense closing — fentanyl toxicologist's 'previous use' statement raised; no alcohol in Eric's body
During defense closing arguments, Wendy Lewis referenced the forensic toxicologist's acknowledgment that fentanyl found in Eric Richins' system 'could have been left over from a previous use.' Lewis also argued there was no alcohol in Eric's body — contending this undermines the prosecution's theory that fentanyl was placed in the Moscow mule or lemon drop shot, since there would be ethanol present if he had consumed a cocktail. (Note: The toxicology report confirmed ethanol was found at a low level — this is the defense's characterization in closing argument.)
Utah 'slayer statute' — Richins family pursuing civil claims post-verdict
Following the guilty verdict, KPCW reported that in civil court, the Richins family is pursuing claims against Kouri Richins under Utah's 'slayer statute,' a law that bars an individual from inheriting property from someone they killed. This civil litigation was ongoing alongside the criminal trial and remains unresolved.
Fox News — Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine
Fox News' verdict article disclosed that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine (an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid), in addition to the lethal fentanyl levels. This supplements existing records of quetiapine being found in Eric's system at a sub-therapeutic blood level; the gastric fluid concentration figure had not previously been specified in the case record.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's signature described as 'one pen stroke' on Mirror Lake Diner receipt
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth specifically noted that on the Mirror Lake Diner receipt from Valentine's Day 2022, Kouri's signature is 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' This was used to connect Kouri to the receipt and to the purchase of the sandwich prosecutors allege she laced with fentanyl.
Defense closing — Nancy Peterson drove one way to drug pickup (Lauber inconsistency)
During defense closing arguments, Wendy Lewis pointed to a specific inconsistency in Carmen Lauber's testimony: Lauber initially said Nancy Peterson drove her to pick up the drugs, but then said she actually drove one way. This was presented as one of several examples of Lauber being 'not a truthful person.'
Prosecution closing — orange notebook inconsistencies identified
During closing arguments, Bloodworth pointed to specific inconsistencies in Kouri Richins' orange notebook journal: (1) the notebook states the celebratory drinks were had in the bedroom, not the kitchen; (2) the notebook states Eric was on the phone when Kouri went to her son's room around 9:30-9:45 p.m., but cell phone records show Eric was off the phone before 9 p.m. Bloodworth argued: 'When people make up stories, they are inconsistent in the retelling.'
Prosecution closing — lemon drop shot and Moscow mule theory explicitly stated
For the first time explicitly stated in closing argument, Bloodworth argued that Kouri used both the Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot to administer the fatal fentanyl dose. He argued that Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Bloodworth cited Kouri's own orange notebook as evidence that both drinks were consumed. Defense attorney Lewis responded: 'There was no evidence — none — that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink. That was argument. Argument is not evidence.'
Prosecution closing — Eric's phone inactive for 87 minutes on Valentine's Day
Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that all activity on Eric Richins' phone ceased for 87 minutes in the middle of a busy workday after he ate the Valentine's Day sandwich. Shortly after activity resumed, he called Cody Wright, who heard fear in his voice. This specific 87-minute gap was not previously captured in the trial record.
Prosecution closing — Kouri called IRS twice in three days before Valentine's Day attempt
Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that Kouri Richins called the IRS twice in the three days before the alleged Valentine's Day 2022 poisoning attempt on Eric. He argued this showed her attention to Eric's finances immediately before the attempt. This specific detail about IRS calls had not been previously captured in trial testimony coverage.
Prosecution closing — GIFs accessed 'the exact minute' deputies signed log out of house
Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that the three money-themed GIFs were accessed on Kouri's phone at 8:29 a.m. on March 4, 2022 — 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.' He also argued that whoever accessed them 'turned the phone this way to view them better.' Bloodworth stated there was 'no evidence Eric sent these messages' (the GIFs).
Fox News reporting — Eric's gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine
Fox News reported that authorities said Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine, an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid, in addition to the fatal fentanyl level. Previously only noted as 'sub-therapeutic level' in blood; this is the first reported specific gastric fluid quetiapine measurement.
Defense closing — Kouri's text to Chelsea Barney about saving Eric ('I tried so f****** hard')
Bloodworth quoted in his closing rebuttal a self-serving text message Kouri sent to Chelsea Barney after Eric's death, in which Kouri wrote: 'I tried so f****** hard to save him. His lifeless body on my bedroom floor. I pumped so damn hard, so hard, screaming at him to come back to life that I needed him.' Bloodworth argued: 'None of that happened, and she's covering up her involvement in murdering Eric Richins.' This specific text content had not been previously captured in trial testimony records.
Verdict form — financial benefit aggravator confirmed by jury
The verdict form in the Kouri Richins trial shows jurors unanimously agreed that both the murder (Count 1) and the attempted murder (Count 2) of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. This was the aggravating circumstance that elevated the charges to aggravated murder and attempted aggravated murder. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted: 'The money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Fourth mistrial motion — 'black widow' comment; denied by Judge Mrazik
Immediately after Bloodworth's closing argument concluded, defense attorney Kathryn Nester filed a fourth mistrial motion arguing Bloodworth: (1) dehumanized Kouri by calling her a 'black widow'; (2) improperly commented on her demeanor during trial in a way that constituted commentary on her failure to testify; (3) engaged in 'wild speculation' about her mental state. Judge Mrazik denied the motion, finding the 'black widow' comment referred to a woman who kills her husband (not a spider comparison), that Utah courts have addressed demeanor observation arguments, and that he would give a curative instruction. Mrazik added a special jury instruction that jurors must rely on their own observations of the defendant's demeanor, not the prosecutor's characterizations.
Orange notebook — lemon drop shot reference; couple drank both Moscow mule AND lemon drop shot night Eric died
CNN's closing argument coverage confirmed that Kouri's writings found in the family home (the orange notebook) indicate the couple drank both a Moscow Mule cocktail AND a lemon drop shot the night Eric died — not just the Moscow mule as previously understood. Bloodworth used this in closing: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' This supplements the existing orange notebook evidence entry.
Eric Richins' obituary highlights — read into record by EastIdaho on Day 8 (anniversary of Eric's death)
On Day 8 (March 4, 2026, the fourth anniversary of Eric Richins' death), EastIdaho News published key highlights from Eric Richins' obituary in the live blog: He lived to the fullest with few regrets; loved his family, hunting, the family cattle ranch, and his drive as an entrepreneur; was an attentive and loving father; an avid outdoorsman and dedicated hunter; loved to have fun and was always the life of the party; served a two-year mission in Mexico City where he learned to speak Spanish fluently; 'loved fully, laughed loudly, and lived life with reckless abandon.' These details supplement the existing record about Eric's character.
Eric's taxaccount prepared by Greg White — identified as a Richins family member
During Brooke Karrington's Day 8 cross-examination (per EastIdaho Day 7/8 live blog — note: labeled Day 7 in eastidahonews.com but content is Day 8 financial testimony), defense attorney Nester established that Greg White, who prepared Kouri's taxes, is a Richins family member — a connection Karrington was unaware of. Nester also established that the family computer at the Richins home was a C&E laptop, which is likely how Kouri obtained C&E bank statements.
Kouri submitted six inaccurate/inconsistent bank statements to lenders — confirmed in closing
In his closing argument on Day 15, Bloodworth stated that Kouri submitted six inaccurate bank statements to lenders to obtain money — an evolution in which she showed inflated balances to secure loans. Bloodworth confirmed this was part of his financial distress narrative and noted it in the context of her overall fraudulent scheme to borrow money.
Karrington — email between Kouri and Matt Strong discussing 'inconvenience of being married'
During Karrington's cross-examination on Day 8 (per EastIdaho Day 7/8 live blog), Karrington mentioned an email between Kouri and Matt Strong (identified in context as a real estate/lending contact) in which they discussed 'the inconvenience of being married.' This was a detail that emerged during Nester's cross-examination of Karrington and was not previously captured in the case record.
Iron Bridge Financial loan — due Jan. 8, 2022; extended to March 8, 2022; remained unpaid
Forensic accountant Karrington testified (per EastIdaho Day 7/8 live blog) that Kouri had a loan from Iron Bridge Financial that was due January 8, 2022. Kouri did not make the payment and extended the loan by two weeks. During that period, she tried to get a new loan from Excel Financial (under Doreen Kouri's name as principal of K. Richins Realty). The Iron Bridge loan remained unpaid and was extended again to March 8, 2022 — four days after Eric died.
Kouri arrested at title company on May 2023 — borrowing $95,000 on the Barney home as collateral
Forensic accountant Karrington testified (per EastIdaho Day 7/8 live blog) that Kouri was arrested in May 2023 'coming out of the title company in which she borrowed $95,000 using the Barney home as collateral.' Chelsea Barney had given Kouri $45,000 (in January 2022) as a down payment on a home in Kouri's name. The deed was never properly recorded. When Kouri was arrested, she was in the process of taking out $95,000 against that property. This supplements the existing Chelsea Barney financial victimization evidence entry.
Verdict form — jury found financial benefit motive for both murder and attempted murder
CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez confirmed that the verdict form shows jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and the attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. This is a formal legal finding by the jury, separate from the general guilty verdict, establishing that the financial motive aggravator was proven beyond a reasonable doubt on both homicide counts.
Prosecution closing — lemon drop shot and Moscow mule as delivery vehicles
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth explicitly argued for the first time in summary form that Kouri used BOTH the lemon drop shot AND the Moscow mule to administer fentanyl to Eric: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' The prosecution also referenced writings by Kouri found in the family home indicating the couple drank a Moscow Mule AND a lemon drop shot the night Eric died.
Prosecution closing — six-minute CPR delay timer displayed to jury
During the prosecution's closing argument, Bloodworth displayed a countdown timer for the jury while replaying the 911 call, showing there were six minutes between when the dispatcher told Kouri to start CPR and when she said she had started doing so. This was used to argue Kouri was not attempting to save Eric's life.
Kouri's signature on Mirror Lake Diner receipt — 'one pen stroke, doesn't lift pen'
During Bloodworth's closing argument, he pointed out a specific detail about Kouri Richins' signature on the Mirror Lake Diner receipt from Valentine's Day 2022: her signature is one pen stroke and she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper. This was presented as consistent with a quick, purposeful action consistent with the prosecution's theory.
Eric's phone activity ceases 87 minutes on Valentine's Day after eating the sandwich
Prosecutor Bloodworth highlighted in closing arguments that all activity on Eric's phone ceased for 87 minutes in the middle of a busy workday after he ate the Valentine's Day sandwich. Shortly after activity resumed, he called Cody Wright — who heard fear in his voice. This detail was presented in closing arguments as corroboration of the attempted poisoning.
Fox News/AP confirmation — Eric's gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine
Fox News post-verdict article confirmed that authorities said Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid — in addition to the fatal dose of fentanyl. This specific numeric detail for the quetiapine level in Eric's gastric fluid had not previously been captured in the case record.
Defense closing — argued fentanyl was not in Eric's drink because no alcohol found in his system
During defense closing arguments, Lewis argued: 'The fentanyl was not put in a drink because there was no alcohol in Eric's body.' This represents the defense's specific scientific counter-argument to the prosecution's Moscow mule/lemon drop shot theory, based on the toxicology findings showing ethanol was not found at a significant level in Eric's system at the time of his death.
Defense closing — toxicologist acknowledged fentanyl could have been from a previous use
During defense closing arguments, Lewis reminded jurors that the toxicologist during trial testimony acknowledged the fentanyl found in Eric's system could have been left over from a previous use — not necessarily administered the night of his death. This was referenced as raising reasonable doubt about when and how Eric ingested the fentanyl.
Juror foreperson post-verdict account — deliberation process and children's book reaction
Juror No. 2 'Laura' (foreperson) told ABC News/GMA that the jury deliberated for just under three hours and there 'was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She said jurors felt they 'came into that deliberation fully loaded.' On the children's book evidence: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' She said jurors 'were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty' but could not conclude innocence.
Bloodworth closing — Kouri called IRS twice in three days before Valentine's Day attempted murder
Prosecutor Bloodworth highlighted in closing arguments that Kouri spent time on the phone with the IRS two days before Eric Richins died, and had called the IRS twice in the three days before the Valentine's Day attempted murder. This was presented as evidence of her focus on Eric's financial assets and planning for his death.
Verdict form — jury unanimously agreed both murder and attempted murder were for financial benefit
The verdict form in the Kouri Richins murder trial shows that the jury unanimously agreed both the aggravated murder and attempted aggravated murder were committed for financial benefit. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' This is the aggravating circumstance that elevates the charges.
Prosecution closing — 911 call timer showing 6-minute CPR delay
During closing arguments on Day 15, the prosecution replayed the 911 call with a timer displayed showing Kouri Richins waited six minutes before starting CPR on Eric. This was presented as evidence of her lack of urgency in responding to her husband's condition.
Defense closing — hydrocodone bottle residue argument
During closing arguments on Day 15, defense attorney Wendy Lewis specifically argued that the expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle on Eric's nightstand was never tested for fentanyl despite having residue in it, and suggested it could be a place to bring back illicit drugs from Mexico, where Eric had recently traveled. This supplements existing evidence entries about the bottle.
Eric Richins served a two-year mission in Mexico City — spoke Spanish fluently
Eric Richins' obituary detail published in the EastIdaho Day 8 live blog: Eric served a two-year mission in Mexico City where he learned to speak Spanish fluently. This is new biographical detail about the victim not previously in the evidence record.
Kouri Richins' phone — additional granular activity sequence (Day 6 live blog clarification)
EastIdaho Day 6 live blog confirms more granular phone activity sequence from Kotrodimos' testimony: At 3:06 a.m. on March 4, phone unlocked for 28 seconds. At 3:07 a.m., speaker activated. At 3:08 a.m., device travels 243 feet. At 3:10 a.m., phone unlocked for 1 minute 40 seconds. At 3:15 a.m., phone unlocked for 37 seconds. At 3:19 a.m., phone unlocked for 28 seconds, then again for 3 seconds. At 3:21 a.m., phone travels 135 feet. At 3:22 a.m., receiver activated. This is more granular than the existing record which captured only the broad sequence.
Eric Richins phone activity on Valentine's Day 2022 — 87-minute gap in activity
Kotrodimos testified (confirmed via EastIdaho Day 6 live blog) that Eric Richins' phone showed an 87-minute gap in activity between 12:05 p.m. and 1:32 p.m. on Valentine's Day 2022. Kotrodimos analyzed 20 random days of Eric's phone behavior and found this gap was atypical — it was not normal for Eric to have an 87-minute gap during the middle of the day. Prosecution used this to corroborate the allegation that Eric was incapacitated by the alleged poisoning attempt that afternoon.
Eric Richins phone — searched distance from Scottsdale to Nogales at 9:45 p.m. March 3, 2022
Kotrodimos' testimony (confirmed via EastIdaho Day 6 live blog) showed that on March 3, 2022 — the night before Eric died — Eric Richins searched 'how far from Scottsdale to Nogales' at 9:45 p.m. on his phone. At 10:13 p.m., Eric received a text from a contact named 'Raul' that was never opened or read. This is additional granular phone activity detail from the night before Eric's death.
Kouri Richins phoned Mirror Lake Diner at 8:53 p.m. on Valentine's Day 2022 — confirmed via Kotrodimos
EastIdaho Day 6 live blog confirms Kotrodimos testified that on February 14, 2022, at 8:53 p.m., Kouri Richins called the Mirror Lake Diner. The existing record captured the Mirror Lake Diner receipt (placed at 8:55 a.m.) separately. The 8:53 p.m. call on Valentine's Day evening is a distinct and separate communication from the morning order.
Eric Richins served a mission in Mexico City — contextual detail for Mexico/drug connection defense theory
Eric Richins' obituary (published in EastIdaho Day 8 live blog) notes he served a two-year mission in Mexico City and learned Spanish fluently. This contextualizes both his February 2022 hunting trip to Mexico and his phone's Google search for the distance from Utah to Sonora, Mexico shortly before his death — both of which the defense used to argue Eric could have obtained fentanyl independently.
Karrington testimony — Kouri had email with Matt Strong discussing 'inconvenience of being married'
During forensic accountant Brooke Karrington's cross-examination on Day 8 (confirmed via EastIdaho Day 7 live blog), Karrington mentioned there was an email between Kouri and a person named 'Matt Strong' in which they discussed 'the inconvenience of being married.' This detail was not previously captured in the existing evidence record.
Karrington testimony — Kouri arrested while coming out of title company having borrowed $95,000 using Barney home as collateral
EastIdaho Day 7 live blog confirms that Karrington testified Kouri was arrested in May 2023 specifically while coming out of a title company, at which point she had borrowed $95,000 using Chelsea Barney's home as collateral. The Barney home had previously been purchased for Chelsea using a $45,000 down payment Chelsea provided. The $95,000 unauthorized loan is additional financial fraud detail not previously captured.
Kouri's tax returns — Karrington found $400,000 in expenses omitted from all tax financial records
EastIdaho Day 7 live blog confirms Karrington testified that Kouri's tax returns were missing approximately $400,000 in loan obligations — leaving those expenses off all tax financial records. Karrington also found Greg White (Kouri's tax preparer) is a Richins family member, which Karrington was unaware of before being informed by defense attorney Nester.
C&E family computer — sent to Gabler before law enforcement, via Becky Lloyd
EastIdaho Day 7 live blog confirms Karrington testified that the family computer at the Richins home was a C&E laptop, and that Kouri got the C&E bank statements through that computer. This contextualizes how the computer ended up with Gabler (Cody Wright sent Becky Lloyd to pick it up and it went to Katie Richins-Benson then Gabler, as captured in the existing Day 11 record).
Verdict form — jurors unanimously agreed murders committed for financial benefit
The verdict form in the Kouri Richins trial confirmed that jurors unanimously agreed both the murder (Count 1) and the attempted murder (Count 2) were committed for financial benefit. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' This is an aggravating circumstance finding that is separate from the guilty verdicts themselves.
Eric Richins gastric fluid — 16,000 ng/ml quetiapine quantified
Fox News' post-verdict article confirmed that authorities said Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid that was prescribed to Kouri Richins. This is the first time a specific quantitative figure for quetiapine in the gastric fluid has been publicly reported; prior records noted only that quetiapine was found at a 'sub-therapeutic level' in blood.
Prosecution closing — 'lemon drop shot' theory first articulated publicly
During Bloodworth's closing argument, he articulated for the first time publicly that prosecutors believe Kouri administered fentanyl through BOTH the Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis responded: 'There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into the drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.' Writings by Kouri Richins found in the family home confirmed the couple drank both a Moscow Mule cocktail and a lemon drop shot.
Six-minute CPR delay timer shown to jury during closing arguments
During prosecution closing arguments, Bloodworth replayed the 911 call with a countdown timer displayed on screen showing that six minutes elapsed from when the dispatcher instructed Kouri to begin CPR until she said she started. The timer stopped at 5 minutes 56 seconds. Bloodworth argued this demonstrated Kouri was not immediately trying to revive Eric. Defense did not specifically rebut the timer during Lewis's closing.
Defense closing — alternative explanation for deleted messages and searches
Defense attorney Lewis argued in closing that Kouri may have deleted text messages because of the affair and drug purchases for Eric — 'You'd probably want that off your phone.' Lewis also argued that Kouri's web searches about fentanyl, prisons, and investigations were made after she learned her husband died of fentanyl and she feared being a suspect: 'even an innocent person would be worried that they are a suspect in a homicide investigation and would look up information about prisons.' Lewis also argued Kouri made a profit on each home she flipped and the foreclosures all occurred after her arrest.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's signature described: 'one pen stroke, doesn't lift the pen'
Bloodworth noted during closing arguments that Kouri's signature on the Mirror Lake Diner receipt for the Valentine's Day sandwich order 'is one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' This was presented as identification evidence linking Kouri to the sandwich pickup.
Utah 'slayer statute' — Eric's family pursuing civil claims
KPCW post-verdict reporting confirmed that Eric Richins' family is pursuing civil claims against Kouri Richins under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which bars a person from inheriting property from someone they killed. Kouri is also litigating property issues with Eric's family in civil court. These civil proceedings are separate from the criminal cases.
Karrington testimony confirmed — Kouri also made inaccurate tax filings overstating income
The EastIdaho Day 7-8 live blog (Karrington testimony) confirms additional details not previously captured: Karrington found Kouri's tax returns were 'incorrect' — she understated expenses and overstated net income to make the business look more profitable to attract lenders, but as a result actually overpaid taxes. An accurate return would have shown a loss in 2021. Karrington also noted Kouri had $70,000-$80,000 in state and federal tax liens (joint with Eric). The family home computer was a C&E laptop, which is likely how Kouri obtained C&E bank statements. Greg White (a Richins family member) prepared Kouri's taxes; Karrington was unaware of the family relationship.
Verdict form — financial benefit finding confirmed
The verdict form in the Kouri Richins trial confirmed that jurors unanimously agreed both the murder (Count 1) and the attempted murder (Count 2) of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. This was confirmed by CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez's review of the verdict form. The financial benefit finding is an aggravating factor under Utah law and was central to the prosecution's theory.
Prosecution closing — lemon drop shot named as second fentanyl delivery vehicle
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth explicitly named both the Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot as the vehicles through which Kouri Richins administered fentanyl to Eric. He stated Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day when a sandwich allowed Eric to notice something wrong before ingesting enough. The lemon drop shot was presented as a delivery method that would have worked too fast for Eric to notice. This is consistent with Kouri's own orange notebook mentioning both drinks but had not previously been explicitly argued as a dual-delivery theory.
911 call — CPR timer: approximately 6-minute delay shown in closing
During Bloodworth's closing argument, a countdown timer was displayed alongside the 911 call recording showing the elapsed time from when the dispatcher instructed Kouri to begin CPR to when she said she started. The timer showed approximately 6 minutes. Bloodworth also highlighted that Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the call — 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.' Fox 13 reported the timer displayed '5 minutes 56 seconds' as the CPR delay in prosecution's presentation.
Bloodworth closing — GIF timing precision: accessed 'exact minute deputies signed log out of house'
Prosecutor Bloodworth argued in closing that the three money-themed GIFs were accessed on Kouri's phone at 8:29 a.m. — 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house' after the initial March 4, 2022 scene investigation. He also argued that whoever accessed them 'turned the phone this way to view them better,' suggesting intentional viewing rather than accidental access. This provides the most precise framing yet of the prosecution's GIF timing argument.
Kouri's phone call to Mirror Lake Diner confirmed at 8:53 a.m. on Valentine's Day via phone records
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated in closing argument that cell phone records show Kouri called the Mirror Lake Diner at 8:53 a.m. on February 14, 2022 (Valentine's Day). The diner's own records showed a phone order placed at 8:55 a.m. under the name 'Corey.' The 2-minute discrepancy may reflect connection time vs. order time. This corroborates the prosecution's theory that Kouri placed the order for the sandwich allegedly laced with fentanyl.
Prosecution closing argument — lemon drop shot as secondary delivery vehicle for fentanyl
During closing arguments on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth argued for the first time in open court that the fentanyl was administered to Eric Richins via both the Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot. Bloodworth: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis immediately rebutted: 'There was no evidence — none — that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.' Kouri's orange notebook was cited by Bloodworth as evidence that both a Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot were consumed the night of Eric's death. The lemon drop shot had not been specifically identified as a potential delivery vehicle earlier in trial testimony.
Verdict form — jury unanimously found financial benefit as the aggravated circumstance for both murder and attempted murder
The verdict form confirmed jurors unanimously agreed that both the murder and the attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted: 'The money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' This is a specific finding on the aggravated circumstances beyond simply the guilty verdict on each count.
Bloodworth closing — Kouri's phone activity on night of Valentine's Day poisoning attempt: 87-minute gap in Eric's phone activity after eating sandwich
During Bloodworth's Day 15 closing argument, he stated that on Valentine's Day 2022, all activity on Eric's phone ceased for 87 minutes in the middle of a busy workday after he ate the sandwich. After activity resumed, he called Cody Wright — who testified he heard fear in Eric's voice. This specific 87-minute phone activity gap was presented as corroboration of the Valentine's Day poisoning attempt.
Bloodworth closing — IRS calls two days before Eric's death
During his Day 15 closing argument, Bloodworth stated Kouri spent time on the phone with the IRS two days before Eric Richins died (i.e., approximately March 2, 2022). He also noted she called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric on Valentine's Day. This specific detail about IRS contact was referenced as part of the pattern of Kouri's financial desperation.
Eric's total assets per estate planning intake form — $7.6 million listed
During Day 8 cross-examination of Kristal Bowman-Carter (confirmed in the EastIdaho Day 8 live blog), defense attorney Nester showed Bowman-Carter a summary of assets intake form which listed Eric's total assets at $7.6 million. This is distinct from the $4 million+ estate valuation cited in prosecution's opening statements, and likely reflects a gross assets figure including business interests before liabilities. Note: this detail emerged from the Day 8 live blog transcript included in the new articles.
Grossman cross-examination — Caribbean trip was for his birthday; they never went; relationship on-again, off-again
During defense cross-examination of Robert Josh Grossman on Day 9 (confirmed via EastIdaho Day 8 live blog which covered Day 9 testimony as well), Lewis established that the Vacation Express reservation to a Caribbean resort was booked by Kouri as a birthday present for Grossman, scheduled for April 29, 2022. They never went on the vacation. Grossman confirmed his relationship with Kouri was 'on-again and off-again over the years' and that between 2017 and when they became romantically involved, they had 2-3 years during which they didn't speak.
Bloodworth closing — Kouri's signature on credit card receipt at Mirror Lake Diner: 'one pen stroke, she doesn't lift the pen off the paper'
During Bloodworth's Day 15 closing argument, he displayed the Mirror Lake Diner receipt and noted that Kouri's signature on it was 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' He used this as a small detail corroborating Kouri as the person who picked up the Valentine's Day order.
Quetiapine in Eric's gastric fluid — 16,000 ng/mL confirmed by Fox News coverage
Fox News' verdict article specifically confirmed that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid — which was prescribed to Kouri Richins. This specific numerical level for quetiapine in the gastric fluid had not been previously captured in the evidence record.
Prosecution closing argument — lemon drop shot identified as second possible fentanyl delivery vehicle
In closing arguments on March 16, 2026, Prosecutor Bloodworth stated that writings found in the Richins home (Kouri's orange notebook) indicate the couple drank both a Moscow Mule cocktail AND a lemon drop shot the night Eric died. Bloodworth argued the lemon drop shot format made it harder to detect — 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' This is the first time the lemon drop shot was explicitly identified in closing as a likely delivery vehicle alongside the Moscow mule.
Verdict form — jury unanimously found financial benefit was the aggravating factor in both murder and attempted murder
The verdict form in the Kouri Richins case confirmed that the jury unanimously agreed both the aggravated murder and attempted aggravated murder were committed for financial benefit — the statutory aggravating circumstance required for the aggravated murder charge. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' This is distinct from the general guilty verdict and provides insight into which aggravating factor the jury found proven.
Prosecution closing — CPR timer displayed during 911 call replay; Kouri waited 6 minutes
During closing arguments on March 16, 2026, the state played the 911 call and displayed a countdown timer on the courtroom screen showing how long Kouri waited to give Eric CPR after being instructed by the dispatcher. The state showed Kouri waited approximately 6 minutes before starting CPR. The CPR time clock stopped at 5 minutes 56 seconds. Bloodworth argued she was 'not immediately trying to revive him' and was instead establishing her alibi narrative during the call.
Defense closing — hydrocodone bottle residue argument preserved for jury
In defense closing arguments on March 16, 2026, attorney Wendy Lewis explicitly argued that the expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle found on Eric's nightstand — which had residue but was never tested for fentanyl — 'could be a good place to bring back illicit drugs from Mexico.' Lewis noted: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' This was Lewis's closing articulation of the defense's Mexico/hydrocodone bottle theory, presented directly to the jury despite the court denying a 'lost evidence' instruction for the bottle.
Prosecution closing — Kouri booked Caribbean vacation for April 2022 in December 2021
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth argued that Kouri Richins booked the Caribbean vacation with Robert Josh Grossman in December 2021 — months before Eric's March 4, 2022 death — and that 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.' This timeline establishes that Bloodworth argued Kouri's intent to cause Eric's death predated even the Valentine's Day poisoning attempt.
Kouri orange notebook — additional entry: March 3, 2022 journal entry content (expanded detail)
The EastIdaho Day 12 live blog (Article 39) provides additional content from Kouri's orange notebook journal entry for March 3, 2022 — the night Eric died. The entry states: Eric was really upset about a hunting situation in Mexico; they had a celebratory drink and went to bed; she went to sleep with her son who wasn't feeling well; got into bed around 3 a.m.; Eric was cold; she nudged him and he didn't respond; he was pale/yellow and his mouth was open; she called 911; they told her to do CPR; she pulled him off the bed and started compressions; as EMTs did CPR, 'blood was squirting everywhere'; she screamed at them that they were doing it wrong; she sat in the corner rocking back and forth; an EMT asked her to leave; she paced in the living room and called her mom; the EMT told her Eric didn't make it; she ran to the bathroom and vomited; kids woke up and she yelled for them to stay in their rooms; Kouri's mom arrived; the EMT confirmed Eric was gone; she called Gene Richins around 3:45/4 a.m. and Gene answered 'so perky. It was very strange.' Bloodworth argued in closing that certain details in the notebook contradicted her other statements — she said in the notebook Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's room, but Eric's phone activity shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m.
Jail call — Kouri and Lisa Darden discussing the sandwich (August 22, 2023) — additional dialogue confirmed
The EastIdaho Day 12 live blog (Article 39) provides more complete dialogue from the August 22, 2023 jail call between Kouri and Lisa Darden played during O'Driscoll's testimony. In the call: Lisa asks who picked up the sandwiches from the diner — Kouri says she did. Lisa mentions a 'love letter put on the front seat with the sandwiches.' Lisa asks if the sandwiches were eaten in the office. Kouri says: 'I put a love note on a poisonous sandwich and put it in his car? What the hell?' and 'They are nuts.' Kouri says 'When people get up to testify and I say that was a lie, that did not happen, you can't compete with somebody who was actually there.' Lisa says 'That's enough of that.' A separate call from August 22, 2023 between Kouri and her brother DJ is also played — Kouri laughing; DJ says 'that's not at all what happened. Where did you get this bull****.' They discuss the Mirror Lake sandwiches and DJ says he has receipts to prove it. These additional dialogue details supplement the existing August 2023 jail call evidence entries.
Kouri text to Eric — January 31, 2022 exchange; 'Love you' and 'Gummy time' texts
During O'Driscoll's testimony (EastIdaho Day 12 live blog), text messages between Eric and Kouri from January 31, 2022 were shown to the jury. Eric asks if she wants to grab lunch; she says she can't but says 'celebratory shot tonight!!' Later, Eric offers to bring her soup and asks 'What do you want beautiful?' She tells him what she wants from Dairy Keen or Kneaders. Eric replies 'Gummy time?' and she says 'Yes!' These messages were presented showing a seemingly normal domestic relationship between the couple shortly before Eric's death.
Prosecution closing — Bloodworth argued Kouri 'feigned ignorance' about quetiapine in call with Dr. Christensen
In closing, Bloodworth argued that Kouri was prescribed quetiapine, it was found in Eric's system, and yet she pretended not to know what it was when speaking to Dr. Christensen. 'She feigns the ignorance,' Bloodworth said. 'She has a master's degree. In feigning ignorance with Dr. Christensen, she was fishing for information to craft her defense.' This supplements the existing evidence entry about the Kouri-Christensen phone call.
Prosecution closing — Eric's debt picture described as 'nearly $8 million' at time of Midway mansion closing
In closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth stated Kouri had 'a growing debt picture nearing $8 million' when she closed on the Midway mansion. He also noted that October 2021 was 'the beginning of the downward financial death spiral' of her realty business. A chart was shown to jurors showing Kouri had 'over $359,453 in overdraft charges' and 'nearly $8 million in debt when Kouri closed on the Midway mansion.' This supplements the existing forensic accountant testimony that cited approximately $7.5 million in debt.
Prosecution closing argument — 'black widow' 911 call framing with CPR timer
During closing arguments on Day 15, prosecutor Bloodworth replayed the 911 call and displayed a countdown timer showing Kouri waited six minutes from when the dispatcher told her to start CPR to when she said she began. Bloodworth stated: 'That is not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It's the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He also argued Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the call — 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
Prosecution closing — Midway mansion closing date argument
Bloodworth argued in closing that Kouri was supposed to close on the Midway mansion on March 4 but signed on March 5 — 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money... that's why she signed on the 5th.' He also argued she 'hedged' on the closing date deliberately. He stated Kouri had seven phone calls with a money lender on the day of Eric's death.
Verdict form — jurors unanimously agreed murder and attempted murder committed for financial benefit
Per CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez, who covered the trial closely, the verdict form showed jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. Casarez noted: 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Defense closing — Eric's orange notebook inconsistency argued
Defense attorney Lewis argued during closing that the orange notebook showed Kouri's story was internally inconsistent — she wrote Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's room around 9:30-9:45 p.m., but phone records showed Eric was off the phone before 9 p.m. Bloodworth used this same point to argue Kouri fabricated her account.
Defense closing — 2016 hydrocodone bottle with residue argued as possible drug transport container
Defense attorney Lewis argued in closing that the expired 2016 hydrocodone prescription bottle found on Eric's nightstand — which had residue but was never tested — could have been 'the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico' where Eric had traveled shortly before his death. This was raised as an alternative explanation the prosecution failed to investigate.
Closing argument — prosecution CPR timer: Kouri waited 6 minutes before starting CPR on Eric
During Bloodworth's closing argument on Day 15, the prosecution displayed a countdown clock while replaying the 911 call to show jurors that Kouri waited 6 minutes from when the 911 dispatcher first told her to perform CPR to when she said she started. Bloodworth stated: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' The timer was displayed on screen for the courtroom.
Closing argument — Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during 911 call
Prosecutor Bloodworth highlighted during closing arguments that during the 911 call, Kouri Richins referred to Eric as 'it' — specifically 'I can't move it' — rather than 'him.' Bloodworth stated: 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.' This was presented as evidence of Kouri's state of mind.
Verdict form — jury found both murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit
CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez confirmed that the verdict form showed jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and the attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. This indicates the jury specifically found and agreed on the financial motive aggravator for both the murder and attempted murder counts.
Closing argument — lemon drop shot detail confirmed by prosecution
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that Kouri used both the Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot to administer the fentanyl: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' He also stated that writings by Kouri found in the family home (orange notebook) confirmed both a Moscow Mule and a lemon drop shot were consumed the night of Eric's death.
Eric Richins' gastric fluid — 16,000 ng/mL quetiapine confirmed by Fox News
Fox News reported that authorities said Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine, an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid — which was prescribed to Kouri Richins. This specific gastric fluid concentration was not previously captured in the evidence record.
Defense closing — specific arguments about Walk the Dog letter, hydrocodone bottle, GIFs, and internet searches
Defense attorney Wendy Lewis made the following specific arguments in closing: (1) The Walk the Dog letter 'never went to anyone — it was nothing more than thoughts on paper'; (2) The expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle with residue on Eric's nightstand was never tested and could have been used to bring illegal pills back from Mexico; (3) The GIFs were accessed at the same time as a photo of the Midway mansion Eric had sent, suggesting they were all from the night before not celebratory; (4) Internet searches about fentanyl, prisons, etc. were the result of Kouri learning her husband died of fentanyl and being scared as an innocent suspect; (5) 'There is no evidence — none — that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink'; (6) She argued Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive' financially.
Prosecution closing — 'lemon drop shot' theory for fentanyl delivery method confirmed
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth for the first time explicitly argued that Kouri may have administered fentanyl to Eric via a lemon drop shot in addition to the Moscow mule: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis objected in her closing that Bloodworth 'waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink, without any evidence to back that up. That was argument. Argument is not evidence.' Bloodworth had not previously named the lemon drop shot as a delivery vehicle during witness testimony. Kouri's orange notebook referenced the couple drinking a Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot on the night of March 3, 2022.
Prosecution closing — CPR delay timer displayed to jury
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth replayed the 911 call with a countdown timer on screen showing the time that elapsed from when the dispatcher first instructed Kouri to begin CPR to when she said she started — approximately 6 minutes. Bloodworth argued: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' He also noted Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the call.
Insurance application error — incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins
CNN reported that the application for the $100,000 TruStage life insurance policy (the one at issue in the forgery count) contained errors, including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins. An insurance agent testified to this at trial. This detail was not previously captured in the case record.
Defense closing — dried residue in hydrocodone bottle raised as possible Mexico drug container
During defense closing arguments, attorney Wendy Lewis raised the empty 2016 hydrocodone bottle found on Eric's nightstand and suggested: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis argued the bottle — which was never tested for fentanyl residue — could have been used to transport illicit drugs from Eric's Mexico trip. She said it had 'residue in it' per crime scene photos. This is a more explicit articulation of the defense theory regarding the bottle than previously captured.
Kouri's childhood background — disclosed in Bloodworth closing from 'life story' document
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth described Kouri Richins' background: her father went to prison and her mother was an alcoholic. He argued she sought to distance herself from this by appearing 'privileged, affluent and successful.' This is consistent with the 'life story' document from the Sedona retreat admitted into evidence, which referenced her father's imprisonment and mother's gambling addiction — but in closing, Bloodworth specifically characterized the mother as an 'alcoholic' rather than a 'compulsive gambler' as stated in the retreat document. The exact characterization should be treated with care; the Sedona document referenced 'compulsive gambler.'
Verdict form — jury found financial benefit as aggravating circumstance
The jury's verdict form confirmed jurors unanimously found that both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' This is the specific aggravating circumstance that elevates the charges to aggravated murder.
Eric Richins gastric fluid — 16,000 ng/ml quetiapine confirmed
Fox News post-verdict reporting confirmed that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine, an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid, which was prescribed to Kouri Richins. This is the first time the specific quetiapine level in gastric fluid has been publicly reported; prior reporting only noted 'sub-therapeutic level' in blood.
Defense motion to appoint counsel for Lisa Darden — sealed court filing
Post-verdict Fox News reporting confirmed that defense attorneys filed a motion (apparently before or during trial) requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother), which the state objected to. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed by the court. The defense renewed the effort in December 2025, with portions made public. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense sought court-appointed attorneys for Darden and several other potential witnesses. This suggests Darden could face legal exposure if called as a witness at the sentencing or in other proceedings.
Prosecution closing argument — lemon drop shot and Moscow mule theory of administration
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth for the first time explicitly stated his theory of how fentanyl was administered: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He argued Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day — the sandwich allowed Eric to notice something was wrong — and switched to drinks. Defense attorney Lewis responded: 'There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into the drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.' CNN also confirmed that writings by Kouri Richins found in the family home indicate the couple drank a Moscow Mule cocktail AND a lemon drop shot the night of Eric's death.
Kouri Richins had 7 phone calls with a money lender on the day of Eric's death
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated in closing arguments that Kouri had seven phone calls with a money lender on the day of Eric's death (March 4, 2022), emphasizing the immediacy of her financial desperation. Previously recorded only as general financial distress evidence.
Orange notebook inconsistency — Eric's phone activity vs. Kouri's account
Bloodworth pointed out in closing arguments that in Kouri's orange notebook, she wrote that Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's bedroom around 9:30-9:45 p.m. on the night of March 3, 2022. However, Eric's phone activity data shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m. — creating an inconsistency Bloodworth called part of a 'fake story.' 'When people make up stories, they are inconsistent in the retelling.'
Kouri told Eric's father Eric died from COVID and a lung fungus
Bloodworth referenced in closing arguments that Kouri told Eric's father Gene that Eric died of COVID and a lung fungus — the same illness Eric's mother had died from. Bloodworth called this 'not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.' This supplements the existing Day 1 record entry about Gene Richins' testimony that Kouri told him the ME said Eric died of a fungal lung infection and COVID, adding prosecutorial framing of deliberate cruelty.
Eric Richins' estate subject to Utah 'slayer statute' civil action by family
KPCW post-verdict reporting confirmed that Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri Richins under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which makes it illegal to inherit property from the person they killed. This civil litigation is separate from the criminal sentencing and the pending 26-count financial crimes case.
Closing argument — prosecution detailed the Valentine's Day poisoning theory with Moscow mule and lemon drop shot
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth explicitly argued for the first time to the jury that Kouri administered fentanyl in both a Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot on the night of March 3, 2022: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' He also argued Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day, when Eric could tell something was wrong with the sandwich and set it aside. Defense attorney Lewis responded: 'There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into the drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up. That was argument. Argument is not evidence.'
Verdict form — jury unanimously found murder committed for pecuniary gain and by administration of lethal substance
The verdict form confirmed that the 8-member jury unanimously agreed beyond a reasonable doubt on two specific aggravating circumstances: (1) 'The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain' and (2) 'The homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Prosecution closing — IRS phone calls two days before Eric's death
Prosecutor Bloodworth disclosed in closing argument that Kouri made phone calls to the IRS twice in three days before Eric Richins died — suggesting she was dealing with debt-related financial pressure in the final days before his murder. This detail was referenced in the EastIdaho live blog of Day 15 closing arguments and had not been previously highlighted in testimony coverage.
Defense closing — argued lemon drop shot 'no alcohol in Eric's body' theory
Defense attorney Lewis argued in closing that fentanyl was not put in a drink because 'there was no alcohol in Eric's body.' The toxicology found only small amounts of ethanol. Lewis argued the state's drink-spiking theory was invented for closing arguments without evidentiary support. This supplements prior evidence about the toxicology findings.
TruStage insurance application — incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins noted
CNN's post-verdict article confirmed that the application for the $100,000 TruStage/CMFG life insurance policy included an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins — a detail established during insurance agent testimony at trial. This supplements the existing evidence about the forgery/insurance fraud counts and was referenced in Bloodworth's closing argument.
Defense closing — argued Eric's orange notebook account inconsistencies (drink location and Eric's phone activity)
Defense attorney Lewis pointed out in closing that Kouri's orange notebook states the celebratory drink was consumed in the bedroom — inconsistent with prosecution's theory the Moscow mule was made in the kitchen. Lewis also raised that Kouri's notebook says Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's room at 9:30-9:45 p.m., but Eric's phone activity showed he was off the phone before 9 p.m. Lewis used these details to argue the notebook was 'self-serving.' Prosecution countered these same inconsistencies to argue Kouri's story was fabricated.
Eric Richins obituary details — two-year Mexico mission; served cattle ranch; avid outdoorsman
EastIdaho live blog of Day 8 (March 4, 2026) included Eric Richins' obituary summary read at the start of coverage on the 4th anniversary of his death: Eric served a two-year mission in Mexico City where he learned to speak Spanish fluently; he loved hunting, the family cattle ranch, hauling hay, feeding animals, and mending fences; he loved his family and was an attentive father; he served as 'the life of the party'; he 'loved fully, laughed loudly, and lived life with reckless abandon.' This provides additional biographical detail about the victim not previously captured in the case record.
Prosecution closing argument — lemon drop shot and Moscow mule as delivery mechanism
In closing arguments on March 16, 2026, prosecutor Bloodworth explicitly argued for the first time in closing that Kouri Richins used BOTH a lemon drop shot AND a Moscow mule to administer the fatal fentanyl to Eric: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He argued the Valentine's Day sandwich attempt failed because Eric could taste something was wrong and set it aside, but 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis challenged this in her closing: 'There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.' The orange notebook, which Kouri authored, reportedly references both a Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot the night of Eric's death — Bloodworth cited this as confirming both drinks were consumed.
Verdict form — jury found homicide committed for pecuniary gain and by lethal substance administration
The verdict form read aloud by Judge Mrazik confirmed jurors unanimously agreed on two aggravating circumstances beyond a reasonable doubt: (1) the homicide was committed for pecuniary gain; and (2) the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity. CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Defense closing — fentanyl not in drink because no alcohol in Eric's toxicology
Defense attorney Wendy Lewis argued in her March 16 closing argument that the state's theory that fentanyl was put in Eric's drink is disproven by his toxicology: 'The fentanyl was not put in a drink because there was no alcohol in Eric's body.' She also raised that 90-120 oxycodone pills from the Lauber purchases were never found or tested, and argued the investigation was driven by confirmation bias — 'working backwards from a conclusion.'
Prosecution closing — Kouri spent time on phone with IRS two days before Eric died; called Mirror Lake Diner the day of Valentine's Day attempt
Bloodworth noted in his March 16 closing that two days before Eric died (March 2, 2022), Kouri spent time on the phone with the IRS. He also noted she called the Mirror Lake Diner to order 'the potentially fatal sandwich' on Valentine's Day and pointed out her signature on the receipt was 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' These details were presented as part of the prosecution's circumstantial timeline.
Prosecution closing — Bloodworth argued Kouri's 'narcissistic injury' visible during Karrington testimony
Bloodworth told jurors during his closing argument that they could observe Kouri's demeanor during different witnesses and noted: 'You observed that when Brooke Karrington testified about the financial distress of her business, she was exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury. She was bothered because the world saw she is indeed not a success and not affluent.' This was one of the demeanor comments that led to the defense's fourth mistrial motion.
Motion for mistrial No. 4 — filed during Day 15 closing arguments, denied
Defense attorney Kathryn Nester filed the fourth mistrial motion of the trial during closing arguments on Day 15 (March 16, 2026), after Bloodworth's prosecution closing. Nester argued Bloodworth (1) dehumanized the defendant by calling her a 'black widow'; (2) improperly commented on Kouri's demeanor in a way that amounted to a comment on her failure to testify; and (3) made 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind. Judge Mrazik denied the motion, ruling the 'black widow' comment referred to a woman who killed her husband, the Utah Court of Appeals disagrees with the demeanor objection, and offering to give a special curative instruction that jurors must rely on their own observations rather than Bloodworth's characterizations. The instruction was given. Total mistrial motion count at trial: 4 filed, 3 denied, 1 withdrawn.
Jury composition at deliberations — 6 men and 2 women after 4 female alternates excused
When Judge Mrazik excused the 4 alternate jurors (Jurors 9, 10, 11, and 12) before deliberations began on Day 15, the EastIdahoNews live blog confirmed all 4 alternates were women. This means the deliberating jury consisted of 6 men and 2 women — different from the 12-person seated jury (6 men, 6 women) described earlier in trial. The 8-person deliberating jury is consistent with Utah's rules for deliberations.
Defense motion to appoint counsel for Lisa Darden — filed and renewed, both sealed
Post-verdict reporting (Fox News, March 19, 2026) via former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirms that defense attorneys filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother) before trial. The state objected. Both the defense request and the prosecution's objection remain sealed by the court. The defense renewed the request in December 2025; some portions of that filing were made public. The filings suggest Darden could have been a key witness, though the exact scope of her potential testimony remains unclear.
Prosecution closing argument — 'lemon drop shot' theory for fentanyl administration
In his closing argument on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth argued Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day and used a lemon drop shot (in addition to the Moscow mule) to administer the fatal fentanyl to Eric: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Kouri's orange notebook journal entries referenced both a Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot, which Bloodworth cited as Kouri's own written confirmation of the method. Previously the prosecution had primarily referenced the Moscow mule; the lemon drop shot as a co-vehicle for the fentanyl is newly argued in closing.
Verdict form — aggravating circumstances unanimously found by jury
The verdict form confirmed that the jury unanimously found two aggravating circumstances beyond reasonable doubt: (1) the homicide was committed for pecuniary gain; and (2) the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity. Judge Mrazik read these specific findings aloud when announcing the verdict. This is the formal legal basis for the aggravated murder conviction.
Prosecution closing — 911 CPR delay countdown clock shown to jury
During closing arguments, Prosecutor Bloodworth played the 911 call with a countdown clock displayed on screen showing how long elapsed from when the dispatcher first instructed Kouri to begin CPR until she said she started. The clock showed approximately 6 minutes elapsed. Bloodworth argued: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' The CPR time clock stopped at 5 minutes 56 seconds. This visual was a new piece of demonstrative evidence presented during closing, not during trial testimony.
TruStage $100,000 life insurance application — incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins
CNN and closing argument coverage confirms that the $100,000 TruStage life insurance policy application — the specific document subject to the forgery and insurance fraud charges — contained errors including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins. An insurance agent testified to this during trial. This detail was referenced in Bloodworth's closing argument but had not been specifically captured as a distinct evidentiary item in the existing case record.
Kouri Richins wore a floral blouse (white with pale blue and peach flowers) at verdict reading
Multiple news outlets confirmed Kouri Richins was wearing a white blouse with pale blue and peach-colored flowers when the verdict was read on March 16, 2026. She lowered her head and began breathing deeply as the judge announced the guilty verdicts.
Verdict form — aggravating circumstances confirmed unanimously by jury
The verdict form in the Kouri Richins trial confirmed that all eight jurors unanimously agreed: (1) the homicide was committed for pecuniary gain; and (2) the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity. Judge Mrazik read the full aggravating circumstances language aloud when announcing the verdict. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted the verdict form shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Defense closing argument — lemon drop shot added as second alleged delivery vehicle for fentanyl
In his closing argument on March 16, 2026, Chief Prosecutor Bloodworth argued that Kouri administered the fatal fentanyl through both the Moscow Mule cocktail AND a lemon drop shot, stating: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' Bloodworth argued she 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day by switching from a sandwich to a shot that would be swallowed before Eric could detect it. A lemon drop shot had not previously been identified as a specific alleged delivery vehicle in the existing case record.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's phone accessed GIFs 'the exact minute' deputies signed the log out of the house
In his closing argument, Bloodworth presented a new specific correlation: Kouri's phone accessed the three money-themed GIFs at 8:29 a.m. on March 4, 2022 — which he stated was 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.' He also stated that whoever accessed the GIFs 'turned the phone this way to view them better.' This timeline correlation between the deputies' departure and the GIF access had not previously been explicitly stated.
Eric Richins' obituary detail — mission to Mexico City, fluent Spanish speaker
East Idaho News published Eric Richins' full obituary excerpt as part of Day 9 context. Key detail not previously in evidence record: Eric Richins 'served a two-year mission in Mexico City where he learned to speak Spanish fluently.' This is relevant to the defense's theory that Eric had contacts in Mexico and could have obtained fentanyl there, and to the Walk the Dog letter's references to Mexico.
Prosecution closing — Bloodworth argues Kouri closed Midway mansion on March 5 deliberately, waiting to confirm Eric was dead
In his closing argument, Bloodworth argued that Kouri Richins deliberately delayed closing on the Midway mansion from March 4, 2022 (the contractual deadline, the day Eric died) to March 5, 2022 (the day after his death): 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money, she knew she could do something with the mansion and that's why she signed on the 5th.' This presents a new prosecutorial interpretation of the closing date discrepancy already in evidence.
Slayer statute civil proceedings — Eric's family pursuing claim against Kouri
KPCW's post-verdict reporting confirmed that Eric Richins' family is pursuing civil claims against Kouri Richins under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which provides that it is illegal to inherit property from a person one has killed. This is a distinct civil proceeding from the criminal murder case, separate from the probate/trust litigation previously captured in the record.
Closing argument — prosecution: Bloodworth described 'lemon drop shot' as second delivery vehicle for fentanyl
In his closing argument on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth argued Kouri used both the Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot to administer fentanyl to Eric on the night he died — saying she learned from the Valentine's Day sandwich mistake: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' This is the first explicit prosecution argument that a lemon drop shot (in addition to the Moscow mule) was a delivery vehicle. Kouri's own orange notebook mentioned both a Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot, which Bloodworth referenced as supporting this theory.
Prosecution closing — Kouri called the IRS twice in three days before the Valentine's Day attempt
Prosecutor Bloodworth disclosed in closing argument that Kouri Richins had called the IRS twice in the three days before the Valentine's Day 2022 alleged poisoning attempt — a detail not previously reported in trial coverage. Bloodworth used this to argue Kouri was focused on finances as she prepared the alleged attempt.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's pen signature is one continuous stroke on Mirror Lake Diner receipt
Prosecutor Bloodworth, during closing argument, pointed out that Kouri Richins' signature on the Mirror Lake Diner receipt from Valentine's Day 2022 consists of a single pen stroke — she does not lift the pen off the paper. This was presented as a characteristic detail of her signature style, relevant to the forgery analysis and the receipt corroborating she picked up the breakfast order.
Verdict form — pecuniary gain and substance administration aggravating circumstances confirmed
The verdict form read aloud by Judge Mrazik after the jury returned its verdict confirmed that jurors unanimously agreed on both aggravating circumstances for the aggravated murder count: (1) 'The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain'; and (2) 'The homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' These specific aggravating circumstances were confirmed by CNN's trial coverage post-verdict.
Prosecution closing — Bloodworth argued Kouri closed mansion on March 5 (not March 4) deliberately
In closing argument, Bloodworth argued Kouri was required to close on the Midway mansion on March 4, 2022 (the day Eric died), but instead closed on March 5 — the day after his death. He argued this was deliberate: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money, she knew she could do something with the mansion and that's why she signed on the 5th.' He framed it as Kouri 'hedging.'
Defense closing — Lewis admitted defense opening statements included things that 'didn't come into trial'
Defense attorney Wendy Lewis acknowledged in her closing argument that things said by the defense in opening statements 'didn't come into trial,' explaining that 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence — they are.' This is the defense's formal acknowledgment that its opening promises (including Eric's alleged drug addiction, witnesses who would testify about a happy marriage, etc.) were not fulfilled at trial.
Juror deliberation detail — roundtable discussion before vote; cellphone data most pivotal
Foreperson Laura (Juror No. 2) disclosed in her ABC GMA interview that rather than taking an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion to talk through the evidence and their reactions before voting. She identified cellphone data tracking movements tied to alleged drug purchases as the evidence that 'blew her out of the water.' Juror Christie (No. 3) identified undercover narcotics officer Sgt. Eric Haskell's testimony as the most powerful for her.
Eric Richins' assets listed as $7.6 million total on intake form — confirmed via Bowman-Carter testimony
During Kristal Bowman-Carter's Day 9 testimony (confirmed in Article 33/EastIdaho Day 8 live blog which includes Day 9 cross-examination), the estate planning attorney's intake form listed Eric's total assets at $7.6 million. This supplements the existing prosecution opening statement figure of $4 million+ (estate) and Karrington's financial testimony.
TruStage $100,000 insurance policy — received Feb. 3, 2022; first deduction scheduled Feb. 14, 2022
Anne Coates (CMFG/TruStage) testified (confirmed in Article 33/EastIdaho Day 8 live blog) that the $100,000 life insurance policy application on Eric Richins was received on Feb. 3, 2022, and the first billing statement showed an automatic withdrawal for premiums was scheduled for Feb. 14, 2022 — Valentine's Day, the same day as the alleged poisoning attempt. This timing detail was not previously in the evidence record.
TruStage $250,000 policy payout — check sent June 17, 2022, for $251,558.82
Anne Coates (CMFG/TruStage) testified (confirmed in Article 33/EastIdaho Day 8 live blog) that a check was sent to Kouri Richins on June 17, 2022, in the amount of $251,558.82 to pay for the $250,000 life insurance policy plus interest. The $100,000 policy was still under investigation at that time because deaths within two years of a new policy trigger a review.
Kouri called CMFG/TruStage multiple times asking about prescription drug status of fentanyl
Anne Coates testified (confirmed in Article 33/EastIdaho Day 8 live blog) that the insurance company called Kouri and asked if fentanyl was prescribed to Eric because there was a $50,000 bonus rider that would pay out if Eric died from a prescription drug. Kouri said it was not prescribed and she didn't know where it came from. Kouri called back the next day to confirm the drug was not prescribed.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's net worth was negative $1.6 million when she 'murdered Eric'; described as 'narcissistic injury' during Karrington testimony
Bloodworth stated in closing: Kouri's net worth was negative $1.6 million when she murdered Eric. He also told jurors they had observed Kouri's demeanor during Karrington's financial testimony — that Kouri was 'exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury. She was bothered because the world saw she is indeed not a success and not affluent.' This is the first time Bloodworth's 'narcissistic injury' characterization of Kouri's reaction to the financial testimony was reported.
Prosecution closing — Eric had Disneyland plans with sons; was planning to buy mountain cabin with father
Prosecutor Bloodworth argued in closing that Eric Richins 'had every reason to live' — specifically citing that he was making plans to go to Disneyland with his sons and was planning to buy a cabin in the mountains with his father. These details were referenced to rebut any suicide theory.
Verdict form — aggravated circumstances confirmed by jury
The verdict form in the Kouri Richins trial confirmed that jurors unanimously agreed the homicide was committed for two aggravated circumstances: (1) pecuniary gain, and (2) by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity. Judge Mrazik read the verdict form aloud in court. This is the first public confirmation of the specific aggravated circumstances the jury found proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's note accompanying Valentine's Day sandwich described as a 'love note'
During the prosecution's closing argument on March 16, 2026, Bloodworth described the Valentine's Day 2022 sandwich Kouri left for Eric as being accompanied by a 'love note' — framing the poisoning attempt as disguised as a gift. This supplements existing record entries about the Valentine's Day sandwich delivery method.
Kouri's Vacation Express Caribbean trip booked for April 29, 2022 — Grossman's birthday; confirmed as birthday present
During Grossman's cross-examination (confirmed in EastIdaho Day 9 live blog transcript published as Article 39), Wendy Lewis asked about the Vacation Express invoice that Kouri booked for her and Grossman. Grossman confirmed it was for April 29, 2022, and described it as a birthday present. They never went on the vacation. This confirms the specific date of the Caribbean resort booking and that it was framed as a birthday gift — Bloodworth used this booking in closing to argue Kouri 'booked it knowing [Eric] would not' be alive in April.
Eric's total assets at time of estate plan — $7.6 million
During Kristal Bowman-Carter's cross-examination (confirmed in EastIdaho Day 9 live blog transcript Article 39), defense attorney Nester showed a summary of assets intake form listing Eric's total assets of $7.6 million at the time he set up his estate plan. Bowman-Carter confirmed that while Eric was alive he could do whatever he wanted with his money, but once he died, Katie Richins-Benson (as trustee) would decide how much money to give Kouri — subject to the rules of the trust.
Juror deliberation process — roundtable discussion before vote; no not-guilty check on any element
Jury foreperson Laura (Juror #2) confirmed in a post-verdict interview with ABC News that jurors held a roundtable discussion to talk through the evidence before taking any vote — rather than immediately voting on guilt or innocence. She confirmed: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' This provides insight into the deliberation process that resulted in a unanimous guilty verdict on all 5 counts in approximately 3 hours.
Kouri Richins had seven phone calls with a money lender on the day of Eric's death
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated in closing argument that Kouri Richins had seven phone calls with a money lender on the day of Eric's death (March 4, 2022), at which point her net worth was 'negative $1.6 million.' This detail from the prosecution's closing is sourced from NPR's trial coverage and supplements the existing financial distress evidence record.
Kouri called the IRS twice in three days before Valentine's Day 2022 attempted murder
During the prosecution's closing argument, Bloodworth stated that Kouri Richins called the IRS twice in three days before the Valentine's Day 2022 alleged attempted murder. He also displayed cell phone tower mapping showing times of messages between Carmen Lauber and Kouri around the same period. Kouri then called the Mirror Lake Diner to order the allegedly fatal sandwich and picked it up herself. Bloodworth noted her signature on the receipt was 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.'
Orange notebook inconsistency — Eric's phone activity contradicts Kouri's written account
During prosecution's closing argument, Bloodworth noted an inconsistency between Kouri's orange notebook entry and phone data: the notebook says Eric was on the phone when she went into her son's bedroom around 9:30-9:45 p.m. on March 3, 2022, but Eric's phone activity shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m. Bloodworth used this to argue that 'when people make up stories, they are inconsistent in the retelling' and that 'much of it is fake.'
Kouri told Eric's dad Eric died from COVID and a lung fungus — prosecution characterized as 'cruel'
During the prosecution's closing rebuttal, Bloodworth stated that Kouri told Eric's father Gene Richins that Eric died from COVID and 'a lung fungus that Eric's mom died of.' Bloodworth called this 'not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.' This detail about what specifically Kouri told Gene was previously captured only as the medical examiner 'denied making such a statement' — the prosecution's closing now confirms the specific false cause of death Kouri told Gene.
Kouri's wedding — married Eric in 2013, prenuptial agreement included exception for death
NPR's post-verdict article confirmed that Kouri married Eric in 2013 and that the prenuptial agreement included an important exception: while Kouri would not have rights to Eric's property if they divorced, she would under the prenup terms if Eric 'died while the two were lawfully married.' This is the first confirmation that the prenuptial agreement explicitly had a death-during-marriage exception, which prosecution argued was Kouri's motive for murder rather than divorce.
Prosecution closing argument — CPR delay timer; '6 minutes' shown to jury on countdown clock
During his closing argument on Day 15 (March 16, 2026), Prosecutor Bloodworth replayed the 911 call with a countdown timer on the screen showing that Kouri waited approximately 6 minutes (specifically 5 minutes 56 seconds per the EastIdaho live blog) from when the dispatcher told her to perform CPR until she said she started doing it. Bloodworth argued this showed she 'was not immediately trying to revive him.' He also noted she said 'I can't move it' rather than 'I can't move him,' arguing she 'dehumanized' Eric because she had murdered him.
Prosecution closing — Kouri called IRS twice in 3 days before Valentine's Day attempted murder
Prosecutor Bloodworth disclosed during Day 15 closing arguments that Kouri Richins called the IRS twice in three days before the Valentine's Day 2022 alleged poisoning attempt. He also noted she called the Mirror Lake Diner to order the allegedly poisoned sandwich — and that her signature on the receipt was 'one pen stroke; she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.'
Prosecution closing — booked Caribbean trip in December 2021 knowing Eric would not be alive
Prosecutor Bloodworth argued in closing that Kouri Richins booked an all-inclusive Caribbean vacation with Grossman for April 2022 in December 2021 — before the Valentine's Day attempted poisoning and before Eric's death. 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.' This supplements the existing record of the Caribbean trip booking but adds Bloodworth's specific argument about the December 2021 booking date.
Verdict form — jury confirmed both murder and attempted murder committed for financial benefit
CNN and other outlets confirmed via the verdict form that jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. This reflects the 'aggravated' element of the murder charges — the specific aggravating circumstance identified by the jury was financial gain.
Prosecution closing — Kouri closed on Midway mansion March 5 because she was waiting to confirm Eric was dead
Prosecutor Bloodworth argued in Day 15 closing that Kouri was required to close on the Midway mansion by March 4, 2022, but chose to wait and closed on March 5 — the day after Eric died. Bloodworth said: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money, she knew she could do something with the mansion, and that's why she signed on the 5th.' This supplements existing evidence entries about the closing date.
Prosecution closing — Kouri had seven phone calls with a money lender on the day Eric died
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated in closing arguments that Kouri Richins had seven phone calls with a money lender on the day of Eric's death — emphasizing the urgency of her financial desperation on that specific day.
Defense closing — no alcohol found in Eric's system; argued against drink-lacing theory
Defense attorney Wendy Lewis argued in Day 15 closing that fentanyl was not put in Eric's drink 'because there was no alcohol in Eric's body.' Lewis stated: 'The state waited until closing to tell you, oh, she put it in a drink, without any evidence to back that up. There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into the drink.' The prosecution responded in rebuttal that the fentanyl was in his stomach via oral ingestion.
Eric Richins served a two-year LDS mission in Mexico City — spoke Spanish fluently
The EastIdaho Day 8 live blog (covering Day 9 of trial) included biographical details from Eric Richins' obituary: he served a two-year mission in Mexico City where he learned to speak Spanish fluently. He loved hunting, his family cattle ranch, and was described as 'always the life of the party.' This provides additional biographical context.
Kouri-Grossman text exchange — Kouri described dream of living at Midway mansion with Grossman, running it as event center and farm
The EastIdaho Day 8 live blog (covering Day 9 Grossman testimony in real time) captured additional text message content: In a Feb. 23, 2022 text to Grossman, Kouri described a dream where 'Robert quit his job, she divorced and they came up with millions. They bought the Midway mansion and rent it out and charge $12,000 to stay in the mansion. And they start a farm.' This supplements existing Grossman text evidence entries.
Grossman cross-examination — confirmed he was told Eric had an affair; confirmed Kouri paid him $25,000 for flipping a house
From EastIdaho Day 8 live blog (Day 9 Grossman cross-examination by Lewis): Grossman confirmed he was told Eric had an affair. He remembered Kouri paying him $25,000 after Eric died but said it was for a house they flipped together — not simply a gift. He confirmed the Caribbean vacation was booked as a birthday present for him (Vacation Express, April 29, 2022); they never went. He confirmed his relationship with Kouri was 'on-again and off-again over the years.'
Prosecution closing — Kouri underreported expenses to tax accountant; submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders six times
Bloodworth stated in Day 15 closing that Kouri underreported her expenses when flipping homes to her tax accountant, resulting in paying more taxes than necessary — indicating she was concerned with the appearance of success rather than sophisticated business management. He also stated she submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders six times to obtain money.
Verdict form — aggravating circumstances confirmed by jury
The jury verdict form, read aloud by Judge Mrazik at 6:34 p.m. on March 16, 2026, stated: 'We the jury unanimously agree that the prosecution has proved the following circumstance beyond reasonable doubt: The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' This confirms that jurors unanimously found both aggravating circumstances required for aggravated murder. Per CNN, this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Eric Richins gastric fluid quetiapine level — 16,000 ng/mL
Fox News post-verdict reporting states that authorities found Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine (an antipsychotic medication, sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid and prescribed to Kouri Richins). This supplements the existing toxicology evidence — quetiapine was previously confirmed in Eric's system but the specific gastric fluid concentration of 16,000 ng/mL had not been publicly reported.
Bloodworth closing — 800 Kouri-Lauber texts in three months
In closing arguments on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth stated and graphics confirmed that Kouri Richins and Carmen Lauber exchanged approximately 800 text messages in the three months leading up to Eric's death (January through March 2022), averaging 10-11 texts per day. This was corroborated by digital forensics expert Kotrodimos' Day 6 testimony (confirmed via EastIdaho Day 6 live blog). After March 2022, the exchange rate dropped to approximately 3 texts per day — a roughly 70% decrease.
Defense sealed motions — court-appointed counsel sought for Lisa Darden and other witnesses
Post-verdict Fox News reporting confirms defense attorneys made multiple attempts to have court-appointed counsel for Lisa Darden before trial — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Former attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden (state objected; both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed). The defense renewed the effort in December and portions were made public. The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for 'several other potential witnesses.' The exact scope of Darden's potential testimony remains unclear.
Closing argument — CPR delay timer: 5 minutes 56 seconds
During Bloodworth's prosecution closing argument on Day 15, a countdown clock was displayed as the 911 call was played, showing how long Kouri waited to begin CPR after the dispatcher instructed her to. The clock reached 5 minutes and 56 seconds. Bloodworth argued: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' This is the specific measured duration of the CPR delay, previously referenced in the record only as approximately '6 minutes.'
Prosecution closing — Caribbean vacation booked December 2021 for April 2022
Bloodworth stated in closing that Kouri Richins booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman in December 2021 for April 2022. He argued: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.' This is the first specific disclosure that the Caribbean trip was booked in December 2021 — four months before the check-in date and before the alleged Valentine's Day poisoning attempt.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's phone locked at 3:06 a.m. clarification (28 seconds, speaker activated at 3:07 a.m.)
The East Idaho News Day 6 live blog (which covered Day 6 Saturday proceedings including Kotrodimos testimony) provides a more granular phone timeline: At 3:06 a.m., the phone is unlocked for 28 seconds. At 3:07 a.m., the speaker is activated. At 3:08 a.m., the device travels 243 feet. At 3:10 a.m., the phone is unlocked for 1 minute 40 seconds. At 3:15 a.m., unlocked for 37 seconds. At 3:19 a.m., unlocked for 28 seconds, then again for 3 seconds. At 3:21 a.m., the phone travels 135 feet. At 3:22 a.m., the receiver is activated (consistent with the 911 call). Previously the existing record captured the 3:06 a.m. and 3:08 a.m. data points but not the 3:10, 3:15, 3:19, and 3:22 timestamps or the specific unlock durations.
Prosecution closing argument — CPR delay countdown clock shown to jury
During Bloodworth's closing argument on Day 15 (March 16, 2026), the state replayed the 911 call with a countdown clock displayed on screen showing it was approximately 6 minutes from when the dispatcher told Kouri to perform CPR to when she purportedly started. Bloodworth argued: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' He also argued Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the call — 'I can't move it' — which he described as 'dehumanizing.' This specific framing and the countdown clock display were not previously in the record.
Eric Richins' gastric fluid quetiapine concentration — 16,000 ng/mL confirmed
Fox News reporting on charging documents and trial evidence confirmed that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid. The existing record noted quetiapine was found in Eric's system at a sub-therapeutic blood level; this specific gastric fluid concentration figure is newly confirmed from post-verdict reporting.
Verdict form — unanimously specified pecuniary gain and lethal substance administration as aggravating circumstances
The verdict form read aloud by Judge Mrazik specified: 'We the jury unanimously agree that the prosecution has proved the following circumstance beyond reasonable doubt: The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' This confirms the jury found both financial motive and the poisoning method proven beyond a reasonable doubt.
Bloodworth closing — Kouri booked Caribbean vacation in December 2021 knowing Eric would not be alive in April
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth argued that Kouri Richins' December 2021 booking of an all-inclusive Caribbean vacation for herself and Grossman for April 2022 was evidence of premeditation: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.' This is a more specific premeditation argument than previously captured — placing the intent as early as December 2021.
Bloodworth closing — Lemon drop shot and Moscow mule both potentially used to administer fentanyl
In his closing argument, Bloodworth argued both the Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot were potentially used to administer the fatal dose: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' This is the first time the lemon drop shot has been identified by name as a possible delivery vehicle in the prosecution's argument. Previously only the Moscow mule was specifically named.
Defense closing — argument that fentanyl could have been residue from prior use (toxicologist acknowledgment)
In her closing argument, defense attorney Wendy Lewis pointed to a toxicologist's acknowledgment during testimony that the fentanyl found in Eric's body could theoretically have been left over from a previous use — presenting this as a reasonable alternative to the prosecution's theory that fentanyl was administered in the drink on March 3-4, 2022.
Closing argument detail — Bloodworth argued Kouri deferred closing on Midway mansion until after Eric's death
In his closing, Bloodworth argued Kouri had been required to close on the Midway mansion by March 4, 2022 (the day Eric died) but chose to close on March 5 instead: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money... and that's why she signed on the 5th.' This is a new prosecutorial inference from the timing of the mansion closing not previously captured in the record.
Defense motion for appointed counsel for Lisa Darden — filed and objected to; both sealed
Post-verdict Fox News reporting confirmed that before the verdict, defense attorneys made multiple attempts to have the court appoint counsel for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure for Darden. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the motion was filed, the state objected, and both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed by the court. The defense renewed the effort in December 2025 and portions of that filing were made public. The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
Utah 'slayer statute' — Eric Richins' family pursuing civil claims against Kouri
KPCW post-verdict reporting confirmed that in civil court, the Richins family is pursuing claims against Kouri Richins under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which provides that it is illegal to inherit property from a person you killed. This is ongoing civil litigation separate from the criminal case and the financial crimes case.
Verdict form — aggravating circumstances found by jury
Judge Mrazik read the verdict form aloud after the jury returned its guilty verdicts. The form confirms the jury unanimously found two aggravating circumstances beyond reasonable doubt: (1) 'The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain'; (2) 'The homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' Legal analyst Jean Casarez noted the pecuniary gain finding shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Quetiapine in Eric's gastric fluid — quantified at 16,000 ng/ml
Fox News coverage of the verdict confirmed that authorities said Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine, an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid. Quetiapine was prescribed to Kouri Richins. This specific quantification was not previously reported in trial coverage — the existing record noted only that quetiapine was found at a 'sub-therapeutic level' in the blood toxicology.
Defense closing — 90-120 pills referenced as total drug purchase quantity
During Wendy Lewis's closing argument, she stated the state claimed 'somewhere' there were '90 to 120 oxycodone pills' from the drug purchases but they couldn't find or test them. Lewis argued: 'They didn't trace that fentanyl.' This is the first time the approximate total number of pills purchased through Lauber was publicly stated in the context of closing arguments.
Prosecution closing — Eric's phone silent for 87 minutes on Valentine's Day after eating sandwich
During Bloodworth's closing argument, he stated that after Eric ate the Valentine's Day sandwich, 'all activity on Eric's phone ceases for 87 minutes in the middle of a busy workday.' Activity then resumed and Eric called Cody Wright and Joshua Kaze. This specific 87-minute silence on Eric's phone was not previously captured in the evidence record.
Prosecution closing — Kouri called IRS twice in three days before Valentine's Day poisoning attempt
During Bloodworth's closing argument, he noted that Kouri Richins had two phone calls with the IRS in the three days before she allegedly attempted to murder Eric on Valentine's Day 2022, and two days before Eric died she was again on the phone with the IRS. This was presented as evidence of her financial desperation and planning.
Kouri's prenuptial agreement — exception clause confirmed: she would inherit if Eric died while married
The prenuptial agreement between Kouri and Eric Richins is confirmed via closing argument and NPR post-verdict reporting to include a specific exception: while Kouri would have no rights to Eric's property if they divorced, she would have rights if Eric died while they were lawfully married. Bloodworth stated: 'Their prenuptial agreement meant that if she left him, she would also leave most of his money.' This exception clause is the financial core of the prosecution's motive argument.
Lemon drop shot — confirmed as drink served the night Eric died, alongside Moscow mule
Multiple post-verdict sources (Daily Mail, CNN, USA Today) and Bloodworth's closing argument confirm that on the night of March 3, 2022, Kouri served Eric both a Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot during their celebratory drinks. Kouri's writings found in the family home (orange notebook) indicate the couple drank both a Moscow mule cocktail and a lemon drop shot. Bloodworth argued in closing: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow mule, just to be good and sure.' The existing record noted only the Moscow mule; the lemon drop shot was referenced in passing but not clearly confirmed as part of the same serving event.
Kouri's contact with IRS on day of Eric's death — seven phone calls with money lender
NPR's post-verdict article confirmed that Kouri Richins had seven phone calls with a money lender on the day of Eric's death (March 4, 2022). This supplements the existing financial distress evidence and was referenced in Bloodworth's closing argument in the context of her desperate need for cash to close on the Midway mansion.
Life insurance policies timeline — four policies purchased 2015-2017 totaling $1.9 million without Eric's knowledge
NPR's post-verdict article confirms that at the time of Eric's death, he was insured by at least six different policies. At least four of those — totaling $1.9 million — were purchased by Kouri between 2015 and 2017 without Eric's knowledge. She also made herself the beneficiary of another policy held jointly with Eric and his business partner just months before his death (which Eric changed back once the insurance company alerted him). This clarifies and expands the existing insurance policy evidence.
Closing argument — Bloodworth's 'black widow' 911 call framing
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth replayed the first minute of Kouri's 911 call and told jurors: 'The first minute is not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It is the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He also argued that Kouri delayed CPR for approximately 6 minutes after being instructed by the dispatcher, and that she referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the call — 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
Closing argument — prosecution lemon drop shot / Moscow mule fentanyl delivery theory
In closing argument, Bloodworth argued for the first time the specific mechanism of fentanyl delivery: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis countered in closing: 'There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.'
Eric's gastric fluid quetiapine level — 16,000 ng/mL
Fox News closing argument coverage confirms that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication prescribed to Kouri and sometimes used as a sleep aid. This specific gastric fluid concentration figure had not previously been reported in the case record and supplements the existing evidence of quetiapine in Eric's toxicology.
Closing argument — December 2021 Caribbean vacation booking as evidence of premeditation
Bloodworth argued in closing that Kouri booked the all-inclusive Caribbean vacation for herself and Grossman in December 2021 — months before Eric's death — as evidence of premeditation: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.' He argued this shows Kouri intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021.
Slayer statute — Eric's family pursuing civil claims against Kouri
KPCW post-verdict reporting confirms that Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri Richins in civil court under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which provides it is illegal to inherit property from a person you killed. This is a distinct civil proceeding from the criminal sentencing and the separate financial crimes case.
Eric Richins gastric fluid quetiapine concentration — 16,000 ng/ml
Fox News' March 16, 2026 article on the verdict confirmed that authorities said Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid. This specific gastric fluid concentration figure was not previously captured in the case record, though quetiapine's presence in Eric's system at a sub-therapeutic blood level was already known.
Closing argument — Bloodworth's specific lemon drop shot and Moscow mule theory
In closing arguments on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth for the first time explicitly articulated how he believed fentanyl was administered: through both the Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot. He argued: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis objected: 'That was argument. Argument is not evidence. They waited until closing to tell you, Oh, she put it in a drink, without any evidence to back that up.' Kouri's orange notebook entry also referenced both a Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot, per Bloodworth's closing.
Kouri-Lauber text volume — approximately 800 texts in three months
In closing arguments on Day 15, Prosecutor Bloodworth stated that in the three months leading up to Eric Richins' March 2022 death, Kouri Richins and Carmen Lauber exchanged around 800 texts — averaging approximately 10-11 per day. This more precise figure supplements existing records which noted 'hundreds' of texts and graphics showing 'distinct patterns of communication.' Confirmed via Daily Mail and CNN post-verdict coverage.
Four mistrial motions total — fourth filed and denied on Day 15 (closing arguments)
A fourth mistrial motion was filed by defense attorney Kathy Nester on Day 15 after Bloodworth's closing argument. Nester alleged: (1) Bloodworth 'dehumanized' Richins by calling her a 'black widow'; (2) Bloodworth improperly referred to her as a 'narcissist'; (3) Bloodworth made improper comments on Richins' demeanor tantamount to commenting on her failure to testify. Judge Mrazik denied the motion after a recess, ruling the 'black widow' statement was about a woman who killed her husband, the demeanor comments were addressed by a curative instruction, and Bloodworth did not comment on Richins' right not to testify. Final mistrial tally: (1) Week 1 DENIED March 2; (2) Day 9 DENIED Day 13; (3) Day 10 WITHDRAWN Day 11; (4) Day 15 DENIED.
Slayer statute civil proceedings against Kouri Richins
KPCW's post-verdict reporting (March 16, 2026) and NPR's March 18 article confirmed that Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri Richins in civil court under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which prohibits a person from inheriting property from the person they killed. This civil litigation is separate from both the murder case and the separate financial crimes case.
Verdict form — jury unanimously found homicide committed for pecuniary gain and by lethal substance administration
The jury verdict form specified that the jury unanimously agreed on two aggravating circumstances: (1) the homicide was committed for pecuniary gain; and (2) the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in a lethal amount, dosage or quantity. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Judge Mrazik read the form aloud in court at the time of the verdict.
Quetiapine gastric fluid concentration — 16,000 ng/mL confirmed
Fox News confirmed from court records/charging documents that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine (an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid that was prescribed to Kouri Richins). This specific concentration figure was not previously captured in the case record, which had noted only that quetiapine was found at a sub-therapeutic level in his blood.
Lemon drop shot confirmed as second celebratory drink — admitted via Kouri's orange notebook writings
During closing arguments, Bloodworth confirmed that writings by Kouri found in the family home indicated the couple drank both a Moscow Mule cocktail AND a lemon drop shot on the night Eric died. Previously only the Moscow mule was consistently cited. Bloodworth argued the lemon drop shot would be thrown back quickly before Eric could notice any problem. This was also confirmed by NBC News and CNN's coverage of the closing arguments.
Insurance application — incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins
During closing arguments (confirmed by CNN), the $100,000 TruStage life insurance policy application — the forgery count — contained errors including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins. Prosecutors cited this as evidence the application was completed by Kouri without Eric's knowledge or participation.
Kouri-Lauber communication volume — approximately 800 texts in three months
During closing arguments (confirmed by Daily Mail), prosecutors presented evidence that Kouri and Carmen Lauber exchanged approximately 800 text messages in the three months leading up to Eric Richins' death — averaging 10-11 per day. Graphics shown to the jury also displayed distinct communication patterns on the days drug purchases were made: Kouri contacting Lauber, Lauber contacting Crozier, then Lauber and Richins communicating repeatedly, with Lauber and Crozier also communicating during the same timeframes.
Defense pre-trial motions to appoint counsel for Lisa Darden — confirmed as sealed
Fox News confirmed via former defense attorney Skye Lazaro that defense attorneys made multiple attempts prior to and during trial to have court-appointed counsel for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden, suggesting she faced potential legal exposure. The defense filed an initial motion (state objected; both filings sealed), then renewed the effort in December 2025 (portions made public). The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro confirmed the December renewal was about protecting Darden's constitutional rights.
Closing argument evidence — prosecution's 6-minute CPR delay argument
Prosecutor Bloodworth argued during closing that from the time the 911 dispatcher first instructed Kouri to perform CPR to when she said she started doing it was approximately 6 minutes. He played the 911 call with a countdown clock showing this delay. He also noted Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' ('I can't move it') rather than 'him' — arguing Eric had been dehumanized in her mind after she murdered him.
Closing argument — prosecution: Kouri closed on Midway mansion March 5, not March 4, because she waited to confirm Eric was dead
Prosecutor Bloodworth argued in closing that Kouri was supposed to close on the Midway mansion on March 4, 2022 — the day Eric died — but she signed on March 5. Bloodworth argued: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money, she knew she could do something with the mansion and that's why she signed on the 5th.' This argument adds prosecutorial framing to the previously established factual record that closing occurred March 5.
Closing argument — prosecution: Caribbean vacation booked in December 2021 knowing Eric would not be alive
Prosecutor Bloodworth argued in closing that Kouri Richins booked the Caribbean resort vacation with Grossman in December 2021 — before the Valentine's Day poisoning attempt — and that 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.' This places the intent to murder as early as December 2021 in the prosecution's theory.
Verdict form — jury unanimously found murder and attempted murder committed for pecuniary gain
The verdict form read by Judge Mrazik confirmed: 'We the jury unanimously agree that the prosecution has proved the following circumstance... beyond reasonable doubt: The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Eric Richins' gastric fluid — 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine confirmed
Fox News reported that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine, an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid — in addition to the fatal fentanyl dose. This specific quantified level in gastric fluid had not previously been captured in the case record (the existing record noted quetiapine was found at sub-therapeutic levels in blood). The gastric fluid concentration is substantially higher.
TruStage life insurance application — incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins
CNN's post-verdict article confirmed that the application for the $100,000 TruStage (CMFG) life insurance policy — the policy at the center of the forgery count — contained errors including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins. This detail had not previously been captured in the case record and supplements the existing evidence on the forgery count.
Kouri Richins-Grossman texts — fuller closing argument context: fantasizing about divorce and millions
AP and ABC News reporting on Day 15 closing arguments confirmed prosecutors showed the jury text messages between Richins and Grossman in which she 'fantasized about leaving her husband, gaining millions in a divorce and marrying Grossman.' This represents prosecution's closing argument framing of previously admitted text evidence.
Verdict form — pecuniary gain and lethal substance administration confirmed as aggravating circumstances
The jury's verdict form unanimously found both aggravating circumstances required for aggravated murder: (1) the homicide was committed for pecuniary gain; and (2) the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance in a lethal amount, dosage, or quantity. Judge Mrazik read the full verdict form language aloud in court. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted the pecuniary gain finding shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Prosecution closing — CPR delay timer: 5 minutes 56 seconds before Kouri began compressions
During Bloodworth's closing argument, prosecutors displayed a countdown clock while replaying the 911 call, showing the time elapsed from when the dispatcher told Kouri to start CPR to when she said she began performing it. The timer stopped at 5 minutes 56 seconds. Bloodworth argued this delay showed Kouri was not immediately trying to revive her husband.
Defense closing — 800 texts between Kouri and Lauber in 3 months; average 10-11 per day
Daily Mail reporting on the prosecution's closing confirmed that in the three months leading up to Eric's March 2022 death, Kouri Richins and Carmen Lauber exchanged approximately 800 text messages — averaging 10-11 per day. Graphics shown to the jury revealed distinct patterns of communication on certain days correlating with alleged drug purchases: Richins initiating contact with Lauber, Lauber contacting Crozier, then repeated communications within the same timeframe as Lauber and Crozier exchanged drugs and cash.
Prosecution closing — gastric fluid quetiapine level: 16,000 ng/mL
Fox News reporting on the trial confirmed that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication (also used as a sleep aid) sometimes prescribed to Kouri Richins. This detail was referenced by prosecutors in connecting the quetiapine in Eric's system to Kouri's prescriptions.
Eric Richins lived a mission in Mexico City and spoke fluent Spanish — from obituary/Day 8 live blog
The EastIdaho Day 8 live blog published a summary of Eric Richins' life from his obituary at the start of the March 4, 2026 session. Key facts: Eric served a two-year LDS mission in Mexico City and learned to speak Spanish fluently; he was an avid outdoorsman and dedicated hunter; he loved his family, hunting, the family cattle ranch, and entrepreneurship; 'there was never a dull moment when you were around Eric'; he loved fully, laughed loudly, and lived life with 'reckless abandon.'
TruStage $100,000 insurance policy — application errors including incorrect Social Security number for Eric
CNN's verdict-day article confirmed that the application for the $100,000 TruStage (CMFG) life insurance policy — the policy at the center of the forgery count — contained errors, including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins. An insurance agent testified to this at trial. A forensic document specialist testified Eric Richins' signature on the application was 'probably forged.' This supplements existing insurance fraud evidence.
Defense closing — Vacation Express trip was for Grossman's birthday; they never went on the vacation
Defense attorney Wendy Lewis confirmed in closing arguments that the Vacation Express Caribbean resort reservation Kouri booked for herself and Grossman was intended as a birthday present for Grossman. They never went on the vacation. Grossman confirmed in his Day 9 cross-examination that the reservation was scheduled for April 29, 2022, and they did not take the trip.
Verdict form — unanimous agreement on aggravated circumstances
The verdict form confirmed the jury unanimously agreed the murder was committed for pecuniary gain AND by means of the administration of any substance in a lethal amount, dosage or quantity. Judge Mrazik read the specific language: 'We the jury unanimously agree that the prosecution has proved the following circumstance … beyond reasonable doubt: The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
Defense closing argument — specific arguments and admissions
Defense attorney Wendy Lewis made several notable arguments and admissions during closing: (1) She admitted the defense said things in opening statements that 'didn't come into trial' but said strategies change; (2) She acknowledged Kouri's business was 'struggling' but argued Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive'; (3) She said Crozier 'changed his story from what the prosecution wanted him to say' and asked 'why risk his immunity'; (4) She argued the toxicologist said fentanyl 'could have been left over from a previous use'; (5) She said 'there is no evidence that fentanyl was put into the drink' and the state 'waited until closing to tell you'; (6) She raised the expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle: 'What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?'; (7) She argued Kouri's internet searches were done because 'an innocent person would be worried' after becoming a suspect.
Prosecution closing — lemon drop shot theory and 'black widow' framing
In his closing argument, Prosecutor Bloodworth introduced and named a specific theory not previously articulated in trial: that Kouri administered fentanyl via both a Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot. He stated: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' He described this as Kouri having 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day. The orange notebook refers to a lemon drop shot — Bloodworth connected this to how the fentanyl was administered. Writings by Kouri Richins found in the family home indicate the couple drank a Moscow Mule cocktail AND a lemon drop shot.
Prosecution closing — 911 call CPR delay timer shown to jury
During Bloodworth's closing argument, a countdown clock was displayed on-screen while the 911 call was replayed, showing the elapsed time between when the dispatcher told Kouri to begin CPR and when she stated she had begun. Bloodworth argued it was six minutes from when Kouri was told to do CPR to when she said she started — and that she referred to Eric as 'it' on the call ('I can't move it') rather than 'him,' arguing 'she murdered him. Eric is an it.' The countdown clock showed CPR time ending at 5 minutes 56 seconds.
Prosecution closing — Kouri's Grossman texts about Midway mansion life plans
During closing arguments, Bloodworth displayed text messages between Kouri and Grossman from earlier in the trial showing that Kouri was simultaneously sending very excited texts to Grossman about the Midway closing while 'kind of blowing Eric off' in texts to Eric about the same closing. Bloodworth argued this showed she was 'more interested in spending time with Josh Grossman than Eric' and had dreamed of living in the Midway mansion with Grossman running it as an event center.
Prosecution closing argument — 'black widow' reference from Chelsea Barney recorded call
During Bloodworth's closing argument, he referenced Kouri Richins as a 'black widow.' Defense attorney Nester objected and moved for a mistrial, arguing Bloodworth called Kouri a black widow. Judge Mrazik clarified the 'black widow' comment was actually Chelsea Barney's statement from a recorded phone call (the March 19, 2022 call with Bryce Knudsen), not Bloodworth's own characterization. Judge denied the mistrial but issued a special instruction telling jurors to rely on their own observations of the defendant rather than the prosecutor's characterizations of her demeanor.
Verdict form — both counts of murder/attempted murder found to be 'for financial benefit'
The jury's verdict form confirmed that jurors unanimously agreed both the aggravated murder and attempted aggravated murder of Eric Richins were committed 'for financial benefit' — the aggravating circumstances specified in the charges. CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez reported this detail, noting it shows financial motive was paramount in jurors' minds.
Prosecution closing — lemon drop shot theory introduced for first time in closings
In his closing argument, Bloodworth for the first time specifically argued Kouri administered fentanyl via both a Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis pushed back: 'There was no evidence — none — that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.' Lewis also argued there was no alcohol in Eric's body, which she said contradicted the theory that fentanyl was put in his drink. Writings by Kouri found in the family home (the orange notebook) indicate the couple drank a Moscow Mule and a lemon drop shot that evening.
Eric's total assets per intake document — $7.6 million listed
During cross-examination of estate planning attorney Kristal Bowman-Carter (per EastIdaho Day 8 live blog), the intake worksheet Eric filled out listed his total assets at $7.6 million. This supplements existing evidence about Eric's estate value and the prosecution's opening statement that the estate was worth over $4 million.
Kouri told Grossman she got a life insurance policy — seemed 'surprised and unexpected'
During Grossman's Day 9 testimony, on cross-examination by Lewis (per EastIdaho Day 8 live blog), Grossman said Kouri told him in a text message that she got a life insurance policy and she 'seemed surprised and unexpected that she was getting a life insurance policy.' This supplements existing Grossman testimony detail.
Kouri and Eric text messages from January-March 2022 showing normal couple interactions
During Det. O'Driscoll's Day 13 testimony (per EastIdaho Day 12 live blog), several text exchanges between Eric and Kouri were shown: On Jan. 31, 2022, Eric texted asking when she was coming home; on Jan. 5, 2022, they discussed repair estimates for a property; a March 2, 2022 exchange showed Kouri texting Eric 'celebratory shot tonight!!' about the Midway mansion closing and Eric responding 'Okay, love ya'; Eric asked if she wanted to grab lunch on March 2 but she said she couldn't. These exchanges show routine couple communication in the weeks before Eric's death.
Orange notebook — fuller journal entry including running to bathroom to vomit and CPR detail
The fuller text of Kouri's orange notebook journal entry (per EastIdaho Day 12 live blog covering O'Driscoll testimony) includes: she grabbed her phone and called 911; pulled Eric off the bed and started compressions; when EMTs arrived and did CPR, 'blood was squirting everywhere'; she screamed at them they were doing it wrong; she sat in the corner rocking back and forth; she called her mom; the EMT told her Eric didn't make it; 'she ran to the bathroom and vomited'; the kids woke up and she yelled for them to stay in their room; she curled up around the toilet; her mom arrived; she called Gene Richins at around 3:45/4 a.m. and he answered 'so perky. It was very strange.' Also a separate timeline page showed: his death date, trying to get the safe open, Celebration of Life the day after, Eric's funeral, Kouri starts counseling, boys start counseling, search warrant, Det. Woody calls, private investigator, court motions, Kouri learned Eric had consulted with a divorce attorney. Bloodworth noted the bathroom vomiting detail was not corroborated by body camera footage — he could not see Kouri running to the bathroom.
Kouri Richins texts from March 22, 2023 about children's book sales goals
Text messages between Kouri and her brother from March 22, 2023 (per EastIdaho Day 12 live blog) showed Kouri discussing book sales: she makes $5.35 per book on Amazon (they print and ship); her goal was to sell 100,000 books by end of the year; the next 30 days were for marketing. Bloodworth argued in closing: 'Kouri wrote the book to make money — she wanted to sell 100,000 copies. Kouri didn't write the book and not only did she not write the book, she wasn't a good writer.'
August 22, 2023 jail call — Kouri and Lisa Darden discuss sandwich allegation; Kouri admits picking up the sandwiches herself
A second recorded phone call between Kouri and her mother Lisa Darden (from Aug. 22, 2023) was played in court during O'Driscoll's testimony (per EastIdaho Day 12 live blog). In this call, Lisa asks Kouri who picked up the sandwiches from the diner. Kouri says she did. Lisa says 'That's enough of that.' Lisa asks about a love letter allegedly put on the front seat of his truck with the sandwiches. Kouri says: 'What in the hell. They are nuts.' A separate Aug. 22, 2023 call between Kouri and her brother DJ also references the sandwiches — DJ says 'that's not at all what happened' and says he has receipts to prove it. This supplements the previously captured Kouri-Darden call in which she called the allegations 'nuts'; this call specifically captures Kouri confirming she picked up the sandwiches.
Kouri texts about Hayden Jeffs — called him 'another one wanting 15 minutes of fame'
Text messages between Kouri and her mother from May 31, 2023 (per EastIdaho Day 12 live blog) were admitted into evidence. They discussed Hayden Jeffs, with Kouri calling him 'another one wanting 15 minutes of fame.' This provides additional context for Kouri's awareness of Jeffs' potential testimony against her.
Life insurance policy application — incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins
CNN's trial coverage confirmed that the $100,000 life insurance policy application prosecutors alleged Kouri forged included errors, including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins. An insurance agent testified about this error. This supplements existing evidence about the insurance fraud/forgery counts.
Bloodworth closing — October 2021 identified as 'beginning of the downward financial death spiral'
In his closing argument, Bloodworth specifically characterized October 2021 as 'the beginning of the downward financial death spiral' of Kouri Richins' realty business, with a growing debt picture nearing $8 million. He also argued that Kouri intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021, when she booked a vacation with Grossman for April 2022.
Defense closing — acknowledgment of defense opening statements not coming to fruition
During closing, defense attorney Lewis explicitly acknowledged: 'They said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial, but strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' This is a notable admission that some of the defense's promised evidence (likely including the Mexico/fentanyl theory witnesses) did not materialize at trial.
Defense closing — Lauber admitted lying to judge for Las Vegas trip
During defense closing argument, Lewis highlighted that Carmen Lauber wrote a letter to Judge Mabey in February 2024 saying she had been 100% compliant with her probation in order to get permission to visit her boyfriend in Las Vegas — but she had not been compliant. Lauber admitted on the stand: 'If the officer said that, then it is true' (re: the alcohol violation). Lewis argued: 'She admitted it on the stand! I was untruthful with the judge to get something I wanted.' This supplements and confirms the Lauber drug court violation evidence already in the record.
Verdict form — financial benefit aggravator confirmed on murder and attempted murder counts
CNN reported that the verdict form showed jurors unanimously agreed both the aggravated murder and attempted aggravated murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit — a specific aggravating circumstance on the verdict form. CNN legal analyst Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' This is the first public disclosure of the specific aggravator checked on the verdict form.
Prosecution closing — Kouri called IRS twice in days before Valentine's Day poisoning attempt
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that Kouri Richins was on the phone with the IRS twice in the three days before the Valentine's Day 2022 alleged poisoning attempt. He used this to argue she was in financial desperation at the time of the alleged attempted murder. This specific detail was disclosed for the first time in closing argument reporting.
Prosecution closing — GIF timing: accessed at 'exact minute' deputies signed log out of house
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that the three money-themed GIFs were accessed on Kouri's phone at 8:29 a.m. on March 4, 2022 — 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house' — and that whoever accessed them turned the phone sideways to view them better. This specific connection between the log-out time and the GIF access time was stated for the first time in closing argument.
Prosecution closing — lemon drop shot as second poisoning vehicle
Prosecutor Bloodworth argued during closing arguments that the fentanyl was administered not only in the Moscow mule but potentially also in a lemon drop shot: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He argued the lemon drop shot was a better delivery mechanism than the sandwich used on Valentine's Day because 'you throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body.' Kouri's orange notebook writings referenced both a Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot as the celebratory drinks. The lemon drop shot as a prosecution theory was first explicitly advanced in closing argument.
Eric Richins — served a two-year LDS mission in Mexico City; spoke Spanish fluently
East Idaho News published Eric Richins' obituary excerpts on Day 8 (Trial Day reporting), which included: Eric served a two-year mission in Mexico City where he learned to speak Spanish fluently. This biographical detail was not previously in the case record and is relevant context for the defense theory about Eric's Mexico connections.
Eric Richins total assets at death — $7.6 million per estate planning intake form
During Day 8 cross-examination (Bowman-Carter), defense attorney Nester showed the jury an intake form prepared by estate planning attorney Kristal Bowman-Carter listing Eric's total assets at $7.6 million. This is a more specific figure than the $4 million estate value cited in prosecution's opening statement and supplements the existing financial record.
Prosecution closing — Kouri Richins underreported expenses to tax accountant; submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders six times
Prosecutor Bloodworth stated during closing arguments that: (1) Kouri underreported her expenses in flipping homes to her tax accountant, resulting in paying more taxes than she would have — showing she was interested in the 'appearance of success' rather than actual financial management; (2) she submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders on six separate occasions to obtain money. These specific details were advanced during closing arguments.
Eric Richins' total debt at time of Midway mansion closing — nearly $8 million per prosecution closing
Prosecutor Bloodworth showed a chart during closing arguments indicating Kouri had nearly $8 million in debt when she closed on the Midway mansion — a slightly higher figure than the $7.5 million cited in Karrington's Day 8 testimony. The closing argument figure may reflect total obligations including foreclosure liabilities not captured in the March 2022 snapshot.
Kouri's orange notebook — additional detail: Eric described as 'on the phone' when Kouri went to son's room, but phone records contradict this
Prosecutor Bloodworth pointed out during closing arguments that Kouri's orange notebook entry stated Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's bedroom around 9:30–9:45 p.m. on March 3, 2022. However, Bloodworth argued that Eric's phone activity data showed he was off the phone before 9 p.m. — making Kouri's own written account internally inconsistent with the phone data. This specific inconsistency was highlighted for the first time in closing argument.
Kouri's orange notebook — additional detail: stated celebratory drink happened in bedroom (not kitchen)
Prosecutor Bloodworth noted during closing arguments that Kouri's orange notebook entry placed the celebratory drink in the bedroom (not the kitchen), which he used to argue the drink was the delivery mechanism and that Kouri's narrative was crafted accordingly. This specific detail from the orange notebook had not been previously reported.
Kouri Richins — told Grossman she grew up scrubbing rich people's toilets in Park City; wanted to own those homes
Text messages shown through Grossman's Day 8/9 testimony (and confirmed in EastIdaho Day 8 live blog) showed Kouri told Grossman she grew up 'scrubbing rich people's toilets' in Park City and told herself she would one day own those homes. This supplements the existing Kouri-Grossman text message evidence and provides biographical context for prosecution's 'appearance of success' narrative.
Prosecution closing — Bloodworth's 'black widow' statement and 911 call replay
During prosecution closing on March 16, Bloodworth replayed the 911 call for jurors and stated: 'That's not the sound of a wife becoming a widow — it's the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He argued Kouri spent 6 minutes on the call before beginning CPR, and said her calling Eric 'it' rather than 'him' showed dehumanization. Defense moved for mistrial over the 'black widow' characterization; Mrazik denied it but gave a curative instruction.
Verdict form confirms jury found murders were committed for financial benefit
Per CNN's post-verdict coverage, the verdict form specifically shows jurors unanimously found that both the aggravated murder and attempted aggravated murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit — the aggravating circumstance elevating the charges to aggravated murder. This is the first confirmation of what the verdict form contained.
Orange notebook — additional content from Day 12 live blog (March 10, 2026)
The EastIdaho Day 12 live blog confirms additional content from Kouri's orange notebook admitted into evidence. Per the live blog of O'Driscoll's Day 13 testimony: one page shows a timeline Kouri wrote of Eric's activities the night he died — 'brushing teeth, Moscow mules, January–March 21st gone, funeral (don't have my phone), kids bed around 9, drink around 9.' A separate page shows a timeline of events following Eric's death from Kouri's perspective including: 'Eric's death, trying to get the safe open, the celebration of life the day after Eric died, Eric's funeral, Kouri starts counseling, boys start counseling, search warrant, Det. Woody calls, private investigator, court motions, Kouri learned Eric had consulted with a divorce attorney.' Additionally, Kouri's first-person journal entry from March 3, 2022 (the night before Eric died) includes: she and Eric had a celebratory drink; she went to sleep with her son around 9:30–9:45 p.m.; she got into bed around 3 a.m.; Eric was cold; she nudged him and he didn't respond; she jumped out of bed — he was pale/yellow, mouth open; she called 911; EMTs arrived and performed CPR, during which 'blood was squirting everywhere'; she 'screamed at them that they were doing it wrong'; she sat in the corner rocking back and forth; an EMT asked her to leave the room; she paced in the living room; she called her mom; the EMT told her Eric didn't make it; she ran to the bathroom and vomited; the kids woke up and she yelled for them to stay in their room; she curled up around the toilet; her mom arrived; the EMT told her Eric was gone; she called Gene Richins around 3:45/4 a.m. — he answered 'so perky. It was very strange.'
Kouri-Lisa Darden phone call (August 22, 2023) — full content confirmed
From the EastIdaho Day 12 live blog, a recorded call between Kouri Richins and her mother Lisa Darden from August 22, 2023 (while Kouri was in jail) was played in court during O'Driscoll's Day 13 testimony. In the call: Lisa asks who picked up the sandwiches from the diner on Valentine's Day — Kouri says she did; Lisa says 'That's enough of that' and asks about a love letter put on the front seat with the sandwiches; Kouri responds: 'I put a love note on a poisonous sandwich and put it in his car? What the hell? ... They are nuts.' Lisa confirms she read that the sandwiches were eaten in the office. Kouri says 'When people get up to testify and I say that was a lie, that did not happen, you can't compete with somebody who was actually there.' She also calls O'Driscoll and the detectives 'idiots.' This is the fuller version of the call previously captured only as 'They are nuts.'
Kouri-DJ Darden text (August 22, 2023) — Mirror Lake Diner sandwiches
From the EastIdaho Day 12 live blog, a text exchange between Kouri Richins and her brother DJ from August 22, 2023 was also admitted. In it, DJ says 'that's not at all what happened. Where did you get this bull****' — they are discussing the Mirror Lake Diner sandwiches. DJ says he has 'receipts to prove it.' Kouri is laughing during a corresponding phone call. This is a distinct exchange from the May 24, 2023 suicide text and the children's book texts.
Kouri-Eric text — March 2, 2022 (day before lunch at Mirror Lake Cafe)
From the EastIdaho Day 12 live blog, text messages between Kouri and Eric from March 2, 2022 were admitted and shown to jurors. Eric asks if she wants to grab lunch — she says she can't but 'celebratory shot tonight!!' She says she has to do paperwork because 'everyone is funding tomorrow' and promised to go on a walk with Virginia. Eric responds 'Okay, love ya.' She writes back 'Love you.' This places an affectionate text exchange between Eric and Kouri the day before Eric had lunch with Cody Wright at Mirror Lake Cafe.
Eric's phone activity March 3, 2022 — additional detail: Scottsdale to Nogales search at 9:45 p.m.; Raul text at 10:13 p.m. unread
From the EastIdaho Day 6 live blog (Kotrodimos testimony), additional granular phone data for Eric Richins on March 3, 2022: at 9:45 p.m., Eric searched 'how far from Scottsdale to Nogales' (Nogales is on the Arizona-Mexico border, near Sonora, Mexico hunting area); at 10:13 p.m., he received a text message from a contact named 'Raul' — the message was never opened or read by Eric. This supplements the existing phone data evidence and is consistent with the defense's Mexico hunting trip theory.
Kouri phone activity — granular unlocking sequence on March 4, 2022 (more precise timestamps)
From the EastIdaho Day 6 live blog (Kotrodimos testimony, more granular than Day 7 record): at 3:06 a.m., Kouri's phone is unlocked for 28 seconds; at 3:07 a.m., the speaker is activated; at 3:08 a.m., the device travels 243 feet; at 3:10 a.m., the phone is unlocked for 1 minute and 40 seconds; at 3:15 a.m., the phone is unlocked for 37 seconds; at 3:19 a.m., the phone is unlocked for 28 seconds; then again for 3 seconds; at 3:21 a.m., the phone travels 135 feet; at 3:22 a.m., the receiver is activated. This is more granular than the existing record which had 3:06 a.m. unlocked → 14 sec later speaker → 3:08 a.m. moved 243 feet → 3:21 a.m. 911 call.
Eric Richins' phone — 87-minute gap on Valentine's Day confirmed; atypical vs. other days
From the EastIdaho Day 6 live blog (Kotrodimos testimony): on Valentine's Day 2022, a graph of Eric's cell phone activity shows an 87-minute gap between 12:05 p.m. and 1:32 p.m. in which no movement data was recorded. Kotrodimos analyzed 20 random days from Eric's phone and this gap was 'not typical' for him to have during the middle of the day. Additionally, within that gap context, Eric's phone activity ceases for 87 minutes — after which activity resumes and he calls Cody Wright (who described 'fear in his voice'). This confirms the 87-minute gap detail previously noted but establishes the precise time range.
Kouri-Carmen Lauber text volume — 800 texts January through March 15, 2022; 70% drop afterward
From the EastIdaho Day 6 live blog (Kotrodimos testimony): Kouri and Carmen exchanged 800 text messages between January 2022 and March 15, 2022 — approximately 10-11 texts per day. Between March 16, 2022 and the end of the year, there were approximately 600-650 texts — about 3 per day. This represents approximately a 70% decrease in communication frequency after Eric's death, which prosecutors argue is significant. Previously the record noted only 'hundreds of texts between January and May 2022' — the specific count and the post-March 15 drop are new.
Kouri's phone — Caribbean vacation reservation found on device
From the EastIdaho Day 6 live blog (Kotrodimos testimony): Kotrodimos located a vacation reservation found inside Kouri's device. Previously the record noted prosecutors said in opening statements that Kouri 'booked an all-inclusive Caribbean resort trip' with a check-in date approximately one month after Eric's death. This confirms that reservation data was actually extracted from Kouri's phone and was part of the digital forensics evidence reviewed by Kotrodimos.
IRS calls — Kouri called IRS three times on February 11 and twice in the days before Eric's death (March 2)
From the EastIdaho Day 6 live blog (Kotrodimos testimony) and Day 15 closing argument: Kouri called the IRS three times on February 11, 2022 (the date of one of the drug purchases). Bloodworth also stated in closing that 'two days before Eric Richins died, Kouri spent time on the phone with the IRS' and that 'she called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric.' The February 11 IRS calls (confirmed per Kotrodimos) and the March 2 call detail records (confirmed per Kotrodimos timeline showing a 3-minute outgoing call to IRS at 10:22 a.m. on March 2) add specificity to the financial desperation narrative.
Bloodworth closing — Kouri booked Caribbean vacation in December 2021 knowing Eric would not be alive
In his closing argument, Bloodworth alleged that Kouri Richins booked the Caribbean vacation with Grossman for April 2022 in December 2021 — well before Eric's death. He stated: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.' This places the booking in December 2021, contemporaneous with the Becky Lloyd 'better if Eric was dead' conversation.
Kouri mirror Lake Diner call — timed at 8:53 p.m. on February 14, 2022 (not 8:55 a.m. as previously recorded)
The EastIdaho Day 6 live blog (Kotrodimos testimony) shows that on February 14, 2022, Kouri called the Mirror Lake Diner at 8:53 p.m. — note: the existing record states the order was placed at 8:55 a.m. per Gabriel Morin's receipt. The Kotrodimos phone data timestamp of 8:53 p.m. may reflect a different time or the PM time may relate to a different call. The existing receipt testimony from Morin (8:55 a.m. order, picked up at 9:07 a.m.) is from a different source and remains in the record. The p.m. call at 8:53 p.m. may be an additional call not previously captured. Further review notes the Day 6 live blog states '8:53 p.m.' in context of a cell tower exhibit showing Feb. 14 activity — it is possible this refers to 8:53 a.m. given the existing receipt evidence. This is flagged as a potential discrepancy in reporting.
Prosecution closing — Bloodworth argued Kouri's different text tone to Grossman vs. Eric around Midway closing
In closing argument, Bloodworth showed text messages Kouri was simultaneously sending to Josh Grossman and Eric Richins about the Midway mansion closing. He argued she was 'very excited' in texts with Josh but 'kind of blows Eric off' — presenting this as evidence her emotional investment was in Grossman and the post-Eric future, not in her marriage.
Lemon drop shot — identified as possible second fentanyl delivery vehicle in closing argument
During prosecution closing arguments on Day 15, Bloodworth argued for the first time that Kouri Richins may have used both the Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot to administer fentanyl to Eric Richins on the night of March 3, 2022. He noted writings by Kouri found in the family home indicate the couple drank both a Moscow Mule cocktail and a lemon drop shot that evening. Bloodworth argued: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' This theory — using both drinks — was not explicitly presented in testimony but was argued in closing.
Verdict form — jurors unanimously found financial benefit as aggravating circumstance
Per CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez's post-verdict analysis, the verdict form showed jurors unanimously agreed that both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit. This specific finding on the verdict form confirms the financial motive theory was central to the jury's conviction on both homicide counts.
Defense motion for court-appointed counsel for Lisa Darden — sealed filings
Post-verdict reporting by Fox News Digital confirmed that prior to trial, defense attorneys filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother) to protect her constitutional rights before she potentially testified. The state objected. Both the defense request and the prosecution's objection remain sealed by the court. The defense renewed the effort in December 2025, with portions of that filing made public. The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
Jury composition clarification — final deliberating jury was 6 men and 2 women
East Idaho News live coverage of the verdict on Day 15 confirmed that after four alternate jurors (four women) were excused before deliberations, the eight deliberating jurors consisted of six men and two women. Prior trial records indicated '6 men, 6 women' for the full 12-person panel including alternates; the final deliberating eight were 6 men and 2 women.
Timeline · 839 Events
May 139:30 AM
Sentencing for Kouri Richins is scheduled for 9:30 a.m. on Wednesday, May 13, 2026 — the day Eric Richins would have turned 44. The aggravated murder charge carries a sentence of 25 years to life in prison. Judge Mrazik will decide whether Kouri receives life without parole or a sentence with the possibility of parole after reviewing a pre-sentence investigation report and hearing victim impact statements.
eastidahonews.com
May 139:30 AM
Sentencing hearing scheduled for 9:30 a.m. on May 13, 2026 — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Kouri Richins faces 25 years to life in prison. A pre-sentence investigation report has been ordered. After sentencing, she is expected to be transferred from Summit County Jail to Utah State Prison.
eastidahonews.com
May 139:30 AM
SENTENCING SCHEDULED: Kouri Richins sentencing hearing set for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. MST before Judge Richard Mrazik. May 13 would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. A pre-sentence investigation report was ordered. Aggravated murder carries a sentence of 25 years to life in prison. Judge will hear victim impact statements from Eric Richins' family and determine whether to impose life without parole or a sentence with possibility of parole.
usatoday.com
Mar 25
MSN/national outlets confirm sentencing scheduled for May 13, 2026, at 9:30 a.m. MST — the date that would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Kouri faces 25 years to life in prison. The aggravated murder conviction alone carries that sentence.
msn.com
Mar 25
Juror No. 3 'Christie' spoke with EastIdahoNews.com reporter Nate Eaton in a 60-minute interview. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned for jury duty. Jury selection was conducted virtually; she received an email the next day saying she had been selected. The first time she saw Richins was at opening statements — 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad.' Christie sat in the middle of the front row and took fervent notes. She said Richins had 'a really good poker face.' The most powerful witness for her was the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed. She was also moved by Grossman's testimony — he appeared 'devastated' — and by Eric's family's grief. Christie said the moment that shocked her most was when the defense abruptly rested: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side.' She said she went home mentally exhausted every day and often went to bed early. The jury reached its verdict in less than three hours. Judge Mrazik met with jurors afterward and encouraged them to speak openly about the case. After reading more about the case, Christie said she is confident the jury made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 24
Post-verdict: Juror #3 (Christie) spoke with EastIdahoNews.com reporter Nate Eaton in a 60-minute interview. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned, had no preconceived notions, and was selected after completing the questionnaire virtually. She sat in the middle of the front row of the jury box and took fervent notes throughout. She described Kouri as having a 'really good poker face' — 'I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The most powerful testimony for her was from the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed — she said it gave her an inside look at the drug trade. She was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's testimony — he appeared 'devastated' — and by Eric Richins' family members' grief. The most shocking moment of the trial was when the defense abruptly rested without presenting evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Christie said she went home mentally exhausted every day during the trial. After Judge Mrazik met with jurors post-verdict and encouraged them to speak openly, she read more about the case and is 'confident' the jury made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 23
Juror 'Laura' spoke out in an interview with ABC's 'Good Morning America' about the deliberation process. Laura said her initial impression of Richins was sympathetic — 'The first thing we hear is these terrible things about her … and she's just sitting there like all by herself. At first, I was thinking that Kouri was definitely feeling trapped.' Her opinion shifted dramatically after prosecutors presented forensic evidence, particularly cell phone data: 'I was blown out of the water.' Rather than taking an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion to talk through the evidence and their reactions. 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty … and it was really heartbreaking.' Laura described Richins as appearing 'like a statue' and showing little reaction even when the verdict was read. Laura confirmed: 'We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.'
foxnews.com
Mar 23
Juror 'Christie' (Juror #3) spoke out in a 60-minute interview with EastIdahoNews.com reporter Nate Eaton. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned. Jury selection was conducted virtually; she received an email the next day confirming her selection. First seeing Richins at opening statements, Christie recalled: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad. They told us right away she had kids and my heart broke.' She sat in the middle of the front row and took fervent notes throughout. She described Richins as having 'a really good poker face — I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The testimony that hit hardest was from the undercover narcotics officer (whose testimony was not livestreamed), which she found most powerful as it gave an inside look at the drug trade. She was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's emotional testimony — he 'appeared devastated' — and by the grief of Eric's family members. The moment that shocked her most was when the defense abruptly rested without calling witnesses: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Jurors were not permitted to discuss the case with each other until deliberations. Christie went home mentally exhausted every day and often went to bed early. The jury reached its verdict in less than three hours. Judge Mrazik met with jurors afterward and encouraged them to speak openly with loved ones. After reading more about the case, Christie said she is confident the jury made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 23
Post-verdict scrutiny of Lisa Darden: Defense attorneys made multiple attempts during the case to have court-appointed counsel assigned for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure if Darden were called to testify. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro told Fox News Digital that the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden, but the state objected. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed that effort in December, and portions of the filing were made public. Lazaro said: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. The filings suggest Darden could be a key witness, though the exact scope of her potential testimony remains unclear. Darden could not be reached for comment. KPCW also confirmed that in civil court the family is pursuing 'slayer statute' claims and that the separate financial crimes case scope 'may have just grown.'
foxnews.com
Mar 23
Juror Laura speaks publicly in ABC's 'Good Morning America' interview: Juror Laura (first name only) described the deliberation process. She said her initial sympathy for Kouri — 'at first I was thinking that Kouri was definitely feeling trapped' — shifted dramatically once prosecutors presented forensic evidence, particularly cellphone data: 'I was blown out of the water.' Rather than taking an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion. 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty ... and it was really heartbreaking.' The jury 'all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' Laura described Richins as appearing 'like a statue' during the trial and showing little reaction even when the verdict was read.
foxnews.com
Mar 23
Juror Christie (Juror #3) speaks publicly in EastIdahoNews interview: Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned. Jury selection was conducted virtually and she received an email the next day confirming her selection. She described Kouri as having 'a really good poker face.' The testimony that had the greatest impact on her was from an undercover narcotics officer whose testimony was not livestreamed — she described it as 'the most powerful' and said it gave 'an inside look at the drug trade.' She was also struck by emotional testimony from Grossman, who appeared 'devastated,' and by Eric's family members whose grief 'made clear how close they all were.' The moment that shocked her most was when the defense abruptly rested without presenting any evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' The jury reached its verdict in less than three hours. Judge Mrazik met with jurors afterward and encouraged them to speak openly about the case. After reading more about the case post-verdict, Christie said she is confident the jury made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 23
Fox News reporting on Lisa Darden and defense motions for appointed counsel: Fox News confirmed that defense attorneys made multiple attempts prior to trial to have counsel appointed for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure if she were called to testify. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro told Fox News Digital that the defense initially filed a motion requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden, the state objected, and both filings remain sealed. In December, the defense renewed the effort and portions were made public. Lazaro confirmed: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro previously defended the 2006 overdose death of Darden's partner as consistent with the broader opioid crisis: '[She] was one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction. It is tragic, and, unfortunately, quite common.'
foxnews.com
Mar 22
Post-verdict: Legal analyst Nathan Evershed (NewsNation) details what comes next for Kouri Richins: (1) She will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing on May 13, 2026, after which she will transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. (2) Judge Mrazik will review a pre-sentence investigation (PSI) report, hear from attorneys, and receive victim impact statements from Eric's family before deciding whether she receives life without parole or a sentence with possibility of parole. (3) Preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; once filed, the Utah Attorney General's Office will respond and the case will move to oral arguments before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. (4) One potential appeal argument: venue — the defense sought to move trial to Salt Lake County but was denied. (5) Death penalty was not pursued — the decision was made in consultation with Eric's father and sisters; Evershed noted 'there is certainly no guarantee that a jury would be ruling to have a death penalty' in a case with 'all the intricacies of marriage and relationship and home and children and family dynamics.' (6) Civil lawsuit by Eric's family is unlikely: 'Ms. Richins has no assets' and would face significant difficulty. However, restitution in the criminal case is possible though difficult given she will be earning 'maybe 10 cents an hour' in prison. (7) Eric's family is pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute' — which says it is illegal to inherit property from someone you killed — in civil court. (8) The separate 26-count financial crimes case remains pending; it is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue it.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 22
Post-verdict: Utah 'slayer statute' civil proceedings confirmed. Per KPCW's post-verdict article, Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute' in civil court, which holds it is illegal to inherit property from someone you killed. Kouri is also litigating property issues with Eric's family separately in civil court. The scope of the separate financial crimes case (26 felonies filed June 2025) may grow; it is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue a trial in that case.
kpcw.org
Mar 22
Juror No. 3 (Christie) speaks publicly with EastIdahoNews.com in a 60-minute interview. Christie says she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned. Jury selection was conducted virtually and she received an email the next day saying she had been selected. She sat in the middle of the front row and took fervent notes. On Kouri's demeanor: 'She had a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The most powerful testimony for Christie was from the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell, whose testimony was not livestreamed). She was also struck by Grossman's 'devastated' appearance and by the grief of Eric's family. The most shocking moment: the defense resting without presenting any evidence. 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' After reading more about the case, she is confident they made the right call. Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict and encouraged them to speak openly about the case.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 22
Fox News reports post-verdict focus on Kouri's mother Lisa Darden and potential legal exposure. Defense attorneys had made multiple attempts during the case to have counsel appointed for Darden — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirms the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden; the state objected. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed that effort in December and portions were made public. Lazaro: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
foxnews.com
Mar 22
Post-verdict: Ali Staking (Kouri's childhood friend) speaks in an exclusive ABC News '20/20' interview (episode 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial,' aired Friday March 20, 2026). Staking says she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She describes Eric Richins as a 'dedicated dad' and a 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance': 'He had so much more life to live and he wanted so much for his boys.' Staking says: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day. I don't think there's anywhere else he'd wanna be.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire suggested the defense's zero-witness decision may reflect confidence that the prosecution hadn't made its case: 'They may believe the prosecution didn't make out their case, that having any witness on the stand wouldn't make sense because they've already won their case.'
abcnews.com
Mar 22
Post-verdict legal analysis (NewsNation / Nathan Evershed): Kouri will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. Judge Mrazik will review a probation (pre-sentence investigation) report, hear victim impact statements from Eric's family, and decide whether she will receive life without parole or a sentence with possibility of parole. Evershed: 'At the end of the day, she is going to prison for a very long time.' On the death penalty: not pursued; decision made in consultation with Eric's father and sisters. Evershed: 'In a case like this, with all the intricacies of marriage and relationship and home and children and family dynamics, there is certainly no guarantee that a jury would be ruling to have a death penalty.' On civil lawsuit: 'Ms. Richins has no assets... to try to do something like that would be very, very difficult.' On appeals: preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; one possible argument is trial venue. On the 26 additional financial charges: it is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue that case.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 21
Post-verdict — Ali Staking exclusive interview with ABC 20/20: Staking spoke to '20/20' (episode 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' airing March 20, 2026 on ABC/Hulu) and said she and her children were 'devastated' by Eric's death. Said she told her children along the way 'Sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it,' and her kids would ask if she did — 'I'd say I don't think so. But, you know, it sometimes looks like it.' Staking said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She described Eric as 'a dedicated dad,' 'a goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance,' and said 'He had so much more life to live and he wanted so much for his boys.' Staking said: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day. I don't think there's anywhere else he'd wanna be.'
abcnews.com
Mar 21
Juror No. 3 (Christie) speaks publicly via EastIdahoNews.com interview with Nate Eaton: Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned — 'I had no preconceived notions whatsoever.' Jury selection was conducted virtually and she received an email saying she had been selected. She sat in the middle of the front row of the jury box and took fervent notes. Her observations: (1) An undercover narcotics officer's testimony (not livestreamed) was the most powerful for her and gave the best inside look at the drug trade; (2) Grossman's testimony — he appeared 'devastated'; (3) Eric Richins' family members' grief made clear 'how close they all were'; (4) The moment that shocked her most was when the defense abruptly rested without presenting any evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything'; (5) The jury was not allowed to discuss the case until deliberations; Christie went home mentally exhausted every day; (6) The jury reached its verdict in less than three hours; (7) Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict and 'encouraged jurors to speak openly about the case with loved ones'; (8) After reading more about the case, Christie is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.' The one piece of evidence that really stood out to her was not specified in the article text.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 21
Post-verdict — Juror Christie (Juror No. 3) speaks to EastIdahoNews.com in a 60-minute video interview: Christie knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned. Jury selection was conducted virtually; she received an email the next day saying she was selected and first saw Richins the morning of opening statements. 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad. They told us right away she had kids and my heart broke.' She sat in the middle of the front row and took fervent notes. She described Richins as having 'a really good poker face.' The most powerful testimony for her was from an undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell) whose testimony was not livestreamed. She was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's testimony — he appeared 'devastated' — and by Eric's family members whose grief made clear 'how close they all were.' The moment that shocked her most was when the defense abruptly rested without calling any witnesses: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' The jury reached its verdict in less than three hours. Judge Mrazik met with jurors afterward and encouraged them to speak openly about the case.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 21
Post-verdict: KPCW reports that in addition to the murder conviction, Kouri Richins still faces 26 felony charges in a separate financial crimes case filed in June 2025. It is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue that case. In civil court, Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which bars a person from inheriting property from someone they killed. Kouri is also litigating property issues with Eric's family in civil court. KPCW noted the trial originally scheduled to last until March 27 concluded more than a week early due to the defense resting without witnesses.
kpcw.org
Mar 21
Post-verdict juror interview: Christie (Juror No. 3) spoke with EastIdahoNews.com reporter Nate Eaton in a 60-minute video interview. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before jury selection and had 'no preconceived notions whatsoever.' She said jury selection was conducted virtually and she was notified by email the following day that she had been selected. She first saw Kouri on the morning of opening statements: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad. They told us right away she had kids and my heart broke.' Christie sat in the middle of the front row of the jury box, took fervent notes, paid attention to every witness, and often glanced at Kouri to gauge her reaction: 'She had a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The most powerful testimony for Christie was an undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell) whose testimony was not livestreamed, giving an inside look at the drug trade. Christie was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's emotional testimony — he appeared 'devastated.' The moment that shocked her most was when the defense abruptly rested without presenting any evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' The jury reached its verdict in less than three hours. Judge Mrazik met with jurors afterward and encouraged them to speak openly. After reading more about the case, Christie said she is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 21
Juror No. 3, identified as 'Christie,' gives interview to EastIdahoNews.com. Christie says she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned and had 'no preconceived notions whatsoever.' Jury selection was conducted virtually; she found out by email she had been selected. Her first time seeing Richins was at opening statements: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad.' Christie says Richins had 'a really good poker face.' Most powerful testimony for her: the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed. She was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's testimony — he appeared 'devastated' — and by the grief of Eric's family members. The most shocking moment: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything' — referring to the defense resting without witnesses. The jury reached a verdict in less than 3 hours. Judge Mrazik met with jurors afterward and encouraged them to speak openly about the case with loved ones. Christie says after reading more about the case, she is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 21
EastIdahoNews.com exclusive — Juror Christie (Juror #3) interview: Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before jury duty — 'I had no preconceived notions whatsoever.' Jury selection was conducted virtually; she was notified by email the next day she had been selected. The first time she saw Kouri was opening statements: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad. They told us right away she had kids and my heart broke.' Christie sat in the middle of the front row and took notes throughout. On Kouri: 'She had a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The most impactful testimony for Christie was the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell) whose testimony was not livestreamed. She was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's emotional testimony and by the grief of Eric's family. The most shocking moment: when the defense abruptly rested without presenting evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Christie went home mentally exhausted every day. After the verdict, Judge Mrazik met with jurors and encouraged them to speak openly about the case. After reading more about the case, Christie is confident the jury made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 21
Post-verdict — Juror No. 3 'Christie' speaks to East Idaho News reporter Nate Eaton in a 60-minute interview. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned and had 'no preconceived notions whatsoever.' Jury selection was conducted virtually; she received an email the next day saying she had been selected. The first time she saw Richins was the morning of opening statements: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad. They told us right away she had kids and my heart broke.' Christie sat in the middle of the front row of the jury box, took fervent notes, and often glanced at Richins: 'She had a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The most powerful testimony for Christie was from an undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed, which gave an inside look at the drug trade. Christie was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's testimony (he appeared 'devastated') and by Eric's family members' grief. The moment that shocked her most was when the defense rested without presenting any witnesses: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Christie went home mentally exhausted every day and often went to bed early. After the verdict, Judge Mrazik met with jurors and encouraged them to speak about the case; after reading more about the case, Christie said she is confident the jury made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 21
Juror Christie (Juror #3) spoke publicly with EastIdahoNews.com reporter Nate Eaton in a 60-minute interview. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned, had no preconceived notions, and selected virtually. The first time she saw Richins was the morning of opening statements: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad. They told us right away she had kids and my heart broke.' Christie sat in the middle of the front row of the jury box and took fervent notes. She described Richins as having 'a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The most powerful testimony for Christie was from an undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Eric Haskell, whose testimony was not livestreamed), which gave her 'an inside look at the drug trade.' She was also struck by Grossman's emotional testimony and the Richins family's grief. The moment that shocked her most was when the defense rested without evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' The jury reached its verdict in less than three hours. After Judge Mrazik met with jurors post-verdict and encouraged them to speak openly, Christie read more about the case and is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 21
Juror Christie (Juror No. 3) spoke to EastIdahoNews.com: Said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned; completed jury selection virtually and received email confirmation she was selected; described Kouri as 'a small, frail woman' on first sight; said Kouri had 'a really good poker face'; the most powerful testimony for her was the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed; was also struck by Grossman's testimony — he appeared 'devastated' — and by Eric's family members' grief; the most shocking moment was when the defense abruptly rested without calling witnesses: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything'; went home mentally exhausted every day; after reading more about the case post-verdict, she is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.' Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 21
ABC 20/20 special 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' aired on ABC on March 20, 2026, featuring new interviews with a juror and a friend of Kouri's. Primetimer confirmed the special aired and explored details of the case. The defense team is expected to begin the appeals process after sentencing.
primetimer.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict juror interview: Christie, Juror #3, spoke to EastIdahoNews.com. Key revelations: (1) Christie knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned — 'I had no preconceived notions whatsoever'; (2) Jury selection was conducted virtually; she received an email the next day saying she had been selected; (3) First saw Richins on the morning of opening statements — 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman'; (4) Christie sat in the middle of the front row and took fervent notes throughout; (5) Kouri 'had a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking'; (6) The undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell, whose testimony was not livestreamed) was the most powerful witness for Christie — 'gave an inside look at the drug trade'; (7) Was also struck by Grossman's emotional testimony — he appeared 'devastated'; (8) The defense resting without witnesses was the most shocking moment: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything'; (9) Jury deliberated for less than three hours; (10) Judge Mrazik met with jurors afterward and encouraged them to speak openly about the case; (11) After reading more about the case, Christie is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 20
POST-VERDICT — Ali Staking, Kouri's childhood best friend who testified at trial, spoke to ABC News '20/20' for a program titled 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' airing March 20 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC. Staking said she and her children were 'devastated' by Eric's death. During the case: 'Sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it... I don't think so. But, you know, it sometimes looks like it.' After the verdict, Staking said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire said this reflected the defense's confidence that prosecutors hadn't made their case. On Eric: 'He had so much more life to live and he wanted so much for his boys. He was a dedicated dad and a goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' Staking: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day.'
abcnews.com
Mar 20
POST-VERDICT — Fox News reported that defense attorneys made multiple pre-trial attempts to have counsel appointed for Kouri's mother, Lisa Darden, suggesting potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense initially filed a motion requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden; the state objected. Both the motion and the objection were sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December 2024; portions were made public. The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The exact scope of Darden's potential testimony remains unclear. Defense attorneys Nester and Ramos did not respond to Fox News requests for comment.
foxnews.com
Mar 20
POST-VERDICT — KPCW reported that Kouri Richins still faces 26 felonies in a separate financial crimes case filed last June. It is unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue that case. Additionally, in civil court, Richins is litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family, who are pursuing claims against her under Utah's 'slayer statute' — which says it is illegal to inherit property from the person they killed.
kpcw.org
Mar 20
Friend Ali Staking speaks publicly about the verdict in ABC '20/20' interview: Staking said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She described the verdict as 'surreal' and said she had told her children along the way: 'Sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it.' She described Eric as a 'dedicated dad' and 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' Staking said: 'He had so much more life to live and he wanted so much for his boys. I'm gonna remember just how much he loved them.' A new '20/20' episode titled 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' aired Friday, March 20 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC.
abcnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict — Fox News reports on Lisa Darden / motion for appointed counsel: Defense attorneys made multiple attempts to have counsel appointed for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden before trial, suggesting she could face potential legal exposure if called to testify. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense initially filed a motion requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden; the state objected. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December 2025, with portions of that filing made public. Lazaro said: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Sentencing is confirmed for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. MST.
foxnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict — ABC '20/20' episode 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' airs Friday, March 20, 2026 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC, streaming next day on Hulu. Ali Staking (Kouri's childhood friend who testified at trial) interviewed: 'I said, along the way, "Sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it." Then my kids would say, "Well, did she?" And I'd say "I don't think so. But, you know, it sometimes looks like it."' Staking said it was 'surreal' learning Eric had died, described him as 'a dedicated dad' and 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance' and said 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day.' She was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire commented the zero-witness strategy 'may believe the prosecution didn't make out their case.'
abcnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict: Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother) scrutiny intensifies. Fox News Digital reported that defense attorneys made multiple attempts to have counsel appointed for Darden, an unusual move suggesting she could face potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden — the state objected; both filings remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December (with portions made public) — reportedly seeking court-appointed attorneys for several potential witnesses. The exact scope of Darden's potential testimony remains unclear. Lazaro said the defense sought to protect Darden's constitutional rights. Darden could not be reached for comment. The Fox News report also confirmed Darden's 2006 partner's death involved oxycodone toxicity, and that Lazaro has previously characterized that death as consistent with the broader opioid crisis.
foxnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict reporting (Fox News): Defense attorneys previously filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother), but the state objected. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed that effort in December 2025, with portions of the filing made public. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. The filings suggest Darden could be a key witness going forward, though the exact scope of her potential testimony remains unclear. Lazaro also reiterated her earlier position that Darden's 2006 partner's death was consistent with the opioid crisis: '[She] was one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction.'
foxnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict juror interview: Fox News reported additional detail from Laura (foreperson) via GMA interview. Laura said her early sympathy for Kouri 'flipped' once forensic evidence was presented. At first she thought 'Kouri was definitely feeling trapped' — then she was 'blown out of the water' by the evidence. Laura described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' throughout trial with little emotion, even at the verdict. Laura confirmed jurors' initial emotional reluctance: 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty.'
foxnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict: Fox News reported that growing attention is focusing on Kouri Richins' mother Lisa Darden amid new court filings. Defense attorneys made multiple attempts to have counsel appointed for Darden — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden, but the state objected. Both the request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. In December 2025, the defense renewed the effort and portions of the filing were made public. Lazaro: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' Defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. The exact scope of Darden's potential testimony remains unclear.
foxnews.com
Mar 20
Juror Laura (foreperson, Juror No. 2) spoke publicly in an exclusive interview with ABC News' Good Morning America. She said her initial impression of Richins was that she was 'kind of nondescript' and showed little emotion. Jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than immediately voting. 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' She described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' during trial and showing little reaction even when the verdict was read. She said jurors were shocked by the children's book evidence: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' She added: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She also said: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
abcnews.com
Mar 20
Juror Laura (foreperson) additional detail: She said jurors came into deliberations 'fully loaded' and the key to evaluating the case was to 'zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama.' She said cellphone data that helped jurors track movements tied to drug purchases was pivotal for her personally: 'I was blown out of the water.' Regarding the evidence: 'We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.'
foxnews.com
Mar 20
ABC 20/20 special 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' aired on March 20, 2026 on ABC, featuring new interviews with a friend of Kouri's and a juror (Christie, Juror #3).
primetimer.com
Mar 20
Juror interviews published: Foreperson Laura (Juror No. 2) spoke to ABC News / Good Morning America. Key quotes: 'She was kind of nondescript... I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe'; 'I was blown out of the water' by the cellphone data; 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing'; 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded'; 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty... it was really heartbreaking'; 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom'; jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than taking an immediate vote; everyone 'led to the same conclusion that she was guilty'; Kouri appeared 'like a statue' throughout the trial; jurors were 'hit with a truck' when told about the children's book — 'We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.'
abcnews.com
Mar 20
Fox News Digital reported on Lisa Darden's legal exposure post-verdict: Defense attorneys had filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden; the state objected; both filings remain sealed. Per former defense attorney Skye Lazaro: the defense renewed that effort in December (2025) and portions were made public; 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro pushed back on the 2006 suspicious overdose characterization, saying Darden's partner 'was one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction.'
foxnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict: ABC News '20/20' special episode 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' aired Friday, March 20, 2026 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC, with streaming the following day on Hulu. Ali Staking (Kouri's childhood friend who testified at trial) was interviewed exclusively. Staking said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense' presented. She described Eric Richins as a 'dedicated dad' and a 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' She said: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day. I don't think there's anywhere else he'd wanna be.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire said the defense's no-witnesses strategy 'may reflect the defense's confidence that the prosecution didn't make out their case.'
abcnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict: Ali Staking's exclusive interview with '20/20': Staking said she and her children were 'devastated' about Eric's death. She told her children along the way: 'Sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it,' to which her kids would ask 'Did she?' and she responded 'I don't think so. But sometimes it looks like it.' She said it was 'surreal' learning Eric had died, describing him as a 'dedicated dad' and 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance' who 'had so much more life to live and wanted so much for his boys.' Staking said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' On Eric: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day. I don't think there's anywhere else he'd wanna be.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire suggested the defense's zero-witness strategy reflected confidence that 'the prosecution didn't make out their case, that having any witness on the stand wouldn't make sense because they've already won their case.'
abcnews.com
Mar 20
ABC '20/20' airs episode titled 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' on Friday, March 20, 2026 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC, streaming the next day on Hulu. The episode examines the case and includes an exclusive interview with Ali Staking.
abcnews.com
Mar 20
ABC's '20/20' aired an episode titled 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' on March 20, 2026 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC, streaming the next day on Hulu. The episode featured an exclusive interview with friend and witness Ali Staking, who said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense' and described Eric Richins as 'a dedicated dad' and 'a goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' Staking said: 'He had so much more life to live and he wanted so much for his boys.' Staking previously told her children along the way 'Sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it' but said 'I don't think so.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire commented that the defense's zero-witness choice 'may [reflect] the defense's confidence' that prosecution hadn't made out its case.
abcnews.com
Mar 20
ABC '20/20' episode 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' aired Friday, March 20, 2026 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC and streaming on Hulu. Ali Staking appeared in an exclusive interview, saying she and her children were 'devastated' about Eric's death and that along the way she sometimes thought Kouri might have done it. Staking said it was 'surreal' learning of Eric's death and described him as a 'dedicated dad' and a 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' She said it was 'very surprising that there was no defense.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire commented that the defense may have believed the prosecution didn't make out their case and that 'having any witness on the stand wouldn't make sense because they've already won their case.'
abcnews.com
Mar 209:00 PM
ABC News '20/20' special episode 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' is scheduled to air at 9 p.m. ET on ABC and stream the next day on Hulu.
abcnews.com
Mar 20
ABC News '20/20' episode titled 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' airs on ABC and streams on Hulu the following day (March 21). The episode includes an exclusive interview with Ali Staking, Kouri's childhood best friend who testified at trial. Staking said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She described Eric Richins as a 'dedicated dad' and a 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' Staking said she wants Eric to be remembered as a 'loving dad' — 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire commented on the zero-witness strategy: 'They may believe the prosecution didn't make out their case, that having any witness on the stand wouldn't make sense because they've already won their case.'
abcnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict: Ali Staking, Kouri Richins' childhood best friend who testified at trial, speaks with ABC News '20/20' in an exclusive interview for an episode titled 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' airing March 20, 2026 on ABC and streaming the next day on Hulu. Staking says she and her children were 'devastated' by Eric's death and described him as a 'dedicated dad' and 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' She said she sometimes told her children 'sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it' but added 'I don't think so.' She says she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire suggested the zero-witness strategy reflected the defense's belief that 'the prosecution didn't make out their case.' Staking says she wants Eric remembered as a 'loving dad': 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day.'
abcnews.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict context: KPCW reports that Kouri Richins is also litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family in civil court. The family is pursuing claims against her under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which says it is illegal to inherit property from the person they killed. It is also unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case filed June 27, 2025.
kpcw.org
Mar 20
Post-verdict legal commentary on next steps: Former Utah prosecutor Nathan Evershed told NewsNation that Kouri Richins will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. At sentencing, Judge Mrazik will review a pre-sentence investigation report, hear from attorneys, and consider victim impact statements. Evershed said: 'At the end of the day, she is going to prison for a very long time.' He noted the only question is whether she receives life without parole or a sentence that includes the possibility of parole 'some decades from now.' On civil litigation, Evershed said a civil suit is unlikely because Kouri has no assets. On appeals, Evershed said preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; one potential argument could focus on venue, given the denied change of venue motions. The Utah Attorney General's Office would respond to any appeal, with the case likely going to the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. The death penalty was not sought — per NewsNation, this decision was made in consultation with Eric Richins' father and sisters.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict media coverage: ABC News announced 'IMPACT x Nightline: Love, Money & Murder: The Kouri Richins Trial' began streaming on Disney+ and Hulu on March 19, 2026. '20/20: Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' aired Friday, March 20, 2026 on ABC (9-11 p.m. EDT), featuring exclusive interviews with Ali Staking (one of Kouri's closest friends since junior high), the jury foreperson, and Kouri's family members, as well as police body-camera footage from the night Eric Richins died. ABC News contributor Brian Buckmire commented on the defense's zero-witness strategy: 'They may believe the prosecution didn't make out their case, that having any witness on the stand wouldn't make sense because they've already won their case.'
detpress.com
Mar 20
Post-verdict: Ali Staking, Kouri's childhood best friend who testified at trial, gave an exclusive interview to ABC's 20/20. She said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She described Eric Richins as a 'dedicated dad' and a 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance' who 'had so much more life to live.' She said: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day. I don't think there's anywhere else he'd wanna be.' On the case, Staking said she had told her children along the way: 'Sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it,' and her kids would ask 'Did she?' and she would respond 'I don't think so. But, you know, it sometimes looks like it.'
abcnews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict: Fox News Digital reports defense attorneys had previously made multiple attempts to have counsel appointed for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden — an unusual move suggesting Darden could face potential legal exposure if called to testify. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed: the defense initially filed a motion requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden (state objected; both filings remain sealed). In December, the defense renewed the effort and portions were made public. Lazaro: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro also pushed back on the 2006 suspicious overdose characterization of Darden's partner, saying '[she] was one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction.'
foxnews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict analysis: Former Utah prosecutor and defense attorney Nathan Evershed confirmed for NewsNation: (1) Kouri's sentencing options include life without parole or a sentence that includes the possibility of parole after decades — 'The only question is, if there's a chance of her possibly having parole some decades from now'; (2) The appeal process will take up to a year to prepare; the Utah Attorney General's Office will respond and the case will proceed to the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals; (3) One likely appeal argument is venue — the denied motion to move trial from Summit County to Salt Lake County; (4) Eric Richins' family could pursue civil claims but it is unlikely given Kouri has no assets; (5) Restitution in the criminal case is possible but 'with her now being in prison and maybe working for 10 cents an hour, it's just not going to happen'; (6) Death penalty was not sought — the decision was made in consultation with Eric Richins' father and sisters.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 19
POST-VERDICT — Juror Christie (Juror #3) spoke exclusively to EastIdahoNews.com reporter Nate Eaton in a 60-minute interview. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before jury selection, which was conducted virtually. Her first impression of Richins: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad. They told us right away she had kids and my heart broke.' Richins had 'a really good poker face.' The most powerful testimony for Christie was from the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed. She was also struck by Grossman's testimony — he appeared 'devastated' — and by testimony from Eric's family members whose grief showed 'how close they all were.' The moment that shocked Christie most: when the defense rested without calling any witnesses. 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Jurors were not allowed to talk about the case with each other until deliberations. Christie went to bed early each night mentally exhausted. After the verdict, Judge Mrazik met with jurors and encouraged them to speak openly about the case. After reading more about the Richins case, Christie is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict CNN analysis of how prosecutors proved case without finding murder weapon: CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted that cell phone records were pivotal in corroborating Lauber's testimony, adding 'so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' Casarez noted that the verdict form showed jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit — 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' The Walk the Dog letter was described as 'damning' because it showed a 'step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing' — making all other coincidences more believable. Legal analyst Hershon stated: 'It's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action that she put together step by step by step.'
cnn.com
Mar 19
Juror No. 2 (foreperson Laura) speaks publicly: In an exclusive interview with ABC News' 'Good Morning America,' foreperson Laura (Juror No. 2) described her experience. Key details: (1) Her first impression of Kouri was 'kind of nondescript — she didn't really show that much emotion'; (2) The jury was 'fully loaded' going into deliberations — 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing'; (3) The jury did not immediately vote — they held a roundtable discussion first; (4) 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking'; (5) The jurors were shocked by the children's book revelation — 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this?'; (6) The cell phone data was pivotal — 'I was blown out of the water' — and helped jurors track movements tied to alleged drug purchases; (7) Laura described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' with little reaction even when the verdict was read; (8) 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' Laura also said jurors evaluated evidence by trying to 'zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama.'
abcnews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict legal analysis — what happens next (NewsNation/Evershed): Former Utah prosecutor Nathan Evershed stated Kouri will remain in Summit County Jail until sentencing, after which she will transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. At sentencing, Judge Mrazik will review a probation report and hear victim impact statements from Eric's family before determining life without parole or a sentence with possibility of parole. Evershed said preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; potential arguments could include the venue denial (defense had sought to move trial from Summit County to Salt Lake County). Evershed said a civil lawsuit by Eric's family is unlikely: 'Ms. Richins has no assets.' Kouri will have an opportunity to speak at sentencing, though Evershed said it is unlikely she will. Death penalty had not been sought — the decision was made in consultation with Eric's father and sisters.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict — KPCW reports on civil litigation and separate financial case: Kouri Richins is litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family in civil court. Eric's family is pursuing claims under the Utah 'slayer statute,' which says it is illegal to inherit property from a person they killed. It is unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue the separate 26-felony financial crimes case filed June 2025.
kpcw.org
Mar 19
Post-verdict: Juror Christie (Juror No. 3) gives interview to EastIdahoNews.com. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned. She described Kouri as 'a small, frail woman' who had 'a really good poker face.' She said the most powerful testimony for her came from an undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Eric Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed and gave an 'inside look at the drug trade.' She was also struck by the emotional testimony of Robert Josh Grossman, who appeared 'devastated,' and by Eric's family whose grief showed 'how close they all were.' Christie said the moment that shocked her most was when the defense abruptly rested without presenting any evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' The jury reached its verdict in less than three hours. Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict and encouraged them to speak openly about the case with loved ones. Christie said after reading more about the case, she is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict analysis and what happens next: Former Utah prosecutor Nathan Evershed told NewsNation that Kouri faces 25 years to life in prison for aggravated murder alone, with the specific sentence to be decided by Judge Mrazik at the May 13 sentencing. Mrazik will review a probation/pre-sentence investigation report, hear from attorneys, and receive victim impact statements from Eric Richins' family before determining whether Richins will receive life without parole or a sentence with the possibility of parole. Evershed noted the family will likely have multiple speakers including Gene Richins and Eric's sisters. Kouri Richins will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake. After sentencing, the defense is expected to begin the appeals process, which can take up to a year to prepare. One potential appeal argument: the denial of the venue change motion. A civil lawsuit by Eric's family is considered unlikely because Richins has no assets. Restitution in the criminal case is possible but limited given her expected prison wages.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict: Juror #3 (Christie) spoke with EastIdahoNews.com reporter Nate Eaton in a 60-minute interview. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned — 'I had no preconceived notions whatsoever.' She was selected virtually and the first time she saw Richins was the morning of opening statements: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad.' Christie sat in the middle of the front row, took fervent notes, and often glanced at Richins. 'She had a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The most powerful testimony for her was from the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed. She was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman, who appeared 'devastated,' and by the grief of Eric Richins' family members. The moment that shocked her most: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything' — referring to the defense resting without witnesses. After reading more about the case following the trial, Christie says she is confident she and fellow jurors made the right call. Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict and encouraged them to speak openly about the case with loved ones.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict legal analysis (NewsNation): Former Utah prosecutor and defense attorney Nathan Evershed stated that Kouri Richins faces 25 years to life in prison; sentencing will be decided by Judge Mrazik after he reviews a pre-sentence investigation report and hears from attorneys and victim impact statements from Eric Richins' family. 'The only question is, if there's a chance of her possibly having parole some decades from now.' On appeals: preparing a thorough appeal can take up to a year; the case will likely go to the Utah Court of Appeals or Utah Supreme Court. Venue was identified as one potential appeal argument. Evershed noted Eric Richins' family is unlikely to pursue a civil lawsuit: 'Ms. Richins has no assets... With her now being in prison and maybe working for 10 cents an hour, possibly it's just not going to happen.' The family could pursue restitution in the criminal case. Kouri will stay at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict juror interview: Laura (Juror No. 2, jury foreperson) spoke exclusively with ABC News/Good Morning America. Laura said her initial impression of Kouri was that she was 'kind of nondescript' and showed 'little emotion.' Rather than taking an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion to talk through the evidence. 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty ... and it was really heartbreaking.' She said jurors were 'fully loaded' going into deliberations despite the short 3-hour timeframe. 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She said jurors were hit 'like a truck' by the children's book/ghostwriter evidence: 'We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' Foreperson Laura described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' and showing little reaction even when the verdict was read. She added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
abcnews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict juror interview: Laura (foreperson) told ABC News that cell phone data was pivotal in reaching a guilty verdict: 'I was blown out of the water' by the cell phone data showing movements tied to alleged drug purchases. 'We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' She said jurors needed to 'zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama' to evaluate the case. She identified the prosecution's financial evidence and circumstantial evidence pattern as key. Laura confirmed the jury had not yet taken a vote when beginning deliberations — they first held a group discussion.
abcnews.com
Mar 19
Juror No. 2, identified as 'Laura,' the foreperson, gives exclusive interview to ABC News' Good Morning America. Laura describes her experience: first saw Richins as 'kind of nondescript' with little emotion — 'like a statue.' The jury did not immediately vote but held a roundtable discussion to talk through evidence. 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' 'We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' Jurors were 'hit with a truck' when told about the children's book in the final days of testimony. 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' Laura adds: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' The cell phone data was pivotal: 'I was blown out of the water' — it 'helped jurors track movements tied to alleged drug purchases.'
abcnews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict reporting (Fox News) confirms: Sentencing is scheduled for May 13 at 9:30 a.m. MST. Richins' defense attorneys had previously sought court-appointed counsel for Lisa Darden, an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure for Darden. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro tells Fox News Digital: the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden, the state objected, and both filings remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December; some portions were made public. Lazaro: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Regarding Lisa Darden's 2006 suspicious overdose connection, Lazaro told Fox: the earlier death was 'consistent with the broader opioid crisis' — '[She] was one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction.'
foxnews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict — Lisa Darden scrutiny intensifies: Fox News reports that defense attorneys made multiple attempts to have court-appointed counsel assigned to Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother), an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden; state objected. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. Defense renewed the effort in December, and portions of that filing were made public. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro told Fox News Digital: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro previously told Fox News that the 2006 death of Darden's romantic partner was consistent with the broader opioid crisis: '[She] was one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction.'
foxnews.com
Mar 19
Post-verdict: Fox News Digital reported on growing attention to Kouri Richins' mother Lisa Darden ahead of sentencing and ongoing legal proceedings. Defense attorneys had made multiple attempts to have court-appointed counsel designated for Darden — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro told Fox News Digital that the defense initially filed a motion requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden, which the state objected to. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed by the court. In December, the defense renewed that effort and portions of the filing were made public. Lazaro said the filing asked for Darden to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights. The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro pushed back on characterizations of the 2006 death of Darden's partner, saying: '[She] was one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction. It is tragic, and, unfortunately, quite common.'
foxnews.com
Mar 19
'IMPACT x Nightline: Love, Money & Murder: The Kouri Richins Trial' began streaming on Disney+ and Hulu on March 19, 2026. '20/20: Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' aired on ABC on March 20, 2026 (9-11 p.m. EDT) and streamed the next day on Disney+ and Hulu. The 20/20 episode included exclusive interviews with jury foreperson Laura and with Ali Staking (Kouri's childhood friend who testified at trial). ABC News commentary provided by Dan Abrams, Brian Buckmire, and Josh Margolin.
detpress.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict analysis: Former Utah prosecutor Nathan Evershed commented on what happens next. On sentencing: Judge Mrazik will review a probation report, hear from attorneys and victim impact statements from Eric Richins' family (likely his father, sisters, and others) before deciding between life without parole or a sentence that includes possibility of parole. On appeals: preparing a credible, thorough appeal can take up to a year; the Utah Attorney General's Office will respond; the case will likely go to the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. One potential appeal argument: venue — the defense had sought to move the trial to Salt Lake County. On a civil lawsuit: 'Ms. Richins has no assets, and so to try to do something like that would be very, very difficult.' On the death penalty: prosecutors chose not to seek it, in consultation with Eric Richins' father and sisters; Evershed noted the family dynamics and difficulty of securing a unanimous death penalty verdict were likely factors.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 18
CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez (also an attorney) provided post-verdict analysis. On motive: 'A motive gives the "why" — why an alleged crime was committed by the defendant sitting in the courtroom. Juries want to know why. That gives them a reason to convict.' On the verdict form: 'Jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit — which shows the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' On cell phone evidence: it 'added so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' On Lauber: 'If [the jury] hadn't believed her, there may not have been a conviction.' On the Walk the Dog letter: analyst Hershon said: 'What she put in that letter makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable, from the prosecutor's point of view. Because all of these other things, it's not just another coincidence... It's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Juror foreperson 'Laura' (Juror No. 2) speaks exclusively to ABC News' 'Good Morning America' about the deliberations. Laura described Kouri as 'kind of nondescript' during the trial — 'She didn't really show that much emotion. I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe.' Laura said deliberations lasted about 3 hours: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She described jurors as 'fully loaded' going into deliberations: 'To evaluate the case and to look at the evidence we had to zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama.' On the children's book revelation in the final days of testimony: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' Laura noted jurors were emotionally affected: 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' She added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
wsjm.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Sentencing confirmed for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. MST — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. The aggravated murder charge alone carries a sentence of 25 years to life in prison. Judge Mrazik will review a probation report, hear from attorneys, and hear victim impact statements from Eric Richins' family before determining whether she will receive life without parole or a sentence that includes the possibility of parole. Kouri Richins will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, after which she will transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict legal analysis: Former Utah prosecutor Nathan Evershed told NewsNation that preparing a credible, thorough appeal can take up to a year. One potential appellate argument could focus on trial venue — the defense had sought to move the trial from Summit County to Salt Lake County, which was denied. The Utah Attorney General's Office will respond to any appeal filed, with the case moving to oral arguments likely before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals before a final ruling. Eric Richins' family could pursue a civil lawsuit, but Evershed said it is unlikely as Kouri has no assets. Kouri will have an opportunity to speak at sentencing, but Evershed said it is unlikely she will. Prosecutors chose not to pursue the death penalty in this case, a decision made in consultation with Eric Richins' father and sisters.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: One member of the public, Selena Armithee, attended nearly the entire trial and was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict came down (due to amended decorum order excluding the public). Armithee said she had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during the proceedings. She said Kouri 'was shaking when I came in; you could see her shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision and said she personally believed there was not enough to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Kouri Richins was guilty. She said: 'It was extremely intense and stressful.' CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted the verdict form showing jurors agreed both crimes were for financial benefit demonstrates 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
kutv.com
Mar 18
Juror No. 2 (foreperson 'Laura') speaks to Good Morning America/ABC News in an exclusive interview. Key disclosures: (1) Deliberations lasted approximately three hours; (2) 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing'; (3) 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded'; (4) On Kouri's demeanor during trial: 'She was kind of nondescript. She didn't really show that much emotion. I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe'; (5) On the children's book being revealed in the final days: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange'; (6) 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking'; (7) 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom'; (8) The jury focused on 'zooming in on little bits of evidence' and ignoring 'all the fluff and ignore the drama.'
wsjm.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict legal analysis and what happens next: Attorney Nathan Evershed confirmed Kouri Richins will stay at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before permanent housing assignment. Sentencing on May 13 will include a probation report, victim impact statements from Eric's family, and statements from attorneys. Judge Mrazik will determine whether she receives life without parole or a sentence that includes the possibility of parole. Evershed said preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year. Potential appeal issues include the trial venue (denied change to Salt Lake County); appeal will go to Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. Civil lawsuit against Kouri by Eric's family is unlikely given she has no assets. Restitution possible but unlikely given prison wage rates. Kouri also still faces 26 felony charges in the separate financial crimes case; it is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue that trial. In civil court, the Richins family is pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute' — which says it is illegal to inherit property from someone you killed. Death penalty was not pursued — decision was made in consultation with Eric's father and sisters.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict CNN analysis: CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez and legal analyst Hershon commented on the conviction. Casarez: 'If [the jury] hadn't believed [Lauber], there may not have been a conviction.' Cell phone records 'added so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' Casarez noted the verdict form confirmed jurors unanimously agreed both murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit — 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Hershon called the Walk the Dog letter 'damning' — 'This was a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing.' Hershon: 'What she put in that letter makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable... It's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action that she put together step by step by step.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict juror interviews: Juror No. 2, the foreperson (identified only as 'Laura'), spoke to ABC News 'Good Morning America.' Key revelations: (1) The jury was 'shocked' to learn about the ghostwritten children's book — 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange'; (2) Jurors immediately held a roundtable discussion rather than taking a vote — 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty... and it was really heartbreaking'; (3) 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing'; (4) Laura described Kouri as 'like a statue' throughout the trial who 'didn't really show that much emotion'; (5) Cell phone data was pivotal — 'I was blown out of the water' by the phone evidence; (6) 'We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty'; (7) 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded'; (8) The jury focused on 'zooming in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignoring all the fluff and ignore the drama'; (9) Laura described 'this devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
wsjm.com
Mar 18
POST-VERDICT — CNN legal analysis: Prosecutors focused on financial motive and the Walk the Dog letter. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez: 'Juries want to know why. That gives them a reason to convict.' Casarez also said: 'If [the jury] hadn't believed [Lauber], there may not have been a conviction' but that cell phone records 'bolstered Lauber's testimony, adding so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' Attorney Hershon called the Walk the Dog letter 'damning': 'This was a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing.' The verdict form showed jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit. The jurors found the aggravated circumstances — money — unanimously. Casarez: 'The money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict — CNN analysis confirms verdict form showed jury found both murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit: CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez (also an attorney) noted the verdict form showed 'jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit' — confirming 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Casarez also noted cell phone records 'bolstered Lauber's testimony, adding so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' She said: 'If [the jury] hadn't believed her, there may not have been a conviction.' Attorney Hershon quoted: the Walk the Dog letter 'was a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing' and 'makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable, from the prosecutor's point of view.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict additional detail (Fox News): Authorities confirmed that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid — in addition to the fatal fentanyl dose. This is the first time the specific gastric fluid quetiapine level has been publicly reported (previously only noted as 'sub-therapeutic level' in blood).
foxnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict additional detail (NPR/CNN): Confirmed that Eric Richins' father and sisters, in consultation with prosecutors, made the decision not to seek the death penalty. Former prosecutor Evershed noted: 'In a case like this, with all the intricacies of marriage and relationship and home and children and family dynamics... there is certainly no guarantee that a jury would be ruling to have a death penalty.' CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez stated: 'If [the jury] hadn't believed [Lauber], there may not have been a conviction,' and that cell phone records 'added so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' CNN legal analyst Hershon said the Walk the Dog letter was 'damning' — 'This was a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing' — and that the letter 'makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable from the prosecutor's point of view.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
CNN trial analyst Jean Casarez publishes post-verdict analysis: The verdict form showed jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit — 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Casarez notes cell phone records bolstered Lauber's testimony: 'If [the jury] hadn't believed her, there may not have been a conviction.' Casarez also identifies the Walk the Dog letter as 'damning' evidence: 'What she put in that letter makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable, from the prosecutor's point of view. Because all of these other things, it's not just another coincidence... It's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
ABC News '20/20' — Ali Staking exclusive interview: Kouri Richins' childhood best friend Ali Staking spoke exclusively with '20/20' (airing Friday March 20 on ABC). Staking said she and her children were 'devastated' about Eric's sudden 2022 death. She said she had previously told her children 'sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it' but 'I don't think so.' She was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She described Eric as a 'dedicated dad' and 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' 'He had so much more life to live and he wanted so much for his boys.' Staking said: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day. I don't think there's anywhere else he'd wanna be.'
abcnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: CNN Trial Correspondent and attorney Jean Casarez analyzed the conviction. Casarez stated the cellphone data was pivotal in bolstering Carmen Lauber's testimony: 'Cell phone records displayed in court bolstered Lauber's testimony, adding so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' Casarez noted jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit, per the verdict form, showing 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' The Walk the Dog letter was called 'damning' by legal analyst Hershon, who said it 'makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable from the prosecutor's point of view... it's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action that she put together step by step by step.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict — Foreperson Laura (Juror No. 2) speaks to ABC News 'Good Morning America': Laura said her initial impression of Richins was that she was 'kind of nondescript' and 'like a statue' — showing little emotion. 'I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe.' Rather than an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion about the evidence. 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She said jurors 'came into that deliberation fully loaded' and needed to 'zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama.' Cellphone data was what 'blew her out of the water' — helping jurors trace movements related to alleged drug purchases: 'We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' On the children's book reveal: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' On the defense resting without witnesses: 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty... and it was really heartbreaking.' She added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
abcnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict civil litigation disclosed: KPCW reported that in addition to the pending separate 26-count financial crimes case (filed June 2025), Eric Richins' family is pursuing civil claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which says it is illegal to inherit property from a person you killed. It is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue the separate financial crimes trial.
kpcw.org
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Fox News Digital reported that defense attorneys had made multiple attempts before and during trial to have counsel appointed for Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother), an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense initially filed a motion requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden, the state objected, both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December (2025) and portions were made public. The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
foxnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Juror Christie (Juror #3) spoke with EastIdahoNews.com reporter Nate Eaton in a 60-minute interview. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned. Jury selection was conducted virtually and she received an email saying she was selected. Christie sat in the middle of the front row of the jury box. She took fervent notes and often glanced at Richins to gauge her reaction: 'She had a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The most powerful testimony for Christie was the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Eric Haskell) whose testimony was not livestreamed, giving jurors 'an inside look at the drug trade.' She was also struck by Grossman's testimony — he appeared 'devastated' — and by Eric's family members whose grief made clear 'how close they all were.' The moment that shocked Christie most was when the defense abruptly rested without presenting any evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Christie went home mentally exhausted every day and often went to bed early. Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict and encouraged them to speak openly about the case. Christie said after reading more about the case, she is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Jury foreperson Laura (Juror #2) spoke exclusively with ABC News' 'Good Morning America.' Laura said her initial impression of Richins was that she was 'kind of nondescript' — 'She didn't really show that much emotion. I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard.' Laura said: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She said: 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' Rather than taking an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion to talk through evidence and reactions. The moment that most shocked jurors was learning about the children's book: 'Everyone just felt like they were hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' Laura described Richins as largely emotionless during the trial — 'like a statue' — and said she showed little reaction even when the verdict was read. On sympathy: at first she thought Kouri 'was definitely feeling trapped,' but that changed once prosecutors presented forensic evidence, particularly cell phone data. 'I was blown out of the water,' Laura said. 'We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' Laura said: 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' She added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
abcnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: CNN legal analysis noted the key role of cell phone evidence in the conviction. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted that despite Carmen Lauber's credibility issues, 'cell phone records displayed in court bolstered Lauber's testimony, adding so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' Casarez said the verdict form confirms jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit, showing 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Former prosecutor and defense attorney Hershon described the Walk the Dog letter as 'damning' — 'a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing.' Hershon said: 'What she put in that letter makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable, from the prosecutor's point of view... it's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action that she put together step by step by step.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Juror Laura (Juror No. 2 and foreperson) spoke exclusively to ABC News' Good Morning America. She said her initial impression of Kouri shifted dramatically as the trial unfolded. 'The first thing we hear is these terrible things about her and she's just sitting there like all by herself. At first, I was thinking that Kouri was definitely feeling trapped.' That changed once prosecutors presented forensic evidence. 'I was blown out of the water,' she said, pointing to cellphone data. 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' Rather than taking an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion. 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' She said: 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty. They were hoping she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' She described the verdict: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
abcnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Juror Christie (Juror No. 3) spoke exclusively to EastIdahoNews.com. She said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned and had 'no preconceived notions whatsoever.' She described Kouri as 'a small, frail woman' whose kids made her sad initially. She took fervent notes during the trial and sat in the middle of the front row of the jury box. She said the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell, whose testimony was not livestreamed) gave her the most powerful testimony — giving her an inside look at the drug trade. She was also struck by the emotional testimony of Grossman and by Eric's family's grief. The moment that shocked her most: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything' — referring to the defense resting without witnesses. After reading more about the case post-verdict, she said she is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.' Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Fox News reports on previously sealed defense motions regarding Kouri Richins' mother Lisa Darden. Defense attorneys made multiple attempts to have court-appointed counsel for Darden — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure if she were called to testify. Former attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden (state objected; both filings remain sealed). In December, the defense renewed the effort with some portions made public. Lazaro stated: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
foxnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: CNN legal analysis confirms that jurors unanimously found the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit, per the verdict form. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez stated the cell phone records were 'pivotal' in corroborating Lauber's testimony: 'They were pivotal dates, pivotal times, to when prosecutors say the drugs were purchased and close to the time they were administered.' Casarez also said: 'If the jury hadn't believed [Lauber], there may not have been a conviction.' CNN also quoted attorney Hershon calling the Walk the Dog letter 'a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing — this was a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action that she put together step by step by step.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: NewsNation reports on what happens next for Kouri Richins. Former Utah prosecutor Nathan Evershed stated: 'At the end of the day, she is going to prison for a very long time.' Richins will remain in Summit County Jail until sentencing, after which she'll transfer to Utah State Prison for intake. Evershed noted sentencing will include a probation report, victim impact statements (he expects Eric's father, sister, and others), and attorneys. The only question at sentencing: whether she receives life without parole or a sentence with the possibility of parole. Evershed said a credible appeal can take up to a year to prepare. One potential argument: trial venue (denied change of venue to Salt Lake County). He noted the prosecution was aware of 'internal drama' in the case. Evershed said a civil lawsuit by Eric's family is unlikely because 'Ms. Richins has no assets.' Prosecutors chose not to seek the death penalty in consultation with Eric Richins' father and sisters.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict analysis (CNN, March 18): CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez, an attorney who closely covered the trial, analyzed why the prosecution prevailed despite not proving exactly how fentanyl was administered. Casarez stated: (1) 'Motive gives the why — why an alleged crime was committed by the defendant sitting in the courtroom. Juries want to know why. That gives them a reason to convict.' (2) Cell phone records 'bolstered Lauber's testimony, adding so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' (3) 'If the jury hadn't believed her [Lauber], there may not have been a conviction.' (4) On the Walk the Dog letter: 'What she put in that letter makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable, from the prosecutor's point of view.' (5) 'It's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action that she put together step by step by step.' (6) The verdict form's 'pecuniary gain' finding shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Legal analyst Hershon (via CNN) also noted the Walk the Dog letter was 'a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: NPR confirms Kouri told KPCW in April 2023 (before her arrest) that writing the children's book 'brought a little peace to me and my boys' and was 'a really good distraction from this last year.' She described it as helping her family through the first holidays without Eric. She was arrested weeks after that KPCW interview.
npr.org
Mar 18
CNN publishes post-verdict analysis. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez states that cell phone records 'bolstered Lauber's testimony, adding so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' She notes Carmen Lauber: 'If they hadn't believed her, there may not have been a conviction.' Defense attorney Hershon (CNN contributor) describes the Walk the Dog letter as 'damning': 'This was a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing... What she put in that letter makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable, from the prosecutor's point of view.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
NPR published post-verdict report (March 18, 2026) confirming additional detail: Eric Richins was Kouri's second husband. Kouri Richins is also litigating property issues with Eric's family in civil court. In civil court, the Richins family is pursuing claims against her under the 'slayer statute' in Utah law, which says it is illegal to inherit property from the person they killed. Kouri Richins faces 26 other felony charges in the separate financial case filed last year; it is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue that case to trial. The sentencing on May 13 would have been Eric's 44th birthday.
npr.org
Mar 18
Additional detail from NPR post-verdict article: At the time of Eric's death, he was insured by at least six different policies. At least four of those — totaling $1.9 million — were, unbeknownst to Eric, purchased by Kouri between 2015 and 2017. She also made herself the beneficiary of another policy held jointly with Eric and his business partner just months before his death, though Eric changed it once his insurance company alerted him. Prosecutors allege she intended to use insurance money to finish and flip the $2 million mansion in Wasatch County — an investment Eric's family said he did not approve of.
npr.org
Mar 18
Additional Fox News detail: Eric's gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid — confirmed in the Fox News March 16, 2026 article. This is the specific gastric fluid concentration of quetiapine not previously captured in the case record.
foxnews.com
Mar 18
Juror No. 2 'Laura,' the foreperson of the Kouri Richins trial jury, spoke publicly in an exclusive interview with ABC News' 'Good Morning America.' Laura said her initial impression of Richins as 'kind of nondescript' shifted dramatically as the trial unfolded. 'I was blown out of the water' by the cell phone data showing drug purchase movements. Jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than taking an immediate vote. 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' Laura: 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty ... and it was really heartbreaking.' Jurors were shocked to learn about the children's book: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' She described Richins as 'like a statue' during trial. Laura added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
abcnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Ali Staking (Kouri's childhood best friend and trial witness) spoke exclusively with ABC News '20/20' for an episode titled 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial' airing March 20, 2026 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC. Staking said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She described Eric as a 'dedicated dad,' a 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance' with 'so much more life to live.' She said learning of Eric's death was 'surreal.' On whether Kouri did it: 'Sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it. Then my kids would say, "Well, did she?" And I'd say "I don't think so. But, you know, it sometimes looks like it."' Staking said: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day. I don't think there's anywhere else he'd wanna be.'
abcnews.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict context (CNN analysis, March 18): CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez analyzes how prosecutors secured the conviction without proving exactly how the fentanyl was administered. She notes: 'A motive gives the why — why an alleged crime was committed by the defendant. Juries want to know why. That gives them a reason to convict.' The jury found unanimously that the murders were committed for financial benefit per the verdict form. Casarez identifies the cell phone data as adding 'so much credibility to the circumstantial case' — corroborating Lauber's testimony by placing her and Crozier's phones near the Maverik in Draper on the three key dates. CNN legal analyst/attorney Steve Hershon describes the Walk the Dog letter as 'a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges' and calls it 'damning' — noting 'it's not just another coincidence... It's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action.' Defense closing argument acknowledged the house-flipping business was 'struggling' but argued Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive.'
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict legal analysis: CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez, an attorney who closely covered the trial, assessed the conviction. She noted the verdict form showed jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit — 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' She said cell phone records were pivotal in corroborating Lauber's testimony: 'They were pivotal dates, pivotal times, to when prosecutors say the drugs were purchased.' She called the Walk the Dog letter 'damning' and described it as 'a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing.' She noted prosecutors never proved how Kouri administered the fentanyl but argued that circumstantial evidence was sufficient.
cnn.com
Mar 18
Post-verdict: Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro told Fox News Digital that prior to trial, defense attorneys filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother) to protect her constitutional rights — the state objected and both the request and opposition remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December (2025), with portions of that filing made public. Lazaro said the defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro maintained that the 2006 death of Darden's romantic partner was 'consistent with the broader opioid crisis' and was 'one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction.'
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict legal analysis (NewsNation, March 17, 2026): Former Utah prosecutor and defense attorney Nathan Evershed provided analysis on what happens next. Kouri Richins will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. Sentencing is scheduled May 13. Judge Mrazik will review a probation report, hear from attorneys and victim impact statements from Eric Richins' family before determining whether she receives life without parole or a sentence with the possibility of parole. Evershed: 'At the end of the day, she is going to prison for a very long time.' On appeal: preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; once filed, the Utah Attorney General's Office will respond; the case will move to oral arguments, likely before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. Evershed said a venue argument (denied change of venue to Salt Lake County) is a potential appeal issue. On death penalty: prosecutors chose not to pursue it in consultation with Eric Richins' father and sisters; Evershed noted the 'intricacies of marriage and relationship' made a unanimous death penalty verdict unlikely. On civil suit: 'Ms. Richins has no assets'; Eric's family is pursuing claims under the Utah 'slayer statute' (illegal to inherit from someone you killed) in civil court. Evershed said restitution in the criminal case is unlikely to be meaningful given prison wages.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: KPCW confirmed that Kouri Richins still faces 26 felonies in a separate financial crimes case filed June 2025. It is unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue that case to trial following the murder conviction. Additionally, in civil court, Richins is litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family; the family is pursuing claims against her under the Utah 'slayer statute,' which prohibits inheriting property from a person they killed.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict juror interview: Juror No. 2, the foreperson named 'Laura,' gave an exclusive interview to ABC News 'Good Morning America.' Key statements: (1) 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' (2) 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' (3) On the children's book: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' (4) 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' (5) On Kouri in court: 'She was kind of nondescript. She didn't really show that much emotion. I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe.' (6) 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' The foreperson described the deliberation process as requiring jurors to 'zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama.'
wsjm.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: One member of the public, Selena Armithee, who attended nearly the entire trial (missing only two days), was the only public member in the courtroom when the verdict was read. She said she had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during the proceedings. She described Kouri as 'visibly shaking' before jurors entered. Armithee said she believed there was not enough evidence to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Kouri was guilty. She described the experience as 'extremely intense and stressful' and said she likely will not attend another trial in person.
kjzz.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez commented on the verdict. On the verdict form showing financial benefit as the motive for both murder and attempted murder: 'The money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' On Lauber's testimony: 'If they hadn't believed her, there may not have been a conviction.' Cell phone records 'added so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' Legal analyst Ron Hershon described the Walk the Dog letter as 'damning': 'This was a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing.' He said the letter made 'everything else that happened in the trial more believable from the prosecutor's point of view' — because 'it's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action that she put together step by step by step.'
cnn.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Juror foreperson 'Laura' (Juror No. 2) gives an exclusive interview to ABC News' Good Morning America. She describes her first impressions of Kouri Richins: 'She was kind of nondescript. She didn't really show that much emotion. I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe.' On deliberations: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' 'To evaluate the case and to look at the evidence we had to zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama.' On the children's book: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' On the emotional weight: 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' On the outcome: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
whmi.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict legal analysis (Nathan Evershed, former Utah prosecutor): Kouri Richins will remain in Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. Sentencing will include a probation report, victim impact statements from Eric's family, and attorney arguments. Judge Mrazik will decide between life without parole or a sentence with the possibility of parole. Preparing a thorough appeal can take up to a year; the case would then go to the Utah Attorney General's Office before oral arguments before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. One potential appeal argument: venue — the defense had sought to move the trial from Summit County to Salt Lake County. Eric Richins' family could pursue a civil lawsuit but it is unlikely given Kouri has no assets. Restitution in the criminal case is also possible but unlikely to be meaningful given prison wages of approximately 10 cents per hour.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: KPCW confirms that in civil court, Kouri Richins is litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family. The family is pursuing claims against her under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which prohibits a person from inheriting property from someone they killed. Also confirmed: it is unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case filed in June 2025.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Defense team statement post-verdict: Attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester and Alex Ramos issued a written statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' The defense team also stated before closing arguments: 'We believe in the jury system, and we trust the process.'
fox13now.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: KPCW confirms that in the civil arena, Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which prohibits inheriting from a person the beneficiary killed. The separate financial crimes case (26 felony counts filed June 2025) remains pending; it is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue that trial. Kouri is also litigating property issues with Eric's family in civil court.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict context from NPR/KPCW: Kouri Richins promoted her children's book 'Are You With Me?' on KPCW radio in April 2023, saying the process 'brought a little peace to me and my boys' and was 'a really good distraction from this last year.' This interview occurred approximately one month before her May 2023 arrest. NPR also notes Eric Richins did not know Kouri had cut him out of her estate plan — actually, it was the reverse: Eric had quietly cut Kouri out of his will and set up the living trust, and Kouri found out days after his death.
npr.org
Mar 17
POST-VERDICT — Juror Laura (foreperson, Juror No. 2) spoke exclusively to ABC's Good Morning America. Laura described her initial impression of Richins as 'kind of nondescript' with very little emotion — 'like a statue.' She said the jury discussed the evidence roundtable-style before voting. 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' On the three-hour deliberation: 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' Jurors were 'hit with a truck' when they learned about the children's book in the final days of testimony. 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty... they were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' She added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' Laura described the cellphone data as evidence that 'blown out of the water' changed her view. 'We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.'
wsjm.com
Mar 17
Verdict detail — Juror Christie (Juror #3) spoke with EastIdahoNews.com. She knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned. Jury selection was conducted virtually; she received an email the next day saying she was selected. First time she saw Richins was the morning of opening statements — Richins 'seemed like a small, frail woman.' Christie sat in the middle of the front row, took fervent notes, and often glanced at Richins. Said Richins had 'a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' Most impactful witness: the undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell), whose testimony was not livestreamed. Christie was also struck by Grossman's 'devastated' emotional testimony. Most shocking moment: the defense abruptly resting without presenting any evidence. 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Christie went home mentally exhausted every day. Judge Mrazik met with jurors after verdict and encouraged them to speak openly. After reading more about the case, Christie is confident the jury made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict — Lisa Darden potential legal exposure: Fox News Digital reports defense attorneys made multiple attempts to have counsel appointed for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden prior to trial — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden; the state objected. Both filings remain sealed. Defense renewed the effort in December; portions of that filing were made public. The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. The exact scope of Darden's potential testimony or legal exposure remains unclear.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict — Civil litigation update: KPCW reports that in civil court, Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri Richins under the 'slayer statute' in Utah law — which says it is illegal to inherit property from the person they killed. The civil case is ongoing alongside the murder sentencing and separate financial crimes case. It is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case filed June 2025.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict — Appeals process outlook: Former Utah prosecutor/defense attorney Nathan Evershed told NewsNation that preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year. Once filed, the Utah Attorney General's Office will respond, and the case will move to oral arguments before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. One potential appeal argument: the trial venue (denied change to Salt Lake County). Evershed noted: 'I don't know how that will land, or if that's even going to be something that will be remotely even considered.' Evershed also noted Eric Richins' family could theoretically pursue a civil lawsuit but: 'Ms. Richins has no assets, and so to try to do something like that would be very, very difficult.' Restitution in the criminal case is possible but 'with her now being in prison and maybe working for 10 cents an hour, possibly it's just not going to happen.'
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict legal analysis: Former Utah prosecutor and defense attorney Nathan Evershed told NewsNation that Kouri Richins 'is going to prison for a very long time.' He noted: (1) Judge Mrazik will review a probation report and hear from attorneys and victim impact statements before determining life without parole vs. a sentence with possible parole; (2) Preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; (3) The Utah Attorney General's Office will respond to any appeal; (4) The case will likely move to oral arguments before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals; (5) One potential appeal argument focuses on venue — the defense had sought to move the trial from Summit County to Salt Lake County; (6) Although Utah allows the death penalty, prosecutors chose not to pursue it — the decision was made in consultation with Eric Richins' father and sisters; (7) A civil lawsuit by Eric's family is unlikely because Richins has no assets; (8) The family can pursue restitution in the criminal case.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict — Lisa Darden legal exposure: Fox News reported that defense attorneys had made multiple attempts before trial to have counsel appointed for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro told Fox News the defense filed an initial motion requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden, the state objected, and both filings remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December 2025, with portions made public. Lazaro said: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Lazaro previously characterized the 2006 death of Darden's partner as consistent with the broader opioid crisis: '[She] was one of the millions that suffered from, and ultimately succumbed to, opioid addiction. It is tragic, and, unfortunately, quite common.'
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict — KPCW confirmed: The separate 26-count financial crimes case filed June 2025 remains pending; it is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue trial on those charges. Kouri is also litigating property issues with Eric's family in civil court. Eric's family is pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which prohibits inheriting property from a person one has killed.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict — Juror Laura (foreperson, Juror No. 2) speaks to ABC News/GMA: Laura was the foreperson (Juror No. 2). She described her initial impression of Richins as 'kind of nondescript' with little emotion — 'like a statue.' She said her sympathy for Kouri flipped once forensic evidence was presented: 'I was blown out of the water.' Cell phone data tracking the alleged drug purchases was a pivotal piece of evidence. The jury chose a round-table discussion rather than a formal vote: 'We decided to just go one by one around the table and just let it out.' Laura said: 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she would be innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' On the verdict form, there was 'never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' Laura said: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She said the jury felt 'fully loaded' coming into deliberations. The children's book revelation struck jurors hard: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck.' On Kouri's demeanor when the verdict was read: 'I think she was surprised and she was shocked and upset. I didn't sense any remorse whatsoever.' Laura noted: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' The jury deliberated for approximately 3 hours. After the verdict, Judge Mrazik spoke with jurors and encouraged them to speak openly about the case.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Juror Laura (foreperson, Juror No. 2) gives first public interview to ABC News' 'Good Morning America.' Laura described her initial impression of Kouri as 'nondescript' — difficult to read any emotion from. She said the jury held a roundtable discussion before voting rather than taking an immediate vote. 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty … and it was really heartbreaking.' She said jurors hoped Richins was innocent but could not reach that conclusion. On the children's book revelation: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' Laura said the cell phone data that corroborated Lauber's drug purchase timeline was the pivotal piece of evidence: 'I was blown out of the water.' She said jurors 'came into that deliberation fully loaded' and there was 'never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' Laura described the verdict as taking just under three hours. She noted Richins showed no emotion even when the verdict was read — 'like a statue.' She added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Juror No. 2 (Laura), the foreperson, spoke to ABC News 'Good Morning America' in an exclusive interview. She described her initial impression of Kouri as 'kind of nondescript' — 'She didn't really show that much emotion.' On deliberations: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' Jurors held a roundtable discussion before voting. 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty… They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' On the children's book revelation: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' On the verdict: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' The cell phone data was pivotal: 'I was blown out of the water… We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' Rather than taking an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion first. Laura described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' throughout trial with little reaction.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict (KPCW): Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri Richins under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which says it is illegal to inherit property from the person they killed. Kouri is also still litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family in civil court. It is unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case filed June 2025.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Kouri Richins' defense attorneys issued a written statement (attributed to Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos) reiterating their client's innocence claim: 'Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. ... Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' Prosecution and defense both declined to comment directly to media after the verdict, per Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict legal analysis (NewsNation): Former Utah prosecutor/defense attorney Nathan Evershed analyzed next steps. He said Kouri will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before permanent housing assignment. He said Kouri will have an opportunity to speak at sentencing but it is unlikely she will. Judge Mrazik will review a probation report, hear from attorneys and victim impact statements (from Eric's family — Gene Richins, sisters, others) before determining whether Kouri will receive life without parole or a sentence with possibility of parole. Evershed said preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; once filed, the Utah Attorney General's Office will respond, then oral arguments before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. One potential appellate argument is the venue issue (trial kept in Summit County over defense objection). Evershed said a civil lawsuit by the Richins family is unlikely because Kouri 'has no assets.' Restitution may be pursued in the criminal case but with limited practical result given prison wages.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: KPCW reports that in civil court, Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which bars inheriting property from a person they killed. The separate 26-count financial crimes case filed June 2025 remains pending; it is unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue a trial in that case.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict: CNN trial analyst commentary noted that jurors unanimously agreed the murder was committed for pecuniary (financial) gain, showing 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' CNN noted that the prosecution's evidence that Kouri applied for a $100,000 TruStage life insurance policy included an incorrect Social Security number for Eric — a detail insurance agent testimony had established at trial.
cnn.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Fox News reported that defense attorneys had previously filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother) — an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. The state objected and both filings remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December 2025 and portions of that filing were made public. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' Lazaro also said the defense sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict legal analysis from former Utah prosecutor/defense attorney Nathan Evershed (NewsNation): Richins faces 25 years to life in prison, with sentencing to be decided by Judge Mrazik. The judge will review a probation report, hear from attorneys, and hear victim impact statements from Eric Richins' family before determining whether she receives life without parole or a sentence with the possibility of parole. Kouri will have an opportunity to speak at sentencing, though Evershed said it is unlikely she will. She will remain in Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake. Regarding appeals: preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; the Utah AG's Office will respond; the case will likely go to oral arguments before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. Venue change (denied twice) is a potential appeal argument. A civil lawsuit by Eric's family is possible but unlikely given Kouri has no assets. The family is pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which prevents a person from inheriting property from someone they killed.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
KPCW post-verdict reporting confirms: The murder trial, originally scheduled to last until March 27, wrapped up more than a week early. Richins still faces 26 felonies in another case prosecutors filed last June; it is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue that case. In civil court, Richins is litigating property issues with Eric's family. The family is pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which says it is illegal to inherit property from the person they killed. Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn confirmed neither side would comment directly after the verdict.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
ABC News 'Good Morning America' exclusive interview with Laura — jury foreperson (Juror No. 2): Laura said her initial impression of Richins was that she was 'kind of nondescript' and showed little emotion. Laura said: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' On deliberations: 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' Rather than taking an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion. 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty … and it was really heartbreaking.' 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' Laura said the cellphone data was the pivotal evidence: 'I was blown out of the water — we all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' She described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' with little reaction even when the verdict was read. Laura confirmed jurors unanimously agreed the homicide was committed for financial (pecuniary) gain.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict to answer questions. He encouraged them to speak openly about the case with loved ones if they wished. Amy Richins issued a fuller statement on behalf of Eric's family: 'Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his voice as we all continue to heal.' KPCW reported that neither side would comment directly after the verdict, per Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Former prosecutor and defense attorney Nathan Evershed commented on what happens next for Kouri Richins. He said she will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing on May 13, after which she will transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. At sentencing, Judge Mrazik will review a probation report, hear from attorneys and victim impact statements from Eric's family before determining whether she will receive life without parole or a sentence that includes the possibility of parole. Evershed said an appeal 'can take up to a year' to prepare. Potential appeal arguments may include the venue denial (Summit County vs. Salt Lake County). Evershed said a civil lawsuit by Eric's family against Kouri is unlikely because 'Ms. Richins has no assets.' He noted the family may pursue restitution in the criminal case. Regarding the death penalty, Evershed noted prosecutors chose not to pursue it and said the decision was made 'in consultation with Eric Richins' father and sisters.' Evershed said: 'At the end of the day, she is going to prison for a very long time.'
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: KPCW reported that Kouri Richins still faces 26 felonies in a separate financial crimes case filed in June 2025. It is unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue that case. Additionally, in civil court, Richins is litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family, who are pursuing claims against her under the 'slayer statute' in Utah law — which says it is illegal to inherit property from the person they killed.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict analysis (NewsNation, March 17): Former Utah prosecutor/defense attorney Nathan Evershed commented on what happens next for Kouri Richins: (1) She will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing on May 13, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before permanent housing; (2) Sentencing: Judge Mrazik will review a probation report, hear from attorneys, and receive victim impact statements from Eric's family; 'The only question is if there's a chance of her possibly having parole some decades from now'; (3) Preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year; appeal likely to Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals; (4) One potential appeal argument: venue — defense had sought Salt Lake County but was denied; (5) Although Utah allows the death penalty, prosecutors chose not to pursue it — per court filings, the decision was made in consultation with Eric's father and sisters; (6) A civil lawsuit by Eric's family is unlikely because 'Ms. Richins has no assets.'
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Defense attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos issued a written statement following closing arguments (before the verdict): 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning... Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' The defense team expressed confidence in the jury system. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis also stated during closing: 'I'm sure you want me to stop talking, but I'm afraid to stop talking.'
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reporting: New detail on Eric's gastric fluid — Fox News reports that authorities found Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine (an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid), in addition to the fentanyl. This supplements the existing toxicology record. CNN also confirmed the verdict form shows jurors unanimously found both aggravating circumstances: (1) the homicide was committed for pecuniary gain; and (2) the homicide was committed by administration of a substance in a lethal amount.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reporting: Juror #2 (foreperson 'Laura') gave exclusive interview to ABC News' 'Good Morning America.' Laura said her initial impression of Kouri shifted from sympathy to conviction as the trial progressed. She described Kouri as 'like a statue' and said she showed 'little emotion' during the trial. Laura said jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than an immediate vote. 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She said: 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' Jurors were 'hit like a truck' when they learned about the ghostwritten children's book. 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' She added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.'
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reporting: Juror #3 'Christie' gave interview to EastIdahoNews.com. Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before jury duty. Jury selection was conducted virtually and she received an email the next day saying she had been selected. She sat in the middle of the front row and took detailed notes throughout the trial. The most powerful testimony for her was from an undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell, whose testimony was not livestreamed). She was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's 'devastated' testimony and the grief of Eric's family members. The moment that shocked her the most was when the defense abruptly rested without presenting any evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict and encouraged them to speak openly. Christie said after reading more about the case, she is confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reporting: Juror foreperson Laura (Juror #2) told ABC News that cellphone data was pivotal — she was 'blown out of the water' by the evidence showing phone movements tied to alleged drug purchases. 'I was blown out of the water. We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' She added that forensic evidence in particular drove the shift from sympathy to guilty verdict.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reporting: Legal analyst Nathan Evershed (former Utah prosecutor) told NewsNation that Kouri Richins will remain in Summit County Jail until sentencing, after which she will transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. He said the judge will review a probation report and hear victim impact statements before deciding whether to impose life without parole or a sentence with possibility of parole. He noted preparing a thorough appeal can take up to a year. One potential appeal argument: venue — the defense sought to move the trial from Summit County to Salt Lake County and was denied. He noted the death penalty was not pursued — prosecutors made that decision in consultation with Eric's father and sisters, weighing 'the complexities of the case, including family dynamics.' He said Eric's family could theoretically pursue a civil lawsuit but it is unlikely: 'Ms. Richins has no assets.'
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reporting: Fox News reported that defense attorneys made multiple attempts before the verdict to have counsel appointed for Lisa Darden, an unusual move suggesting she could face potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden; the state objected. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December (2025); portions of that filing were made public. Lazaro said: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reporting (KPCW): Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn said neither side would comment directly after the verdict. KPCW also confirmed that in civil court, the Richins family is pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which says it is illegal to inherit property from someone you killed. The financial crimes case (26 felonies filed June 2025) remains pending; it is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue that trial.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict detail confirmed (CNN/AP): The verdict form specified jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for pecuniary (financial) gain — showing 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds' per CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez. Casarez also noted that cell phone records corroborating Carmen Lauber's testimony 'added so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' The Walk the Dog letter was described by legal analyst Hershon as 'damning' because it showed 'a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing.'
cnn.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict detail (Ali Staking ABC 20/20 interview): Kouri's childhood best friend Ali Staking, who testified during the trial, gave an exclusive interview to ABC News '20/20' (episode 'Murder She Wrote: The Kouri Richins Trial,' airing March 20, 2026 on ABC). Staking said she was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She described Eric Richins as a 'dedicated dad' and a 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance' who 'had so much more life to live.' Staking said throughout the case she told her children 'sometimes it looks like Kouri might have done it' but also said 'I don't think so.' She said it was 'surreal' learning of Eric's death.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reaction: Selena Armithee, described as the only member of the general public inside the courtroom when the verdict was read (she had attended almost every day of the trial, missing only two, and had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during the proceedings), told KUTV she was 'surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision' and personally believed there was not enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. 'It was extremely intense and stressful,' she said.
kutv.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict reporting (Daily Mail): Eric Richins' father Eugene was observed in the courtroom remaining stoic and bowing his head while the verdict was read. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden, who had stood by her daughter throughout the case, remained 'stony-faced and pursed her lips.' Kouri was described as wearing a 'floral patterned shirt' with her 'hair scraped back in a neat bun' and appeared stoic but 'gasped and hung her head as soon as Judge Richard Mrazik read out her conviction on the first count.'
dailymail.co.uk
Mar 17
Post-verdict detail (Fox News / additional confirmation): Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid — according to Fox News reporting on charging documents and trial evidence. This supplements the existing record noting quetiapine was found in his system at sub-therapeutic levels; the specific gastric fluid concentration figure is newly reported.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict juror interview — Foreperson Laura (Juror No. 2) speaks to ABC News/GMA: Laura, the jury foreperson, gave an exclusive interview to ABC News' 'Good Morning America.' Key statements: (1) Her initial impression of Kouri: 'She was kind of nondescript. She didn't really show that much emotion. I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe.' (2) On deliberations: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' (3) 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' (4) Jurors held a roundtable discussion before taking any vote: 'To evaluate the case and to look at the evidence we had to zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama.' (5) Cell phone data was the turning point for her: 'I was blown out of the water. We all led to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' (6) On the children's book: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' (7) On fellow jurors' emotions: 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' (8) 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' (9) Kouri appeared 'like a statue' and showed little reaction even when the verdict was read — initial impression had shifted from sympathy to guilty conviction after seeing forensic evidence.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict juror interview — Christie (Juror No. 3) speaks to EastIdahoNews.com: Christie said she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being selected. She was selected virtually and did not see Kouri until opening statements. She sat in the middle of the front row of the jury box. Key statements: (1) First impression of Kouri: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad. They told us right away she had kids and my heart broke.' (2) Kouri had 'a really good poker face. I couldn't tell what she was thinking.' (3) The undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell, whose testimony was not livestreamed) was the most powerful witness for her, giving an inside look at the drug trade. (4) Also found Grossman's testimony impactful — he appeared 'devastated.' (5) The moment that shocked her most: when the defense rested without presenting any evidence. 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' (6) Went home mentally exhausted every day and often went to bed early. (7) After reading more about the case post-verdict, she is confident she and fellow jurors made the right call. Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict and encouraged them to speak openly about the case with loved ones.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict details on Fox News Darden legal exposure reporting: Defense attorneys made multiple attempts prior to and during trial to have counsel appointed for Lisa Darden, an unusual move suggesting she could face potential legal exposure if called to testify. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro told Fox News Digital the defense initially filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Darden, but the state objected. Both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed by the court. The defense renewed the effort in December (2025), and portions of the filing were made public. Lazaro said: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Darden has not been charged with any crime.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict confirmed: Jury composition correction — KPCW confirms the deliberating jury consisted of 6 men and 2 women (8 primary jurors). This corrects the existing record which stated '6 men and 6 women' — that was the initial 12-person seated panel; after 4 alternates (who included some women) were excused, the deliberating body was 6 men and 2 women.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine — confirmed by Fox News coverage of the verdict. This specific quantification of quetiapine in Eric's gastric fluid had not previously been reported in the case record.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Kouri Richins-Eric's prenuptial agreement confirmed in closing arguments — the agreement included an exception: if Eric died while the two were lawfully married, she would have rights to his property. Without this exception, she would leave the marriage with nothing if they divorced. Bloodworth stated in closing: 'Their prenuptial agreement meant that if she left him, she would also leave most of his money.' NPR also confirmed Kouri 'took a quarter of a million dollars in equity out of Eric Richins' home, without him knowing it, so that she could start her own business and earn enough money to leave Eric Richins' — which Eric discovered in September 2020, by which point she had charged more than $30,000 on his credit and withdrawn at least $100,000 from his bank accounts.
npr.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Prosecution closing argument detail — Bloodworth argued Kouri 'intended to cause her husband's death as early as December 2021' when she booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman for April 2022. 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.' This specific framing of the December 2021 vacation booking as premeditation evidence was a key prosecution closing argument.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Defense closing argument detail — Lewis told the jury she was 'afraid to stop talking' and that she 'wished she could follow them into the jury room.' She said if Kouri 'accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric died, that is not aggravated murder.' She also said if Kouri had just told investigators she got the pills for Eric when asked, 'we probably wouldn't be sitting here today.' Lewis acknowledged 'they said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial' but said the defense has no obligation to present evidence. Defense post-verdict written statement: 'After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 17
Juror No. 2 (Laura, the foreperson) speaks publicly in an exclusive interview with ABC News / Good Morning America. She describes deliberations as taking approximately 3 hours. 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She says: 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' On the children's book revelation: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' On finding Kouri guilty: 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' On the impact: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' On initial impression of Kouri: 'She was kind of nondescript. She didn't really show that much emotion. I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe.' Later: Kouri appeared 'like a statue.' The pivotal evidence for Laura was cell phone data showing movements tied to alleged drug purchases: 'I was blown out of the water.' Jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than taking an immediate vote.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Juror No. 2 (Laura), the jury foreperson, spoke with ABC News' Good Morning America. She described deliberations: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She said: 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' She described her initial impression of Richins as 'kind of nondescript' with little emotion, but said her sympathy shifted when forensic evidence was presented — specifically cell phone data: 'I was blown out of the water.' Rather than an immediate vote, jurors held a roundtable discussion. 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty... and it was really heartbreaking.' She said: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' On the children's book reveal: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' Laura appeared in Good Morning America interview. She confirmed the eight-member jury consisted of six men and two women.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
KPCW reports that in civil court, Kouri Richins is litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family. The family is pursuing claims against her under the 'slayer statute' in Utah law, which says it is illegal to inherit property from a person one killed. It remains unclear whether prosecutors will pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case given the murder conviction.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Fox News reports that defense attorneys had previously filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden (Kouri's mother), which the state objected to — both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December 2025 and portions were made public. The filings suggest Darden could be a key witness in future proceedings. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed the motion was filed to 'protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict juror interviews: Jury foreperson Laura (Juror No. 2) told ABC News' Good Morning America that jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than taking an immediate vote. She said: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' Laura said she was initially sympathetic toward Kouri — 'At first, I was thinking Kouri was definitely feeling trapped' — but changed her view after forensic evidence, especially the cell phone data. 'I was blown out of the water.' She described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' and showing little reaction even when the verdict was read. She said: 'People were really sad because they did not want to find her guilty … and it was really heartbreaking.' She added: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' On the children's book evidence: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' She said jurors felt they came into deliberations 'fully loaded.' The jury deliberated for just over 3 hours, evaluating each 'little bit of evidence' and ignoring 'all the fluff and drama.'
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict juror interview: Christie (Juror No. 3) told EastIdahoNews.com she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned and 'just wanted to keep an open mind and find the truth.' Jury selection was conducted virtually for her; she received an email saying she was selected. She said Kouri had a 'really good poker face' and she 'couldn't tell what she was thinking.' The undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Haskell, whose testimony was not livestreamed) was the most powerful witness for her — giving an inside look at the drug trade. She was also struck by emotional testimony from Robert Josh Grossman, who appeared 'devastated,' and by the grief of Eric's family members. The moment that shocked her most was when the defense abruptly rested without calling witnesses: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict and encouraged them to speak openly about the case. After reading more about the case, Christie is confident in the verdict.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict disclosure — Lisa Darden and appointment of counsel: Fox News Digital reports that defense attorneys made multiple attempts during the case to have counsel appointed for Kouri's mother Lisa Darden, an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro told Fox News that the defense initially filed a motion requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden, which the state objected to; both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed the effort in December, and portions were made public. Lazaro said 'they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights' and the defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: KPCW reports the civil litigation between Kouri Richins and Eric Richins' family continues. Eric's family is pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which says it is illegal to inherit property from a person they killed. The separate financial crimes case (26 felony charges filed June 2025) remains pending; it is unclear whether prosecutors will still pursue that trial.
kpcw.org
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Ali Staking (Kouri's childhood best friend who testified at trial) spoke to ABC's '20/20' program (airing March 20, 2026 at 9 p.m. ET on ABC). Staking said she was 'devastated' about Eric's death, describing him as 'a dedicated dad' and 'a goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance.' She said it was 'surreal' and that along the way she sometimes told her children 'it sometimes looks like Kouri might have done it.' She was 'very surprised that there was no defense.' She wants Eric to be remembered as 'a loving dad' and said: 'I believe Eric is with his kids all the time every day.'
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict CNN analysis: CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez (also an attorney) noted that jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit per the verdict form — 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Casarez said cell phone records 'added so much credibility to the circumstantial case' and bolstered Lauber's testimony. CNN legal analyst Hershon called the Walk the Dog letter 'damning': 'This was a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing. What she put in that letter makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable.' Casarez noted the verdict form confirmed the aggravated circumstances — pecuniary gain and lethal substance administration.
cnn.com
Mar 17
Verdict form detail confirmed via CNN reporting: Jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed 'for financial benefit' — the aggravating circumstances specified on the verdict form. CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez noted this shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' The verdict form explicitly called out financial benefit as the aggravating factor agreed upon by all jurors.
cnn.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Legal analyst Nathan Evershed (NewsNation) confirmed Kouri will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before permanent housing assignment. He confirmed Judge Mrazik will review a probation/pre-sentence report, hear from attorneys, and receive victim impact statements from Eric's family before determining whether she receives life without parole or a sentence with possibility of parole. Evershed said preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year. He identified the trial venue issue (Summit vs. Salt Lake County) as one possible appeal argument. He noted Eric's family could pursue civil remedies but that Kouri has no assets making this difficult. On the death penalty: prosecutors chose not to pursue it, in consultation with Eric's father and sisters, partly due to the complexities of the case and uncertainty of a unanimous death penalty verdict.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict Fox News reporting: Defense attorneys had previously filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden, an unusual move suggesting potential legal exposure if called to testify. The state objected. Both filings remain sealed. The defense renewed that effort in December 2025, and portions of the filing were made public. Former defense attorney Skye Lazaro confirmed: 'It is my understanding from what was made public they asked for her to be appointed counsel to protect her constitutional rights.' The defense also sought court-appointed attorneys for several other potential witnesses. Defense attorneys Nester and Ramos did not respond to Fox News requests for comment.
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Juror No. 2 (Laura, the foreperson) gave an exclusive interview to ABC News' 'Good Morning America.' Key disclosures: (1) Her initial impression of Kouri was that she was 'kind of nondescript' — 'She didn't really show that much emotion. I was trying to get some vibe from her and it was very hard to pick up any kind of vibe.' (2) The jury never had a 'not guilty' check on any element: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' (3) Jurors 'led to the same conclusion' after phone/cell data evidence: 'I was blown out of the water.' (4) Deliberations: 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' Jurors started with a roundtable discussion rather than an immediate vote. (5) On the children's book: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange.' (6) On guilt: 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' (7) On the impact: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' (8) Laura described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' and showing little reaction even when the verdict was read.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Juror No. 3 (Christie) gave an interview to EastIdahoNews.com. Key disclosures: (1) She knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before being summoned; jury selection was conducted virtually. (2) First impression of Kouri: 'She just seemed like a small, frail woman. It made me sad.' (3) Kouri had a 'really good poker face.' (4) The testimony that made the biggest impact on her was the undercover narcotics officer whose testimony was not livestreamed — gave an inside look at the drug trade. (5) She was also struck by Robert Josh Grossman's testimony; he appeared 'devastated.' (6) The most shocking moment: when the defense abruptly rested without presenting any evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' (7) After the verdict, Judge Mrazik met with jurors and encouraged them to speak openly. (8) Christie said after reading more about the case post-verdict, she is confident they made the right call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: CNN legal analyst Jean Casarez and attorney Daniel Hershon commented on the evidence that drove the conviction. Casarez noted: jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit (per the verdict form), showing 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Cell phone records corroborating Lauber's testimony 'added so much credibility to the circumstantial case.' The Walk the Dog letter was described as 'damning' by Hershon: 'This was a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony to counteract the charges she was facing.' Hershon said the letter 'makes everything else that happened in the trial more believable, from the prosecutor's point of view.' Casarez noted that 'consciousness of guilt — through what a defendant said or did or didn't say — can speak volumes to a jury.'
cnn.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Juror No. 2 (foreperson Laura) speaks with ABC News 'Good Morning America' in an exclusive interview. She describes the deliberation process: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' She says the jury did not immediately vote but held a roundtable discussion. Key moments for her: (1) initial impression of Kouri was 'nondescript' — 'She didn't really show that much emotion'; (2) her impression shifted when prosecutors presented cell phone data — 'I was blown out of the water'; (3) the children's book revelation left jurors feeling 'hit with a truck' — 'We're like, what? What the hell is this? It was so odd and so strange'; (4) 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking'; (5) 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded'; (6) 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' Laura describes Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' and showing little reaction even when the verdict was read.
abcnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Juror No. 3 (Christie) speaks with EastIdahoNews.com. She says she knew 'absolutely nothing' about the case before jury selection and was selected virtually. She took notes throughout and paid attention to every witness. The most powerful testimony for her was from an undercover narcotics officer (Sgt. Eric Haskell) whose testimony was not livestreamed, which gave 'an inside look at the drug trade.' She was also struck by emotional testimony from Robert Josh Grossman, who appeared 'devastated,' and from Eric Richins' family members whose grief made clear 'how close they all were.' The moment that shocked her most was the defense resting without calling any witnesses or evidence: 'Utter shock. We all walked out of the courtroom wide-eyed. I wanted to hear their side. I was open to it. But they didn't present anything.' After the verdict, Judge Mrazik met with jurors privately and encouraged them to speak openly about the case with loved ones. After reading more about the case, Christie says she is 'confident she and fellow jurors made the right call.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict: Juror Laura (foreperson, No. 2) told Fox News/ABC that cell phone data was pivotal — jurors were led 'to the same conclusion that she was guilty.' She confirmed jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than immediately voting. She described initial sympathy for Kouri that 'flipped' as the evidence was presented. The jury found unanimously that both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit, per the verdict form — which CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez noted 'shows the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
foxnews.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict legal analyst commentary: Former Utah prosecutor/defense attorney Nathan Evershed (NewsNation) says Kouri will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before permanent housing assignment. He says the judge will review a probation report, hear from attorneys and victim impact statements from Eric's family before determining whether she receives life without parole or a sentence including possibility of parole. He identifies the change-of-venue denial as a potential appeal argument but notes the judge 'did a pretty good job ruling on that.' He says a credible appeal can take up to a year to prepare before oral arguments before the Utah Supreme Court or Court of Appeals. He describes a civil lawsuit as unlikely because 'Ms. Richins has no assets.' He also confirms former attorney Skye Lazaro disclosed that the defense had filed a motion requesting the court appoint counsel for Lisa Darden, with the state objecting — both the defense request and prosecution's objection remain sealed. The defense renewed the motion in December 2024 and portions were made public.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 17
Post-verdict juror interviews: Juror foreperson Laura (Juror No. 2) gave an exclusive interview to ABC's Good Morning America. She said jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than taking an immediate vote. She described deliberations: 'Even though it was just three hours, I felt like we came into that deliberation fully loaded.' She said the evidence that 'blew her out of the water' was the cellphone data tracking movements tied to alleged drug purchases. She described Kouri as appearing 'like a statue' throughout trial, showing little reaction. On the children's book revelation, she said: 'Everyone just felt like they're hit with a truck. We're like, what? What the hell is this?' She added: 'People were really sad, because they did not want to find her guilty. They were really hoping that she was innocent. And we couldn't come to that conclusion, and it was really heartbreaking.' She said: 'This devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' On evidence: 'To evaluate the case and to look at the evidence we had to zoom in on these little bits of evidence and kind of ignore all the fluff and ignore the drama.'
abcnews.com
Mar 168:30 AM
Closing arguments and jury instructions scheduled for Monday, March 16, 2026. Both prosecution and defense are expected to deliver closing arguments before the case is handed to the jury for deliberations. This will be the final day of attorney argument before the case goes to the jury.
kpcw.org
Mar 168:30 AM
Trial Day 15 (Week 4, Day 1): Closing arguments and jury instructions begin at 8:30 a.m. General public excluded from the courtroom; seating reserved for both families and media only. Both prosecution (Bloodworth) and defense (Nester) expected to deliver closing arguments. Jury deliberations to follow. No content from closing arguments has been published yet as of this update.
abc4.com
Mar 168:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Closing arguments began at 8:30 a.m. as scheduled. General public excluded from the courtroom. Both families received two rows; media one row. Jury instructions to be read before deliberations begin. No content from the closing arguments has been publicly reported yet as of the last update (March 16, 2026).
kpcw.org
Mar 168:29 AM
Trial Day 15 — Jury instructions read by Judge Mrazik before closing arguments. Judge read instructions beginning at 8:34 a.m. Key instructions: jury of 8 will deliberate (alternates 9, 10, 11, 12 excused but remain on standby); Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier both received 'informant' instruction (not 'snitch'); jury reminded defendant not testifying cannot be considered evidence of guilt; direct vs. circumstantial evidence explained; verdict on each count must be unanimous; motive instruction was removed.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:30 AM
Legal analysts Nathan Evershed and Skye Lazaro commented publicly on the defense's zero-witness strategy and the significance of closing arguments. Evershed said: 'They will be arguing in their closing argument that we don't need to make a case — we have nothing to prove. It is solely upon the prosecution to prove this beyond a reasonable doubt.' He also noted: 'By putting her up on the stand, you can open the door — she says something and all of a sudden all the stuff you were trying to keep out is coming in.' Lazaro said: 'Closing arguments are really your last opportunity to sell the jury. The state gets to go first, then the defense gets to go, and the state gets the last say because it's their burden to prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.' Both analysts agreed the defense's decision to rest without witnesses signals the strategy of arguing the prosecution failed to meet its burden of proof. Evershed predicted closing arguments would take all day Monday.
kutv.com
Mar 169:01 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing argument by Brad Bloodworth begins. Bloodworth argued Kouri Richins was 'intensely ambitious,' driven by 'an intense desire to appear privileged, affluent and successful,' and 'wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money.' He stated: 'There was a way forward. Eric had to die.' Bloodworth argued she had means (illicit street drugs), motive (money and a fresh start with Josh Grossman), and opportunity (the only other adult in the home). He described Kouri's debt as nearing $8 million and said October 2021 was 'the beginning of the downward financial death spiral.' He argued she booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman in December 2021 'knowing' Eric would not be alive in April: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:22 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth replayed the 911 call for jurors during closing, with a countdown clock on screen showing how long before Kouri began CPR — approximately 6 minutes from when the dispatcher first asked her to start. Bloodworth argued Kouri 'dehumanized' Eric by referring to him as 'it' rather than 'him' during the call ('I can't move it'). Bloodworth said: 'That's not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It's the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He argued she gave her alibi — that she was in her son's room — immediately, 'distancing herself from the time and the place that she murdered Eric.' Kouri had told Chelsea Barney in texts that she 'pumped so damn hard' trying to revive Eric; Bloodworth said 'none of that happened' and it was a cover-up.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:44 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth closing argument continued: argued Kouri did not understand the trust or the buy-sell agreement — 'The morning Eric died, she had a plan on how to spend Eric's money, not realizing it was trust money.' He argued Kouri's orange notebook was inconsistent — she wrote they had the celebratory drink in the bedroom, but other accounts say the kitchen; she wrote Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's room around 9:30-9:45 p.m., but Eric's phone activity ended before 9 p.m. Bloodworth argued: 'When people make up stories, they are inconsistent in the retelling.' He told jurors Kouri asked Grossman about killing someone in Iraq 'because she was working through her own feelings on killing and wanted Josh to help her work through those feelings.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:05 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth closing argument: argued Kouri intentionally delayed closing on the Midway mansion until March 5 (the day after Eric died) because she 'wanted to make sure Eric was dead before she closed.' He displayed internet searches made on Kouri's phone on April 13, 2022 (the day of the search warrant). He referenced the five times lethal dose of fentanyl as evidence she wanted Eric 'not only dead but good and dead.' He also argued about the Valentine's Day attempted poisoning: 'She learned from her mistake' — with the sandwich Eric partially set aside, but with the Moscow mule/lemon drop shot, 'you throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric knew something was wrong, it was in his body.' He said she 'distanced herself from the dirty deed' by leaving the bedroom when she murdered him and leaving the county when she attempted to murder him on Valentine's Day.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:22 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth closing argument on financial distress: stated Kouri had nearly $8 million in debt when she closed on the Midway mansion; she submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders six times to get money; she lost nearly $900,000 flipping homes (not counting foreclosures); she lost millions more in foreclosures; payday lenders would no longer lend to her; she was 'barely paying toward them.' Bloodworth: 'Kouri Richins lost money flipping homes. She was not a sophisticated business person. She didn't even understand fundamental accounting, fundamental tax reporting.' Also noted Kouri took $45,000 from Chelsea Barney's tip money, used it for other purposes, and lied to her friend saying it had been applied to a loan.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:06 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth closing argument on insurance fraud and forgery: displayed insurance documents and changes made to them; showed the application for Eric's life insurance signed weeks before he died, stating 'Eric did not sign the application — it was probably a simulated forgery' per handwriting expert testimony. Said of Kouri: 'She's a taker, not an asker.' Bloodworth also argued Eric did not die by suicide — 'he was planning to go to Disneyland, he loved his sons, he was planning to buy a cabin with his father' — and did not use illicit drugs. Stated: 'The evidence proves that Kouri Richins murdered, attempted to murder Eric Richins and that she committed two counts of insurance fraud and forgery. The evidence does not support any other explanation.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:17 AM
Trial Day 15 — FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION (defense): Immediately after Bloodworth's closing argument concluded, defense attorney Kathryn Nester moved for a mistrial. She argued Bloodworth: (1) 'dehumanized' the defendant by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider; (2) improperly commented on Kouri's demeanor in the courtroom — which Nester characterized as a comment on her failure to testify; (3) engaged in 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind 'completely made up by Mr. Bloodworth with no evidence whatsoever.' Nester also argued Bloodworth wrongly told jurors any illicit drug could support aggravated murder. Judge Mrazik denied the mistrial motion. He ruled: the 'black widow' comment came from a recorded phone call (Chelsea Barney referring to Kouri), not fabricated by Bloodworth; comments on demeanor were permissible but he would provide a curative instruction; he did not find that Bloodworth commented on Kouri's right not to testify. Mrazik agreed to issue a curative instruction telling jurors they may consider their own observations of the defendant's demeanor but may NOT consider counsel's statements about the defendant's demeanor.
kutv.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing argument by Wendy Lewis begins after lunch recess. Lewis opened by saying Kouri's 'world collapsed' when she found Eric cold in the early morning hours of March 4. Lewis argued the entire case was an example of 'confirmation bias' — 'Instead of looking at the evidence to determine what happened, the state determined what happened and then found the evidence to support it.' Lewis showed the 'witch/widow' optical illusion again, displaying Kouri on the floor the night Eric died: 'Witch or widow?' She argued the investigation was 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias.' She said Kouri made the call 'nobody ever wants to make' and argued: 'There is no wrong way to grieve. They're asking you to judge how she is acting at that moment and then use that moment as evidence of guilt.' Lewis disclosed she had been unexpectedly widowed herself when she 'was not much older than Kouri' and had two small children.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing (Lewis) continued: Lewis argued the investigation was led by the Richins family from day one, with private investigator Gabler 'sidestepping the Constitution.' She argued: 'Side-stepping these important constitutional rights by hiring a private investigator who then lets law enforcement know what to do taints this entire investigation.' She attacked O'Driscoll: 'He couldn't testify how the fentanyl got into Eric's system. He said, well, he ingested it. There was no evidence — none — that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink.' She argued fentanyl was not put in a drink because there was no alcohol in Eric's body. Lewis argued Carmen Lauber 'never dealt fentanyl' and that detectives 'put the word fentanyl in her mouth.' She praised Crozier's credibility over Lauber's: 'He has nothing to gain. He just told you the truth.' Lewis noted pills from Lauber to Kouri were never tested. She asked why investigators never did a hair follicle test on Eric.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:37 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing (Lewis) continued: Lewis addressed the affair, saying Eric was also possibly having an affair ('there were parts of Eric's life that he didn't share with people'). She noted Kouri broke things off with Grossman and they never went on the Caribbean trip. On money: 'If this case were about money, Eric was worth so much more to Kouri alive.' On internet searches: 'Of course she's worried. An innocent person would be worried. Anyone would be worried if they just found out they are a suspect in a homicide investigation.' On the Walk the Dog letter: 'There were several things in the letter that were true and the letter never went to anyone. So it was nothing more than thoughts on paper.' On the GIFs: argued they were accessed at same time as Eric's March 3 photo of the mansion — 'It's likely all the GIFs were sent the night before.' On the empty pill bottle: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' On the Valentine's Day incident: 'Eric joked about his wife trying to poison him and when he ate the egg sandwich on Valentine's Day, he had an allergic reaction to something and took a nap. There is no world in which that is attempted murder beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:50 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing (Lewis) conclusion: Lewis said: 'If after looking at all the evidence you believe Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric died, that is not aggravated murder, and you must find her not guilty.' On forgery: 'There was no evidence that Kouri is guilty of forgery.' Lewis concluded: 'I'm sure you want me to stop talking, but I'm afraid to stop talking.' She asked jurors not to take a vote about guilt or innocence but to talk about where there is reasonable doubt: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands. The courage to stand between a member of this community and the state. Do not let them fool you. Do not fall for red herrings. Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove this case beyond a reasonable doubt.' Also told jurors: 'If she, Kathy Nester or Alex Ramos did anything to offend that, don't hold that against Kouri Richins.' Lewis: 'You must find Kouri Richins not guilty.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:15 PM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution rebuttal closing (Bloodworth): Bloodworth acknowledged much of the evidence is circumstantial: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. But circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' He argued there was 'plenty of proof to convict' based on Lauber's corroborated testimony. He addressed the Walk the Dog letter: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation.' He read lines from the letter, including one stating that if Ronnie does not say these things, she will be convicted. He accused the defense of 'parlor tricks' in referencing the witch/widow image: 'Parlor tricks are not legal standards.' He argued 'a lot of the defense's argument is based around trying to explain' the Walk the Dog letter, calling it a 'fake story she told her brother to testify to.' He also noted each of the three times Lauber was at the Maverik in Draper, 'so was Robert Crozier' per digital evidence. Bloodworth: 'There is no other rational explanation. And despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.'
abcnews.com
Mar 168:29 AM
Trial Day 15: Jury instructions read by Judge Mrazik beginning at 8:29 a.m. Judge instructed jurors on: the presumption of innocence; burden of proof (beyond reasonable doubt); how to evaluate witness testimony including immunity witnesses; the difference between direct and circumstantial evidence; immunity instructions for Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier; the fact that defendant's failure to testify cannot be used against her; jurors must consider each count separately and unanimously; methods of chance prohibited. Jury of 8 primary jurors plus 4 alternates seated; alternates identified as jurors 9, 10, 11 and 12.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Jury instructions completed; jury sent to deliberate. Judge excused jury at approximately 2:57 p.m. to begin deliberations. He stated Utah juries consist of 8 jurors (alternates 9, 10, 11, 12 were excused but told service is not over in case they must be recalled). Jurors received a computer containing all evidence but not connected to the internet. Three bailiffs were sworn in. Judge told jury their first task is to appoint a foreperson; all verdicts must be unanimous; they may submit written questions via bailiffs. A note from Juror No. 2 asked about a factual stipulation that should have been included with materials — a stipulation of fact was subsequently included. Jury is composed of 6 men and 2 women (alternates were 4 women).
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:20 PM
Trial Day 15 — VERDICT: Jury reached a verdict after approximately three hours of deliberations. Verdict was announced at 6:20 p.m. MDT. KOURI RICHINS FOUND GUILTY ON ALL FIVE COUNTS: (1) Aggravated murder — GUILTY; (2) Attempted aggravated murder — GUILTY; (3) Insurance fraud — GUILTY; (4) Insurance fraud (second count) — GUILTY; (5) Forgery — GUILTY. The verdict was unanimous. Kouri Richins lowered her head and remained still as Judge Mrazik read each guilty verdict. Sentencing was scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 11:30 a.m. Kouri Richins faces up to life in prison without parole on the aggravated murder count. The murder charge carries a sentence of 25 years to life.
nbcnews.com
Mar 166:30 PM
Post-verdict — Defense statement: After the verdict, Kouri Richins' attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos released a statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. ... Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. ... Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.'
nbcnews.com
Mar 169:20 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing: Bloodworth argued the cause of death was fentanyl administered via the Moscow mule and/or lemon drop shot. He said: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He said Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day — the sandwich could be set aside, but a shot is swallowed instantly. 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' He also argued the orange notebook's account of the celebratory drink placed it in the bedroom, not the kitchen, and that Eric's phone showed he was off the phone before 9 p.m. — inconsistent with Kouri's account that he was on the phone when she went to her son's room at 9:30-9:45 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing: Bloodworth replayed the 911 call with a CPR countdown timer on screen, showing approximately six minutes elapsed between the dispatcher's instruction to begin CPR and Kouri's claim of starting. He argued: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' He said she 'dehumanized' Eric — calling him 'it' rather than 'him' on the call. He argued: 'It was not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It was the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He said she immediately presented her alibi — 'I was in my son's room' — distancing herself from the time and place of the murder. He contrasted the 911 call with self-serving texts Kouri later sent to Chelsea Barney claiming she 'pumped so damn hard, screaming at him to come back' — saying none of that happened.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:47 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing: Bloodworth told jurors Kouri asked Grossman if he had ever killed anyone because 'she was working through her own feelings on killing and wanted Josh to help her work through those feelings.' He argued she did not understand Eric's trust structure and falsely believed she would inherit his money. 'The morning Eric died, she had a plan on how to spend Eric's money, not realizing it was trust money.' Bloodworth also argued: she hedged on the mansion closing — she was supposed to close March 4 but signed March 5, after confirming Eric was dead, because she needed his money to proceed with the mansion.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:00 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing: Bloodworth showed internet searches from Kouri's phone on April 13, 2022, including: 'what is a lethal.dose.of.fetanayl,' 'if someone is poisned what does it go down on the death certificate as,' 'kouri richins kamas net worth,' and others. He argued: 'She didn't search if someone accidentally overdoses. She searches if somebody is poisoned, because that is what happened.' He also argued the GIFs accessed at 8:29 a.m. — 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house' — were accessed by Kouri turning the phone sideways to view them better, and 'there is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out of the house.' He acknowledged the images from Eric's March 3 texts were also accessed but said 'details matter' — distinguishing the GIFs.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:22 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing (financial section): Bloodworth detailed Kouri's financial misconduct: she lost nearly $900,000 flipping homes (not counting foreclosures), had nearly $8 million in debt at mansion closing, had $359,453+ in overdraft charges, submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders six times, and did not understand 'fundamental accounting.' He said: 'Kouri Richins needed cash immediately when she murdered Eric.' He argued she took $45,000 from Chelsea Barney's tips and lied about applying it to a house down payment. He also cited the payday lenders who eventually stopped lending to her. He described October 2021 as the 'beginning of the downward financial death spiral.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:43 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing (Valentine's Day section): Bloodworth argued that on Valentine's Day, Kouri called the IRS twice in three days before the attempt, then 'called the Mirror Lake Diner to order the potentially fatal sandwich.' He noted Kouri's signature on the receipt is 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' He said Eric's phone went silent for 87 minutes in the middle of a busy workday after eating the sandwich, then resumed when he called Cody Wright with 'fear in his voice.' He argued Kouri left the scene: 'She leaves the bedroom when she murders him. She leaves the county when she attempts to murder him ... so when she calls 911, she can say she wasn't even there.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:58 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing (insurance/forgery section): Bloodworth showed insurance documents and argued: 'Eric did not sign the application. It was probably a simulated forgery,' per Throckmorton's testimony. He argued Kouri's motive was money and a fresh start. He said: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.' He described her as 'a taker, not an asker.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:06 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing: Bloodworth said Kouri's December 2021 vacation booking with Grossman proved premeditation: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.' He also told the jury about Kouri's reaction to Karrington's testimony: 'You observed that when Brooke Karrington testified about the financial distress of her business, she was exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury. She was bothered because the world saw she is indeed not a success and not affluent.' He also said Kouri 'hid her face because she doesn't know how to react because she's not grieving. She just murdered Eric. ... She wasn't crying.' He told jurors: 'See through her facade, check her ambition, do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:45 AM
Trial Day 15 — Special jury instruction on demeanor given; lunch recess: After denying the fourth mistrial motion, Judge Mrazik gave the jury a special instruction: they should consider their own observations of the defendant's demeanor during trial, not what the prosecution told them to observe. Lunch recess until 12:45 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Post-verdict legal context: Kouri Richins now faces a sentence of 25 years to life in prison on the aggravated murder count alone. She also still faces 26 felony counts in the separate financial crimes case filed June 2025; it is unclear whether prosecutors plan to proceed with that case. In civil court, Eric Richins' family is pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which bars a person from inheriting property from someone they killed.
kpcw.org
Mar 16
Additional closing argument detail — Prosecution: Bloodworth told jurors Kouri 'closed on the Midway mansion the day after Eric died' and argued: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew she would have his money.' He said Kouri did not understand the trust structure and 'the morning Eric died, she had a plan on how to spend Eric's money, not realizing it was trust money.' Bloodworth argued Kouri asked Grossman about killing in Iraq because 'she was working through her own feelings on killing and wanted Josh to help her work through those feelings.' He argued the orange notebook contains inconsistencies: Kouri wrote they had the celebratory drink in the bedroom, not the kitchen, and that Eric was on the phone when she left for her son's room around 9:30-9:45 p.m., but Eric's phone activity shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m. Bloodworth showed searches Kouri made on April 13, 2022, the day of the first search warrant, noting: 'She searched if someone is poisoned, because that is what happened.' He also noted the 2016 empty hydrocodone bottle is 'immaterial' because Eric had no hydrocodone in his toxicology.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Additional closing argument detail — Defense: Lewis told jurors that on Feb. 20, 2022, Ali Staking had a visit with Kouri during which Kouri stated she had broken things off with Grossman nine months earlier. Lewis argued Crozier's trial testimony (that he sold oxycodone, not fentanyl) is more credible than Lauber's because 'he has nothing to gain.' Lewis acknowledged in closing that the defense said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial: 'Strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' Lewis argued Carmen lied to a judge by writing a letter saying she was 100% compliant with drug court to get permission to go to Las Vegas. Lewis noted investigators never did a hair follicle test on Eric. Lewis told jurors: 'I'm sure you want me to stop talking, but I'm afraid to stop talking.' Lewis asked jurors to 'be courageous' if they don't see evidence beyond a reasonable doubt: 'Courage is what this moment demands. The courage to stand between a member of this community and the state.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Additional closing argument detail — Prosecution on GIFs: Bloodworth argued: 'There is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out of the house.' He said: 'We don't know who sent these images, but we do know that they were accessed on Kouri's phone at 8:29 — the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house and that whoever accessed them turned the phone this way to view them better.' Bloodworth argued the Midway mansion photo accessed at the same time was NOT the photo Eric sent the night before; he said 'Details matter' regarding which image was accessed.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Additional closing argument detail — Prosecution on orange notebook inconsistency with Barney: Bloodworth noted a discrepancy between Kouri's orange notebook account and her text to Chelsea Barney. In the notebook, Kouri wrote Eric was awake when she went to her son's bedroom. But Kouri told Chelsea via text that Eric was asleep when she left. Bloodworth argued: 'When people make up stories, they are inconsistent in the retelling.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:55 PM
Trial Day 15 — Jury begins deliberations: Judge Mrazik excused the four alternate jurors (jurors 9, 10, 11, and 12 — all four women) before deliberations. The deliberating jury consists of six men and two women (8 primary jurors). Judge explained the verdict form has each count separated, all verdicts must be unanimous, and jurors may submit written questions. Exhibits are in the jury room on a computer that cannot connect to the internet. Judge ordered dinner for the jury around 5 p.m. Jury began deliberating at approximately 3 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Additional prosecution closing detail — Bloodworth on Kouri's grief vs. Katie's grief: Bloodworth played clips contrasting Kouri's reaction to Eric's death vs. Katie Richins-Benson's reaction, arguing Kouri 'hid her face because she doesn't know how to react because she's not grieving. She doesn't want other people to see her non-reaction.' Bloodworth also argued Kouri 'could not face her father-in-law that night because she could not face the father of the man she had just killed.' He also noted Kouri told Eric's father Eric died of COVID and a fungal infection: 'That is not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 163:07 PM
Trial Day 15 — Juror note about stipulation of fact: As jurors were walking out to begin deliberations, the bailiff received a note from Juror No. 2 asking whether they were supposed to receive a hard copy of a factual stipulation. The court addressed this on the record and confirmed the stipulation of fact would be included with documents sent to the jury room.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Prosecution closing argument additional detail — lemon drop shot: Bloodworth argued for the first time in full detail during closing that Kouri used BOTH the Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot to administer fentanyl: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' This is the first explicit argument connecting a lemon drop shot (referenced in Kouri's orange notebook writings about the drinks that evening) to the method of poisoning.
cnn.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Verdict reached: A verdict was reached at approximately 5:52 p.m. MDT after approximately three hours of deliberation. Judge announced the verdict would be read at 6:20 p.m. Kouri Richins was described as trembling and visibly shaking in the courtroom as the room filled. Eric's father had not yet arrived so the reading was delayed slightly. Eric Richins' family and supporters were seated in rows 4 and beyond; Kouri's mother and a handful of supporters/friends were in row 2. Kouri was seated at the defense table with her attorney.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Additional insurance fraud/forgery closing detail: Bloodworth told jurors that the $100,000 TruStage life insurance application contained errors including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins. He argued regarding forgery: 'She's a taker, not an asker.' He showed insurance documents and changes made to information on them, and noted the application for Eric's term life insurance policy from early 2022 was signed weeks before Eric died.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:30 PM
VERDICT: Kouri Richins found GUILTY on ALL FIVE COUNTS. The female foreperson stood and confirmed the jury had reached a unanimous verdict. Judge Richard Mrazik read each count: Count 1 — aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — insurance fraud (two counts): GUILTY. Count 5 — forgery: GUILTY. Kouri Richins looked down and remained still/bowed her head as the first 'guilty' was read; a look of shock appeared on her face. Multiple Eric Richins family members were in tears. Judge polled each juror individually; each said 'Yes.' One male juror appeared quite emotional; another juror was wiping his eyes. Judge told the jury they could now speak with anyone they wished — his prior instructions no longer apply. They may speak to media and attorneys if they wish.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:37 PM
Post-verdict: Sentencing scheduled. Judge Mrazik dismissed the jury and thanked them for their service. A pre-sentence investigation report was ordered. Defense attorney Lewis confirmed Kouri Richins waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Sentencing was scheduled for 9:30 a.m. on Wednesday, May 13, 2026 — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Prosecutors and Eric Richins' family declined to give statements Monday evening.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:40 PM
Post-verdict reaction — Eric Richins' family: Eric's sister Amy Richins spoke outside the Summit County Courthouse: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. So just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Amy also read a family statement: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful to everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys as we all continue to heal.' Multiple family members were in tears following the verdict.
abc4.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict statement — defense attorneys: Kouri Richins' attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos issued a joint statement: 'Over the past several weeks, the jury has had the opportunity to hear the full evidence — not the headlines, not the speculation, but the facts. We believe in the jury system, and we trust the process. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. ... Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' The statement also said: 'For nearly three years the public has heard accusations about Kouri that created a narrative far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt.' Defense attorneys declined to give statements in person at the courthouse Monday evening.
foxnews.com
Mar 168:29 AM
Trial Day 15 begins at 8:29 a.m. Judge Mrazik takes the bench and confirms both sides are ready. Packed courtroom: Kouri Richins' family received 24 wristbands, Eric Richins' family received 24 wristbands, and 10 journalists were on the front row. Eric Richins' father, sisters, and other family members present. Kouri Richins' mother Lisa Darden is present on the second row.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:15 PM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution rebuttal by Brad Bloodworth. Bloodworth acknowledged the evidence is largely circumstantial: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. But circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' He argued Lauber's testimony was corroborated and said Crozier's phone was at the Maverik in Draper on exactly three dates, each time with Lauber's phone. Bloodworth said the Walk the Dog letter shows Kouri knows she bought fentanyl and had to explain it by blaming Eric. He stated: 'Despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.' He referenced Grossman: 'Josh Grossman loved Kouri Richins. He thought she loved him. You saw him testify. He was gutted. A grown-a** man gutted.' Bloodworth told jurors: 'See through her facade, check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.' He concluded: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation.' Bloodworth noted the manner of death listed as 'undetermined' is immaterial: 'You determine the manner of death. It's murder. Aggravated murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 163:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Jury began deliberations at approximately 3 p.m. after closing arguments concluded. The case was submitted with eight primary jurors (six men and two women) — four alternates (jurors 9, 10, 11, 12) were excused from deliberations but instructed to remain available. A stipulation of fact was sent back to the jury room. Juror No. 2 sent a note saying they thought they were supposed to receive a hard copy of a factual stipulation; this was resolved. Judge ordered jurors dinner around 5 p.m. The jury deliberated for approximately three hours before reaching a verdict.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:20 PM
Trial Day 15 — A verdict was announced at approximately 5:52 p.m. MDT, to be read at 6:20 p.m. When jurors entered the courtroom, Kouri Richins was visibly trembling. The female foreperson confirmed a unanimous verdict had been reached and handed the verdict form to the bailiff. Judge Mrazik warned the gallery: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT: Kouri Richins found GUILTY on all five counts. Count 1 — Aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 3 — Insurance fraud: GUILTY. Count 4 — Insurance fraud: GUILTY. Count 5 — Forgery: GUILTY. The jury deliberated for just under three hours. Kouri Richins stared at the floor and took deep breaths as Judge Mrazik read the verdict; a look of shock appeared on her face as the first 'guilty' was read and she immediately hung her head. Eric Richins' family members were in tears. Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. One juror appeared emotional; another was wiping his eyes. Judge polled each juror individually; each confirmed the unanimous verdict.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:34 AM
Judge Mrazik reads jury instructions beginning at instruction No. 13 (the first 12 were given before opening statements). Key instructions include: jurors must follow his instructions even if they disagree; closing arguments are not evidence; jurors should rely on their own memory of evidence; judge is neutral; jurors may believe all, part, or none of witness testimony; the defendant is presumed innocent; law enforcement testimony should not be given more weight than other testimony; defendant not testifying does not imply guilt; Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier are covered by an 'informant' instruction — they were given immunity and can be prosecuted for perjury if they lied; direct vs. circumstantial evidence explained; all verdicts must be unanimous.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:41 PM
Following the verdict, Judge Mrazik scheduled sentencing for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. — the date that would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis confirmed Kouri waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. A pre-sentence investigation report was ordered. Judge dismissed the jury and thanked them for their service, informing them they are now free to speak with media and attorneys if they wish.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:01 AM
PROSECUTION CLOSING ARGUMENT begins. Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth delivers approximately a 2-hour closing argument going count-by-count. He opens by describing Kouri's background — father went to prison, mother was an alcoholic — saying Kouri wanted to appear privileged. Core argument: 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money.' He describes Kouri as 'intensely ambitious' and argues she killed Eric to maintain a 'facade of privilege, affluence and success.' He urges jurors: 'See through her facade, check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict reaction: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins told reporters: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. So just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' The family released a statement: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful to everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys as we all continue to heal.' Kouri Richins' defense attorneys released a pre-verdict statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt.' Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn said neither side would comment directly after the verdict.
apnews.com
Mar 169:20 AM
Bloodworth argues fentanyl was administered via the Moscow Mule and/or lemon drop shot. Quote: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He argues Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day — one can set aside a fentanyl-laced sandwich, but 'you throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric knew something was wrong, it was in his body.' He also contends Kouri distanced herself from the 'dirty deed' by leaving the bedroom when she murdered Eric and leaving the county when she attempted to murder him.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Bloodworth plays the 911 call for the jury. He displays a countdown clock showing how long Kouri waited to give Eric CPR — six minutes from when the dispatcher told her to begin CPR to when she said she started. He argues she used the 911 call to present an alibi narrative, 'distancing herself from the time and the place that she murdered Eric.' He notes Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' ('I can't move it') rather than 'him': 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.' CPR time clock stopped at 5 minutes 56 seconds.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:44 AM
Bloodworth argues Kouri had 'no idea' the house was in a trust, didn't understand the buy-sell agreement, and thought she would inherit everything. 'The morning Eric died, she had a plan on how to spend Eric's money, not realizing it was trust money.' He contends she closed on the Midway mansion the day AFTER Eric died because 'she didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead.' He also states Kouri called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric on Valentine's Day, then called the Mirror Lake Diner to order the 'potentially fatal sandwich.' He notes Kouri's signature on the diner receipt is 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:55 AM
Bloodworth argues Kouri's orange notebook shows inconsistencies in her story: she wrote they had the celebratory drink in the bedroom, not the kitchen; she wrote Eric was on the phone when she went to their son's bedroom around 9:30-9:45 p.m. but Eric's phone activity shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m. He says: 'When people make up stories, they are inconsistent in the retelling.' He also argues all text messages presented to the jury were recovered from other phones because Kouri deleted them from hers — 'That is part of her cover-up.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:02 AM
Bloodworth shows the jury internet searches Kouri made on April 13, 2022 (the day of the first search warrant execution). He highlights the search 'If someone is poisoned, what does it go down on the death certificate as' — noting: 'She doesn't search if someone accidentally [overdoses]. She doesn't search if somebody is dead for unknown reasons. She searches if somebody is poisoned, because that is what happened.' He also references the $1.6M negative net worth when she murdered Eric and states she had 'nearly $8 million in debt when Kouri closed on the Midway mansion.' He argues her business was a facade: 'She was not a sophisticated business person. She didn't even understand fundamental accounting, fundamental tax reporting.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:27 AM
Bloodworth references Chelsea Barney's $45,000 life savings taken by Kouri: 'taking $45,000 from her best friend's tips and saying she would be applying it toward a down payment.' He says Kouri used the money to pay off a payday lender and other debts. He also tells jurors Kouri told Eric's dad he died of 'COVID and a lung fungus' — 'That is not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.' He argues the GIFs were accessed 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house' at 8:29 a.m. on March 4.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:38 AM
Bloodworth tells jurors they got to observe Kouri during the trial. He argues: 'You observe that when we played the 911 call during trial, her affect was flat. No emotions. You also observed that when Brooke Karrington testified about the financial distress of her business, she was exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury.' He shows the Celebration of Life video from the night after Eric died, showing adults joking around and drinking. He also references Kouri asking Josh Grossman if he had ever killed anyone: 'She asked that because she was working through her own feelings on killing and wanted Josh to help her work through those feelings.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:01 AM
Bloodworth addresses the forgery and insurance fraud charges: 'She's a taker, not an asker.' He shows insurance documents and changes made, and references the application for Eric's life insurance policy weeks before he died: 'Eric did not sign the application. It was probably a simulated forgery.' He tells the jury: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:06 AM
Bloodworth references the Walk the Dog letter in closing: 'There's a lot to unpack in this. … Kouri Richins knows four months after she's been arrested for Eric Richins' murder, a year and a half after she's murdered him, she knows that she bought fentanyl and she has to explain it. And how does she explain it? A year and a half after murdering Eric Richins? She blames it on Eric.' He states the letter was written to get her brother to testify to a narrative that would explain everything. He notes Kouri never told paramedics, deputies, or detectives she bought fentanyl for Eric at the time of his death.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:14 AM
In the final minutes of his closing, Bloodworth goes through a list of defense statements made during trial and after each one says 'There's no evidence of that.' He references Josh Grossman: 'Josh Grossmann loved Kouri Richins. He thought she loved him. You saw him testify. He was gutted. A grown-a** man gutted.' He concludes by stating every shred of evidence proves Eric did not die by suicide, reading lines from the Walk the Dog letter, and arguing: 'All the evidence in this case proves Kouri murdered her husband and the father of her three children. There is no other rational explanation for the evidence.' He also replays the 911 call and says: 'It was not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It was the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He tells jurors to 'listen to how Kouri Richins, on the 911 call, immediately presents her alibi narrative.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:17 AM
FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION filed by defense attorney Kathryn Nester immediately after Bloodworth finished his closing argument and before the jury returned. Nester argued: (1) Bloodworth 'dehumanized' the defendant by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider — improper; (2) Bloodworth improperly commented on Kouri's courtroom demeanor, which Nester characterized as a comment on her failure to testify; (3) Bloodworth engaged in 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind 'completely made up by Mr. Bloodworth'; (4) Bloodworth made incorrect statements about which drugs could support aggravated murder. Nester moved for mistrial on all points. Judge Mrazik recessed to collect his thoughts.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:41 AM
Judge Mrazik DENIES the fourth mistrial motion. Rulings: (1) The 'black widow' comment was not about an insect but a statement about a woman killing her husband — Bloodworth noted it stemmed from Chelsea Barney's recorded phone call with Bryce Knudsen; (2) Regarding Kouri's demeanor, Mrazik said the Utah Court of Appeals disagrees with Nester's objections and that he did not view it as a comment on her failure to testify — he could tell jurors to rely on their own observations rather than what Bloodworth said; (3) Bloodworth did not comment on her silence or right not to testify. Mrazik issued a special jury instruction telling jurors they must rely on their own observations of the defendant, not what the prosecutor said about her demeanor. Jury brought back in. Lunch break until 12:45 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
DEFENSE CLOSING ARGUMENT begins. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis handles the closing. She opens by revisiting the night of March 3-4, 2022, describing Kouri as a mother tending to a crying child before returning to bed and discovering Eric cold: 'Something feels wrong. She turns on the light, and when she looks at her husband, really looks at him, she realizes something is terribly wrong. In that moment, Kouri Richins' world collapsed.' She shows the widow/witch optical illusion image from opening statements: 'Witch or widow?' She argues: 'There is no wrong way to grieve. They're asking you to judge how she is acting at that moment and then use that moment as evidence of guilt.' Lewis reveals she was unexpectedly widowed herself: 'If I learned one thing during this trial, I learned I didn't grieve right.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:00 PM
Defense closing argument continues. Lewis argues the investigation was driven entirely by the Richins family: 'Everything about this investigation was led by [Eric Richins'] family. They started on day one, and they continued until trial.' She calls the investigation 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias' — an example of confirmation bias, 'working backwards from a conclusion.' She argues investigators never secured the scene, never asked where the gummies were, and didn't search places where gummies were found a month later. Lewis argues O'Driscoll 'didn't investigate any other leads' and didn't attempt to corroborate information. She references Todd Gabler: 'He was in the house numerous times, not wearing gloves, finding things and calling the police. … Todd Gabler was in and out of that house numerous times by himself. He also told you he was completely fair and unbiased. He had two hypotheses — suicide and homicide. He ignored any others, including accident.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:12 PM
Lewis attacks Carmen Lauber's credibility at length: 'She's not a truthful person.' She notes Lauber lied to a judge by submitting a false compliance letter to go to Las Vegas; that Lauber told Lewis she was not on anti-anxiety medicine but told Bloodworth she was; and that Lauber said Nancy Peterson drove to pick up the drugs but then changed to saying she drove one way. Lewis argues: 'Can you feel for Carmen Lauber? You can. Can you believe her beyond a reasonable doubt? You cannot.' She argues investigators 'walked into the interview with Carmen to tell them what happened rather than to hear her version of events. Carmen said she was scared of fentanyl.' Lewis: 'The state's entire house of cards is being held by her.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:25 PM
Lewis defends Robert Crozier's testimony: 'Crozier changed his story from what the prosecution wanted him to say to what they didn't want him to say. Why do this? Why risk his immunity? It would have been so much easier for him to stick with his original story.' She argues Crozier 'has nothing to gain. He just told you the truth.' Lewis addresses the fentanyl itself: 'The state cannot confirm that Kouri ever bought fentanyl. They want you to do their job for them.' She argues the fentanyl toxicologist said the drug 'could have been left over from a previous use' and there was no alcohol in Eric's body, suggesting fentanyl was not put in a drink. Lewis: 'There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into the drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:37 PM
Lewis addresses the Walk the Dog letter: 'There were several things in the letter that were true and the letter never went to anyone. So it was nothing more than thoughts on paper.' She argues: 'It is absolutely possible that everything she said in that letter was true.' She also revisits the empty hydrocodone bottle: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis addresses the internet searches: Kouri made them because she was 'terrified' and 'scared to death that she was a suspect' — not because she was guilty. She argues that on the GIFs: they were accessed at the same time as a photo of the Midway mansion Eric had sent the night before, suggesting all were from one message thread viewed in the morning.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:43 PM
Lewis addresses money motive: 'If this case were about money, Eric was worth so much more to Kouri alive.' She notes Kouri spent the insurance money within weeks and was still in debt. She also argues Eric was having an affair — possibly more than one — referencing the 'open relationship' text to Bryce Knudsen: 'There were parts of Eric's life that he didn't share with people.' She admits Kouri and Grossman were having an affair: 'Josh Grossmann loved Kouri more than she loved him.' Lewis: 'Was Kouri a brilliant businesswoman? No. Was her business struggling? Yes. Was it fake it until you make it? There was a lot of that going on. … She was a young mother trying to run a business.' She says defense 'said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial' but: 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:53 PM
Lewis addresses the Valentine's Day attempted murder charge: 'Eric joked about his wife trying to poison him and when he ate the egg sandwich on Valentine's Day, he had an allergic reaction to something and took a nap. There is no world in which that is an attempted murder beyond a reasonable doubt.' On forgery: 'There was no evidence that Kouri is guilty of forgery. The state has not proven its case.' Lewis closes: 'They don't have the evidence that Kouri Richins killed her husband so instead they have tried to show you as much evidence as they possibly can to convince you she's the sort of person who would.' She asks jurors not to take a vote about guilt or innocence but to discuss where there is reasonable doubt. 'Do not let them fool you. Do not fall for red herrings. Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.' Lewis concludes: 'I'm afraid to stop talking.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:15 PM
PROSECUTION REBUTTAL CLOSING ARGUMENT: Bloodworth delivers rebuttal. He references the widow/witch image: 'Parlor tricks are not legal standards.' He reminds jurors: 'What the lawyers say is not evidence' — noting there is a reason the state provided cross-references to evidence, 'because there's a reason defense counsel didn't cite you to the evidence.' He argues circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse.' He defends Lauber's testimony as corroborated — both she and Crozier's phones were at the Maverik in Draper only three times, and each time Kouri's phone was in contact with Lauber's. Bloodworth: 'Kouri Richins chose Carmen Lauber, not me. She chose her because she was the drug dealer she knew. Kouri Richins chose Carmen Lauber, not me.' He also states: 'all the evidence in this case proves Kouri murdered her husband.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:50 PM
Jury instructions completed and jury sent to deliberate. Judge Mrazik explains: Utah jury is 8 jurors. There are 12 total; 4 are alternates (juror numbers 9, 10, 11, and 12). Alternate jurors' service does not end — they remain subject to court instructions in case an emergency arises during deliberations. The verdict form covers each of the five counts separately. All verdicts must be unanimous. Jury formally begins deliberations at approximately 3 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 163:07 PM
Juror No. 2 sends a written note to Judge Mrazik asking whether jurors were supposed to receive a hard copy containing a factual stipulation. Judge asks attorneys how they want to proceed. The stipulation of fact is included with documents sent back to the jury room.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:00 PM
Judge orders dinner for the jury around 5 p.m. as deliberations continue into the evening.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Verdict announced: The jury has reached a verdict. It will be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. The jury deliberated for just under three hours total.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:24 PM
Scene inside the courtroom before verdict is read: Kouri is trembling — visibly shaking. Her mother Lisa Darden and a handful of supporters/friends are on the second row. Eric's family and supporters are on the fourth row and beyond. A few members of the public on the third row. Eric's father arrives just before the verdict is read. Judge instructs everyone: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:32 PM
VERDICT READ: The female foreperson confirms the jury has reached a unanimous verdict. COUNT 1 — Aggravated murder: GUILTY. COUNT 2 — Attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. COUNTS 3 and 4 — Insurance fraud (two counts): GUILTY. COUNT 5 — Forgery: GUILTY. Kouri Richins found GUILTY on all five felony counts. As the first 'guilty' was read, a look of shock appeared on Kouri's face and she immediately hung her head. She stared at the floor and took deep breaths. AP reported she was wearing a white blouse with pale blue and peach-colored flowers. Some jurors stared at Kouri; one juror appeared emotional; another juror was wiping his eyes.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:37 PM
Judge Mrazik polls each juror individually. All eight confirm the verdict is unanimous with 'Yes.' Judge dismisses the jury, thanks them for their service, and orders a pre-sentence investigation report. Judge asks if Richins waives the 45-day rule for sentencing — defense attorney Lewis says she does. Sentencing scheduled for 9:30 a.m. on Wednesday, May 13, 2026 — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:40 PM
Outside the courthouse after the verdict: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins gives a statement: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' The family released a written statement: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful to everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys as we all continue to heal.' Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Prosecution and defense attorneys also declined to give statements Monday evening.
ksltv.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Defense attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos released a post-verdict written statement: 'Over the past several weeks, the jury has had the opportunity to hear the full evidence — not the headlines, not the speculation, but the facts. We believe in the jury system, and we trust the process.' In an earlier statement after closing arguments: 'For nearly three years the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. … Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. … Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.'
ksltv.com
Mar 166:55 PM
Court observer Selena Armithee — identified as the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict came down — described the atmosphere: 'She was shaking when I came in; you could see her shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she attended almost every day of the trial (missing only two), was surprised by the speed of deliberations, and personally believed there was not enough to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. She said the experience was 'extremely intense and stressful' and that she likely will not attend another trial in person.
kutv.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Post-verdict: KPCW confirms the jury that convicted Kouri Richins consisted of six men and two women (the deliberating jury of 8, not the full 12-person panel that heard evidence). The murder trial, originally scheduled to last until March 27, concluded more than a week early. KPCW also notes that the separate 26-felony financial crimes case filed in June 2025 is still pending, and it is unclear whether prosecutors plan to pursue it. In civil court, the Richins family is also pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which bars inheriting property from a person one has killed.
kpcw.org
Mar 1610:35 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing detail: Bloodworth showed Celebration of Life video to jury (adults joking and drinking the night after Eric died) and contrasted it with the children's book cover and 'Good Things Utah' appearance. He argued the Walk the Dog letter was written because 'she knows that she bought fentanyl and she has to explain it' — calling it a 'fake story' that she wanted her brother to testify to. Bloodworth also told the jury that Kouri Richins' plan was 'not tethered to reality' when it came to the Midway mansion and that there was 'no evidence Eric sent these messages' (the GIFs). On Kouri's self-serving text to Chelsea Barney after Eric died ('I tried so f****** hard to save him'): 'None of that happened, and she's covering up her involvement in murdering Eric Richins.' On Grossman: 'Josh Grossman loved Kouri Richins. He thought she loved him. You saw him testify. He was gutted. A grown-ass man gutted.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing arguments additional detail — Bloodworth on Kouri's background and closing on the Midway mansion: Bloodworth told jurors Kouri's father went to prison and her mother was an alcoholic/gambler; Kouri wanted to project privilege and success. He argued she 'hedged' on the Midway mansion closing — 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money... that's why she signed on the 5th [of March].' Two days before Eric died, Kouri spent time on the phone with the IRS. Kouri also submitted six inaccurate bank statements to lenders; lost nearly $900,000 flipping homes (not counting foreclosures); paid herself with checks from accounts with negative balances. Bloodworth also addressed Grossman: 'Josh Grossmann loved Kouri Richins. He thought she loved him. You saw him testify. He was gutted. A grown-a** man gutted.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:37 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing additional detail: Lewis argued that Eric was also 'having an affair — possibly more than one,' referencing the 'open relationship' text Eric sent Bryce Knudsen. Lewis said: 'There were parts of Eric's life that he didn't share with people. We all have secrets, and Eric had secrets.' Lewis also noted that Kouri never met up with Josh Grossman after Eric died and eventually ended the relationship. On Crozier: 'Why do this? Why risk his immunity? It would have been so much easier for him to stick with his original story' — Lewis argued Crozier's trial testimony (sold oxycodone) was more credible than Lauber's because he had nothing to gain. Lewis said the state 'cannot confirm that Kouri ever bought fentanyl.' On the 90-120 pills: 'Where are these 90 to 120 pills? We have no idea where that is. They didn't trace that fentanyl.' On deleted texts: 'Maybe it's because Kouri was having an affair and she had asked Carmen to purchase pills. You'd probably want that off your phone.' On prison searches: 'Even an innocent person would be worried that they are a suspect in a homicide investigation and would look up information about prisons.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing arguments additional detail — Lewis on the defense's failure to call witnesses: Lewis acknowledged the defense made statements in opening that did not come into trial: 'Strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' Lewis also told jurors: 'I'm afraid to stop talking' near the end of her argument. She asked jurors: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands. The courage to stand between a member of this community and the state.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing arguments additional detail — 911 call CPR timer: During the prosecution's closing, the state displayed a timer on-screen while playing the 911 call, showing it was six minutes from when the dispatcher told Kouri to start CPR until Kouri said she had started. Bloodworth argued: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' He also noted Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him': 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
scrippsnews.com
Mar 16
Closing arguments additional detail — Bloodworth on the lemon drop shot and Moscow mule as delivery method: In his closing argument, Bloodworth argued for the first time the specific mechanism of how Kouri administered fentanyl: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Defense attorney Lewis pushed back: 'That was argument. Argument is not evidence. They waited until closing to tell you, "Oh, she put it in a drink," without any evidence to back that up.' Separately, writings by Kouri found in the family home (orange notebook) indicate the couple drank a Moscow Mule cocktail and a lemon drop shot the night Eric died — per CNN's reporting from the closing.
cnn.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Verdict reached: Courts staff announce just before 6 p.m. that jury has arrived at a verdict after approximately three hours of deliberation. Verdict to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. Before jury enters, Judge instructs gallery: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down.' Kouri Richins is described as visibly trembling and shaking at the defense table. Eric Richins' father arrives shortly before verdict is read. Kouri's mother and supporters are on the 2nd row; Eric's family is on the 4th row and beyond.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing arguments additional detail — Bloodworth on Kouri's demeanor during trial (overruled objection basis): Bloodworth told the jury they got to observe Kouri Richins during the trial. He claimed when the 911 call was first played in court, her 'affect was flat' with no emotion. He said when forensic accountant Brooke Karrington testified about her financial distress, 'she was exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury. She was bothered because the world saw she is indeed not a success and not affluent.' Defense objected that this was an improper comment on demeanor. Judge Mrazik agreed to give a special curative instruction but denied the mistrial motion.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
Trial Day 15 — VERDICT READ: Judge Mrazik reads verdict before friends and family of both sides. Female foreperson stands and confirms unanimous verdict. Count 1 — aggravated murder (1st-degree felony): GUILTY. Count 2 — attempted aggravated murder (1st-degree felony): GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — insurance fraud (2nd-degree felony, two counts): GUILTY. Count 5 — forgery (3rd-degree felony): GUILTY. Kouri Richins was found GUILTY on all five counts. As the first 'guilty' was read, Kouri Richins looked down at the desk in front of her and immediately hung her head, staring at the floor, taking deep breaths. A look of shock appeared on her face. Multiple family members of Eric Richins were in tears as people filed out. One juror appeared quite emotional; another was wiping his eyes. Judge polls jurors — each confirms 'yes.' Judge thanks jurors for service, dismisses them, informs them they may now speak to media and attorneys if they wish.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing arguments seating detail: Both families received 24 wristbands each to attend closing arguments, per the amended decorum order. Ten journalists occupied the front media row. Eric Richins' father, sisters and other family members were present in the courtroom. Kouri Richins' mother Lisa Darden was also in the courtroom.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Trial Day 15 — Post-verdict proceedings: Judge Mrazik orders a pre-sentence investigation report. Defense attorney Lewis confirms Kouri Richins waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Sentencing is scheduled for Wednesday, May 13, 2026, at 9:30 a.m. MST — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Brad Bloodworth confers with victim's family about available dates. Prosecutors, Eric Richins' family, and Kouri Richins' attorneys decline to give statements Monday evening. Relatives of Kouri Richins leave the courthouse without speaking to media.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Post-verdict: Amy Richins (Eric's sister) gives statement to Associated Press outside courthouse: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Amy shared a family statement: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful to everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys as we all continue to heal.' Multiple cousins and family members gathered in the courthouse parking lot expressing relief. One older cousin: 'I'm here for Eric. Eric did a lot for everybody. He was my cousin. I miss him every day.' Eric's family said they plan to speak more publicly after sentencing. Eric's family said one cousin indicated 'justice will prevail' regarding the separate financial crimes case as well.
ksltv.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Post-verdict: Defense attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos issue written statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning.' In a separate statement (pre-verdict, post-closing): 'Over the past several weeks, the jury has had the opportunity to hear the full evidence — not the headlines, not the speculation, but the facts. We believe in the jury system, and we trust the process.' The defense expressed confidence that Kouri would ultimately be able to return home to her three sons.
scrippsnews.com
Mar 167:30 PM
Post-verdict courtroom observation: Selena Armithee, the only member of the general public permitted inside the courtroom when the verdict came down (having obtained a standby seat), described the atmosphere as extremely tense. She had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during the proceedings. Armithee said Kouri was 'shaking when I came in; you could see her shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee, who attended almost every day of the trial, said she was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision and that she personally believed the evidence was insufficient to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
kutv.com
Mar 168:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Jury instructions and closing arguments begin. Judge Mrazik reads jury instructions beginning at 8:30 a.m. He instructs jurors: the fact the defendant has been charged is not evidence of guilt; they should not consider her failure to testify; Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier are to be evaluated under an 'informant' instruction; direct and circumstantial evidence are equally valid; all verdicts must be unanimous. Alternates identified as jurors 9, 10, 11, and 12.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 163:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Jury deliberations begin at approximately 3:00 p.m. The case went to 8 jurors (6 men, 2 women). Four alternates (jurors 9, 10, 11, 12) were dismissed from deliberations but told their service is not over in case an emergency arises. Jurors received a computer with all evidence that cannot connect to the internet. They began deliberating after approximately 3 p.m. Judge ordered them dinner around 5 p.m. A note from Juror No. 2 (the foreperson) was sent asking about a factual stipulation document — the stipulation was included with materials sent to the jury room.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — VERDICT REACHED: Courts staff announced a verdict had been reached just before 6 p.m. after approximately three hours of deliberation. The verdict was announced at approximately 6:30–6:35 p.m. The female foreperson (Juror No. 2, identified in post-verdict interview as 'Laura') confirmed the jury had reached a unanimous verdict. Judge Mrazik instructed the gallery there could be no outward reactions whatsoever. Kouri Richins was visibly trembling/shaking before jurors entered the courtroom. Eric Richins' family and friends were in rows 4 and beyond; Kouri's mother and supporters were in row 2.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:29 AM
Trial Day 15 opens at 8:29 a.m. Both families received 24 wristbands each to attend closing arguments. Ten journalists seated on media row. Kouri's family in 2nd row; Eric's family in 4th row. Kouri is visibly trembling at the defense table before proceedings begin. Jury walks in at 8:31 a.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT — GUILTY ON ALL FIVE COUNTS: Kouri Richins was found guilty on all five felony counts. Count 1: Aggravated murder — GUILTY. Count 2: Attempted aggravated murder — GUILTY. Count 3: Insurance fraud — GUILTY. Count 4: Insurance fraud — GUILTY. Count 5: Forgery — GUILTY. Kouri stared at the floor and took deep breaths as the judge read the verdict; a look of shock appeared on her face as the first 'guilty' was read and she immediately hung her head. Several jurors were emotional — one man appeared to be crying, another wiped his eyes. Multiple Eric Richins family members were in tears after the verdict. Eric Richins' family members hugged and cried in the courtroom afterward. Kouri's relatives left the courthouse without speaking to media. The jury deliberated for just under three hours. Juror No. 2, the foreperson ('Laura'), later stated: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' The verdict form shows jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and the attempted murder were committed for financial benefit.
townlift.com
Mar 166:41 PM
Post-verdict: Judge Mrazik dismissed the jury, thanked them for their service, and told them his prior instructions no longer apply — they may speak with anyone they wish, including media and attorneys.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Post-verdict family statements: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke outside the courthouse: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' The Richins family also released a written statement: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful to everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys as we all continue to heal.' Eric's cousins and other relatives also gathered in the courthouse parking lot, expressing relief. Kouri Richins' relatives left without speaking to media. Defense attorneys released a written statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning.'
apnews.com
Mar 168:31 AM
Judge Mrazik reads jury instructions to the jury, beginning at instruction No. 13 (the first 12 were given before opening statements). Key instructions include: jurors must follow instructions even if they disagree; closing arguments are not evidence; Mrazik is neutral; the defendant's failure to testify cannot be considered as evidence of guilt; jurors may believe all, part, or none of a witness's testimony; direct vs. circumstantial evidence explained; Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier both given immunity and can be prosecuted for perjury if they lie; jurors must consider each of the five charges separately and all verdicts must be unanimous. Judge explains Utah jury consists of 8 jurors; 12 were empaneled to guard against unforeseen circumstances. Alternates identified as jurors 9, 10, 11, and 12.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:01 AM
Prosecution closing argument begins. Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth opens by describing Kouri's background: her father went to prison, her mother was an alcoholic, and she wanted to appear privileged. He says she met Eric, a successful businessman, had three kids, and 'was on her way' — but was unhappy. Key theme: 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money.' He says the prenuptial agreement meant leaving meant leaving his money, so she took $250,000 in equity from Eric's home without his knowledge to fund her business. His closing is organized count-by-count and element-by-element.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:20 AM
Bloodworth tells jurors: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He says all medical experts testified that the extraordinary amount in Eric's stomach indicates oral ingestion. He reminds jurors the fentanyl was illicit, not prescription. Bloodworth plays the recorded phone call between Kouri and Dr. Erik Christensen, saying Kouri recorded the conversation and feigned ignorance about quetiapine — a drug prescribed to her — because it was found in Eric's body.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Bloodworth replays the 911 call for the jury, with a countdown clock showing how long Kouri waited before starting CPR. He argues the call was not 'the sound of a wife becoming a widow' but 'the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He says Kouri immediately presents her alibi narrative on the call, distancing herself from the time and place of Eric's death. He notes there are six minutes between when the dispatcher tells Kouri to start CPR and when she says she started. He also notes that Kouri refers to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' on the call: 'I can't move it.' Bloodworth says: 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:38 AM
Bloodworth addresses Kouri's demeanor during trial: he tells jurors they observed Kouri and how she reacted during testimony. 'You observe that when we played the 911 call during trial, her affect was flat. No emotions. You also observed that when Brooke Karrington testified about the financial distress of her business, she was exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury. She was bothered because the world saw she is indeed not a success and not affluent.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:44 AM
Bloodworth tells jurors Kouri's plan was to close on the Midway mansion using Eric's money. He says: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money, she knew she could do something with the mansion and that's why she signed on the 5th.' He says she called the IRS twice in the three days before the attempted murder, and called Mirror Lake Diner to order 'the potentially fatal sandwich.' He notes that on Valentine's Day, all activity on Eric's phone ceased for 87 minutes after he ate the sandwich, then he called Cody Wright — who heard fear in his voice.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:05 AM
Bloodworth takes a break at 10:05 a.m. and resumes at 10:20 a.m. After the break, he discusses the aggravated murder aggravators: (1) the 'why' — money; (2) the 'how' — administering a substance in a lethal amount. He displays charts showing Kouri had over $359,453 in overdraft charges and nearly $8 million in debt when she closed on the Midway mansion. 'All the while, she's not paying it off. She's barely sending her creditors any money.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:35 AM
Bloodworth argues Kouri closed on the Midway mansion the day AFTER Eric died: 'Did she close on the Midway mansion in spite of murdering Eric or because she murdered Eric? She hedged.' He says she needed money immediately to close on the mansion. He then discusses Kouri's dreams of living at the Midway mansion with Josh Grossman — 'running it as an event center, farming it and raising kids.' He says: 'She had no idea that her home was in a trust, and she couldn't sell it.' He adds: 'The morning Eric died, she had a plan on how to spend Eric's money, not realizing it was trust money.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:49 AM
Bloodworth addresses the Valentine's Day attempted murder: he shows cell phone tower mapping of messages between Carmen and Kouri. He says Kouri called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric, then called Mirror Lake Diner to order the sandwich — and notes her signature on the receipt shows 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' He argues she 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:01 AM
Bloodworth shows insurance documents, discusses forgery charge, and says: 'She's a taker, not an asker.' He argues both aggravators are met — financial benefit was the motive. He says: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.' He tells jurors to 'see through her facade, check her ambition, do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:14 AM
Bloodworth shows a list of defense attorney statements made during the trial. After each one, he says: 'There's no evidence of that.' He tells jurors: 'In listening to defense counsel closing arguments, please only consider the evidence that has been admitted.' He finishes his closing: 'All the evidence in this case proves Kouri murdered her husband and the father of her three children. There is no other rational explanation for the evidence.' Bloodworth's closing argument lasted approximately 2 hours.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:19 AM
FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION (defense): Immediately after Bloodworth concluded his closing argument, defense attorney Kathryn Nester moved for a mistrial, arguing Bloodworth 'dehumanized' Kouri by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider, that he improperly commented on Kouri's demeanor (which Nester characterized as a comment on her failure to testify), and that there was 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind 'completely made up by Mr. Bloodworth.' Judge Mrazik called a recess to consider the motion.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:41 AM
FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION DENIED: Judge Mrazik returned and denied the defense's fourth mistrial motion. He ruled: the 'black widow' comment was not in reference to an insect but a statement about a woman killing her husband; that he can instruct jurors to rely on their own observations of Kouri's demeanor rather than what Bloodworth said; and that Bloodworth did not comment on Kouri's silence or her right not to testify. Mrazik gave jurors a special instruction: they must rely on their own observations of the defendant's demeanor and not what the prosecutor said about her demeanor. Jurors were brought in at approximately 11:45 a.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Defense closing argument begins after a lunch break at 12:45 p.m. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis handles closing arguments. She opens by describing the night of March 3: Kouri wasn't feeling well, slips into bed, feels her husband, and 'he's cold. Something feels wrong. She turns on the light, and when she looks at her husband, really looks at him, she realizes something is terribly wrong. In that moment, Kouri Richins' world collapsed.' Lewis says the state is asking jurors to judge how Kouri grieved: 'If I learned one thing during this trial, I learned I didn't grieve right.' She shows the Day 1 witch/widow optical illusion image and shows Kouri on the floor the night Eric died, asking: 'Witch or widow?'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:07 PM
Lewis argues the state's entire investigation was 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias' — driven by the Richins family and the private investigator who 'sidestepped the Constitution.' She says: 'Everything about this investigation was led by [Eric Richins'] family. They started on day one, and they continued until trial. They are the ones who initially hired and paid for experts. Their private investigator gave information to the police.' She raises the expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle on Eric's nightstand that was never tested for fentanyl, and suggests it 'could be a good place to bring back illicit drugs from Mexico.' She also argues the Walk the Dog letter 'never went to anyone. So it was nothing more than thoughts on paper' and says 'It is absolutely possible that everything she said in that letter was true.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:30 PM
Lewis addresses the internet searches, GIFs, and other circumstantial evidence. She argues Kouri deleted texts because of the affair and drug purchases — not because of murder. She says Kouri searched for information about fentanyl after learning Eric had died of it, and that 'an innocent person would be worried that they are a suspect in a homicide investigation and would look up information about prisons.' On the GIFs, she says they were accessed at the same time as a photo of the Midway mansion sent by Eric the night before, suggesting they were sent the night before as part of the celebration. Lewis admits: 'There were parts of Eric's life that he didn't share with people... we all have secrets, and Eric had secrets.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:43 PM
Lewis addresses the Valentine's Day alleged poisoning: 'Eric joked about his wife trying to poison him and when he ate the egg sandwich on Valentine's Day, he had an allergic reaction to something and took a nap. There is no world in which that is an attempted murder beyond a reasonable doubt.' She tells jurors that if they believe Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and Eric died, 'that is not aggravated murder and you must find her not guilty.' On the forgery count, she says there was no evidence Kouri is guilty of forgery and the state has not proven its case.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:54 PM
Lewis concludes her closing argument. Final words: 'Do not let them fool you. Do not fall for red herrings. Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove this case beyond a reasonable doubt, and you have the courage. Have the courage to tell them this and find Kouri Richins not guilty.' A 15-minute recess is taken before Bloodworth's rebuttal.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:15 PM
Prosecution rebuttal closing argument (Bloodworth): He shows the witch/widow optical illusion and says: 'Parlor tricks are not legal standards.' He says there is a reason the state cross-referenced every piece of evidence offered, and 'there's a reason defense counsel didn't cite you to the evidence.' He addresses the GIFs: 'There is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out of the house... Details matter. We don't know who sent these images, but we do know that they were accessed on Kouri's phone at 8:29 — the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.' He says Kouri hid her face that night 'because she doesn't know how to react because she's not grieving.' He addresses the Carmen Lauber credibility argument: 'Kouri Richins chose Carmen Lauber, not me. She chose her because she was the drug dealer she knew.' He argues Lauber's testimony is corroborated by digital evidence showing Lauber and Crozier's phones at the Maverik in Draper on the same three dates. He closes: 'See through her facade, check her ambition, do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:55 PM
Jury begins deliberating at approximately 3 p.m. (just before 3 p.m. per KPCW; 2:59 p.m. per EastIdaho live blog). Judge instructs alternate jurors (9, 10, 11, 12) that their service is not yet complete — they may be recalled if needed during deliberations. Exhibits are sent to the jury room on a computer that cannot connect to the internet. Judge orders dinner for the jury at approximately 5 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
A verdict is reached at just before 6 p.m. — announced at 5:52 p.m. Court staff notify parties; verdict to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. The jury deliberated for just under three hours total.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:30 PM
Judge Mrazik reads the verdict. The courtroom is described as tense and quiet. Kouri Richins is visibly trembling and shaking at the defense table before jurors enter. Eric's father and other family members are present. Kouri's mother and supporters are in the second row. Judge issues a strict no-reaction order before the verdict is read: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT: The female foreperson (Juror No. 2, identified by first name as Laura in post-verdict media) stands and confirms the jury has reached a unanimous verdict. Judge Mrazik reads all five counts: Count 1 — Aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — Insurance fraud (two counts): GUILTY. Count 5 — Forgery: GUILTY. Kouri Richins is found GUILTY on all five felony counts. A look of shock appeared on her face as the first 'guilty' was read; she immediately hung her head and stared at the floor, taking deep breaths. Multiple jurors were emotional — one man on the jury appeared quite emotional; another juror was wiping his eyes. Multiple family members of Eric Richins were in tears. Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:40 PM
Post-verdict family reactions outside courthouse: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke to media, sharing the family statement: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful to everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys as we all continue to heal.' Amy also said: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Prosecutors, Eric Richins' family, and Kouri Richins' attorneys declined to give additional statements Monday evening.
ksltv.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Defense attorney statement issued after closing arguments (before verdict): 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning.' The statement was issued by Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos. A second statement issued after deliberations began also said: 'Over the past several weeks, the jury has had the opportunity to hear the full evidence — not the headlines, not the speculation, but the facts. We believe in the jury system, and we trust the process.'
fox13now.com
Mar 168:00 PM
One public spectator inside the courtroom for the verdict — Selena Armithee, who had attended almost every day of the trial — described the atmosphere: Kouri's 'shoulders were visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during the proceedings and was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict came down. She said she was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision and personally believed the evidence was insufficient for conviction beyond a reasonable doubt. 'It was extremely intense and stressful. You could tell my hands were clenched.'
kutv.com
Mar 168:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Closing arguments begin. Judge Mrazik reads jury instructions first. Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth delivers approximately 2-hour closing argument, framing Kouri's background (grew up scrubbing toilets for rich people in Park City, wanted the appearance of a perfect life), her motive (financial desperation and affair with Grossman), and replaying the first minute of the 911 call — telling jurors: 'It was not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It was the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' Bloodworth told jurors: 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money.' Bloodworth also told jurors: 'See through her facade, check her ambition, do not let her get away with murder.' Bloodworth argued that jurors who found Eric's murder was committed for financial benefit were fulfilling their role — and the verdict form shows jurors unanimously agreed both murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit.
apnews.com
Mar 168:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Additional prosecution closing argument detail: During closing arguments, Bloodworth showed jurors text messages between Kouri and Grossman in which she fantasized about leaving Eric, gaining millions in a divorce, and marrying Grossman. Bloodworth also used the internet search history — 'what is a lethal.dose.of.fetanayl,' 'luxury prisons for the rich America,' and 'if someone is poisned what does it go down on the death certificate as' — arguing: 'She didn't search if someone accidentally (overdoses). She doesn't search if somebody is dead for unknown reasons. She searches if somebody is poisoned — because that is what happened.' Bloodworth stated: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.' A timer was displayed during the 911 call replay to show Richins waited six minutes before starting CPR. Bloodworth also told jurors that when the 911 call was first played in court, Kouri's behavior was 'flat, with no emotion,' and that when forensic accountant Brooke Karrington was on the stand, Kouri was 'bothered because the world had allegedly seen that she was not a business success.' Referring to Kouri asking for the 'Michael Jackson stuff,' Bloodworth said: 'She knows she wants it because it is lethal.'
localnews8.com
Mar 168:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — KPCW confirms total mistrial motion count: Defense motioned for a mistrial four times during the trial. All four were either denied or withdrawn: (1) Week 1 — Gipson 'jail calls' comment — DENIED March 2; (2) Day 9 — Lauber drug court violation + undisclosed Mainord texts — DENIED March 11; (3) Day 10 — Kouri referred to 'charges' in recorded call — WITHDRAWN Day 11; (4) Day 15 — Bloodworth 'black widow' comment in closing — DENIED.
kpcw.org
Mar 1610:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Immediately after the prosecution finished its closing argument, defense attorney Wendy Lewis moved for a mistrial (the fourth mistrial motion of the trial), arguing that prosecutor Bloodworth's use of the term 'black widow' dehumanized Kouri Richins. Judge Mrazik denied the motion and instructed the jury to only consider their own observations and not the prosecution's characterization.
fox13now.com
Mar 1611:00 AM
Trial Day 15 — Defense attorney Wendy Lewis delivers closing argument for the defense. Lewis revisited the night of March 3, 2022, describing a mother tending to a crying child before returning to find her world had collapsed. She accused the prosecution of accusing Kouri of 'not grieving properly' and said if Kouri has learned one thing from the trial, it's that she didn't grieve right. Lewis called the investigation 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias,' noting Eric's family hired the private investigator and some of the experts. Lewis argued the alleged fentanyl pills were never found and attacked Lauber's credibility ('She's not a truthful person'). Lewis noted the 2016 hydrocodone bottle on the nightstand was never tested for fentanyl despite having residue, and suggested it could be a place to bring back drugs from Mexico. Lewis addressed the Google searches, saying an innocent person would also search those things after learning their husband died of a lethal dose of fentanyl. Lewis also said prosecutors don't have evidence Kouri killed Eric — 'instead they have tried to show you as much evidence as they possibly can to convince you that she's the sort of person who would.' At the end of her closing, Lewis asked jurors to be courageous if they did not see the evidence as beyond a reasonable doubt.
ksltv.com
Mar 163:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Closing arguments wrap up on Monday afternoon. Case goes to the jury just before 3 p.m. for deliberations.
kpcw.org
Mar 166:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Jury reaches a verdict just before 6 p.m. after approximately three hours of deliberation. Verdict announced at approximately 6:20-6:30 p.m. MDT. Kouri Richins found GUILTY on all five counts: (1) Aggravated murder (1st-degree felony); (2) Attempted aggravated murder (1st-degree felony); (3) Insurance fraud — count 1 (2nd-degree felony); (4) Insurance fraud — count 2 (2nd-degree felony); (5) Forgery (3rd-degree felony). Verdict form shows jurors unanimously agreed both murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit. As the first 'guilty' was read, Richins looked shocked and immediately hung her head; she stared at the floor and took deep breaths as the judge read each verdict. Multiple family members of Eric Richins were in tears. Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins said: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' The Richins family issued a statement: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful to everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys as we all continue to heal.'
apnews.com
Mar 16
Courtroom atmosphere during verdict: A public attendee named Selena Armithee — who had attended nearly every day of trial and had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during the proceedings — was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict came down. She described the atmosphere as 'extremely intense and stressful.' She noted Kouri was 'shaking' with 'shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision and said she personally believed there was not enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. Eric's family gathered in the courthouse parking lot shortly after the verdict; Eric's father was also in the courtroom.
kutv.com
Mar 16
Additional prosecution closing argument detail confirmed: Bloodworth specifically argued that Kouri 'closed on the Midway mansion the day after Eric died' and that she 'hedged' — she was supposed to close March 4 but 'didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead.' He also showed Kouri's statement to police noting it 'started with their drinks the night before, not with her finding him cold — in Kouri Richins' mind, that's when the incident started.' He told jurors that Kouri's plan with the Midway mansion was consistent with her dream of 'living there with Josh Grossman — running it and living there with her kids' — and that she had already planned how to spend Eric's money the morning he died, 'not realizing it was trust money.' He showed body camera video to rebut Walk the Dog letter claims that Kouri ran to the bathroom when EMTs approached her, saying 'we don't see Kouri running to the bathroom' in the footage.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Additional NPR/KPCW post-verdict detail: Fox News and court documents confirm that authorities said Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/ml of quetiapine — an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid that was prescribed to Kouri Richins. This is a previously uncaptured specific quantitative detail from the autopsy. Separately, KPCW reported Kouri is also litigating property issues with Eric's family in civil court, and the family is pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute' which bars inheriting property from someone you killed.
foxnews.com
Mar 16
KPCW confirmed: The murder trial, originally scheduled to last until March 27, wrapped up more than a week early. It is unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue the separate 26-felony financial crimes case. Both the prosecution and defense declined to give statements the evening of the verdict.
kpcw.org
Mar 168:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Jury instructions read. Judge Mrazik began by reading jury instructions to the panel of eight jurors. Instructions included: defendant did not testify and that cannot be held against her; testimony by people given immunity (Lauber and Crozier) is subject to an 'informant' instruction; jurors must reach a unanimous verdict on each count separately; both prosecution and defense have families present with 24 wristbands each; 10 journalists in front row. Both families received seating; general public excluded. Judge noted alternates are jurors 9, 10, 11 and 12.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Courtroom atmosphere detail at verdict: A member of the public, Selena Armithee, was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict was read. She had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during the proceedings. Armithee described the atmosphere as 'extremely intense and stressful' and said she could see Kouri's 'shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she was surprised by how quickly the jury reached a decision and believed there was not enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. She attended almost every day of the trial, missing only two.
kutv.com
Mar 16
Closing argument additional detail — Bloodworth on the orange notebook: Referenced inconsistencies between the orange notebook and other statements. In the notebook, Kouri wrote Eric was awake when she went to her son's bedroom; but she told Chelsea Barney he was asleep. In the notebook, she wrote they had the celebratory drink in the bedroom; but Eric's phone data shows he was off calls before 9 p.m., inconsistent with the notebook timeline. Bloodworth: 'When people make up stories, they are inconsistent in the retelling.' He also said Kouri 'hid her face' because 'she doesn't know how to react because she's not grieving. She doesn't want other people to see her non-reaction. She just murdered Eric. ... She wasn't crying.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Verdict reached. Courts staff announced the jury had arrived at a verdict just before 6 p.m. after almost three hours of deliberation. Verdict to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. Eric's father had not yet arrived when the announcement was made, so the reading was delayed a few minutes. Judge ordered jurors dinner around 5 p.m. In the courtroom: Kouri was trembling and visibly shaking. Kouri's mother and a handful of supporters were on the second row. Eric's family and friends were on the fourth row. A few members of the public were present. Judge told the gallery before the verdict was read: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument additional detail — Bloodworth on Kouri's background: Bloodworth opened by noting Kouri Richins' father went to prison and her mother was an alcoholic. He argued Kouri wanted to appear privileged and met Eric, who was a successful businessman. After having three kids, she was unhappy but the prenuptial agreement meant leaving Eric meant leaving his money. He characterized Kouri as 'intensely ambitious' but 'incompetent' as a businesswoman who 'projected affluence even as she fell deeper into debt.' He cited that Kouri underreported expenses to her tax accountant and submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders six times. He noted that 'Kouri Richins was a suburban mother-real-estate-agent: She does not know a lot about the illicit street drug world, but she knows Michael Jackson died from taking drugs. She knows she wants it because it is lethal, it is fatal, it kills.'
localnews8.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT: GUILTY ON ALL FIVE COUNTS. At approximately 6:34-6:37 p.m. MDT, the eight-person jury (six men, two women) unanimously found Kouri Richins guilty on all five counts: Count 1 — Aggravated murder (GUILTY); Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder (GUILTY); Counts 3 & 4 — Insurance fraud x2 (GUILTY); Count 5 — Forgery (GUILTY). Female foreperson (Juror No. 2, Laura) stood and confirmed unanimous verdict. Kouri Richins looked down at the desk in front of her and took deep breaths as the verdicts were read. A look of shock appeared on her face as the first 'guilty' was read; she immediately hung her head. One male juror appeared quite emotional; another was wiping his eyes. The jury deliberated for just under three hours — verdict came in just after 6:30 p.m. Multiple family members of Eric Richins were in tears. Relatives of Kouri Richins left without speaking to media. The verdict form confirmed jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument additional detail — Defense attorney Lewis on Kouri's state of mind: Lewis argued Eric was also having an affair — possibly more than one — referencing the text about an 'open relationship' with Bryce Knudsen and said 'there were parts of Eric's life that he didn't share with people.' Lewis acknowledged Kouri's affair with Grossman and deleted texts, but argued 'strategies change' as to why the defense did not call witnesses it promised in opening. Lewis said she was 'afraid to stop talking' near the end — 'I'm sure you want me to stop talking, but I'm afraid to stop talking.' She also said regarding the Walk the Dog letter: officials 'didn't fully investigate the claims in the letter because they weren't looking for evidence that could prove Kouri Richins' innocence.' On the Celebration of Life video: 'Can we not smile in our grief? They want to tell you no, but reason and experience tell you different.' On the investigation: 'They were only looking for evidence to confirm their theory. Confirmation bias.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Post-verdict proceedings: Judge Mrazik polled each juror individually — each confirmed 'Yes.' Judge dismissed the jury, thanked them for their service, and told them they were free to speak with anyone they wished. Judge ordered a pre-sentence investigation report. Defense attorney Lewis confirmed Kouri waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Sentencing scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Prosecutors and defense declined to give statements Monday evening. Eric Richins' family said they plan to speak more publicly after sentencing. Amy Richins (Eric's sister) said outside the courthouse: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Eric's family released a statement: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful to everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys as we all continue to heal.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Bloodworth closing argument confirmed specific quote on Eric's estate/prenup: 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins, but she did not want to leave his money. Their prenuptial agreement meant that if she left him, she would also leave most of his money. So Kouri Richins took a quarter of a million dollars in equity out of Eric Richins' home, without him knowing it, so that she could start her own business and earn enough money to leave Eric Richins.' Also confirmed: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.' And on the fentanyl dose: the amount 'shows that Kouri Richins wanted Eric not only dead, but good and dead.'
apnews.com
Mar 16
Additional closing argument detail — Bloodworth on the lemon drop shot: Bloodworth argued in his closing that Kouri administered fentanyl via both the Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot — stating: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' This is the first time the lemon drop shot has been specifically named in the prosecution's theory of how fentanyl was administered — described as the lesson Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day when a sandwich gave Eric time to notice something was wrong. Kouri's orange notebook references the couple drinking a Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot the night Eric died.
cnn.com
Mar 169:00 AM
Prosecution closing argument — Brad Bloodworth delivered approximately a 2-hour closing argument. Key elements: (1) Bloodworth opened by describing Kouri's troubled childhood and her desire to appear privileged after meeting Eric; (2) argued Kouri 'wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money'; (3) replayed the 911 call, displaying a timer showing Kouri waited approximately 6 minutes before beginning CPR — noting Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him'; (4) characterized the 911 call as 'not the sound of a wife becoming a widow — it's the sound of a wife becoming a black widow'; (5) showed the three money-themed GIFs accessed at 8:29 a.m. on March 4, 2022 — 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house'; (6) argued Kouri 'closed on the Midway mansion the day after Eric died because she murdered Eric'; (7) said Kouri 'hedged' on the closing date — waited until she knew Eric was dead before signing; (8) argued both the murder and attempted murder charges were proven element-by-element; (9) referenced the Walk the Dog letter as a 'fake story' crafted to blame Eric; (10) said Eric's cause of death was fentanyl administered via Moscow mule and/or lemon drop shot; (11) argued Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day when fentanyl in the sandwich was detectable; (12) told jurors: 'See through her facade, check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Bloodworth closing argument additional details: Claimed Kouri called the Mirror Lake Diner from her phone at 8:53 a.m. on Valentine's Day 2022 to order the sandwich (previously recorded as 8:55 a.m. from diner records — Bloodworth's phone records show the call was made). Showed Kouri was simultaneously texting both Josh Grossman and Eric about the Midway mansion closing but was 'very excited' in texts with Josh and 'kind of blew Eric off.' Showed cell tower mapping during the alleged drug purchase dates. Discussed that Kouri had called the IRS twice in the three days before Valentine's Day attempted murder. Argued Kouri's demeanor during trial: stated that when the 911 call was first played, 'her affect was flat, no emotions,' and when Karrington testified about financial distress, Kouri 'was exercised because the world saw she is indeed not a success' — described it as 'a narcissistic injury.' Referenced Grossman: 'Josh Grossmann loved Kouri Richins. He thought she loved him. You saw him testify. He was gutted. A grown-a** man gutted.' Also stated: 'She didn't tell anybody that night that Eric used fentanyl because she thought she would get away with it.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:17 AM
FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION — filed by defense attorney Kathryn Nester immediately after Bloodworth concluded his closing argument. Nester argued: (1) Bloodworth 'dehumanized' Kouri by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider; (2) Bloodworth improperly commented on Kouri's demeanor, which Nester characterized as a comment on her failure to testify; (3) there was 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind. Judge Mrazik called a recess, then denied the motion. Mrazik ruled: the 'black widow' comment referred to a woman killing her husband, not a spider; the Utah Court of Appeals disagrees with Nester's objections about commenting on defendant demeanor; and Bloodworth did not comment on Kouri's silence or right not to testify. Mrazik agreed to read a special instruction to jurors that they must rely on their own observations of the defendant and not what the prosecutor said about her demeanor. Mrazik also noted Bloodworth used the word 'narcissist' — which Nester objected to — but overruled on that basis as well. This is the fourth total mistrial motion in the trial (first denied March 2; second denied March 11; third withdrawn March 11; fourth denied March 16).
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Defense closing argument — Wendy Lewis delivered the defense's closing argument. Key elements: (1) Opened by revisiting March 3-4, 2022 — describing Kouri slipping into bed, feeling Eric is cold, turning on the light and 'her world collapsing'; (2) argued Kouri was judged unfairly for how she grieved — 'I learned I didn't grieve right. They want you to look at a woman during the worst moment of her life and to judge her. There is no wrong way to grieve'; (3) showed the witch/widow optical illusion from Nester's Day 1 opening, asking jurors about Kouri's image: 'Witch or widow?'; (4) called the investigation 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias' — 'Everything about this investigation was led by [Eric Richins'] family. They started on day one, and they continued until trial'; (5) attacked Carmen Lauber's credibility — 'She's not a truthful person'; called Lauber's testimony a 'get out of jail free' card; said Lauber held 'all the cards in this case'; (6) argued Robert Crozier's testimony was more credible because 'he has nothing to gain'; (7) argued no evidence fentanyl was put in a drink — 'They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up. There is no evidence that fentanyl was put into the drink'; (8) said deleted texts could be explained by the affair and drug purchases generally; (9) argued internet searches after Eric's death were innocent — a grieving widow learning her husband died of fentanyl might want to know more, and even innocent people would be scared; (10) argued the expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle was never tested — 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?'; (11) argued Eric 'would have been more financially useful to Kouri alive' because the insurance didn't cover her debts; (12) argued the Walk the Dog letter contained things that were true and 'never went to anyone — it was nothing more than thoughts on paper'; (13) said 'It is absolutely possible that everything she said in that letter was true'; (14) told jurors if Eric accidentally ingested fentanyl from pills Kouri unwittingly obtained, that is not aggravated murder; (15) concluded: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands. Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:57 PM
Prosecution rebuttal closing argument — Bloodworth delivered a rebuttal closing. He: (1) addressed the witch/widow illusion — 'Parlor tricks are not legal standards'; (2) noted defense attorneys cited no evidence in closing — 'There's a reason defense counsel didn't cite you to the evidence'; (3) stated circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence; (4) went through a list of defense statements from trial, saying after each one 'There's no evidence of that'; (5) told jurors to consider their own observations of Kouri; (6) stated 'all the evidence in this case proves Eric did not die by suicide' — he was making Disneyland plans, loved his sons; (7) walked through GIF access timing — the GIFs were accessed 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house'; (8) concluded: 'He proves that much of [her story] is fake. … She just murdered Eric. … She wasn't crying.' Bloodworth stated the evidence proves 'There is no other rational explanation for the evidence.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 163:00 PM
Jury begins deliberations at approximately 3 p.m. after closing arguments conclude. Judge excused four alternate jurors (jurors 9, 10, 11, and 12 — four women). Final deliberating jury of eight consists of six men and two women. Judge ordered them dinner around 5 p.m. A stipulation of fact issue arose: Juror No. 2 (the foreperson) sent a note to bailiff noting jurors were supposed to receive a hard copy of a factual stipulation — resolved by attorneys. Jury deliberated with a computer containing all evidence but no internet access.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT: Jury of eight Summit County residents finds Kouri Richins GUILTY on ALL FIVE COUNTS after approximately 3 hours of deliberation. Verdict announced at approximately 6:30-6:34 p.m. MDT. Count 1 — Aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — Insurance fraud (x2): GUILTY. Count 5 — Forgery: GUILTY. The foreperson, a woman (Juror No. 2, identified as 'Laura' in media interviews), confirmed unanimous verdict. As the verdict was read, Kouri Richins was described as 'trembling' and 'visibly shaking' before jurors entered. She looked down at the desk and stared at the floor as the verdict was read; 'a look of shock appeared on her face as the first guilty was read, and she immediately hung her head.' Multiple family members of Eric Richins were in tears. Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Judge polled each juror; each confirmed 'Yes.' One male juror appeared quite emotional; another was wiping his eyes. Judge dismissed jury and thanked them, telling them they may now speak to anyone they wish.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Sentencing scheduled: Judge Mrazik set sentencing for 9:30 a.m. on Wednesday, May 13, 2026 — the day Eric Richins would have turned 44. A pre-sentence investigation report was ordered. Defense attorney Lewis confirmed Kouri waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Kouri Richins will remain at Summit County Jail until sentencing, after which she will transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. The aggravated murder charge alone carries a sentence of 25 years to life in prison. Judge may also consider whether to sentence with or without the possibility of parole.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:41 PM
Jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit, per the verdict form — as confirmed by CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez. This finding means the jury specifically found Kouri acted for financial gain, which was an aggravating factor in both the murder and attempted murder counts.
cnn.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Eric Richins' family reacts outside courthouse: Amy Richins (Eric's sister) said: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his voice as we all continue to heal.' Other family members gathered in the courthouse parking lot. An older cousin said: 'I'm here for Eric. Eric did a lot for everybody. He was my cousin. I miss him every day, think of him every day. Love him.' A younger relative said: 'We're definitely relieved.' Eric's family said they plan to speak more publicly after sentencing. Defense attorneys and prosecutors declined to give statements Monday evening.
kutv.com
Mar 167:30 PM
Defense team issues post-verdict statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' Statement attributed to Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos. Defense attorneys also issued a prior statement during deliberations: 'Over the past several weeks, the jury has had the opportunity to hear the full evidence — not the headlines, not the speculation, but the facts. We believe in the jury system, and we trust the process.'
fox13now.com
Mar 169:00 AM
PROSECUTION CLOSING ARGUMENT (Bloodworth): Bloodworth argued Kouri wanted to 'appear privileged, affluent and successful' and killed Eric for money and a fresh start with Grossman. He stated: 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money.' He replayed the 911 call, saying it was 'not the sound of a wife becoming a widow — it was the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He displayed a timer showing Kouri waited approximately 6 minutes after the dispatcher instructed her to begin CPR before she said she started it. He noted Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the 911 call. He argued Eric did not die of suicide — he had plans to go to Disneyland with his boys and was buying a cabin with his father. Bloodworth stated October 2021 was 'the beginning of the downward financial death spiral' and that Kouri's debt was nearing $8 million. He argued Kouri booked the Caribbean vacation in December 2021 'knowing Eric would not be alive in April.' He stated: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.' He also argued Kouri closed on the Midway mansion on March 5 rather than March 4 because she wanted to confirm Eric was dead first. He called her decision to write a book part of her cover-up and quoted the Walk the Dog letter extensively. In rebuttal, he acknowledged much of the evidence is circumstantial: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. But circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' Final statement: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
DEFENSE CLOSING ARGUMENT (Wendy Lewis): Lewis argued the case was an example of 'confirmation bias — working backwards from a conclusion.' She said the investigation was 'sloppy and driven by bias' and that 'everything about this investigation was led by the Richins family.' She reminded jurors: 'The state cannot tell you how Eric ingested the fentanyl.' She argued Kouri likely deleted texts because of the affair and drug purchases — not murder. On internet searches: 'Of course she's worried. An innocent person would be worried. Anyone would be worried if they just found out they are a suspect in a homicide investigation.' She argued Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive' and that the insurance money didn't cover her debts anyway. She revisited the witch/widow optical illusion from opening statements. She argued there was 'no evidence that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink.' On Carmen Lauber: 'She's not a truthful person.' She also noted Crozier's trial testimony (oxycodone) is more credible than Lauber's because he had nothing to gain. Lewis argued the expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle on the nightstand was never tested and could have been used to bring drugs back from Mexico. On the affair and Caribbean trip: Kouri never went on the trip and broke things off with Grossman. Closing line: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands. The courage to stand between a member of this community and the state. Do not let them fool you. Do not fall for red herrings. Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:57 PM
JURY BEGINS DELIBERATIONS at approximately 3 p.m. Four alternates (jurors 9, 10, 11, 12) were excused from deliberations but instructed their service was not over and they could be recalled. Eight primary jurors — confirmed as six men and two women — began deliberating. Judge ordered them dinner around 5 p.m. A note from Juror No. 2 (the foreperson, Laura) was received asking about a factual stipulation hard copy, which was resolved and sent to the jury room. Jury received a computer with all admitted evidence but no internet access.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
VERDICT ANNOUNCED: A verdict was reached just before 6 p.m. and announced at approximately 6:32 p.m. MDT. The eight-member jury (6 men, 2 women) unanimously found Kouri Richins GUILTY on all five felony counts after approximately three hours of deliberation: Count 1 — Aggravated murder (GUILTY); Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder (GUILTY); Count 3 — Insurance fraud (GUILTY); Count 4 — Insurance fraud (GUILTY); Count 5 — Forgery (GUILTY). Kouri Richins looked down and appeared to stare at the floor, taking deep breaths, as Judge Mrazik read each verdict. Kouri was visibly trembling and shaking before the jury entered. Several jurors appeared emotional during the reading — one wiped his eyes. Family members on both sides left the courtroom hugging and crying. Eric's family was in tears. Kouri's relatives left without speaking to media. Judge polled jurors individually — each confirmed 'Yes.' Sentencing scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. MST — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. A pre-sentence investigation was ordered. Kouri's attorneys waived the 45-day sentencing rule. The aggravated murder charge alone carries 25 years to life in prison. Trial concluded more than a week ahead of the March 27 scheduled end date.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:35 PM
POST-VERDICT: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke outside the courthouse: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his sons as we all continue to heal.' Other family members said the trial was 'rough to relive' but they were 'relieved.' Eric's older cousin: 'I'm here for Eric. He was my cousin. I miss him every day, think of him every day. Love him.' Kouri's attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos issued a written statement after closing arguments: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning.' Defense also expressed hope Kouri 'will ultimately be able to return home to her three sons and rebuild her life.' Prosecutors and Eric Richins' family declined to give statements Monday evening.
kutv.com
Mar 166:40 PM
Judge Mrazik met with jurors after the verdict, dismissed them with thanks, and told them they could now speak with media and attorneys if they wished. He noted all previous instructions about not discussing the case no longer applied.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:29 AM
Trial Day 15 — Jury instructions begin. Judge Mrazik reads jury instructions from instruction No. 13 forward (instructions 1-12 were given before opening statements). Judge instructs jury: law enforcement testimony should not be weighted above other witnesses; defendant not testifying does not mean guilt; each count must be considered separately; all verdicts must be unanimous; 8 jurors needed in Utah; alternates (Jurors 9, 10, 11, 12) are still subject to court instructions in case of emergency. Judge also reads special instruction that jurors must rely on their own observations of defendant's demeanor, not what the prosecutor said about it. Jury foreperson is confirmed to be a woman (Juror No. 2, named Laura). Eric Richins' family and Kouri Richins' family both received 24 wristbands to attend closing arguments. Ten journalists on the front row. Courtroom described as 'packed.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:22 AM
Prosecution closing — Bloodworth stated the cause of death was fentanyl, and 'we know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He stated writings found in the Richins family home (Kouri's orange notebook) indicate the couple drank both a Moscow Mule cocktail and a lemon drop shot the night Eric died. This is the first time the lemon drop shot was specifically linked by the prosecution in closing to being a potential delivery vehicle for the fentanyl in addition to the Moscow mule.
cnn.com
Mar 1610:35 AM
Prosecution closing — additional specific arguments captured from EastIdaho live blog: Bloodworth said Kouri 'closed on the Midway mansion the day after Eric died' — argued she 'hedged,' not closing on the 4th as required because 'she didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead.' Said Kouri called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric. Showed Kouri's signature on a receipt — 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' Said that on Valentine's Day, 'all activity on Eric's phone ceases for 87 minutes in the middle of a busy workday after he ate the sandwich.' Bloodworth said Kouri 'distanced herself from the dirty deed' — 'She leaves the bedroom when she murders him. She leaves the county when she attempts to murder him.' Said Kouri told Eric's dad he died of COVID and a lung fungus 'that is not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.' Said regarding the orange notebook entry that Eric was on the phone when Kouri went to her son's bedroom: 'Eric's phone activity tells a different story. He was off the phone before 9 p.m.' Declared: 'There is no other rational explanation for the evidence.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:37 PM
Defense closing — additional specific arguments: Lewis admitted the defense said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial but said 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence.' Lewis suggested the expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle on Eric's nightstand — which had residue but was never tested — 'could be a good place to bring back illicit drugs from Mexico.' Lewis said the state 'waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.' Lewis said Kouri deleted texts possibly because of the affair or drug purchases: 'You'd probably want that off your phone.' Lewis said Kouri's web searches about fentanyl came after she learned Eric died of fentanyl — and searches about women's prison were because she was scared she was a suspect. Lewis closed: 'You must find Kouri Richins not guilty.' At the very end: 'I'm afraid to stop talking.' Lewis said she apologized if she, Nester or Ramos did anything to offend jurors: 'Don't hold that against Kouri Richins.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Verdict announced: A verdict is reached just before 6 p.m. Court staff announce verdict at approximately 5:52 p.m. Verdict to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. Courtroom described as tense and quiet. Kouri Richins is trembling and visibly shaking at the defense table. Eric Richins' father arrives just before the verdict is read. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden and a handful of supporters sit in the second row; Eric's family on the fourth row.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT — GUILTY ON ALL 5 COUNTS: The female foreperson (Juror No. 2, Laura) stands and confirms the jury has reached a unanimous verdict. Count 1 — Aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — Insurance fraud (x2): GUILTY. Count 5 — Forgery: GUILTY. Kouri Richins looked down and stared at the floor, taking deep breaths, as the judge read the verdict. A look of shock appeared on her face as the first 'guilty' was read and she immediately hung her head. Some jurors appear emotional; one juror wipes his eyes. Judge polls each juror individually — each says 'yes.' Judge thanks jurors for their service, tells them they may now speak freely about the case with anyone they choose. Multiple family members of Eric Richins were in tears as people filed out of the courtroom. Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Kouri Richins faces 25 years to life in prison on the aggravated murder charge alone. The trial lasted 15 days (3 weeks) with 13 days of testimony — ending more than a week earlier than the originally scheduled March 27 conclusion date.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Post-verdict family reactions: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke outside the courthouse: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his voice as we all continue to heal.' Eric's cousin said: 'I'm here for Eric. Eric did a lot for everybody. He was my cousin. I miss him every day, think of him every day. Love him.' Another relative: 'We're definitely relieved.' Family members said the trial 'forced them to relive painful memories.' Eric's family said they plan to speak more publicly after sentencing. Prosecutors, Eric's family and Kouri's attorneys all declined to give statements Monday evening. Kouri's family left the courthouse without speaking to media.
apnews.com
Mar 167:30 PM
Post-verdict defense statement: Defense attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos released a written statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.'
scrippsnews.com
Mar 169:00 PM
Verdict detail — Juror No. 2 (foreperson Laura) described deliberations in interview with Good Morning America: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' Said jurors came into deliberations 'fully loaded' and were 'really sad because they did not want to find her guilty.' Laura said she initially found Kouri 'kind of nondescript' and 'like a statue' with little emotional reaction even when verdict was read. The evidence that most convinced her was cell phone data — she was 'blown out of the water' by the forensic evidence. Jurors held a roundtable discussion rather than taking an immediate vote. Laura described the verdict as 'this devastating reality that this family was torn apart and these poor kids will really basically never have a dad or mom.' Jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit, per the verdict form.
abcnews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Post-verdict: Sentencing scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Judge Mrazik ordered a pre-sentence investigation report. Defense attorney Lewis confirmed Kouri waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Judge dismissed the jury and thanked them for their service. Trial concluded more than a week earlier than the originally scheduled March 27 end date.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Reaction to verdict: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke outside the courthouse: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Amy also said: 'Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his voice as we all continue to heal.' Multiple Eric Richins cousins gathered outside the courthouse, with one older cousin saying 'I'm here for Eric. He was my cousin. I miss him every day.' Relatives described the trial as 'rough to relive.' One trial observer, Selena Armithee — who attended nearly the entire trial and was the only public member inside the courtroom for the verdict — said she 'believed there was not enough to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Kouri Richins was guilty.' She noted Kouri's shoulders were 'visibly shaking before the jury even came in.'
kutv.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Defense statement issued after verdict: Defense attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester and Alex Ramos issued a written statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.'
nbcnews.com
Mar 169:02 AM
Prosecution closing argument (Bloodworth): Bloodworth opens by recounting Kouri's background — her father went to prison, she wanted to appear privileged, met Eric a successful businessman. 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money.' He argues Kouri siphoned $250,000 from Eric's accounts to start her own business and earn enough to leave him. He states October 2021 was the 'beginning of the downward financial death spiral' and her debt neared $8 million. He alleged she intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021 when she booked an April 2022 vacation with Grossman: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.' He described her dreams of living in the Midway mansion with Grossman.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:20 AM
Prosecution closing (continued): Bloodworth argued fentanyl was administered via the Moscow mule and/or lemon drop shot: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' He replayed the 911 call, noting Kouri waited 6 minutes before starting CPR (shown on a countdown clock). He said: 'It was not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It was the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He also noted Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the 911 call: 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:50 AM
Prosecution closing (continued): Bloodworth addressed the Walk the Dog letter: 'Kouri Richins knows four months after she's been arrested for Eric Richins' murder, a year and a half after she murdered him, she knows that she bought fentanyl and she has to explain it. And how does she explain it? She blames it on Eric.' He addressed the GIFs: 'There is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out of the house.' He said she hid her face at the scene 'because she doesn't know how to react because she's not grieving. She just murdered Eric.' He also said she couldn't face her father-in-law 'because she could not face the father of the man she had just killed.' He described Kouri's plan for the Midway mansion (living there with Grossman) and said she closed on it the day after Eric died because 'she didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:38 AM
Prosecution closing (continued): Bloodworth addressed the Valentine's Day attempted murder: 'She learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day. He noted Kouri 'left the county when she attempts to murder him' so she could distance herself. He argued Kouri called the IRS twice in three days before the attempt. He said she ordered the potentially fatal sandwich from Mirror Lake Diner herself. He noted her signature on the receipt was 'one pen stroke — she doesn't lift the pen off the receipt paper.' He showed that all activity on Eric's phone ceased for 87 minutes after he ate the sandwich, and that Eric then called Cody Wright with 'fear in his voice.' Bloodworth also called Kouri's reaction to Karrington's financial testimony a 'narcissistic injury' — she was bothered because the world saw she was not a success.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:06 AM
Prosecution closing (continued): Bloodworth discussed insurance fraud and forgery. 'She's a taker, not an asker,' he said. He showed the insurance application: 'Eric did not sign the application. It was probably a simulated forgery.' He quoted: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.' He discussed Kouri's desired 'fresh start' with Grossman. He stated Josh Grossman 'was gutted. A grown-ass man gutted.' Closing statement: 'See through her facade, check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.' Bloodworth finished his approximately 2-hour closing argument.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:00 PM
Defense closing (continued — Lewis on evidence): Lewis argued there was 'no evidence — none — that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink' and the prosecution 'waited until closing' to claim she put it in a drink. She noted fentanyl was found nowhere in the home: 'Where are these 90 to 120 pills? We have no idea where that is. They didn't trace that fentanyl.' She challenged Carmen Lauber's credibility extensively: 'Can you feel for Carmen Lauber? You can. Can you believe her beyond a reasonable doubt? You cannot.' She noted Lauber lied to a judge about being compliant with drug court. She argued Robert Crozier's testimony was more credible than Lauber's 'because his freedom is not at stake.' She addressed the expired 2016 hydrocodone bottle on Eric's nightstand: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis also argued Eric would have been 'worth so much more to Kouri alive' financially.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:30 PM
Defense closing (continued): Lewis acknowledged Kouri's affair with Grossman and deleted text messages, offering the affair itself and drug purchases as explanations for the deletions. She addressed internet searches: 'Of course she's worried. An innocent person would be worried. Anyone would be worried if they just found out that they are a suspect in a homicide investigation.' She addressed Valentine's Day: 'Eric joked about his wife trying to poison him and when he ate the egg sandwich on Valentine's Day, he had an allergic reaction to something and took a nap. There is no world in which that is an attempted murder beyond a reasonable doubt.' On the GIFs: 'They were accessed at the same time as a photo of the Midway mansion on March 4 ... it's likely all the GIFs were sent the night before [by Eric].' Lewis then addressed the Walk the Dog letter: 'There were several things in the letter that were true and the letter never went to anyone. So it was nothing more than thoughts on paper.' On forgery: 'The state has not proven its case.' Lewis said: 'If after looking at all the evidence you believe Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric died, that is not aggravated murder and you must find her not guilty.' She closed: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands. The courage to stand between a member of this community and the state ... Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:15 PM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution rebuttal (Bloodworth): Bloodworth acknowledged much of the evidence is circumstantial: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. Circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' He called defense 'parlor tricks' and said 'Parlor tricks are not legal standards.' He stated: 'There is a reason the state provided cross-references to every piece of evidence they offered, because what the attorneys say doesn't matter. And there's a reason defense counsel didn't cite you to the evidence.' He went through a list of defense statements and after each one said: 'There's no evidence of that.' He argued Kouri's plan was 'not tethered to reality' regarding the Midway mansion. He stated: 'All the evidence in this case proves Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation.' He closed: 'Despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:55 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense written statement after closing arguments: Attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos issued a written statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning ... Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.'
fox13now.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — VERDICT REACHED: A verdict was reached just before 6 p.m. after approximately 3 hours of deliberation. It was announced the verdict would be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. Inside the courtroom, Kouri Richins was observed trembling and visibly shaking before the jury entered. Eric's family was present including his father (who arrived shortly before the reading). Kouri's mother and supporters were in row 2.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT — KOURI RICHINS FOUND GUILTY ON ALL FIVE COUNTS: Count 1 — Aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — Insurance fraud (two counts): GUILTY. Count 5 — Forgery: GUILTY. Kouri Richins stared at the floor and took deep breaths as the judge read the verdict. A look of shock appeared on her face as the first 'guilty' was read; she immediately hung her head. Jurors were polled individually; each said 'Yes.' One male juror appeared quite emotional; another juror wiped his eyes. Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Judge dismissed the jury and thanked them for their service. Pre-sentence investigation ordered. Sentencing scheduled for May 13, 2026, at 9:30 a.m. MST — which would have been Eric's 44th birthday.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict court proceedings: Judge Mrazik asked Lewis if Richins waived the 45-day rule for sentencing; Lewis confirmed she does. Sentencing set for May 13 after Bloodworth confirmed any day in May works for the prosecution. Pre-sentence investigation report ordered. Judge confirmed jurors may now speak openly with anyone they wish and are no longer bound by prior instructions. The trial, originally scheduled to run through March 27, concluded more than a week early.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Courtroom atmosphere during verdict: One member of the public, Selena Armithee — who attended nearly every day of the trial and was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict was read — said Kouri 'was shaking when I came in; you could see her shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision and had believed there was 'not enough to prove beyond a reasonable doubt that Kouri Richins was guilty.' She said: 'It was extremely intense and stressful. You could tell my hands were clenched.'
kutv.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing: 911 call replayed with CPR countdown timer. Bloodworth replayed the 911 call for jurors with a countdown clock on screen showing how long Kouri waited before beginning CPR — approximately 6 minutes from when the dispatcher first instructed her to start. Bloodworth told jurors Kouri was 'distancing herself' from the time and place of the murder by emphasizing in the call that she was sleeping in her son's room. He noted Kouri referred to Eric's body as 'it' rather than 'him': 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.' Bloodworth said the 911 call was 'not the sound of a wife becoming a widow — it's the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Trial Day 15 — Additional closing argument detail confirmed (AP/ABC News): Bloodworth noted the jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit, per the verdict form. On the verdict form's aggravated circumstances, Casarez (CNN Trial Correspondent) said 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.' Bloodworth also told jurors Kouri had 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day — the sandwich allowed Eric to notice something was wrong, so she switched to a drink. Observer Selena Armithee, the only member of the public in the courtroom when the verdict was read, said Kouri's 'shoulders were visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee had attended nearly every day of the trial and said she had not believed there was enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
apnews.com
Mar 16
Trial Day 15 — Additional defense closing detail confirmed (East Idaho News live blog): Lewis stated that the toxicologist said fentanyl could have been left over from a previous use. She argued there was no alcohol in Eric's body to confirm fentanyl was put in a drink. On Crozier: 'He has nothing to gain. He just told you the truth.' Lewis noted that after all foreclosures — which all occurred post-arrest — the Midway mansion was ultimately sold for $3.4 million, more than the purchase price, without renovation. Lewis acknowledged Kouri deleted texts, suggesting it may have been due to the affair or drug purchases. On the hydrocodone bottle: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis told the jury: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands.' She also admitted defense told jury in opening statements things that 'didn't come into trial — but strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Verdict reached after approximately 3 hours of deliberation. A verdict was announced just before 6 p.m. on March 16, 2026. Before the verdict was read, Kouri Richins was visibly trembling and shaking at the defense table. Her mother and a handful of supporters were in the second row. Eric's family and supporters were in the fourth and back rows. Eric's father arrived just before the verdict was read. Judge Mrazik instructed the gallery that there could be 'no outward reactions whatsoever' to the verdict. The female foreperson (Laura, Juror No. 2) stood and confirmed the jury had reached a unanimous verdict.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Post-verdict: Sentencing date set for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. Judge Mrazik dismissed the jury and thanked them for their service. He ordered a pre-sentence investigation report. Defense attorney Lewis confirmed Kouri waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Sentencing was set for May 13, 2026 — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Bloodworth confirmed any day in May would work for the prosecution. Judge told jurors they could speak with anyone they wished — his previous instructions no longer applied. Jurors were told they could speak with media and attorneys if they wished.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke outside the courthouse after the verdict: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' She added the family's focus is now 'on honoring Eric's life and supporting his voice as we all continue to heal' and that they would support his three sons. Relatives described the trial as 'rough to relive' but expressed relief. Eric's older cousins also gathered outside the courthouse. Kouri Richins' relatives left without commenting to media. Members of the public who attended described a 'tense' and 'intense' atmosphere as the verdict was read.
apnews.com
Mar 1611:19 AM
Trial Day 15 — FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION: After Bloodworth's closing, defense attorney Kathryn Nester moved for a mistrial, arguing Bloodworth: (1) 'dehumanized' Kouri by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider; (2) made improper comments on Kouri's demeanor, which Nester argued constituted a comment on her failure to testify; (3) engaged in 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind. Judge Mrazik denied the motion. He ruled the 'black widow' comment referred to a woman killing her husband, not an insect; that comments on demeanor are permissible per Utah Court of Appeals precedent (he can instruct jurors to rely on their own observations); and that Bloodworth did not comment on Kouri's silence or right not to testify. Mrazik issued a special jury instruction telling jurors to consider their own observations of the defendant's demeanor, not what the prosecutor said about it. This is the fourth mistrial motion of the trial — all four have either been denied or withdrawn.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:50 PM
Jury composition clarification confirmed at verdict: KPCW confirmed the final deliberating jury consisted of six men and two women (8 primary jurors) — not six men and six women as reported during jury selection. The larger group of 12 included alternates; the final deliberating panel was 8 jurors. This corrects the existing record which described '8 primary jurors + 4 alternates (12 total); 6 men, 6 women.'
kpcw.org
Mar 166:34 PM
Trial Day 15 — VERDICT: Jury finds Kouri Richins GUILTY on all five counts. Female foreperson (Juror No. 2, identified as Laura) delivers the verdict. Judge Mrazik reads each count: Count 1 — Aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — Insurance fraud (two counts): GUILTY. Count 5 — Forgery: GUILTY. Kouri Richins stared at the floor and took deep breaths as the verdict was read; she bowed her head as the first 'guilty' was announced. One male juror appeared emotional; another wiped his eyes. Family members on both sides left the courtroom hugging and crying. Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins stated outside the courthouse: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. The verdict came in at approximately 6:34-6:37 p.m. MDT.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:00 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing continued: Bloodworth argued Kouri tried to cover up her involvement starting with the 911 call. He showed internet searches from April 13, 2022 on Kouri's phone, including: 'if someone is poisoned what goes down on the death certificate as.' He said in her orange notebook, Kouri claimed Eric was awake when she went into her son's bedroom, but phone data shows Eric's phone was inactive before 9 p.m. He pointed out inconsistencies — orange notebook says the celebratory drink was in the bedroom, not the kitchen. Bloodworth argued: 'When people make up stories, they are inconsistent in the retelling.' He said the Walk the Dog letter was Kouri's attempt to explain how she bought fentanyl — 'a year and a half after murdering Eric Richins, she blames it on Eric.' Bloodworth said Kouri never told EMTs, paramedics, Dr. Christensen, or anyone else that she bought fentanyl for Eric at the time. He showed the three money-themed GIFs accessed at 8:29 a.m. on March 4, saying 'there is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out of the house.' He said 'Details matter — we don't know who sent these images, but we do know that they were accessed on Kouri's phone at 8:29 — the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.' He also argued Kouri 'hid her face' at the scene because she didn't know how to react, 'because she's not grieving. She just murdered Eric.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:43 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing continued: Bloodworth argued Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day — Eric noticed something was wrong with the sandwich and set it aside. 'You throw a lemon drop shot back. By the time Eric knew something was wrong, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Bloodworth said she distanced herself from the 'dirty deed' — 'She leaves the bedroom when she murders him. She leaves the county when she attempts to murder him.' Bloodworth showed cell phone tower mapping of communications between Carmen and Kouri, and displayed that Kouri called the Mirror Lake Diner to order the 'potentially fatal sandwich.' He noted her signature on a receipt was one pen stroke, not lifting the pen. Bloodworth also referenced that Kouri called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric. He argued she had booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman for April 2022 — 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:00 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing continued: Bloodworth told the jury regarding Grossman: 'Josh Grossmann loved Kouri Richins. He thought she loved him. You saw him testify. He was gutted. A grown-a** man gutted.' Bloodworth showed text messages Kouri sent Grossman the day after the Valentine's Day attempted murder — 'if he could just go away, life would be better' and wanting to marry Grossman. He discussed insurance fraud and forgery, saying Eric 'did not sign the application — it was probably a simulated forgery.' He described Kouri as 'a taker, not an asker' and said she 'created a facade.' Bloodworth played clips of the Celebration of Life video and said of jurors' own observations of Kouri during trial: 'You observe that when we played the 911 call during trial, her affect was flat. No emotions.' He said when Karrington testified about financial distress, 'she was exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury.' Bloodworth told the jury to 'check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:10 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing continued (Lewis): Lewis argued the state could not confirm fentanyl was put in a drink because 'there was no alcohol in Eric's body.' She said: 'They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.' Lewis raised the empty hydrocodone bottle: 'A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' She attacked Lauber's credibility, saying she 'lied to a judge' to get to go to Las Vegas by claiming 100% drug court compliance. She said: 'She's not a truthful person.' Lewis praised Crozier: 'He has nothing to gain. He just told you the truth.' Lewis said the state cannot confirm Kouri ever bought fentanyl, and that Eric had Lyme disease, knee and back pain, and may have asked Kouri to get him pain pills. Lewis acknowledged Kouri's affair, saying 'Eric was also having an affair — possibly more than one.' She said 'Kouri never met up with Josh after Eric died, and Kouri was grieving after Eric's death. Ultimately she broke things off.' Lewis also admitted 'we said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial, but strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence.' She argued the GIFs were tied to the celebration — Eric sent a photo of the Midway mansion the night before, and 'it's likely all the GIFs were sent the night before.' Lewis said: 'If Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric died, that is not aggravated murder, and you must find her not guilty.' She ended: 'Do not fall for red herrings. Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:29 AM
Trial Day 15 begins. Courtroom packed: Kouri's family received 24 wristbands, Eric's family received 24 wristbands, and 10 journalists seated on the front row. General public excluded. Judge Mrazik begins reading jury instructions at 8:34 a.m., skipping to instruction No. 13 (first 12 were read before opening statements). Instructions cover: witness credibility, immunity for Lauber and Crozier, defendant's right not to testify, direct vs. circumstantial evidence, and the elements of each count. Jury instructions conclude and closing arguments begin.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Post-verdict sentencing scheduled: Judge Mrazik ordered a pre-sentence investigation report. Defense attorney Lewis confirmed Kouri Richins waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Bloodworth conferred with Eric's family and confirmed any date in May 2026 would work. Sentencing was scheduled for May 13, 2026, at 9:30 a.m. — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Richins faces 25 years to life in prison on the aggravated murder count. Judge dismissed the jury and formally concluded trial proceedings.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Observer Selena Armithee — who attended almost every day of trial and was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict was read — described seeing Kouri's 'shoulders visibly shaking' before the jury entered. Armithee said she was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision and said she believed there was not enough to prove beyond a reasonable doubt. She said the experience was so emotionally impactful she likely will not attend another trial in person.
kutv.com
Mar 169:00 AM
Prosecution closing argument by Brad Bloodworth begins. Bloodworth opens by describing Kouri's troubled childhood (father went to prison, mother was an alcoholic) and her drive to appear 'privileged, affluent and successful.' He argues she met Eric, used the marriage for financial stability, but wanted to leave without leaving his money. He states: 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money.' He then walks through the five counts element-by-element using a slide presentation. Key arguments: (1) Kouri's net worth was -$1.6 million when she murdered Eric; she had nearly $8 million in debt when she closed on the Midway mansion; (2) Kouri intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021, when she booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman for April 2022 — 'She booked it knowing he would not' be alive; (3) Bloodworth plays the 911 call with a countdown clock showing how long Kouri waited to begin CPR — approximately 6 minutes from when instructed; (4) Bloodworth argues Kouri 'dehumanized' Eric on the 911 call by saying 'I can't move it' rather than 'him'; (5) Bloodworth argues the GIFs were accessed 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house'; (6) Bloodworth plays clips of Kouri vs. Katie's reactions to Eric's death; (7) Bloodworth replays the 911 call and says: 'The first minute is not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It is the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' His approximately 2-hour closing concludes with: 'Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:17 AM
After Bloodworth concludes his closing argument, defense attorney Kathryn Nester moves for a mistrial — the FOURTH mistrial motion of the trial. Nester argues Bloodworth (1) 'dehumanized' the defendant by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider; (2) improperly commented on Kouri's demeanor (which she characterized as a comment on her failure to testify); and (3) engaged in 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind. Judge Mrazik excuses the jury and deliberates briefly. He returns at 11:41 a.m. and denies the motion: he rules the 'black widow' comment refers to a woman who killed her husband, not an insect; notes the Utah Court of Appeals disagrees with Nester's position on demeanor evidence; and offers to give a special instruction that jurors must rely on their own observations of Kouri's demeanor rather than what the prosecutor said. He asks Bloodworth if he objects to such an instruction; Bloodworth does not object. Jury returns. Fourth mistrial motion denied.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Defense closing argument by Wendy Lewis begins after lunch recess. Lewis opens by returning to the night of March 3-4: 'Something feels wrong. She turns on the light, and when she looks at her husband, really looks at him, she realizes something is terribly wrong. In that moment, Kouri Richins' world collapsed.' Lewis calls the investigation 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias' and says it was driven entirely by Eric's family from Day 1. Lewis argues: (1) the fentanyl was not put in a drink because there was no alcohol in Eric's body at death; (2) investigators never tested the empty hydrocodone bottle with residue; (3) there is no evidence fentanyl was put in the drink — 'They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up'; (4) 'If after looking at all the evidence you believe Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric died, that is not aggravated murder, and you must find her not guilty'; (5) Eric may have had secrets including drugs; (6) Crozier's testimony is more credible than Lauber's because he has nothing to gain; (7) Lewis argues the Walk the Dog letter was 'nothing more than thoughts on paper' that never went to anyone; (8) Lewis admits the affair but says Kouri broke things off and they never went on the trip; (9) Lewis acknowledges Kouri's business was struggling but argues Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive than dead'; (10) Lewis shows the witch/widow optical illusion from opening and shows Kouri on the floor the night Eric died: 'Witch or widow?' Lewis closes: 'Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:00 PM
Prosecution rebuttal closing argument by Bloodworth. Bloodworth shows the widow/witch image and says: 'Parlor tricks are not legal standards.' He states: 'A lot of the evidence is circumstantial. It is. People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. Circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' He argues there is 'plenty of proof to convict' Kouri Richins based on Lauber's corroborated testimony. He addresses the Walk the Dog letter: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation. And despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.' He also goes through a list of defense statements from the trial and says after each one: 'There's no evidence of that.' Bloodworth concludes: 'The evidence does not support any other explanation.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Jury announces it has reached a verdict at approximately 5:52 p.m. Verdict announced it will be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. The jury deliberated for approximately 3 hours total.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:24 PM
Courtroom observations before verdict is read: Kouri Richins is trembling and visibly shaking at the defense table. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden and a handful of supporters are in the second row. Eric's family and supporters are in the fourth and fifth rows. A few members of the public are in the third row. Eric's father arrives shortly before the verdict. Judge warns the gallery: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down.' One public observer, Selena Armithee — who attended nearly every day of the trial and had become acquainted with Kouri's sister during the proceedings — was the only member of the general public inside the courtroom when the verdict came down.
kutv.com
Mar 166:32 PM
VERDICT RETURNED — GUILTY ON ALL 5 COUNTS. Judge Richard Mrazik reads the verdict. The female foreperson (Juror No. 2, Laura) confirms the jury has reached a unanimous verdict. Verdicts: Count 1 — Aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 3 — Insurance fraud: GUILTY. Count 4 — Insurance fraud: GUILTY. Count 5 — Forgery: GUILTY. As Judge Mrazik reads the verdict form aloud: 'We the jury unanimously agree that the prosecution has proved the following circumstance beyond reasonable doubt: The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' Kouri Richins stares at the floor and takes deep breaths. She bows her head and shows little emotion as the verdict is read. Some jurors stare at Kouri; one male juror appears emotional, wiping his eyes. Family members of Eric Richins in the courtroom wipe their tears and hold hands. Defense attorneys Kouri's family leaves the courthouse without speaking to media. Relatives of Eric Richins gather outside.
localnews8.com
Mar 166:37 PM
After the verdict is read, Judge Mrazik polls each of the 8 jurors individually. They each confirm 'Yes.' Judge dismisses the jury and thanks them for their service. Judge says a pre-sentence investigation report will be ordered. Defense attorney Lewis confirms Kouri waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Prosecution confers with the victim's family about dates. Sentencing is set for May 13, 2026, at 9:30 a.m. — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Judge tells jurors they are now free to speak with anyone they wish; his previous instructions no longer apply.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict statements outside the courthouse: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins tells AP: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' She adds the family can now focus on honoring Eric's life and supporting his three sons: 'Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his voice as we all continue to heal.' Eric's older cousin tells KUTV: 'I'm here for Eric. Eric did a lot for everybody. He was my cousin. I miss him every day, think of him every day. Love him.' A younger relative says: 'We're definitely relieved.' Eric's family says they plan to speak more publicly after sentencing. Relatives of Kouri Richins leave the courthouse without speaking to media.
kutv.com
Mar 169:05 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing (continued): Bloodworth goes count-by-count and element-by-element. He argues: Kouri asked both Hayden Jeffs and Carmen Lauber for 'Michael Jackson drugs'; she wanted something 'lethal and fatal'; she did not know how to order street drugs but knew what she wanted. He shows the May 4, 2023 jailhouse interview of Robert Crozier where he told investigators he sold Lauber fentanyl. He shows cell phone tower mapping and timeline. Bloodworth argues Kouri intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021 when she booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman for April 2022: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:20 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing (continued): Bloodworth argues the fentanyl was placed in the Moscow mule and/or lemon drop shot. He says cause of death is not immaterial — 'You determine the manner of death. It's murder. Aggravated murder.' He discusses the orange notebook and says Kouri's account is inconsistent — in the notebook she says Eric was awake when she went to her son's room and they had the drink in the bedroom, not the kitchen. Bloodworth plays the 911 call with a countdown clock showing how long Kouri waited before attempting CPR — approximately 6 minutes from when the dispatcher first told her to begin. He notes Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' — 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing (continued): Bloodworth argues Kouri's 911 call was her immediately establishing an alibi narrative — distancing herself from the time and place of Eric's death. 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' He discusses the Walk the Dog letter: 'Four months after she's been arrested for Eric Richins' murder, a year and a half after she's murdered him, she knows that she bought fentanyl and she has to explain it. And how does she explain it? She blames it on Eric.' He argues the letter was a step-by-step plan to get her brother to testify falsely. He shows the video from Eric's Celebration of Life — adults drinking and joking. Shows Kouri's 'Good Things Utah' appearance and children's book. He discusses how Kouri asked Grossman after Eric's death if he had ever killed anyone — 'She asked that because she was working through her own feelings on killing.' He says the three money GIFs were accessed 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:22 AM
Trial Day 15 — Prosecution closing (continued): After a recess, Bloodworth discusses the aggravated murder charge's two aggravating circumstances: (1) money/pecuniary gain and (2) administering a substance in a lethal amount. He shows Kouri had nearly $8 million in debt when she closed on the Midway mansion. He argues October 2021 was 'the beginning of the downward financial death spiral.' Kouri's net worth was -$1.6 million when she murdered Eric. She spent the life insurance proceeds within three months, ending up with approximately $800. 'The infusion was supposed to be Eric's money.' Bloodworth tells jurors they can observe Kouri's demeanor — noting when Karrington testified about her financial distress, Kouri was visibly bothered: 'It was a narcissistic injury.' He argues the closing on the Midway mansion the day after Eric died was deliberate: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead.' He also specifically addresses Kouri's insurance fraud and forgery — citing the TruStage $100,000 policy as having a forged signature and an incorrect Social Security number for Eric: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing (continued): Lewis attacks Carmen Lauber's credibility — argues Lauber had everything to lose, was facing a long prison sentence, and her 'only way out was to testify in this trial.' Lewis says: 'Carmen Lauber was not able to tell you that she bought fentanyl. She agreed on the stand that it was the detectives that first put the word fentanyl in her mouth.' Lewis argues Crozier's testimony is more credible than Lauber's because 'he has nothing to gain. He just told you the truth.' Lewis notes fentanyl was not found anywhere in the home and the 90-120 pills were never found or tested. She raises the empty hydrocodone bottle: 'What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis admits defense made some statements in opening that did not come into trial: 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:30 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing (continued): Lewis argues Eric was also having an affair (possibly more than one), citing the 'open relationship' text. 'There were parts of Eric's life that he didn't share with people.' Lewis argues Kouri never met up with Grossman after Eric died and was grieving. On money, Lewis says Kouri made a profit on all homes she flipped, all foreclosures were after her arrest, and Eric 'was worth so much more to Kouri alive than dead.' Lewis argues the GIFs were accessed at the same time as a photo of the Midway mansion sent the night before by Eric — likely all part of the same message thread. On the Walk the Dog letter, Lewis says several things in the letter were true and it was 'nothing more than thoughts on paper' that never went to anyone. On the attempted murder charge: 'There is no world in which that is an attempted murder beyond a reasonable doubt.' Lewis closes: 'Do not let them fool you. Do not fall for red herrings. Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Post-verdict: KPCW confirmed that the separate financial crimes case against Kouri Richins (filed June 27, 2025; 26 felony counts) is still pending but it is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue a trial on those charges given the murder conviction. The Richins family is also pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute' in civil court, which bars inheritance from a person one has killed. Defense attorney statement reiterated Kouri maintained her innocence throughout.
kpcw.org
Mar 163:07 PM
Trial Day 15 — Juror note: Just as jurors were walking out to begin deliberations, Juror No. 2 (the foreperson) sent a note to the bailiff saying jurors believed they were supposed to receive a hard copy containing a factual stipulation. Judge resolved this by confirming the stipulation of fact was included with documents sent back to the jurors.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument detail confirmed via AP and East Idaho News: Bloodworth stated the closing of the Midway mansion on March 5, 2022 (the day after Eric died) rather than March 4 (the day Eric died, when it was originally due) was deliberate: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money, she knew she could do something with the mansion and that's why she signed on the 5th.' Bloodworth also confirmed the Moscow Mule and lemon drop shot as the alleged delivery mechanism: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' Bloodworth said Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day — 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body.'
apnews.com
Mar 16
Defense closing detail from ABC News and East Idaho News: Defense attorney Wendy Lewis said in closing: 'Kouri Richins was a suburban mother, real estate agent. She does not know a lot about the illicit street drug world.' Lewis argued Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive than dead.' Lewis also acknowledged the defense said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial: 'But strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' Lewis speculated the empty hydrocodone bottle was used to hide drugs Eric brought back from Mexico. Lewis told jurors: 'If after looking at all the evidence you believe Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric died, that is not aggravated murder, and you must find her not guilty.' Lewis said: 'I'm afraid to stop talking' — and the jury 'must find Kouri Richins not guilty.' On the affair: Lewis said Eric was also possibly having an affair (referencing the 'open relationship' text to Bryce Knudsen) and said 'we all have secrets, and Eric had secrets.'
abcnews.com
Mar 166:24 PM
Trial Day 15 — Inside the courtroom before the verdict: Kouri Richins was visibly trembling and shaking at the defense table. One courtroom observer noted her 'shoulders were visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Eric's father had not yet arrived when the courtroom first assembled; the verdict was held a few minutes for him. Eric's family and friends occupied rows 4 and beyond; Kouri's mom and supporters were in the second row; a few members of the public were in the third row. Judge warned the gallery: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Post-verdict: Judge Mrazik polled the jurors individually; each said 'Yes.' Judge dismissed the jury and thanked them for their service. He ordered a pre-sentence investigation report. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis confirmed Kouri Richins waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Bloodworth conferred with victim's family about sentencing date. Sentencing scheduled for Wednesday, May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Judge Mrazik told jurors they can now speak with anyone they wish about the case — all prior instructions no longer apply. Jurors can speak to media and attorneys if they wish.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict — Eric Richins family reaction: Outside the courthouse, Eric's sister Amy Richins told the Associated Press: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' She said the family can now focus on honoring Eric's life and supporting his three sons. Amy also said: 'Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his voice as we all continue to heal.' Eric's older cousins and other relatives gathered in the parking lot. 'I'm here for Eric. Eric did a lot for everybody. He was my cousin. I miss him every day, think of him every day. Love him,' said one cousin. 'We're definitely relieved,' said another relative.
kutv.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict — Defense team statement: Kouri Richins' attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos issued a statement after closing arguments on Day 15: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. ... Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. ... Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' Nester, Lewis, and Ramos had no further public comment after the verdict.
nbcnews.com
Mar 166:50 PM
Post-verdict — legal analyst commentary: Former Utah prosecutor Nathan Evershed told NewsNation that Kouri Richins will remain in Summit County Jail until sentencing, then transfer to Utah State Prison for intake before being assigned permanent housing. He said preparing a credible appeal can take up to a year. One potential appellate argument is the venue decision — Evershed said the judge appeared to handle it well. Evershed said it is unlikely Eric's family will pursue a civil lawsuit given Kouri has no assets. He said Kouri will have an opportunity to speak at sentencing but it is unlikely she will do so. Judge Mrazik will review a probation report and hear victim impact statements before determining whether she receives life without parole or a sentence with the possibility of parole.
newsnationnow.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Post-verdict procedural context: The murder trial, originally scheduled to last through March 27, 2026, concluded more than 10 days early after the defense rested without calling witnesses on Day 14. The final jury composition was 6 men and 2 women (8 primary jurors). The prosecution called 42 witnesses over 13 days of testimony across approximately 3 weeks. The case included 4 mistrial motions — 3 denied, 1 withdrawn. KPCW reports Kouri is also litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family in civil court, and the family is pursuing claims under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which prohibits inheriting property from someone you killed. It remains unclear whether prosecutors will pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case.
kpcw.org
Mar 1610:05 AM
Trial Day 15 — During Bloodworth's closing, he argued: (1) Kouri's net worth was negative $1.6 million when she murdered Eric; (2) she had nearly $8 million in debt when she closed on the Midway mansion; (3) she had over $359,453 in overdraft charges; (4) she submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders at least six times; (5) she underreported expenses to her tax accountant; (6) she took $45,000 from Chelsea Barney's tip savings; (7) she booked the Caribbean vacation trip with Grossman for April 2022, knowing Eric would not be alive — 'She did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not'; (8) she called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric on Valentine's Day; (9) on Valentine's Day, Eric's phone showed 87 minutes of silence in the middle of a busy workday after eating the sandwich; (10) Bloodworth argued she closed on the Midway mansion on March 5 (not March 4) because she was waiting to confirm Eric was dead before signing.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:17 AM
Trial Day 15 — After Bloodworth completed his closing argument, defense attorney Kathryn Nester filed a FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION outside the presence of the jury, arguing that Bloodworth: (1) 'dehumanized' Kouri by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider; (2) improperly commented on Kouri's demeanor during trial, which Nester characterized as a comment on her failure to testify; (3) made 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind. Judge Mrazik denied the motion, finding: the 'black widow' comment referred to a woman who kills her husband and was based on a phone call between Chelsea Barney and Bryce Knudsen played at trial; commenting on a defendant's demeanor is permissible under Utah Court of Appeals precedent; and Bloodworth did not comment on Kouri's silence or right not to testify. Mrazik agreed to give a special instruction to the jury: that they should rely on their own observations of the defendant's demeanor, not what the prosecutor said about it.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:30 PM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth delivers prosecution rebuttal closing argument. He acknowledged: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. Circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' He showed the widow/witch optical illusion from defense opening and said: 'Parlor tricks are not legal standards.' He argued there's a reason the state provided cross-references to every piece of evidence — 'because what the attorneys say doesn't matter. And there's a reason defense counsel didn't cite you to the evidence.' He stated: 'Josh Grossmann loved Kouri Richins. He thought she loved him. You saw him testify. He was gutted. A grown-a** man gutted.' On the Walk the Dog letter: 'It's obvious the letter was written to get her brother to testify to a narrative that would explain everything.' Bloodworth closed: 'Kouri Richins clings to the facade that has enabled her to get away with so much for so long. And despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric. She is intensely ambitious. See through her facade, check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:57 PM
Trial Day 15 — Jury begins deliberating at approximately 3:00 p.m. Four women alternate jurors were excused; the jury consists of six men and two women. Judge Mrazik explained the jury consists of 8 jurors in Utah and reminded the 4 alternates that their service is not over and they cannot discuss the case. Judge ordered dinner for the jury around 5:00 p.m. Juror No. 2 sent a note to the bailiff noting they believed jurors were supposed to receive a hard copy of a factual stipulation; the stipulation was then included with the jury materials.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — A verdict is reached at approximately 5:52 p.m. (announced publicly). Verdict to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. East Idaho News reporter Nate Eaton described the courtroom as 'tense. Quiet. Nobody speaking. Kouri is trembling. Visibly shaking.' Kouri's mother and a handful of supporters/friends were on the 2nd row; Eric's family and supporters on the 4th+ rows. Eric's father arrived shortly before the verdict was read. Judge instructed: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:29 AM
Trial Day 15 — Courtroom seating: Both the Richins family and Kouri's family each received 24 wristbands for attendance. Ten journalists occupied the front row. The courtroom was described as packed.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke to media outside the courthouse: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' She added the family can now focus on honoring Eric's life and supporting his three sons. Eric's cousins and other relatives gathered in the courthouse parking lot; one older cousin said: 'I'm here for Eric. Eric did a lot for everybody. He was my cousin. I miss him every day, think of him every day. Love him.' A younger relative said: 'We're definitely relieved.' Defense attorney statement issued after closing arguments: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof... Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning... Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' — attributed to Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos.
apnews.com
Mar 166:50 PM
Post-verdict courtroom observation: A member of the public named Selena Armithee, who attended nearly every day of the trial and was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict was read, said Kouri 'was shaking when I came in; you could see her shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she had become acquainted with Kouri's sister during proceedings and believed there was not enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. She described the atmosphere as 'extremely intense and stressful.' Armithee said she would not attend another trial in person.
kutv.com
Mar 1612:55 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing: Lewis told jurors there is 'no wrong way to grieve' and criticized the prosecution for judging how Kouri grieved. She argued the investigation was 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias' — that Eric's family 'started on Day One and continued until trial,' hiring a private investigator and experts who later testified for the state. She said investigators never tested an empty hydrocodone bottle with residue found in Eric's bedside table. She also said investigators never secured the scene, never searched the kitchen, and were 'still searching for evidence on Feb. 9 of this year — two weeks before trial.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:07 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing: Lewis attacked Carmen Lauber's credibility at length, stating: 'Carmen Lauber was not able to tell you that she bought fentanyl. She agreed on the stand that it was the detectives that first put the word fentanyl in her mouth, in her head.' Lewis said Lauber had everything to lose and used immunity to avoid prison. Lewis pointed out Lauber lied to a judge by writing a letter falsely claiming 100% compliance with drug court to get permission to go to Las Vegas. Lewis argued Crozier's trial testimony (sold oxycodone) was more credible than Lauber's, and noted he had nothing to gain by contradicting investigators.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:34 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing: Lewis argued Eric may have had a drug history and possibly brought fentanyl back from Mexico. She pointed to the expired hydrocodone bottle: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis argued Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive than dead' given his six-figure income, and that Kouri spent the life insurance proceeds within weeks and was still in debt. She said the state could not tell jurors how fentanyl got into Eric's system. Lewis also argued Eric had an affair — possibly more than one — and that 'Eric had secrets.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument detail — prosecution: Bloodworth told the jury that Kouri Richins' father went to prison and her mother was an alcoholic, and that Kouri wanted to appear privileged and affluent. He described the October 2021 period as the 'beginning of the downward financial death spiral' of Kouri's realty business, with debt nearing $8 million. He argued she intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021, when she booked a vacation with Grossman for April 2022. Bloodworth said Kouri 'hid her face' at the scene because 'she just murdered Eric… she wasn't crying.' He argued Kouri 'could not face her father-in-law that night because she could not face the father of the man she had just killed.' He showed a clip comparison of Kouri's and Katie's reactions to news of Eric's death. Bloodworth described Kouri as a 'taker, not an asker' regarding the insurance document forgery. He said Kouri's plan with the Midway mansion was consistent with her dream of living there with Grossman, but 'she had no idea that her home was in a trust.' He also said: 'She is intensely ambitious. See through her facade, check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:41 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing: Lewis addressed the GIFs, arguing they were 'tied to the celebration' of the mansion closing and accessed at the same time as a photo of the Midway mansion — likely all sent by Eric the night before. She argued there 'is no evidence that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink' — that the prosecution waited until closing to make that argument without any evidentiary support. She also argued the Walk the Dog letter 'never went to anyone' and was 'nothing more than thoughts on paper,' and said 'It is absolutely possible that everything she said in that letter was true.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument detail — defense: Lewis admitted in closing that she and her co-counsel said things in opening statements that did not come into trial, but said 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' Lewis argued Crozier's testimony was more credible because he 'has nothing to gain' — he 'just told you the truth' when he changed his story. Lewis said there were '90 to 120 pills somewhere' but they couldn't find or test them: 'They didn't trace that fentanyl.' She pointed to the 2016 hydrocodone bottle as potentially having been used to transport illegal drugs from Mexico: 'What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis told jurors regarding Eric's Valentine's Day illness: 'Eric joked about his wife trying to poison him and when he ate the egg sandwich on Valentine's Day, he had an allergic reaction to something and took a nap. There is no world in which that is an attempted murder beyond a reasonable doubt.' Lewis argued there was also evidence Eric may have been having an affair or affairs and 'had secrets.' She closed by telling the jury: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands. The courage to stand between a member of this community and the state.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:53 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing: Lewis admitted defense made statements in opening arguments that 'didn't come into trial, but strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence — they are.' She addressed the Valentine's Day incident: 'Eric joked about his wife trying to poison him and when he ate the egg sandwich on Valentine's Day, he had an allergic reaction to something and took a nap. There is no world in which that is an attempted murder beyond a reasonable doubt.' Lewis concluded: 'Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument detail — prosecution rebuttal: Bloodworth showed jurors the Celebration of Life video of Kouri and friends drinking and laughing the day after Eric died and said 'people grieve differently,' then showed her book cover and 'Good Things Utah' appearance. He argued that gummies and other items were sent to the lab but 'none of it confirmed anything.' Bloodworth addressed the manner of death as 'undetermined' on the autopsy: 'You determine the manner of death. It's murder. Aggravated murder.' He said the 2016 empty hydrocodone bottle was 'immaterial because he had no hydrocodone in his toxicology results.' Bloodworth said Kouri telling Eric's dad he died from COVID and a lung fungus 'that is not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.' He walked jurors through what he called inconsistencies in her orange notebook vs. her statements — the notebook says Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's room around 9:30-9:45 p.m., but Eric's phone activity shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Defense closing also included: Lewis acknowledged Kouri's affair and deleted text messages but said she 'may have deleted texts due to an affair or drug purchases.' She told jurors: 'If you believe Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric died, that is not aggravated murder, and you must find her not guilty.' She said on the forgery count there was 'no evidence that Kouri is guilty of forgery.' She also stated: 'I'm afraid to stop talking' as she approached the end. Lewis's closing argument lasted approximately 1 hour 10 minutes.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — A verdict was reached. Courts staff announced just before 6 p.m. that the jury had arrived at a verdict after almost three hours of deliberation. The verdict was scheduled to be read at 6:20 p.m. In the courtroom, Kouri Richins was visibly trembling/shaking before the jury entered. Eric's father arrived just before the verdict was read.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:30 PM
Verdict form detail confirmed: Jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for financial benefit (pecuniary gain) — per the verdict form language read aloud by Judge Mrazik: 'The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez noted the pecuniary gain finding shows 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
cnn.com
Mar 166:32 PM
Trial Day 15 — VERDICT: The jury returned a unanimous guilty verdict on all five counts. Judge Mrazik polled each juror individually; each said 'Yes.' Count 1 — aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — insurance fraud (x2): GUILTY. Count 5 — forgery: GUILTY. Kouri Richins looked down and was visibly shaking as the verdicts were read. One male juror appeared emotional; another was wiping his eyes. Family members on both sides hugged and cried. The verdict was read just after 6:30 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:37 PM
Trial Day 15 — Post-verdict: Judge Mrazik dismissed the jury and thanked them for their service. He told jurors they could speak with anyone they wanted — all previous instructions no longer applied. He asked attorneys about a sentencing date. Brad Bloodworth conferred with the victim's family and said any day in May would work. Richins waived the 45-day rule for sentencing at Lewis's request. Sentencing was set for May 13, 2026, at 9:30 a.m. — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. A pre-sentence investigation report was ordered.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict statements: Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke outside the courthouse: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Amy said the family could now focus on honoring Eric's life and supporting his sons. Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. A public attendee named Selena Armithee — who attended nearly every day of trial (missing only two) — said Kouri was visibly shaking before the jury entered and said she personally believed there was not enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
kutv.com
Mar 162:57 PM
Trial Day 15 — Jury began deliberating at approximately 3:00 p.m. The eight deliberating jurors (6 men, 2 women) were sent to the jury room with exhibits on a non-internet-connected computer. Four alternate jurors (Nos. 9, 10, 11, and 12) were dismissed from the courtroom but told to remain available in case of emergency. Judge ordered dinner for the jury around 5:00 p.m. A verdict was reached just before 6:00 p.m. — approximately 3 hours of deliberation total. Juror No. 2 sent a note during deliberations asking if they were supposed to receive a hard copy of a factual stipulation; judge addressed the issue.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:20 PM
Trial Day 15 — VERDICT: Kouri Richins found GUILTY on all 5 counts. Judge Mrazik warned the gallery before the verdict was read: 'There can be no outward reactions whatsoever. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps.' Kouri was visibly shaking and trembling before the verdict. As Count 1 — aggravated murder — was read GUILTY, Kouri gasped and hung her head. She kept her head bowed as subsequent guilty verdicts were read. Count 2 — attempted aggravated murder — GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — insurance fraud (two counts) — GUILTY. Count 5 — forgery — GUILTY. The verdict form confirmed jurors unanimously agreed the homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and by means of administering a substance in a lethal amount. Eric's family clutched one another; sister Amy silently dabbed tears. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden remained stony-faced. One male juror appeared quite emotional; another wiped his eyes. Judge polled each juror, who each said 'Yes.' Judge dismissed jury and thanked them for their service. Sentencing set for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. — what would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Pre-sentence investigation report ordered. Kouri Richins waived the 45-day rule for sentencing.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
After the verdict, Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins spoke outside the courthouse: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful for everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys.' Amy also told AP: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media.
apnews.com
Mar 16
KPCW reports: In civil court, Kouri Richins is also litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family. The family is pursuing claims against her under the 'slayer statute' in Utah law, which prohibits inheriting property from someone the claimant killed. It remains unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case filed in June 2025.
kpcw.org
Mar 167:00 PM
Defense statement issued after the verdict: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning.' Signed by defense attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos. Defense attorneys are expected to begin the appeals process after sentencing.
fox13now.com
Mar 163:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Jury sent to deliberate just before 3 p.m. Four alternate jurors (Jurors 9, 10, 11, 12 — all women) were excused from deliberations; eight primary jurors (six men, two women) began deliberating. Jurors received a computer with all admitted evidence (not internet-connected). Judge ordered them dinner around 5 p.m. Foreperson was identified as Juror No. 2, named Laura. Juror No. 3 was named Christie. Also noted: courtroom seating had 24 wristbands for Kouri Richins' family and 24 wristbands for Eric Richins' family; 10 journalists in the front row.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 163:07 PM
Trial Day 15 — After jury was excused to deliberate, Juror No. 2 sent a note via the bailiff indicating they believed jurors were supposed to receive a hard copy containing a factual stipulation. Judge addressed it with attorneys and the stipulation of fact was included with documents sent back to the jurors.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Verdict announced: Just before 6 p.m. (approximately 5:52 p.m.), court staff announced the jury had reached a verdict. Judge Mrazik warned everyone in the courtroom to make 'no outward reactions' to the verdict: 'There are folks here against their wills. Everybody deserves your respect. There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps.' Eric's father arrived just before the verdict was read. Kouri was visibly trembling and shaking at the defense table.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT — GUILTY ON ALL FIVE COUNTS: The eight-member jury returned a unanimous guilty verdict on all five felony counts at approximately 6:34 p.m. after deliberating for just under three hours. Count 1: Aggravated murder — GUILTY. Count 2: Attempted aggravated murder — GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4: Insurance fraud (two counts) — GUILTY. Count 5: Forgery — GUILTY. Kouri Richins gasped and hung her head as soon as Judge Mrazik read out the first 'guilty' on Count 1, then kept her head bowed as each subsequent 'guilty' was read. She was visibly shaking. Eric's sister Amy silently dabbed tears from her eyes. Eric's father Eugene bowed his head and remained stoic. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden remained stony-faced and pursed her lips. The jury foreperson was a woman (Juror No. 2, Laura). Jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit, per the verdict form.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Post-verdict: Judge Mrazik polled each juror; each said 'Yes.' One male juror appeared quite emotional; another was wiping his eyes. Judge dismissed the jury and thanked them for their service. He told jurors they could speak with anyone they wanted; all prior instructions about not discussing the case no longer applied. Judge ordered a pre-sentence investigation report. Defense attorney Lewis waived the 45-day rule for sentencing. Sentencing was scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Defense team statement after verdict: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' Statement attributed to Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos.
fox13now.com
Mar 169:20 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth argues fentanyl was administered to Eric via the Moscow mule and/or a lemon drop shot on the night of March 3, 2022. He says: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He argues Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day — a sandwich can be set aside, but 'you throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric knew something was wrong, it was in his body.' He also states Kouri 'distanced herself from the dirty deed' by leaving the bedroom when she allegedly murdered him and leaving the county when she allegedly attempted to murder him.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth replays the 911 call for the jury with a countdown clock showing how long Kouri waited to begin CPR after the dispatcher instructed her to. The clock reaches 5 minutes 56 seconds. He argues: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' He also points out Kouri refers to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' in the call ('I can't move it'), arguing this was dehumanization. He delivers the closing's signature line: 'The first minute is not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It is the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:50 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth addresses the Walk the Dog letter in closing. He argues Kouri wrote it four months after her arrest — a year and a half after the murder — because she knew she had bought fentanyl and needed to explain it: 'She blames it on Eric.' He reads lines from the letter for the jury, including the line that if Ronnie doesn't say the scripted things, 'she's convicted.' He also tells jurors: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation for the evidence.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:05 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth discusses Kouri's financial collapse and motive in detail. He shows charts revealing Kouri had over $359,453 in overdraft charges and nearly $8 million in debt when she closed on the Midway mansion. He states October 2021 was the 'beginning of the downward financial death spiral.' He argues Kouri intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021, when she booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman for April 2022: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.' He also states Kouri's net worth was negative $1.6 million when she murdered Eric. He argues she closed on the Midway mansion the day after Eric died because 'she didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:43 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth addresses the Valentine's Day attempted murder count, arguing Kouri ordered the sandwich from Mirror Lake Diner, called the IRS twice in three days before the attempt, and that 'all activity on Eric's phone ceases for 87 minutes in the middle of a busy workday after he ate the sandwich.' He points out Eric then called both Cody Wright and Josh Kaze, and both described fear in Eric's voice. Bloodworth says: 'Losing your husband on Valentine's Day or on the day you're supposed to close on a big house gets you extra attention — the kind of attention Kouri craved.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:06 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth addresses the GIF evidence, saying: 'There is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out of the house.' He argues: 'We don't know who sent these images, but we do know that they were accessed on Kouri's phone at 8:29 — the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.' He also tells jurors Kouri created a facade of success. He refers to Brooke Karrington's testimony and says that when it was presented, Kouri 'was exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury.' He says Eric did not die by suicide — he loved his sons, was planning trips with family, and was making plans for a cabin with his father.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:00 PM
Trial Day 15 — Lewis continues defense closing. She argues the entire case was an example of 'confirmation bias — working backwards from a conclusion.' She attacks the investigation as 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias,' stating Eric's family 'started on Day One and continued until trial.' She says private investigator Todd Gabler 'only tracked people he thought might lead to information for law enforcement' and didn't follow up on Eric's Mexico trip. She argues investigators never secured the scene, never asked about gummies and didn't find them for a month, never tested the 2016 empty hydrocodone bottle with residue in it. Lewis tells the jury: 'They want you to do their job for them. Tell them no.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:20 PM
Trial Day 15 — Lewis attacks Carmen Lauber's credibility in closing. She argues: 'Carmen Lauber was not able to tell you that she bought fentanyl. She agreed on the stand that it was the detectives that first put the word fentanyl in her mouth, in her head.' She says Lauber 'took that story and she ran with it because she had everything to lose.' She also raises Robert Crozier's trial testimony that he sold oxycodone, not fentanyl, and argues his account is more credible because 'he has nothing to gain.' Lewis raises the 2016 hydrocodone bottle with residue: 'What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' She also says: 'The state cannot confirm that Kouri ever bought fentanyl.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:40 PM
Trial Day 15 — Lewis addresses money motive, affair, and GIFs in closing. On money: 'If this case were about money, Eric was worth so much more to Kouri alive.' She notes Kouri spent the insurance money within weeks and was still in debt. On the affair: Lewis says Josh Grossman loved Kouri more than she loved him, and Kouri 'never met up with Josh after Eric died.' On the GIFs: Lewis argues they were tied to the celebration closing and were likely sent the night before by Eric, noting a photo of the Midway mansion was accessed at the same time. On the forgery count: 'There was no evidence that Kouri is guilty of forgery. The state has not proven its case.' Lewis closes: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands... Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:59 PM
Trial Day 15 — Closing arguments conclude. Case sent to the jury for deliberations just before 3 p.m. The jury was given a computer containing exhibits (not connected to the internet). Four alternates (Jurors 9, 10, 11, 12) were dismissed from deliberations but instructed they remain subject to court rules in case they are needed. Judge checked in with jurors around 4:30-5 p.m. and ordered them dinner around 5 p.m. as they continued deliberating.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Courts staff announced that the jury had arrived at a verdict just before 6 p.m. after almost three hours of deliberation. Verdict announced to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. Inside the courtroom: Kouri was visibly trembling and shaking. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden and a handful of supporters/friends sat in the second row. Eric's family and supporters sat in the fourth row and beyond. Eric's father arrived just before the verdict was read.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict: Outside the courthouse, Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins told the Associated Press and reporters: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' She added: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful for everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys.' Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Eric's cousins also gathered outside the courthouse expressing relief.
apnews.com
Mar 1610:05 AM
Recess during prosecution closing argument at approximately 10:05 a.m.; closing resumed at approximately 10:20 a.m. Bloodworth continued through the Valentine's Day alleged poisoning, financial evidence, insurance fraud, forgery, and the Grossman relationship. He concluded: 'The evidence proves that Kouri Richins murdered, attempted to murder Eric Richins and that she committed two counts of insurance fraud and forgery. The evidence does not support any other explanation.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Defense closing argument (Wendy Lewis): Lewis began by describing Kouri returning to the bedroom to find Eric dead — 'In that moment, Kouri Richins' world collapsed.' She attacked the investigation as 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias,' arguing confirmation bias led investigators to build a case around a predetermined conclusion. Lewis acknowledged Kouri's affair and deleted texts but offered alternative explanations. She attacked Carmen Lauber's credibility extensively — arguing she 'took that story and she ran with it because she had everything to lose' and that 'it was the detectives that first put the word fentanyl in her mouth.' Lewis argued Eric was worth 'so much more to Kouri alive than dead,' that there was no evidence fentanyl was put in Eric's drink, and that the hydrocodone bottle on the nightstand was never tested. She addressed the Walk the Dog letter and said 'it is absolutely possible that everything she said in that letter was true.' Lewis closed: 'Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:57 PM
Jury began deliberations at approximately 3:00 p.m. Eight seated jurors (six men, two women per KPCW; described elsewhere as predominantly older) deliberated. Judge Mrazik ordered dinner for jurors around 5 p.m. Four alternate jurors (Jurors 9, 10, 11, 12) were dismissed from deliberations but remained subject to court instructions. Juror No. 2 sent a note shortly after deliberations began noting they believed the jury should receive a hard copy of a factual stipulation; judge addressed this with attorneys.
kpcw.org
Mar 165:52 PM
Verdict announced just before 6 p.m. (5:52 p.m. per EastIdaho; verdict read at approximately 6:30-6:35 p.m.). Judge told all present: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps.' Prior to the jury entering, Kouri Richins was observed visibly trembling and shaking at the defense table.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
After the verdict was read, Judge Mrazik polled all eight jurors individually; each confirmed the verdict. Judge dismissed the jury, thanked them for their service, and told them his previous instructions about not speaking about the case no longer apply — they may speak with anyone they wish, including media and attorneys. Judge ordered a pre-sentence investigation report. Sentencing scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. MST — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Defense attorney Lewis confirmed Richins waives the 45-day rule for sentencing.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:50 PM
Defense team issued written statement after closing arguments (before the verdict): 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning... Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' Signed by Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos.
fox13now.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — Verdict reached: Approximately 5:52 p.m. MDT, courts staff announced the jury had reached a verdict. Verdict announced at 6:20-6:34 p.m. MDT. Before jurors entered, Judge Mrazik warned everyone: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down.' Kouri Richins was visibly trembling and shaking before the jury entered. The female foreperson (Juror No. 2, named Laura in media coverage) confirmed unanimous verdicts. Judge Mrazik read each count. VERDICT: Count 1 (aggravated murder) — GUILTY. Count 2 (attempted aggravated murder) — GUILTY. Counts 3 & 4 (insurance fraud) — GUILTY. Count 5 (forgery) — GUILTY. Kouri Richins gasped and bowed her head as the first 'guilty' was read; kept her head bowed through all five counts. At least one male juror appeared emotional; another was wiping his eyes. Family members of Eric Richins clutched one another and wiped tears. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden remained stoic and pursed her lips. Eric's father Eugene Richins bowed his head. After the verdict, Judge Mrazik polled the jurors — each said 'Yes.' Judge told jurors they could speak with anyone they wanted and his prior instructions no longer applied. Total deliberation time: just under three hours.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Post-verdict family statements: Outside the courthouse, Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins told reporters: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming... Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' She also stated: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful for everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys.' Eric's father Eugene Richins remained stoic and bowed his head during the verdict. Other cousins and relatives gathered in the parking lot; one older cousin said: 'I'm here for Eric. Eric did a lot for everybody. He was my cousin. I miss him every day, think of him every day. Love him.' Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Defense statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri. Those accusations created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof. After three weeks of testimony, the prosecution has failed to prove its case. The standard in this country is proof beyond a reasonable doubt. That burden has not been met. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning.' — Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, Alex Ramos.
apnews.com
Mar 166:50 PM
Verdict form language confirmed: Judge Mrazik read the verdict form aloud including the specific aggravating circumstances found unanimously by the jury: 'We the jury unanimously agree that the prosecution has proved the following circumstance beyond reasonable doubt: The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' CNN trial analyst Jean Casarez noted that the 'pecuniary gain' finding 'shows the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
usatoday.com
Mar 16
Closing argument additional detail (ABC News): Bloodworth stated that Kouri booked the Caribbean vacation with Grossman in December 2021, arguing: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.' He argued Kouri intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021. He also told jurors Eric did not die by suicide — pointing to his plans to go to Disneyland with his sons and plans to buy a cabin with his father as evidence he had every reason to live. Regarding Lauber: 'Kouri Richins chose Carmen Lauber, not the state. She chose her because she was the drug dealer she knew and she had control over her.'
abcnews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument additional detail (CNN / Daily Mail): Bloodworth argued regarding the lemon drop shot: 'You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' He told jurors the amount of fentanyl 'shows that Kouri Richins wanted Eric not only dead, but good and dead.' Lewis countered: 'That was argument. Argument is not evidence. (The state) waited until closing to tell you, Oh, she put it in a drink, without any evidence to back that up.' Lewis also argued: 'Kouri spent that life insurance within a matter of weeks and was still in debt' — implying murder for insurance proceeds made no financial sense.
cnn.com
Mar 16
Post-verdict: KPCW confirms that in civil court, Kouri Richins is litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family. The family is pursuing claims against her under the 'slayer statute' in Utah law, which states it is illegal to inherit property from a person you killed. The scope of the separate financial crimes case (26 felonies filed June 2025) may have grown; it is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue a trial on those charges.
kpcw.org
Mar 16
Additional closing argument detail (ABCNews): Bloodworth stated the internet search history 'if someone is poisned (sic) what does it go down on the death certificate as' shows knowledge of what happened. 'She didn't search if someone accidentally overdoses. She doesn't search if somebody is dead for unknown reasons. She searches if somebody is poisoned — because that is what happened.' Bloodworth also identified October 2021 as the 'beginning of the downward financial death spiral' of Kouri's realty business. He argued the fact that Kouri never told anyone she bought fentanyl for Eric at his request — not EMTs, Dr. Christensen, or investigators — until after her arrest proves the Walk the Dog letter was fabricated. Bloodworth re-played the 'Celebration of Life' video showing adults drinking and laughing.
abcnews.com
Mar 16
Additional closing argument detail (Daily Mail / AP): Bloodworth described Kouri as a 'black widow' in closing argument, saying the first minute of the 911 call is 'not the sound of a wife becoming a widow — it is the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He also stated: 'The morning Eric died, she had a plan on how to spend Eric's money, not realizing it was trust money.' Separately, the Daily Mail confirms Kouri Richins 'gasped and hung her head' when Judge Mrazik read out her conviction on the first count of aggravated murder, and 'kept her head bowed as she heard the word guilty ring out another four times.' Bloodworth also stated in closing: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.'
dailymail.co.uk
Mar 16
Additional closing argument detail (NPR): NPR reports Bloodworth stated in closing: 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins, but she did not want to leave his money.' NPR also confirms Bloodworth told jurors their prenuptial agreement 'meant that if she left him, she would also leave most of his money. So Kouri Richins took a quarter of a million dollars in equity out of Eric Richins' home, without him knowing it, so that she could start her own business and earn enough money to leave Eric Richins.' Bloodworth also described Kouri as 'intensely ambitious' but 'incompetent.'
npr.org
Mar 16
Courtroom atmosphere at verdict reading (KUTV / observer Selena Armithee): Armithee, who attended nearly every day of the trial and was the only member of the public in the courtroom when the verdict was read, stated: 'She was shaking when I came in; you could see her shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision and personally believed there was not enough to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. She described the experience as 'extremely intense and stressful.'
kutv.com
Mar 16
Additional Fox News closing argument detail confirmed: Bloodworth stated in closing that Eric's gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine. A state toxicologist acknowledged during testimony that Eric Richins could have taken fentanyl before consuming the drink — a point Fox News noted the defense used to challenge the Moscow mule theory. Defense attorney Lewis also stated in closing that there was 'no evidence that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink.' Lewis also acknowledged in closing that defense said things in opening statements that did not come into trial: 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence.'
foxnews.com
Mar 168:29 AM
Trial Day 15 begins. Judge Mrazik reads jury instructions to the panel, starting from instruction No. 13 (the first 12 were read before opening statements). Instructions cover: defendant presumed innocent; burden on prosecution; direct vs. circumstantial evidence; informant instruction for Lauber and Crozier; jurors should not consider defendant's failure to testify as evidence of guilt; jurors may believe all, part, or none of any witness's testimony. Each family (Kouri's and Eric's) received 24 wristbands for courtroom access; 10 journalists in front row. General public excluded per amended decorum order.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:01 AM
Prosecution closing argument begins. Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth opens by framing Kouri as wanting to appear 'privileged, affluent and successful' while her business was in a 'downward financial death spiral.' He argues: 'She wanted to leave Eric Richins but did not want to leave his money.' He states Kouri's net worth was negative $1.6 million when she murdered Eric. He tells jurors: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip [with Grossman, April 2022] thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.' He describes the beginning of financial collapse as October 2021, with debt nearing $8 million.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:22 AM
Bloodworth closing argument (continued): Argues fentanyl was administered via Moscow mule and/or lemon drop shot. 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' Replays 911 call with a timer showing Kouri waited approximately 6 minutes to start CPR after being instructed by dispatcher. States Kouri 'dehumanized' Eric — referring to him as 'it' rather than 'him' in the call. Says: 'The first minute is not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It is the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' Argues Kouri's orange notebook contains inconsistencies — in the notebook she says Eric was awake when she went to her son's room, but she told friend Chelsea he was asleep.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:05 AM
Bloodworth closing argument (continued): Argues Valentine's Day poisoning attempt was real — Kouri 'learned from her mistake' that a sandwich can be set aside, so she later used a drink. Discusses insurance fraud: 'Eric did not sign the application. It was probably a simulated forgery.' Re: Walk the Dog letter: 'Kouri Richins knows four months after she's been arrested for Eric Richins' murder, a year and a half after she's murdered him, she knows that she bought fentanyl and she has to explain it.' Re: Grossman: 'Josh Grossman loved Kouri Richins. He thought she loved him. You saw him testify. He was gutted. A grown-a** man gutted.' Tells jurors regarding Kouri's demeanor during trial: 'You observe that when we played the 911 call during trial, her affect was flat. No emotions.' Describes Karrington testimony response as 'a narcissistic injury' when Kouri reacted to financial testimony.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Defense closing argument delivered by Wendy Lewis. Lewis opens: 'In the early morning hours of March 4, Kouri Richins is up late, slips into bed, feels her husband and he's cold. Something feels wrong.' She argues Kouri's 'world collapsed.' Lewis says: 'This entire case has been an example of confirmation bias — working backwards from a conclusion.' She tells jurors: 'There is no wrong way to grieve. They're asking you to judge how she is acting at that moment and then use that moment as evidence of guilt.' Lewis acknowledges defense said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial, saying 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' She argues Crozier's testimony is more credible than Lauber's because 'he has nothing to gain. He just told you the truth.' Lewis on Lauber: 'She took that story and she ran with it because she had everything to lose.' Lewis on financial motive: 'Kouri spent that life insurance within a matter of weeks and was still in debt. If this case were about money, Eric was worth so much more to Kouri alive.' On the affair: 'Eric was also having an affair — possibly more than one.' Lewis raises the empty hydrocodone bottle: 'What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis concludes: 'Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:00 PM
Bloodworth delivers prosecution rebuttal closing argument. Acknowledges much evidence is circumstantial: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. Circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' Argues there was 'plenty of proof to convict' based on Lauber's corroborated testimony. Returns to Walk the Dog letter: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation.' States: 'Despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.' Shows Celebration of Life video again and says people were 'joking around and drinking.' On internet searches: 'She didn't search if someone accidentally overdoses. She doesn't search if somebody is dead for unknown reasons. She searches if somebody is poisoned — because that is what happened.' Tells jurors: 'Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
A verdict is reached by the jury after approximately three hours of deliberation. Announcement scheduled for 6:20 p.m. MDT. Inside the courtroom: Kouri is trembling and visibly shaking before jury enters. Eric's family and friends in rows 4+; Kouri's mother Lisa Darden and supporters in row 2. A few members of the public are present in row 3 (via standby media pass). Judge Mrazik instructs all present: 'There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Judge Mrazik schedules sentencing for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. MST — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. A pre-sentence investigation report is ordered. Defense attorney Lewis confirms Richins waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Bloodworth confirms any day in May works for the prosecution after conferring with the victim's family. Judge dismisses and thanks the jury. Both sides announced they would not comment directly after the verdict per Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
After closing arguments and before the verdict, Juror No. 2 sent Judge Mrazik a note asking whether jurors were supposed to receive a hard copy containing a factual stipulation. Judge resolved the issue by including the stipulation of fact with documents sent to the jury room.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:45 PM
Outside the courthouse following the verdict, Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins tells reporters: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful for everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys.' She also told the Associated Press: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Eric's cousins and extended family gathered in the parking lot and expressed relief. Kouri Richins' family left the courthouse without speaking to media.
apnews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument detail — Bloodworth on the Caribbean trip: In closing arguments, Bloodworth argued that Kouri Richins booked the all-inclusive Caribbean trip with Grossman for April 2022 in December 2021 — and stated: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April. She booked it knowing he would not.' This supplements the existing record of the Caribbean trip booking as evidence of premeditation.
abcnews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument detail — Bloodworth on the Midway mansion closing date: Bloodworth told jurors Kouri was supposed to close on the Midway mansion on March 4 (the day Eric died) but instead closed on March 5 (the day after). He argued: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money, she knew she could do something with the mansion, and that's why she signed on the 5th.' This is a new prosecution argument presented in closing — specifically framing the delay as intentional.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument detail — Bloodworth on the 911 call CPR delay: During closing arguments, Bloodworth replayed the 911 call with a countdown clock on the screen for jurors, showing it took Kouri approximately 5 minutes and 56 seconds from when the dispatcher told her to perform CPR to when she said she began. Bloodworth stated: 'She is not immediately trying to revive him.' He also noted Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' when saying she couldn't move him — 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument — defense Lewis acknowledges defense opening statements included things that did not come into trial: Defense attorney Wendy Lewis acknowledged during her closing that defense attorneys 'said things in opening statements that didn't come into trial' but argued 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence — they are.' This is an acknowledgment that the defense's promised Eric-was-addicted theory was never substantiated with witnesses.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Fourth mistrial motion filed and denied on Day 15 (closing arguments day): Defense attorney Nester filed a fourth mistrial motion after Bloodworth's closing argument, alleging: (1) Bloodworth 'dehumanized' Richins by calling her a 'black widow'; (2) Bloodworth improperly referred to Richins as a 'narcissist'; (3) Bloodworth made improper comments on Richins' demeanor, which Nester argued amounted to a comment on her decision not to testify. Judge Mrazik denied the motion after a recess to collect his thoughts, ruling: the 'black widow' comment was not about an insect but about a woman who killed her husband; a curative instruction was sufficient for the demeanor issue; Bloodworth did not comment on Richins' silence or right not to testify. Mrazik said he would read a special instruction for jurors to rely on their own observations rather than Bloodworth's description of Richins' demeanor. KPCW confirmed total mistrial motions: (1) Week 1 — DENIED March 2; (2) Day 9 — DENIED Day 13; (3) Day 10 — WITHDRAWN Day 11; (4) Day 15 — DENIED.
kpcw.org
Mar 16
Closing argument context — Bloodworth on the orange notebook inconsistency: During rebuttal, Bloodworth argued that Kouri's orange notebook entry said Eric 'was on the phone when she went into her son's bedroom around 9:30 to 9:45 p.m.' but Eric's phone activity shows he was off the phone before 9 p.m. — calling this an inconsistency showing her account 'is fake.' He also pointed out that the orange notebook says the celebratory drink was consumed in the bedroom, while Kouri had told law enforcement it was in the kitchen.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument — Bloodworth on the GIFs timing: In closing, Bloodworth argued the GIFs were accessed 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house' on the morning of March 4, 2022 — and that 'whoever accessed them turned the phone this way to view them better.' He stated 'There is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out of the house.' He also acknowledged he could not determine who sent the message, but said the phone was accessed at 8:29 a.m. on Kouri's device.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument — Bloodworth on Eric's cause of death and manner of death: Bloodworth addressed the medical examiner's 'undetermined' manner of death ruling, telling jurors: 'Manner of death is immaterial. It's for statistical purposes. You determine the manner of death. It's murder. Aggravated murder.' He also stated that Eric did not ingest contaminated THC gummies, that the gummies were tested and none were tampered with fentanyl, and confirmed that 'one detective who testified said he's never seen marijuana tampered with fentanyl.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Closing argument — Bloodworth on Kouri's demeanor and the Karrington testimony: Bloodworth told jurors they could observe Richins' demeanor throughout trial, and stated: 'You observe that when we played the 911 call during trial, her affect was flat. No emotions. You also observed that when Brooke Karrington testified about the financial distress of her business, she was exercised because that testimony pierced her facade. It was a narcissistic injury. She was bothered because the world saw she is indeed not a success and not affluent.' Judge Mrazik later denied a mistrial motion based on this 'narcissist' language but offered a curative instruction.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
CNN trial correspondent Jean Casarez published post-verdict analysis (March 18, 2026) highlighting key factors in the conviction: (1) Jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder were committed for financial benefit — confirmed via verdict form, showing 'the money was really paramount in those jurors' minds'; (2) Cell phone records bolstered Lauber's testimony — Casarez said the phone data 'added so much credibility to the circumstantial case'; (3) Kouri and Lauber exchanged approximately 800 texts in the three months before Eric's death — about 10-11 per day; (4) The Walk the Dog letter was described as 'damning' — 'a step-by-step and word-by-word plan for testimony'; (5) Bloodworth argued the insurance policy, attempted murder, murder, and insurance claim all formed a unified scheme. Attorney Ben Hershon (quoted in CNN) said the letter made 'everything else that happened in the trial more believable from the prosecutor's point of view — it's now saying this is a pattern, this is a scheme, this is a plan of action that she put together step by step by step.'
cnn.com
Mar 163:00 PM
Jury begins deliberating just before 3 p.m. on March 16, 2026. The 8-person jury (6 men, 2 women) was sent to deliberate after closing arguments concluded. Judge ordered them dinner around 5 p.m. A juror note was received just after deliberations began from Juror No. 2, asking whether jurors were supposed to receive a hard copy of a factual stipulation — judge resolved the issue. Four women were among the alternates excused from deliberations.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
A verdict was reached just before 6 p.m. after approximately three hours of deliberation. Verdict announced to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. Inside the courtroom: Kouri Richins was visibly trembling and shaking before the jury entered. Eric's father arrived shortly before the reading. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden and a handful of supporters sat in the second row. Eric's family and friends sat in the fourth row and beyond. Both families received 24 wristbands each. Judge warned everyone to make 'no outward reactions' to the verdict.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Jury composition correction confirmed at verdict: The eight-member deliberating jury consisted of six men and two women (not six men and six women as reported during jury selection — the 12-person panel included four alternates who were excused before deliberations). KPCW confirmed: 'Eight Summit County jurors, six men and two women, convicted her.'
kpcw.org
Mar 16
Additional closing argument details confirmed from multiple sources: Defense attorney Wendy Lewis acknowledged in closing that statements made in opening arguments 'didn't come into trial — but strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' Lewis argued: 'If after looking at all the evidence you believe Kouri accidentally obtained fentanyl and then Eric died, that is not aggravated murder, and you must find her not guilty.' Lewis said on the affair: Kouri broke things off with Grossman and they never went on the trip. On the Walk the Dog letter: 'It was nothing more than thoughts on paper' that 'never went to anyone.' Lewis admitted the old hydrocodone bottle was potentially used for bringing illicit pills back from Mexico: 'What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' Lewis told jurors: 'I'm sure you want me to stop talking, but I'm afraid to stop talking.' Lewis asked jurors not to take an immediate vote but to talk about where there is reasonable doubt and said: 'Courage is what this moment demands. The courage to stand between a member of this community and the state.'
abcnews.com
Mar 16
Additional prosecution closing details confirmed: Bloodworth described Kouri as 'intensely ambitious' and said she 'clings to the facade that has enabled her to get away with so much for so long.' He stated: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.' On the attempted murder with fentanyl-laced sandwich: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' On the Walk the Dog letter: Bloodworth stated the letter explains why Kouri needed 'to craft her defense around' it. He noted Kouri called the fentanyl amount 'a trace' when speaking with Chelsea Barney — 'Kouri said there was a trace of fentanyl' while the ME found five times a lethal dose. He said Kouri 'chose Carmen Lauber, not the state.'
localnews8.com
Mar 16
Prosecution's lemon drop shot detail confirmed in closing: Bloodworth specified in closing arguments that on the night Eric died, Kouri told law enforcement she made Eric a Moscow mule AND a lemon drop shot — and writings by Kouri found in the family home also indicate both drinks were served. Previously only 'Moscow mule' had been consistently identified. Bloodworth used this to argue Kouri administered fentanyl in the drinks, stating the lemon drop shot would be thrown back quickly before Eric could detect a problem.
cnn.com
Mar 16
Prosecution's 800 Kouri-Lauber texts statistic confirmed in Daily Mail closing summary: In the three months leading up to Eric's March 2022 death, Kouri and Carmen Lauber exchanged approximately 800 texts — an average of 10-11 per day. Graphics shown to the jury also revealed distinct patterns: Kouri initiating contact with Lauber, Lauber contacting Crozier, then Lauber and Richins communicating repeatedly over the following hours, with Lauber and Crozier also communicating within the same timeframe.
dailymail.co.uk
Mar 16
Insurance application error confirmed in closing: During closing arguments, CNN confirmed that the $100,000 TruStage life insurance policy application contained errors including an incorrect Social Security number for Eric Richins — cited by prosecutors as evidence the application was completed by Kouri without Eric's input.
cnn.com
Mar 16
Quetiapine gastric fluid level confirmed — 16,000 ng/mL: Fox News confirmed from court records that Eric Richins' gastric fluid contained 16,000 ng/mL of quetiapine, an antipsychotic medication sometimes prescribed as a sleep aid (and prescribed to Kouri Richins). This was a previously unspecified concentration for the quetiapine finding.
foxnews.com
Mar 16
KPCW clarification on civil proceedings post-verdict: Following the guilty verdict, KPCW reported that Kouri Richins is also litigating property issues with Eric Richins' family in civil court. The family is pursuing claims against her under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which prohibits inheriting property from a person one has killed. It remains unclear whether prosecutors still plan to pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case filed in June 2025.
kpcw.org
Mar 16
Selena Armithee — member of public who attended nearly the entire trial — provided observations from inside the courtroom at verdict: Armithee, who said she had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during the proceedings, was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict was read. She described the atmosphere as 'extremely intense and stressful.' She said Kouri 'was shaking when I came in; you could see her shoulders visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their verdict and said she did not believe there was enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. She said attending the trial was 'so emotionally impactful' she likely will not attend another trial in person.
thenationaldesk.com
Mar 16
Eric Richins family statement after verdict confirmed: Eric's family released a statement confirming their focus is now on caring for his three sons. Eric's cousins and other relatives also spoke outside the courthouse, with one older cousin saying: 'I'm here for Eric. Eric did a lot for everybody. He was my cousin. I miss him every day, think of him every day. Love him.' A younger relative said: 'We're definitely relieved.' Some family members who asked not to be identified said the trial had been difficult because it forced them to relive painful memories, with one cousin saying 'It's been rough to relive it.'
thenationaldesk.com
Mar 168:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — CLOSING ARGUMENTS: Judge Mrazik read jury instructions beginning at 8:30 a.m. Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth delivered a two-hour closing argument, describing Kouri as an 'intensely ambitious' woman who created a 'facade' of success, was in a 'downward financial death spiral,' and murdered Eric for financial gain and to start a new life with Josh Grossman. Bloodworth replayed the first minute of the 911 call, saying: 'The first minute is not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It is the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' Bloodworth argued Eric did not die of accidental overdose or suicide, citing his plans to go to Disneyland and buy a cabin with his father. Bloodworth stated Kouri 'did not book that trip [with Grossman in December 2021] thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April — she booked it knowing he would not.' He argued the GIFs were accessed 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.' He told jurors: 'Do not let her get away with murder.' Bloodworth noted Kouri's net worth was negative $1.6 million when she murdered Eric and she needed cash immediately for the Midway mansion closing. He argued that Kouri told Eric's father he died of COVID and a fungal lung infection — 'that is not only covering up her involvement, that is cruel.' Bloodworth said Kouri 'closed on the Midway mansion the day after Eric died ... she hedged. She was supposed to close on the 4th. She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Trial Day 15 — Bloodworth rebuttal closing (additional details): Bloodworth stated the 'Walk the Dog' letter shows Kouri 'knows that she bought fentanyl and she has to explain it' — and she 'blames it on Eric.' He argued the book was written to make money and Kouri 'wasn't a good writer.' He said: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. Circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' He also stated: 'There's no evidence Eric sent these [GIF] messages... Details matter.' He argued the orange notebook entries were inconsistent with Kouri's other accounts — in the notebook she said Eric was on the phone when she went to her son's room, but Eric's phone showed no activity before 9 p.m. He also said Eric's manner of death as 'undetermined' was 'for statistical purposes — you determine the manner of death. It's murder.' He showed the Celebration of Life video and said adults were joking and drinking. Bloodworth in rebuttal: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:57 PM
Trial Day 15 — JURY DELIBERATIONS BEGIN: The case was submitted to the jury just before 3 p.m. MDT. The jury consisted of eight primary jurors (six men and two women; four alternates were excused). The female foreperson led deliberations. Judge ordered dinner for the jury around 5 p.m. A verdict was reached just before 6 p.m. — approximately three hours after deliberations began.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:34 PM
VERDICT: Kouri Richins FOUND GUILTY ON ALL FIVE COUNTS. Judge Richard Mrazik read the verdict at approximately 6:34 p.m. MDT after the jury deliberated for just under three hours. The jury — eight primary jurors, six men and two women — returned unanimous guilty verdicts on all counts: (1) Aggravated murder (1st-degree felony) — GUILTY; (2) Attempted aggravated murder (1st-degree felony) — GUILTY; (3) Insurance fraud — GUILTY; (4) Insurance fraud — GUILTY; (5) Forgery (3rd-degree felony) — GUILTY. The verdict form specified the jury unanimously agreed the homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and by means of the administration of a substance in a lethal amount. Kouri Richins gasped and bowed her head as the first guilty verdict was read; she kept her head down as 'guilty' rang out four more times. She was visibly shaking before the jury entered. Eric's family members wiped tears and held hands. His sister Amy silently dabbed tears. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden remained 'stony-faced.' Eric's father Eugene bowed his head. Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Post-verdict context confirmed: Eric Richins' family is pursuing civil claims against Kouri Richins under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which bars a person from inheriting property from someone they killed. Kouri also continues to litigate property issues with Eric's family in civil court. The separate 26-count financial crimes case filed June 2025 is still pending; it is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue that trial. Defense attorneys confirmed no rebuttal case and stated Kouri maintained her innocence throughout.
kpcw.org
Mar 166:41 PM
Post-verdict: Judge Mrazik polled all eight jurors, each confirming the unanimous verdict. One male juror appeared quite emotional; another was wiping his eyes. Judge dismissed the jury, thanked them for their service, told them his previous instructions no longer applied, and encouraged them to speak openly about the case. A pre-sentence investigation report was ordered. Sentencing was set for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. MST — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis confirmed Kouri waives the 45-day sentencing rule.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:50 PM
Post-verdict statements: Outside the courthouse, Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins told reporters: 'Four years ago, our family lost the brightest light. Eric is deeply loved and missed every single day. We are grateful for everyone who has worked tirelessly to bring justice for Eric. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his boys.' Amy also told AP: 'Honestly, I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.' Defense attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester and Alex Ramos issued a written statement: 'For nearly three years, the public has heard accusations about Kouri that created a narrative that spread far beyond this courtroom. But in court, accusations are not enough. The law requires proof beyond a reasonable doubt. Kouri has maintained her innocence from the very beginning. Kouri should finally be able to go home to her three young boys and begin rebuilding her life.' Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn said neither side would comment directly after the verdict.
apnews.com
Mar 169:00 AM
Prosecution closing argument by Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth (approximately 2 hours): Bloodworth called Kouri Richins an 'intensely ambitious' woman who created a 'facade of success' while her business was in a 'downward financial death spiral.' He described her as a 'black widow' and said: 'The first minute is not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It is the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' Bloodworth replayed the 911 call, noting Kouri waited approximately 6 minutes after being told to perform CPR before doing so, and said she referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him.' He argued October 2021 was the 'beginning of the downward financial death spiral,' that Kouri's net worth was negative $1.6 million when she murdered Eric, and that she had nearly $8 million in debt when closing on the Midway mansion. Bloodworth said Kouri did not close on the Midway mansion on March 4 but waited until March 5 — the day after Eric died — 'because she knew he would be dead.' Bloodworth argued Kouri had booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman in December 2021 'knowing Eric would not be alive in April.' He showed the money-themed GIFs and argued they were accessed 'the exact minute deputies signed the log out of the house,' saying 'there is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out.' He addressed the Walk the Dog letter: 'Kouri Richins knows four months after she's been arrested... a year and a half after she's murdered him, she knows that she bought fentanyl and she has to explain it. And how does she explain it? She blames it on Eric.' Bloodworth also said Kouri asked Grossman about killing because she was 'working through her own feelings on killing.' On the insurance counts, he stated: 'Kouri Richins wanted to murder Eric Richins, thus took out an insurance policy on his life to get money for murdering Eric Richins. Then she murdered Eric Richins, and then she submitted a claim to get the money.' Bloodworth played the Crozier jailhouse video confirming he sold fentanyl. He told jurors: 'The evidence proves that Kouri Richins murdered, attempted to murder Eric Richins... There is no other rational explanation.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:19 AM
FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION (Day 15): After Bloodworth's closing argument concluded, defense attorney Kathryn Nester moved for a mistrial. Nester argued: (1) Bloodworth 'dehumanized' the defendant by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider; (2) Bloodworth improperly commented on Kouri's demeanor during trial, which Nester characterized as a comment on her failure to testify; (3) Bloodworth made 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind that was 'completely made up.' Judge Mrazik denied the motion. He ruled the 'black widow' comment was a reference to a woman killing her husband (not an insect), that the Utah Court of Appeals disagreed with the defense's position on demeanor commentary, and that Bloodworth did not comment on Kouri's silence or right not to testify. Mrazik agreed to read a special instruction to the jury that they must rely on their own observations of the defendant's demeanor, not what the prosecutor said about it.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Defense closing argument by Wendy Lewis: Lewis used the witch/widow optical illusion from opening statements and said 'if you look at those facts another way, you see a widow.' Lewis argued the case was 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias' — that Eric's family 'started on day one' and drove the entire investigation, hiring private investigators and experts who testified for the state. Lewis argued investigators never tested the empty hydrocodone bottle, never followed up on Eric's Mexico trip, and only looked for evidence confirming their theory: 'Confirmation bias.' Lewis said: 'There is no evidence — none — that fentanyl was put into Eric's drink. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up. That was argument. Argument is not evidence.' Lewis attacked Lauber's credibility: 'Carmen Lauber was not able to tell you that she bought fentanyl. She agreed on the stand that it was the detectives that first put the word fentanyl in her mouth.' Lewis said Crozier 'had nothing to gain' and 'just told you the truth.' Lewis acknowledged Kouri's business was struggling but argued Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive than dead.' On the affair: Kouri broke it off and never went on the Caribbean trip. On the internet searches: 'Of course she's worried. An innocent person would be worried.' On the Walk the Dog letter: 'It is absolutely possible that everything she said in that letter was true.' Lewis said: 'They don't have the evidence that Kouri Richins killed her husband. So instead they have tried to show you as much evidence as they possibly can to convince you she's the sort of person who would.' Lewis told jurors: 'Do not let them fool you. Do not fall for red herrings. Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins.' Lewis also told jurors she was 'unexpectedly widowed when I was not much older than Kouri' and said 'there is no wrong way to grieve.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:27 AM
Courtroom packed for Day 15 closing arguments. Kouri Richins' family received 24 wristbands; Eric Richins' family received 24 wristbands. Ten journalists on front row. Judge Mrazik on the bench at 8:27 a.m. Jury instructions begin at 8:34 a.m. Judge reads instructions 13 onward (1-12 had been read at trial start). Instructions include: jurors should not consider law enforcement testimony above other witnesses; defendant not testifying cannot be considered evidence of guilt; Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier fell under an 'informant' instruction; direct vs. circumstantial evidence explained; verdict must be unanimous on all counts; alternates (jurors 9, 10, 11, 12) identified.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:57 PM
Case submitted to jury for deliberations at approximately 3 p.m. Eight jurors (six men and two women — confirming the final jury composition differed from the earlier 6/6 split reported during jury selection; four alternates excused) began deliberations. The jury received a computer containing admitted exhibits not connected to the internet. Juror No. 2 sent a note shortly after deliberations began asking whether a factual stipulation would be provided in hard copy; judge confirmed it would be included with jury materials. Judge planned to check in with jurors around 4:30 p.m. regarding whether to continue or retire for the evening. Judge ordered dinner for jurors around 5 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Verdict announced: A verdict was reached just before 6 p.m. and announced at approximately 6:20-6:34 p.m. MT. After less than three hours of deliberations, the eight-member Summit County jury unanimously found Kouri Richins GUILTY on all five felony counts. Kouri was visibly shaking and trembling before jurors entered. As Judge Mrazik read the first count of aggravated murder, Kouri gasped, put her head down, and began breathing heavily. Count 1 — Aggravated murder (1st-degree felony): GUILTY. Count 2 — Attempted aggravated murder (1st-degree felony): GUILTY. Count 3 — Insurance fraud (2nd-degree felony): GUILTY. Count 4 — Insurance fraud (2nd-degree felony): GUILTY. Count 5 — Forgery (3rd-degree felony): GUILTY. One male juror appeared emotional; another was wiping his eyes. Eric Richins' family clutched one another; his sister Amy silently dabbed tears. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden remained stony-faced. Kouri's relatives left without speaking to media. Judge Mrazik warned everyone before the verdict that there could be 'no outward reactions whatsoever.' The verdict form confirmed jurors unanimously found both murder and attempted murder were committed for pecuniary gain.
kpcw.org
Mar 169:01 AM
Prosecution closing argument: Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth begins. He argued Kouri Richins was 'intensely ambitious' and created a 'facade' of success while her business was in a 'downward financial death spiral.' Her motive: money and a fresh start with Grossman. Bloodworth stated Eric Richins did not die by suicide — he loved his sons, was planning to go to Disneyland, and was buying a cabin with his father. He argued Eric did not use illicit drugs and Kouri never told anyone Eric used illicit drugs. Bloodworth said Kouri intended to cause Eric's death as early as December 2021, when she booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman for April 2022: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:20 AM
Bloodworth closing continued: Argued the fentanyl was delivered via the Moscow mule and/or lemon drop shot — 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He said Kouri 'learned from her mistake' on Valentine's Day — a sandwich could be set aside, but 'you throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' Bloodworth replayed the 911 call with a CPR countdown timer showing Kouri waited approximately 5 minutes 56 seconds after being told to start CPR before doing so. He argued Kouri was 'distancing herself' in the call by immediately establishing she was in her son's room. He said she referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' — 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Bloodworth closing: 'The first minute is not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It is the sound of a wife becoming a black widow.' He described Kouri as a 'black widow' who killed her husband for financial gain and to start a new life with her boyfriend. He argued the internet searches prove her knowledge: 'She didn't search if someone accidentally overdoses. She doesn't search if somebody is dead for unknown reasons. She searches if somebody is poisoned — because that is what happened.' He displayed the orange notebook inconsistencies — Kouri wrote Eric was awake when she went to her son's room, but told Chelsea Barney he was asleep. He also argued the three money-themed GIFs were accessed 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:05 AM
Bloodworth closing continued: Detailed aggravated murder charges — two aggravators: (1) why: money (pecuniary gain); (2) how: administering a substance in a lethal amount. Argued Kouri closed on the Midway mansion on March 5 (day after Eric died) deliberately: 'She didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she knew he would have his money, she knew she could do something with the mansion and that's why she signed on the 5th.' Bloodworth argued Carmen Lauber's testimony is corroborated by cell phone data — Lauber was at the Maverik in Draper exactly three times, and each time Crozier was also there. He stated Kouri 'chose Carmen Lauber, not me.' Also addressed insurance fraud and forgery counts: 'She's a taker, not an asker.' The Walk the Dog letter was argued as Kouri's attempt to create a 'fake story' for her brother 'to explain everything.' Recess taken at approximately 10:05 a.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:20 AM
Bloodworth closing resumed and concluded: Bloodworth addressed Kouri's use of a 'narcissistic injury' framing — argued that when financial expert Karrington testified, Kouri was bothered 'because the world saw she is indeed not a success and not affluent.' He showed the Celebration of Life video to the jury, then said 'People grieve differently' and followed with a photo of Kouri's children's book cover and her 'Good Things Utah' appearance. He said Kouri commissioned the book 'to make money' and 'wanted to appear as one' who could write. Closing ended: 'All the evidence in this case proves Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation for the evidence. And despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.' Bloodworth told jurors: 'See through her facade, check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Defense closing argument: Defense attorney Wendy Lewis delivers the defense's closing. She began by showing the witch/widow optical illusion from Nester's opening statement and asked jurors: 'Witch or widow?' Lewis argued the investigation was 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias' and 'confirmation bias from the start.' She said this entire case was led by Eric's family: 'They started on Day One and continued until trial. They are the ones who initially hired and paid for experts. Their private investigator gave information to the police.' She argued that after four years of investigation, no murder weapon was found, no fentanyl was found in the home, and no evidence showed fentanyl was put into Eric's drink — 'That was argument. Argument is not evidence. They waited until closing to tell you she put it in a drink without any evidence to back that up.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:00 PM
Defense closing continued: Lewis argued Kouri was 'grieving' and there is 'no wrong way to grieve': 'They want you to look at a woman during the worst moment of her life and to judge her. There is no wrong way to grieve. They're asking you to judge how she is acting at that moment and then use that moment as evidence of guilt.' Lewis challenged the prosecution's star witness Carmen Lauber: 'Carmen Lauber was not able to tell you that she bought fentanyl. She agreed on the stand that it was the detectives that first put the word fentanyl in her mouth, in her head.' Lewis argued Crozier's testimony was more credible than Lauber's because 'he has nothing to gain.' Lewis raised the hydrocodone bottle: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' She asked who else had the opportunity to take the pills — 'Eric.' On insurance/forgery: 'The state has not proven beyond a reasonable doubt that there was any fraud or forgery.' Lewis closed: 'Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt. You must find Kouri Richins not guilty.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:58 PM
Defense closing also included: Lewis acknowledged 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.' She said Eric was 'worth so much more to Kouri alive than dead' given his six-figure income and that the life insurance money was spent within weeks with Kouri still in debt. She raised the open relationship text between Eric and Bryce Knudsen to suggest Eric had secrets. She argued on the GIFs: they were accessed at the same time as a photo of the Midway mansion Eric sent the night before — 'It's likely all the GIFs were sent the night before.' On the affair: 'Kouri never met up with Josh after Eric died, and Kouri was grieving after Eric's death. Ultimately she broke things off.' Lewis admitted they made statements in opening statements that didn't come into trial. She told the jury: 'Be courageous. Courage is what this moment demands.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:15 PM
Prosecution rebuttal closing: Bloodworth acknowledged that much of the evidence is circumstantial: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. But circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' He said there was 'plenty of proof to convict' based on Lauber's corroborated testimony. He showed the witch/widow image and said: 'Parlor tricks are not legal standards.' He read back portions of the Walk the Dog letter, stating it was Kouri's attempt to explain the fentanyl evidence after the fact. He said: 'There is no other rational explanation. And despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.' Prosecution rebuttal concluded.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Verdict reached: Courts staff announced the jury had arrived at a verdict just before 6 p.m. Monday after almost three hours of deliberation. Verdict to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:24 PM
Observations from inside the courtroom before verdict was read: Kouri Richins was trembling and visibly shaking before the jury even entered. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden and a handful of supporters/friends were in the 2nd row. Eric's family and supporters were in the 4th row and beyond. Eric's father Gene Richins arrived just before the verdict was read. Judge Mrazik warned everyone in the courtroom to make 'no outward reactions' to the verdict and told them to keep their hands folded in their laps and look down if overcome with emotion.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:41 PM
Verdict form confirmed: Jurors unanimously agreed both the murder and attempted murder of Eric Richins were committed for pecuniary (financial) gain, per the verdict form — satisfying the aggravated murder circumstances. CNN Trial Correspondent Jean Casarez noted: 'The money was really paramount in those jurors' minds.'
cnn.com
Mar 169:01 AM
Prosecution closing argument (Brad Bloodworth, approximately 2 hours): Bloodworth opened by stating Kouri's father went to prison and her mother was an alcoholic — Kouri wanted to appear privileged. He described her as 'intensely ambitious' and her business as in a 'downward financial death spiral.' Key arguments: (1) Kouri could not afford to leave Eric due to the prenuptial agreement; (2) She needed immediate cash and planned to use Eric's money to close on and develop the Midway mansion; (3) She closed the Midway mansion on March 5 — the day after Eric died — saying 'she hedged' and signed on the 5th because she wanted to confirm Eric was dead first; (4) She booked a Caribbean vacation with Grossman in December 2021, 'knowing Eric would not be alive in April'; (5) He replayed the 911 call and argued Kouri distanced herself from the death: 'It was not the sound of a wife becoming a widow. It was the sound of a wife becoming a black widow'; (6) He said Kouri waited 6 minutes after being told to begin CPR before she actually did, and referred to Eric as 'it' on the call — 'She murdered him. Eric is an it'; (7) He told jurors Cody Wright's Carmen Lauber meeting cell data corroborated 3 specific drug purchases; (8) He displayed Kouri's internet searches from April 2022; (9) He argued the Walk the Dog letter showed Kouri's consciousness of guilt and was written to explain the fentanyl by blaming Eric; (10) He argued the GIFs were accessed at the exact minute deputies signed the log out of the house and 'there is no good reason' for this; (11) He showed the Celebration of Life video; (12) He described Kouri as a 'narcissist' whose reaction to financial testimony was a 'narcissistic injury'; (13) He closed: 'Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 16
Courtroom observer Selena Armithee — who attended nearly every day of trial and was the only member of the public inside the courtroom when the verdict was read — described the atmosphere as 'extremely intense and stressful' with her 'hands clenched.' She noted Kouri was 'visibly shaking before the jury even came in.' Armithee said she had become acquainted with Kouri's sister during the proceedings and was surprised by how quickly jurors reached their decision, as she personally believed there was not enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
thenationaldesk.com
Mar 168:27 AM
Day 15 courtroom setup confirmed: Kouri Richins' family received 24 wristbands; Eric Richins' family also received 24 wristbands. Ten journalists on the front row. Public seats were full. Judge Mrazik on the bench at 8:27 a.m. Both families present in courtroom.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:29 AM
Judge Mrazik advises jury they will receive a computer containing trial evidence during deliberations; the computer will not be able to connect to the internet. Jury walked into the courtroom.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Jury reaches a verdict at approximately 5:52 p.m. — just under three hours of deliberations. Verdict announced to parties; reading scheduled for 6:20 p.m. MDT.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:20 PM
VERDICT READ: Judge Mrazik reads the verdict. Kouri Richins is found GUILTY on all five counts. Count 1: Aggravated murder — GUILTY. Count 2: Attempted aggravated murder — GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4: Insurance fraud — GUILTY on both. Count 5: Forgery — GUILTY. The jury unanimously agreed the murder was committed for pecuniary gain and by means of administration of a substance in a lethal amount. Judge read the verdict form: 'We the jury unanimously agree that the prosecution has proved the following circumstance … beyond reasonable doubt: The homicide was committed for pecuniary gain and the homicide was committed by means of the administration of any substance administered in any lethal amount, dosage or quantity.' Kouri Richins stared at the floor and took deep breaths / put her head down and showed little emotion / was visibly trembling before jurors entered. Eric Richins' family members wiped tears and held hands. Kouri's mother and supporters were on the second row; Eric's family was on the fourth row.
townlift.com
Mar 168:58 AM
Jury instructions complete. Judge reads all five counts. Count 1: aggravated murder — Kouri Richins intentionally and knowingly caused the death of Eric Richins. Count 2: attempted aggravated murder. Count 3 and 4: insurance fraud. Count 5: forgery. Every juror must agree; verdicts must be unanimous.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:12 AM
Bloodworth walks jurors through each count with slide presentation. He says Kouri asked two people — Hayden Jeffs and Carmen Lauber — for the 'Michael Jackson drugs.' He notes: 'She doesn't know how to order a street drug, but she knows she wants the Michael Jackson stuff. She knows she wants it because it is lethal. It is fatal. It kills. And she wanted lethal, fatal death.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:20 AM
Bloodworth tells jurors evidence proves Kouri killed Eric with a Moscow mule and/or lemon drop shot: 'We know that Eric ingested the fentanyl from the Moscow mule, the lemon drop shot or both.' He says all medical experts testified an extraordinary amount of fentanyl in Eric's stomach indicates oral ingestion. He also discusses the orange notebook journal entry as corroborating that the couple had a celebratory drink. He argues Kouri's account is inconsistent with the details.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:30 AM
Bloodworth plays the 911 call again for the jury with a countdown clock on screen showing how long Kouri waited before beginning CPR — approximately 6 minutes from when the dispatcher first instructed her. He argues she was establishing an alibi: 'She is distancing herself from the time and the place that she murdered Eric.' He also argues Kouri referred to Eric as 'it' rather than 'him' during the call: 'Eric is no longer a him. She murdered him. Eric is an it.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:42 AM
Bloodworth contrasts Kouri's 911 call behavior with her 'self-serving' texts to Chelsea Barney after Eric's death, in which she described trying hard to save him and screaming at him to come back. He argues: 'None of that happened.' He says Kouri hid her face from Gene Richins (Eric's father) that night because she could not face the father of the man she had just killed. He plays clips comparing Kouri's reaction to Katie's reaction when told of Eric's death.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:47 AM
Bloodworth references Kouri asking Grossman in the Uinta Mountains if he had ever killed anyone: 'She asked that because she was working through her own feelings on killing and wanted Josh to help her work through those feelings.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:50 AM
Bloodworth addresses the Walk the Dog letter in closing: 'Kouri Richins knows four months after she's been arrested for Eric Richins' murder, a year and a half after she murdered him, she knows that she bought fentanyl and she has to explain it. And how does she explain it? She blames it on Eric.' He says the letter was Kouri crafting a fake story for her brother to testify to — never telling authorities during the investigation that she bought drugs for Eric.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:22 AM
Bloodworth details Kouri's financial distress: net worth was -$1.6 million when she murdered Eric; nearly $8 million in debt when she closed on the Midway mansion; over $359,453 in overdraft charges; repeatedly submitted inaccurate bank statements to lenders to obtain money. He argues Eric's money was the 'infusion' her collapsing business needed immediately.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:33 AM
Bloodworth argues Kouri 'hedged' on the Midway mansion closing: she was supposed to close on March 4, the day Eric died, but she didn't want to close until she knew Eric was dead because she wanted access to his money. She signed on March 5 instead. He also notes Kouri spent time on the phone with the IRS two days before Eric died and called the IRS twice in three days before attempting to murder Eric on Valentine's Day.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:43 AM
Bloodworth addresses Valentine's Day poisoning attempt and argues Kouri 'learned from her mistake' — with a sandwich Eric could partially reject, but a lemon drop shot would be ingested before Eric could notice anything was wrong. He also argues Kouri distanced herself: 'She leaves the bedroom when she murders him. She leaves the county when she attempts to murder him.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:49 AM
Bloodworth highlights that on Valentine's Day 2022, all activity on Eric's phone ceased for 87 minutes in the middle of a busy workday after eating the sandwich. After activity resumed, Eric called Cody Wright — and Cody heard fear in his voice. He also points out that Kouri told Ali Staking after Valentine's Day that it was like an allergic reaction and 'not at all dramatic' — which Bloodworth characterizes as covering up the poisoning.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:01 AM
Bloodworth discusses insurance fraud and forgery counts. He shows insurance documents and changes. He says: 'Eric did not sign the application. It was probably a simulated forgery.' He argues Kouri's motive for murder was both money and a 'fresh start' with Josh Grossman — noting she booked a Caribbean trip for April 2022 knowing Eric would be dead by then: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:14 AM
Bloodworth also told the jury that Josh Grossman 'was gutted' — 'A grown-a** man gutted' — by his love for Kouri. He argues the GIFs were accessed 'the exact minute that deputies signed the log out of the house' and 'whoever accessed them turned the phone this way to view them better.' He says: 'There is no good reason these images were accessed the minute Eric's body was wheeled out of the house.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:17 AM
FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION: After Bloodworth concluded his initial closing argument, defense attorney Kathryn Nester moved for a mistrial outside the presence of the jury. She alleged Bloodworth: (1) 'dehumanized' Kouri by calling her a 'black widow' and comparing her to a spider; (2) improperly commented on Kouri's demeanor during trial (which Nester framed as a comment on her failure to testify); and (3) engaged in 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind. Judge Mrazik denied the motion. He noted: the 'black widow' comment was Chelsea Barney's statement from a recorded call — not Bloodworth's own characterization; Utah Court of Appeals disagreed with Nester's demeanor arguments; and Bloodworth did not comment on Kouri's right not to testify. Judge agreed to read a special jury instruction telling jurors to rely on their own observations of the defendant's demeanor, not Bloodworth's characterizations.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:45 AM
Judge reads special jury instruction: jurors should consider their own observations of Kouri Richins and not rely on what the prosecutor said about her demeanor. Jury then takes a lunch break until 12:45 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:50 PM
Defense closing argument begins. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis delivers the defense's closing argument. She opens with a framing: 'In the early morning hours of March 4, Kouri Richins is up late, slips into bed, feels her husband and he's cold... In that moment, Kouri Richins' world collapsed.' She argues the state has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt and there are other reasonable explanations for Eric's death.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1612:57 PM
Lewis references the witch/widow optical illusion Nester showed in opening statements, shows an image of Kouri on the floor the night Eric died and asks: 'Witch or widow?' She defends how Kouri grieved and argues jurors cannot judge a woman during the worst moment of her life: 'There is no wrong way to grieve. They're asking you to judge how she is acting at that moment and then use that moment as evidence of guilt.' She also describes Kouri telling her young sons their father was dead.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:00 PM
Lewis argues the investigation was 'sloppy' and 'driven by bias' — confirmation bias from the start. 'Instead of looking at the evidence to determine what happened, the state has determined what happened, and then they found the evidence to support it.' She criticizes investigators for not securing the scene, not testing the cocktail cups, not investigating Eric's Mexico trip, and failing to ask about gummies during initial search. She notes investigators still searched the home as recently as Feb. 9, 2026, two weeks before trial.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:04 PM
Lewis attacks private investigator Todd Gabler: 'He was in the house numerous times, not wearing gloves, finding things and calling the police.' She says Gabler had only two hypotheses — suicide and homicide — ignoring accident. She also criticizes Det. O'Driscoll: 'He didn't investigate any other leads and he didn't attempt to corroborate information.' She tells jurors: 'Everything about this investigation was led by the Richins family. They started on Day One and continued until trial.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:07 PM
Lewis raises the Walk the Dog letter defense: 'There were several things in the letter that were true and the letter never went to anyone. So it was nothing more than thoughts on paper.' She also asks: if Kouri had just killed him with illicit drugs, why didn't she just say yes when asked if she bought fentanyl for him? 'If she had just said yes, we probably wouldn't be sitting here today.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:12 PM
Lewis addresses the deleted texts: 'Maybe it's because Kouri was having an affair and she had asked Carmen to purchase pills. You'd probably want that off your phone.' On the internet searches about fentanyl: 'Kouri did the web searches about fentanyl after she learned Eric had died and her searches about women's prison were done because she was scared to death that she was a suspect. Of course she's worried. An innocent person would be worried.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:17 PM
Lewis raises the fentanyl and alcohol argument: 'The state cannot confirm that Kouri ever bought fentanyl.' She also argues the fentanyl was not put in a drink because there was no alcohol found in Eric's body. She argues: 'The state is throwing around a lot of theories because they don't have one. They don't know what happened.' She also states: 'Where are these 90 to 120 pills? We have no idea where that is. They didn't trace that fentanyl.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:34 PM
Lewis defends Crozier's trial testimony: 'He has nothing to gain. He just told you the truth.' She also raises Eric's Lyme disease, chronic pain, and the expired hydrocodone bottle on his nightstand: 'Why would that be sitting out? A six-year-old prescription bottle? What might be the best way to bring illegal pills back from Mexico?' She argues Eric did not have to be an addict to ask Kouri to get him pain pills.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:41 PM
Lewis argues on the affair that Eric may also have been having an affair — possibly more than one — and had secrets. She says Kouri and Grossman never went on the Caribbean trip and Kouri was grieving after Eric's death. On money: 'If this case were about money, Eric was worth so much more to Kouri alive.' She says Kouri made profits on the homes she flipped and all foreclosures were after her arrest.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:43 PM
Lewis addresses the GIFs: 'They made such a fuss about these. They were accessed on March 4 and were tied to the celebration.' She says a photo was sent the night before by Eric and it's likely all the GIFs were sent the night before — they may have all been accessed together. Lewis also said defense admitted in opening statements that 'strategies change and we aren't under any obligation to present evidence. They are.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:50 PM
Lewis argues on Valentine's Day: 'Eric joked about his wife trying to poison him and when he ate the egg sandwich on Valentine's Day, he had an allergic reaction to something and took a nap. There is no world in which that is an attempted murder beyond a reasonable doubt.' She also argues on the insurance/forgery counts: the state has not proven beyond a reasonable doubt that there was any fraud or forgery. Final line: 'Kouri Richins did not kill Eric Richins. The state did not prove the case beyond a reasonable doubt... Do not let them fool you. Courage is what this moment demands.' Lewis finishes. Court recessed 15 minutes.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:32 PM
Bloodworth shows the Celebration of Life video in his rebuttal, showing adults joking and drinking. He says 'people grieve differently' and then shows Kouri's book cover and her appearance on 'Good Things Utah.' He also notes Kouri had loans with extraordinary interest rates and payday lenders would no longer lend to her. He closes with the Walk the Dog letter: reads lines from it including that if Ronnie does not say these things, she's convicted. Final line: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation for the evidence. And despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.' Bloodworth is done.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:50 PM
Judge Mrazik reads additional jury instructions. He explains the jury verdict form — separated by count, one verdict per count, all verdicts must be unanimous. He explains Utah juries consist of 8 jurors (with 4 alternates who remain on standby in case needed). He identifies alternates as jurors 9, 10, 11, and 12. He tells alternates they cannot discuss the case. He asks the clerk to swear in three bailiffs to watch over jurors during deliberations.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:57 PM
Jury officially sent to deliberate at approximately 2:57-2:59 p.m. Four women were the alternates who were excused from deliberations. The deliberating jury consists of six men and two women. Judge instructed jurors to appoint a foreperson first. Almost immediately, Juror No. 2 sent a note asking about a factual stipulation — judge resolved the issue and confirmed the stipulation of fact would be included with documents sent to the jury room.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:00 PM
Judge ordered dinner for the jury around 5 p.m. during deliberations.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
VERDICT REACHED after approximately 3 hours of deliberations. Verdict announced at approximately 6:20 p.m. MDT. Kouri Richins was visibly trembling/shaking before jury entered. Eric Richins' father arrived just before the verdict was read. Kouri's mother and a handful of supporters on the second row; Eric's family on the fourth row and beyond. One EastIdahoNews reporter was inside the courtroom.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:20 PM
Judge instructs gallery: 'There can be no outward reaction whatsoever to the verdict. There simply cannot be any outward reactions. You have to keep your hands folded in your laps. If you feel overcome with emotion, just look down. We cannot have any outward reaction.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:32 PM
VERDICT READ: Female foreperson (Juror No. 2, named Laura) stands and confirms the jury has reached a unanimous verdict. Verdict form handed to judge. Count 1 — AGGRAVATED MURDER — GUILTY. Count 2 — ATTEMPTED AGGRAVATED MURDER — GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — INSURANCE FRAUD (x2) — GUILTY. Count 5 — FORGERY — GUILTY. Kouri Richins looked down and remained still while each verdict was read. One male juror appeared emotional; another juror was wiping his eyes. Kouri was found GUILTY on ALL FIVE FELONY COUNTS.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:35 PM
Judge polls the jurors individually — each says 'Yes' to confirm their verdict. Judge tells the jury they can speak with anyone they want going forward; all prior instructions no longer apply. Jurors may speak with media and attorneys if they wish.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:37 PM
Judge sets SENTENCING for 9:30 a.m. on Wednesday, May 13, 2026 — which would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday. Defense attorney Lewis confirms Kouri waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. Prosecution confirms any day in May works after conferring with the victim's family. A pre-sentence investigation report is ordered.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:41 PM
Judge dismisses jury and thanks them for their service. Court adjourned. Kouri Richins remains in Summit County Jail and will transfer to Utah State Prison for intake after sentencing, before being assigned permanent housing. Eric Richins' sister Amy Richins told AP News: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.'
townlift.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Post-verdict: Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn said neither side would comment directly after the verdict. In civil court, the Richins family continues to litigate property issues under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which says it is illegal to inherit property from a person you killed. The separate 26-count financial crimes case filed June 2025 is still pending; it is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue that case to trial.
kpcw.org
Mar 168:29 AM
Closing arguments begin at 8:29 a.m. on Day 15. Judge Mrazik reads jury instructions first (starting at instruction No. 13; the first 12 were given before opening statements). He explains charges, immunity witness instruction (Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier identified as 'informant' witnesses), direct vs. circumstantial evidence, and instructs that Kouri's decision not to testify cannot be held against her. Prosecution and defense each receive 24 wristbands for family/supporters; 10 journalists seated in the front row; courtroom is full but general public excluded. Both families and friends of Kouri and Eric are present. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden is on the back row.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1610:05 AM
Recess taken during Bloodworth's closing argument at approximately 10:05 a.m.; argument resumes at 10:20 a.m. Bloodworth additionally argues: Kouri's calls to the IRS two days before Eric's death show financial desperation; Kouri told Eric's father he died from COVID and a lung fungus (his mother's cause of death) — described as 'cruel'; the Walk the Dog letter shows she had to explain the fentanyl 'a year and a half after murdering Eric Richins' and blamed it on Eric; she showed no grief because 'she just murdered Eric... She wasn't crying'; and 'Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1611:45 AM
Judge Mrazik denies the fourth mistrial motion. He reads the jury a special instruction directing them to rely on their own observations of the defendant's demeanor and not on what Bloodworth said about it. Lunch break called until 12:45 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
Trial Day 15 — A verdict is announced at approximately 5:52 p.m. MDT. It will be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. The jury deliberated for just under three hours. In the courtroom, Kouri Richins is visibly trembling and shaking before the jury enters. Her mother Lisa Darden and a handful of other supporters are in the second row; Eric's family and supporters are in the fourth row and beyond. Eric's father Gene Richins arrives just before the verdict is read. A member of the public named Selena Armithee — who attended nearly the entire trial — is the only member of the public in the courtroom when the verdict comes down.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 161:58 PM
Lewis ends defense closing. 15-minute recess until 2:15 p.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:52 PM
Judge Mrazik excuses the jury to begin deliberations at approximately 2:57 p.m. Four alternate jurors (Nos. 9, 10, 11, 12) are identified and dismissed from deliberations but told their service is not yet complete in case they are needed. The final deliberating jury consists of six men and two women (KPCW confirms: 'Eight Summit County jurors, six men and two women'). Note: this differs from the earlier jury composition report of 6 men and 6 women — the final 8 deliberating jurors are 6 men and 2 women after alternates are excused. Jurors are given a computer containing all evidence (not connected to the internet). Exhibits are in the jury room. Verdict form is separated into each count, requiring unanimous verdicts.
kpcw.org
Mar 163:07 PM
Juror No. 2 sends a note to the bailiff indicating they believe the jury was supposed to receive a hard copy containing a factual stipulation. Judge confirms the stipulation of fact will be included with documents sent to the jury room. This is a procedural clarification shortly after deliberations begin.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:00 PM
Judge Mrazik orders dinner for the jury around 5 p.m. as deliberations continue.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
A verdict is announced at approximately 5:52 p.m. MDT — after approximately three hours of deliberation. The verdict is scheduled to be read at 6:20 p.m. MDT. Courts staff announce the jury has reached a verdict just before 6 p.m. The courtroom is described as tense and quiet; Kouri Richins is visibly trembling and shaking at the defense table. Her mother Lisa Darden and a handful of supporters are on the second row; Eric's family and supporters are on the fourth row. Eric Richins' father arrives before the reading begins.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:30 PM
VERDICT: Judge Mrazik reads the verdict. The female foreperson (Juror No. 2, named Laura) confirms a unanimous verdict has been reached. COUNT 1 — AGGRAVATED MURDER: GUILTY. COUNT 2 — ATTEMPTED AGGRAVATED MURDER: GUILTY. COUNTS 3 AND 4 — INSURANCE FRAUD (x2): GUILTY. COUNT 5 — FORGERY: GUILTY. Kouri Richins found GUILTY ON ALL FIVE FELONY COUNTS. Kouri stared at the floor and took deep breaths as the verdict was read. Judge polls each juror individually; each confirms 'Yes.' One male juror appears emotional; another is wiping his eyes. Kouri's relatives left the courthouse without speaking to media. Eric's family members, including sister Amy Richins, gathered outside and expressed relief. Amy Richins said: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother. Our focus is now on honoring Eric's life and supporting his sons as we all continue to heal.' The trial concluded more than a week ahead of the March 27 scheduled end date.
apnews.com
Mar 166:39 PM
Post-verdict: Judge Mrazik dismisses the jury and thanks them for their service. He tells jurors they can now speak with anyone they want — all previous instructions no longer apply. He says they can speak with media and attorneys if they wish. Judge orders a pre-sentence investigation report. Defense attorney Lewis waives the 45-day rule for sentencing. After conferring with victim's family about available dates in May, sentencing is scheduled for 9:30 a.m. on Wednesday, May 13, 2026 — the day Eric Richins would have turned 44. Utah State Courts communications director Tania Mashburn says neither side will comment directly after the verdict.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 168:27 AM
Courtroom seating for closing arguments: 24 wristbands were distributed to Kouri Richins' family and 24 to Eric Richins' family. Ten journalists occupied the front row. General public was excluded per amended decorum order. Kouri's mother Lisa Darden was present in the second row. Eric Richins' family — including his father Gene Richins, sisters, and cousins — were present.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 169:05 AM
Additional Bloodworth closing argument detail — prosecution theory on Moscow mule and lemon drop shot: Bloodworth told jurors: 'One can season a sandwich with fentanyl, Eric can eat it, tell something's wrong, set the fentanyl-laced sandwich aside. You throw a lemon drop shot back — by the time Eric would notice the shot was in, it was in his body. Moscow Mule, just to be good and sure.' This was the first time prosecutors specifically argued both the Moscow mule and a lemon drop shot were potential delivery vehicles. Writings by Kouri found in the family home indicate the couple drank a Moscow Mule cocktail and a lemon drop shot the night of Eric's death. Bloodworth also argued Kouri booked the Caribbean trip with Grossman in December 2021 knowing Eric would not be alive in April: 'Kouri Richins did not book that trip thinking Eric Richins would be alive in April, she booked it knowing he would not.'
abcnews.com
Mar 1611:19 AM
FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION — Defense attorney Kathryn Nester moved for a mistrial after Bloodworth's closing argument, arguing he 'dehumanized' Kouri by calling her a 'black widow,' made improper comments about her demeanor (which Nester characterized as an indirect comment on her failure to testify), and engaged in 'wild speculation' about what was in Kouri's mind. Judge Mrazik DENIED the motion. Mrazik said the 'black widow' comment referred to a woman killing her husband (not an insect), noted the Utah Court of Appeals disagrees with Nester's objections about commenting on demeanor, and said Bloodworth did not comment on her silence or right not to testify. Mrazik agreed to provide a special jury instruction that jurors must rely on their own observations of the defendant rather than what the prosecutor said about her demeanor. This is the fourth total mistrial motion in the case: (1) Gipson 'jail calls' — denied March 2; (2) Lauber drug court violation + Mainord texts — denied March 11; (3) 'charges' reference in recorded call — withdrawn Day 11; (4) Bloodworth closing demeanor/dehumanization — denied March 16.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 162:45 PM
Prosecution rebuttal closing by Bloodworth. Bloodworth acknowledged much of the evidence is circumstantial: 'People do not video themselves poisoning their spouse. But circumstantial evidence is just as good as direct evidence.' He argued there was 'plenty of proof to convict' based on Lauber's corroborated testimony and the phone data. He argued the Walk the Dog letter was Kouri's attempt to explain the fentanyl purchase by blaming Eric a year and a half after the murder. He stated: 'All the evidence in this case proves that Kouri Richins murdered her husband, the father of her three children, Eric Richins. There is no other rational explanation. And despite all the evidence, Kouri Richins doubles down and blames Eric.' He closed by telling jurors: 'See through her facade, check her ambition. Do not let her get away with murder.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 165:52 PM
VERDICT REACHED: At approximately 5:52 p.m. MDT, the Summit County jury announced it had reached a verdict after approximately three hours of deliberation. The verdict was announced at 6:20 p.m. MDT. Kouri Richins was visibly trembling and shaking before the jury entered. Her mother Lisa Darden and a handful of supporters were in the second row; Eric's family was in the fourth row. Eric's father arrived just before the verdict was read.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:20 PM
GUILTY VERDICT ON ALL FIVE COUNTS: Judge Mrazik read the verdict. Female foreperson confirmed unanimous verdict. Count 1 — aggravated murder: GUILTY. Count 2 — attempted aggravated murder: GUILTY. Counts 3 and 4 — insurance fraud (x2): GUILTY. Count 5 — forgery: GUILTY. Kouri Richins stared at the floor and took deep breaths as the verdict was read; per AP, she 'looked down and remained still.' Per East Idaho News: 'Kouri is trembling. Visibly shaking.' Some jurors appeared emotional; one man was wiping his eyes. Judge polled all eight jurors — each said 'Yes.' Relatives of Kouri Richins left the courthouse without speaking to media. Eric Richins' family embraced in the courtroom. Juror foreperson Laura (Juror No. 2) later told ABC's Good Morning America: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing.' Judge dismissed jury and thanked them for their service. A pre-sentence investigation report was ordered. Sentencing scheduled for May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. — what would have been Eric Richins' 44th birthday.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 166:50 PM
Additional courtroom atmosphere details at verdict: Trial observer Selena Armithee — who attended nearly every day of the trial as a member of the public and had become acquainted with Kouri Richins' sister during proceedings — was the only member of the general public inside the courtroom when the verdict came down. She described the atmosphere as 'extremely intense and stressful' and said she saw Kouri's shoulders visibly shaking before the jury entered. She attended almost every day of the trial, missing only two, and said she believed there was not enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt.
kutv.com
Mar 167:00 PM
Post-verdict procedural details: Judge dismissed the jury and informed them his previous instructions no longer applied — they could now speak with media and attorneys if they wished. Eric Richins' father Eugene Richins was present in the courtroom for the verdict. Kouri Richins will remain at Summit County Jail until transfer to Utah State Prison for intake following sentencing. A pre-sentence investigation report was ordered. Both sides agreed any date in May would work for sentencing; the court set May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. KPCW reported that in civil court, the Richins family is pursuing claims against Kouri under Utah's 'slayer statute,' which prohibits inheriting property from a person one has killed. It is unclear whether prosecutors will pursue the separate 26-count financial crimes case.
kpcw.org
Mar 15
KPCW reports total expected cost of Kouri Richins' murder trial is 'well into the millions.' Summit County has budgeted approximately $1.2 million for public defenders in 2026, with defense costing approximately $50,000 per month. Prosecution costs totaled $300,000 in 2025 (already paid county employees are not counted). The county avoided raising property taxes only because of a new voter-approved sales tax. Summit County is watching the Tyler Robinson case in Utah County, where county leaders asked the Utah Legislature for $2 million — noting that counties bear the full cost of high-profile trials. Defense attorneys are from the firms 'Nester Lewis' and 'Langford Ramos.'
kpcw.org
Mar 14
Judge Mrazik issued amended decorum order effective March 16, 2026: members of the general public are excluded from the courtroom during closing arguments. Two rows reserved for Kouri Richins' family and guests; two rows for Eric Richins' family and guests; one row for media livestreaming the trial. The Richins family victim representative had requested reserved seating so Eric's family would not have to 'camp out' for seating at closing arguments.
abc4.com
Mar 14
Salt Lake Tribune publishes recap article focused on the 'Walk the Dog' letter — describing it as the most controversial piece of evidence and confirming the prosecution's characterization that it illustrates Kouri's 'consciousness of guilt.' The article was published with a photo showing Kouri Richins in court on March 12, 2026 alongside the first page of the letter.
sltrib.com
Mar 131:00 PM
Post-Day 14 (Friday, March 13, 2026): Attorneys for both sides scheduled to meet with Judge Mrazik at 1 p.m. to discuss jury instructions ahead of Monday's closing arguments. No witnesses or jury presence on this date.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 13
Former Kouri Richins defense attorney Skye Lazaro publicly commented on the defense team's decision to rest without calling witnesses. Lazaro said: 'This is always a strategic decision to be made,' and 'In those cases similar to this I think the defense in this case did a really phenomenal job cross-examining the state, limiting what the state could bring in, making every argument that they possibly could.' Lazaro explained that calling witnesses could allow prosecutors to introduce new rebuttal evidence or strengthen their case, and that sometimes cross-examination alone is sufficient to raise reasonable doubt. She also said: 'It's always hard for people who are watching just to have it end this way.'
kutv.com
Mar 131:30 PM
Jury instruction conference begins at the Summit County courthouse. Judge Mrazik goes page by page through proposed jury instructions with Bloodworth, Nester, Lewis (via WebEx), and Ramos (via WebEx). Kouri Richins is present and follows along in a packet. Pages 1-14 (already read to jurors at trial start) will be included for jurors in the final packet.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 131:32 PM
Prosecutor Fred Burmester objects to the proposed 'snitch' instruction, arguing it does not apply to Carmen Lauber. Defense attorney Nester argues a federal instruction for unindicted co-conspirators would better fit the facts. Judge Mrazik says he will review it on a break. Separately, Nester requests a special instruction specifically addressing Lauber's testimony and her immunity grants.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 131:36 PM
Defense attorney Nester objects to the 'firmly convinced' language in the reasonable doubt instruction, arguing it is not strong enough to convey 'beyond a reasonable doubt.' Judge Mrazik overrules the objection.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 131:51 PM
Jury instruction conference: The motive instruction is debated. Judge Mrazik suggests removing the motive instruction entirely and not instructing jurors regarding motive. Nester approves; Bloodworth agrees. The motive instruction is removed from the final jury instructions.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 131:55 PM
Jury instruction conference: The domestic violence/cohabitation instruction is discussed. Nester argues domestic violence was not part of the trial at all and they do not want it mentioned. The instruction is removed. It is clear Eric and Kouri were cohabitating; the removed instruction covered that element.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 132:00 PM
Jury instruction conference: Parties reach the insurance fraud instruction. Judge suggests striking some language; attorneys agree. Discussion of the definition of insurance fraud and the words 'or anything of value.' Nester wants all language retained; judge suggests pulling part of it.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 132:12 PM
Jury instruction conference: Parties discuss the elements of count four (forgery). A reminder of the five charges is noted: aggravated murder, attempted aggravated murder, and two counts of insurance fraud (forgery count also pending). Discussion of wording including 'Did make, execute or utter' — Nester comments 'Utter is a weird word. Makes me think of a cow.'
eastidahonews.com
Mar 132:47 PM
Jury instruction conference: Nester argues for a specific instruction to be given regarding Detective Jeff O'Driscoll, who was present in the courtroom throughout the entire trial. Judge also discusses the 404b instruction and an in-custody informant instruction. Judge calls a break until 3:15 p.m. to consider remaining issues.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 133:40 PM
Court reconvenes after break. Judge Mrazik issues his rulings on the outstanding jury instruction issues. Jury instruction conference concludes for the day. Closing arguments remain scheduled for Monday, March 16, 2026 at 8:30 a.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 13
Additional context from KPCW live blog re: jury instruction conference: At the end of the conference, a victim representative for Eric Richins' family asked Judge Mrazik to reserve seating for both families during closing arguments. Mrazik agreed to expand seating for both sides but issued an amended decorum order effective March 16 eliminating all public seating: Kouri Richins' family gets two rows; Eric Richins' family gets two rows; media keeps one row in the back right section; the general public will not be allowed into the courtroom during closing arguments. Both families will continue to alternate who sits in front and behind each day.
kpcw.org
Mar 13
Bloodworth flagged during jury instruction conference (pages 41-42 on homicide instructions) that the state is concerned the defense will not accurately characterize intent during closing arguments. The discussion covered intent and aggravated circumstances in the homicide instruction.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 132:07 PM
Jury instruction conference additional ruling (confirmed ABC4 post-Day 14 coverage): Judge Mrazik ruled that Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier will fall under an 'informant' instruction rather than the 'snitch' instruction that defense attorney Nester had argued for. Prosecutor Burmester had objected that the snitch instruction did not apply to Lauber; Nester had argued for a federal unindicted co-conspirator instruction; Judge Mrazik ultimately resolved it as an 'informant' instruction. Separately, Nester argued the jury should receive an instruction that investigators failed to retain the empty hydrocodone bottle after it went to the medical examiner's office — Mrazik pushed back, noting the ME's office could have destroyed it; Prosecutor Burmester noted fentanyl came in envelopes, not a hydrocodone bottle.
abc4.com
Mar 12
Day 14 additional detail — Nick Bonsavage jail call (March 4, 2022): During pre-jury argument about the Norris issue, Prosecutor Bloodworth disclosed that if the defense opened the door via the Norris information, prosecutors would be permitted to introduce a jail call from March 4, 2022 in which Nick Bonsavage (Carmen Lauber's boyfriend/associate) said that Lauber had 'just made money selling fentanyl.' This call had been referenced in prior testimony but the word 'fentanyl' was replaced with 'illicit street drugs' when presented to the jury. The existence of the specific Bonsavage fentanyl statement — suppressed from the jury — adds to the evidence picture about what was excluded from testimony.
ksl.com
Mar 12
Day 14 additional detail — Orange notebook content quote confirmed (Court TV / O'Driscoll Day 13-14 testimony): The orange notebook admitted into evidence contains Kouri's firsthand account of finding Eric's body. One entry reads: 'He was cold, very cold so I pulled the blanket up on him, but his body just felt so strange to me, it was heavy is the only word I can think to describe it. He was pale/yellow, mouth open. An urge came over me that this wasn't good.' This is the first time the specific text of Kouri's journal entry about finding Eric has been publicly reported.
courttv.com
Mar 128:30 AM
Trial Day 14 (Thursday, March 12, 2026) begins. Before the jury was brought in at 10:30 a.m., pre-jury proceedings addressed two issues: (1) A photo Eric Richins had sent Kouri of the Midway mansion ('I just dropped gravel at the Midway mansion') was debated — Prosecutor Bloodworth said it needed a foundation before Nester could question O'Driscoll about a GIF sent by Eric the day before he died. (2) Defense attorney Nester raised her pre-trial motion regarding David Norris — a man who allegedly contacted the Summit County Sheriff's Office saying that in 2019 Eric Richins asked him if he had any fentanyl. Judge Mrazik had previously denied the motion on hearsay grounds (residual hearsay exception not met). Nester proposed asking O'Driscoll four questions about whether he investigated the tip; Bloodworth objected as a transparent attempt to circumvent the ruling. Mrazik initially sided with prosecutors, but after a break, returned with a 2009 Ogden murder case that indicated O'Driscoll could be questioned about Norris' claims — but warned: if the Norris information came in, suppressed prosecution evidence would need to come in too, including statements from Hayden Jeffs about Kouri asking for fentanyl and a Nick Bonsavage jail call from March 4, 2022, in which Bonsavage said Carmen Lauber had 'just made money selling fentanyl.' Judge told the defense: 'This is high-stakes poker.' Defense conferred with Kouri for 30 minutes and ultimately declined to pursue the Norris line of questioning through O'Driscoll.
kpcw.org
Mar 1210:37 AM
Trial Day 14 — Det. Jeff O'Driscoll cross-examination (continued, Day 14): Nester admitted an extraction report showing the three money-themed GIFs were accessed at 8:29 a.m. on March 4, 2022. A photo of a property (the Legacy House/Midway mansion) was also accessed at that time. A second report showed two more GIFs accessed at 10:43 a.m. on March 4 — a set of GIFs not previously identified in trial coverage. O'Driscoll confirmed he viewed both sets of GIFs during the investigation. O'Driscoll confirmed the Kevin Spacey 'Idiots. Idiots everywhere' GIF is from the TV show 'House of Cards.' O'Driscoll also verified that on the morning of Eric's death, someone using Kouri's phone viewed photos Eric had sent her the day before (March 3), indicating other messages were accessed around the same time the money GIFs were viewed — a detail defense used to suggest the phone activity was routine rather than celebratory. Nester established: (1) no fentanyl was found on any tested item in the home; (2) the investigation has lasted four years, with search warrants issued as recently as last month; (3) O'Driscoll could not track Eric's phone movements in Mexico; (4) investigators found a bag of loose hydrocodone pills in the mudroom cabinet that were tested and did not contain fentanyl. When Nester asked 'In all of that, we have no murder weapon, like you haven't found anything that was connected to Eric's death, no fentanyl, correct?' O'Driscoll replied: 'There was a boatload of fentanyl in his stomach that came out of the house with him.' Additional cross-examination: O'Driscoll confirmed Eric was treated for seasonal allergies (trees, grass); EpiPens were found in the Richins' refrigerator; Eric mentioned going to the hospital on Valentine's Day but O'Driscoll was unsure if he actually did. O'Driscoll also acknowledged no testimony was presented about whether Eric gave Kouri permission to sign his name on documents, though he noted that is not required under the forgery statute. Regarding Kouri's orange notebook, Nester noted one entry read 'Kouri starts counseling' — O'Driscoll said investigators obtained Kouri's medical records but did not recall whether mental health records were included.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1211:25 AM
Trial Day 14 — O'Driscoll redirect examination (Bloodworth): Bloodworth asked O'Driscoll what happened to the empty hydrocodone bottle found at the scene; O'Driscoll confirmed it was collected. Bloodworth asked if detectives ever gave Carmen Lauber a ride anywhere other than to court — O'Driscoll said no. Bloodworth confirmed the Kevin Spacey GIF is from the show 'House of Cards.' No further questions. O'Driscoll was released from the stand. Bloodworth then announced the state rests its case at approximately 11:33 a.m. The prosecution called a total of 42 individual witnesses over 2.5 weeks of testimony.
kpcw.org
Mar 1211:33 AM
Trial Day 14 — Defense Rule 17 motion for directed verdict (acquittal): After the state rested, defense attorney Alexander Ramos filed a Rule 17 motion arguing prosecutors failed to prove each of the five counts against Kouri. Ramos argued: (1) the state provided scant evidence that Kouri knowingly purchased fentanyl or was the person to administer it to Eric; (2) there was conflicting testimony between Lauber (who said Kouri asked for and approved fentanyl) and Crozier (who testified he didn't sell fentanyl in early 2022); (3) prosecutors had not proved Kouri signed Eric's name on insurance documents without his knowledge or permission. On the insurance fraud/forgery counts specifically, Judge Mrazik asked Bloodworth to address 'lack of believable evidence regarding intent to defraud.' Bloodworth responded this refers to the $100,000 TruStage life insurance policy — arguing nothing on the application indicates Eric was aware, everything routes back to Kouri's address, and at the time of the forgery she intended to defraud. Judge Mrazik denied the motion, ruling: 'The court is not free to weigh the evidence and thus invade the province of the jury, whose prerogative it is to judge the facts.' Mrazik said if there is any evidence of guilt, 'however slight,' he must submit the case to the jury.
parkrecord.com
Mar 121:00 PM
Trial Day 14 — DEFENSE RESTS WITHOUT CALLING ANY WITNESSES; KOURI RICHINS WAIVES RIGHT TO TESTIFY: After a roughly 90-minute lunch recess in which defense attorneys conferred with Kouri Richins, attorney Wendy Lewis returned to court and announced: 'After consulting with our client, the defense rests.' Kouri Richins formally waived her right to testify. The state announced it will not present a rebuttal case. The defense had previously indicated it planned to call approximately three witnesses; the decision not to call any witnesses was described as surprising. Ali Staking — Kouri's childhood friend — is the only defense witness technically called during trial, as she testified during the state's case due to travel difficulties; no witness was called during the defense's case-in-chief. The jury was dismissed and instructed not to return until Monday, March 16, 2026. Judge Mrazik told the jury they would receive instructions on Monday. Attorneys were scheduled to have a conference call at 4 p.m. regarding jury instructions and a 1 p.m. meeting at the courthouse on Friday, March 13, to discuss jury instructions. Closing arguments for both sides are scheduled for Monday, March 16, 2026.
kpcw.org
Mar 128:30 AM
Additional Norris detail confirmed: Prosecutor Bloodworth disclosed to Judge Mrazik that David Norris called the Summit County Sheriff's Office AFTER Judge Mrazik had already ruled his testimony would be hearsay and not admissible, and that when deputies interviewed Norris he stated he was calling because defense counsel told him he should call. Bloodworth said he did not find Norris credible. Judge Mrazik initially compared the situation to 'a crank from New Jersey' calling the sheriff's office. This supplements the existing Day 14 Norris record.
kpcw.org
Mar 1211:00 AM
Court TV reporting clarifies the Norris 'high-stakes poker' ruling: the State countered that any testimony elicited from O'Driscoll about David Norris's statements would open the door not only to the Nick Bonsavage jail call (Lauber 'making money from the sale of fentanyl') but also to previously suppressed statements by deceased handyman Hayden Jeffs — in which Jeffs told investigators that Kouri Richins had allegedly asked him for fentanyl. This supplements the existing Day 14 Norris record, which had not previously specified that Jeffs' suppressed statements were also at stake.
courttv.com
Mar 1212:30 PM
Court TV reporting (published March 13) confirms that before the lunch break on Day 14, defense lawyers told the court they had 'several witnesses ready to testify' — but after conferring with Kouri Richins during the roughly 90-minute lunch recess, they declined to call any of them. This confirms the defense had a witness list available but made an active choice to rest without calling anyone.
courttv.com
Mar 121:00 PM
Park Record coverage of Day 14 confirms that when Kouri Richins formally waived her right to testify and Judge Mrazik asked her directly whether she waived, it was the first time she addressed the court during her three-week trial. This is a distinct procedural detail not captured in the existing Day 14 record.
parkrecord.com
Mar 118:30 AM
Trial Day 13 (Wednesday, March 11, 2026) begins. Court opened at 8:30 a.m. for attorneys and judge to address remaining legal issues. Jury scheduled to arrive at 1 p.m. Det. Jeff O'Driscoll — the prosecution's final witness — is confirmed to testify today. O'Driscoll is expected to testify about jail calls Kouri Richins made to family members and other aspects of the investigation, including the Walk the Dog letter. The defense has its own witnesses and case to present after O'Driscoll concludes.
kpcw.org
Mar 118:30 AM
Trial Day 13 — Additional context established by KPCW post-Day 11 reporting: Deputy Jayme Woody testified that the investigation into Eric Richins' death had 'all but stalled' by the fall of 2022, approximately six months after his death. The investigation accelerated near the end of 2022 based on information provided by PI Todd Gabler. Additionally, Gabler has been recovering from a procedure fusing vertebrae in his neck during his trial testimony. A 2008 KSL report indicates Gabler has employed tracking devices before, including placing one on the then-Salt Lake County district attorney's family car.
kpcw.org
Mar 118:30 AM
Trial Day 13 pre-jury proceedings: Judge Mrazik DENIED the second mistrial motion (filed Day 9, March 4) — the motion based on Carmen Lauber's drug court violation and undisclosed Det. Mainord texts. As part of his ruling, Mrazik ordered prosecutors to recall Lauber to the stand at 1 p.m. for additional defense cross-examination specifically about the November 2023 drug court violation. The alleged violation: Lauber was 'observed holding an alcoholic drink,' per Mrazik.
kpcw.org
Mar 111:00 PM
Trial Day 13: Jury returned at 1 p.m. Carmen Lauber was recalled to the stand for defense cross-examination by Wendy Lewis about her November 2023 drug court violation. Lauber testified she had gone to a concert with a friend and agreed to buy food and drinks instead of being paid back. She confirmed a probation officer saw her holding a drink at the concert, but said she did not drink. However, when told the probation officer stated she was drinking, Lauber said: 'If the officer said that, then it is true.' Lauber then left the stand.
fox13now.com
Mar 111:30 PM
Trial Day 13: Det. Jeff O'Driscoll — the state's final witness — took the stand for his full testimony. O'Driscoll testified he became lead investigator in March 2023 and wanted to approach the case fresh, starting as if it were the first day. He identified three possible manners of Eric's death: accidental overdose, intentional overdose, or homicide. He testified he was led to Carmen Lauber through phone billing records showing a high volume of contact between Lauber and Kouri; the investigation stalled but phone records comparison revealed numerous missing messages between Kouri and Lauber. O'Driscoll confirmed Eric Richins was not prescribed any fentanyl medication.
parkrecord.com
Mar 111:45 PM
Trial Day 13 — O'Driscoll testimony: Items found during April 2023 search of Carmen Lauber's home presented to jury — drug paraphernalia, a firearm she was not permitted to possess due to her criminal history, THC products, a hat from Eric Richins' business (C&E Stone Masonry), and Eric Richins' obituary pasted in the center of a mirror in Lauber's bedroom, surrounded by inspirational quotes and photos of loved ones. O'Driscoll testified: 'It seems like she had all of these inspirational quotes that helped motivate her through her progression in drug court. And amongst them were photos of her loved ones, her family, and then amongst all of that was Eric Richins' obituary.' O'Driscoll and Det. Eric Mainord then interviewed Lauber six times over the next month, totaling approximately 10 hours.
kpcw.org
Mar 112:00 PM
Trial Day 13 — O'Driscoll testimony: Lauber interview video clips (approximately 100 pages of the ~1,000-page transcript) were played for the jury. In one clip, Lauber said Eric 'didn't deserve that,' though she also said she did not know if what was done was intentional. Another clip showed O'Driscoll telling Lauber they needed details that 'ensure Kouri gets convicted of murder.' When asked about this statement on the stand, O'Driscoll testified it was 'a poor choice of words in hindsight' — that they were requesting details needed for the courtroom and emphasizing the seriousness of the case, and that the information needed to be truthful and detailed without guesses or speculation. O'Driscoll also testified that Lauber tended to minimize her involvement and hold back out of self-preservation, and that her recollection improved as she was shown phone records and maps.
fox13now.com
Mar 112:30 PM
Trial Day 13 — O'Driscoll testimony: Text messages between Eric and Kouri Richins discussing THC gummy use were admitted and published for the jury. Prosecutors then presented evidence of Kouri's April 2023 appearance on 'Good Things Utah' to promote her children's book 'Are You With Me?' — including emails Kouri sent to the show's executive producer requesting to be on the program. O'Driscoll confirmed he watched the appearance. Following the TV appearance evidence, O'Driscoll testified that investigators found evidence on Kouri's cell phone indicating a ghostwriter — specifically the company 'Book Writing Lane' — wrote the book for her. Text messages showed Kouri told friends and family she paid $2,500 for the company to put the book together. Kouri also texted her brother (identified in KPCW live blog as 'DJ Khouri') that she wanted to hire a ghostwriter to write a larger manuscript — 130 pages for $5,000 or up to 250 pages for approximately $10,000 — and noted she would need to change names and take precautions to avoid a defamation lawsuit. She did not state the subject of the larger manuscript.
parkrecord.com
Mar 112:45 PM
Trial Day 13 — O'Driscoll testimony: In March 2023, the Summit County Sheriff's Office received an anonymous Amazon package containing a copy of Kouri Richins' children's book 'Are You With Me?' with a handwritten note reading: 'There are two sides to every story. This is the true Kouri, a devoted wife and adoring mother. Thought you should know. From Anonymous.' O'Driscoll testified that law enforcement subpoenaed Amazon and determined the book was sent by Kouri Richins' mother, Lisa Darden. The Amazon account the package was sent from was registered to Lisa Darden.
ksl.com
Mar 113:00 PM
Trial Day 13 — O'Driscoll testimony: The orange notebook — collected from Kouri's side of the nightstand during the May 8, 2023 search — was admitted into evidence and published for the jury. The notebook contained a journal entry in which Kouri described finding Eric's body and the aftermath of his death. Another page showed a timeline of events following Eric's death, written from Kouri's perspective, including her interactions with Eric's family and learning about the private investigator investigating her.
abc4.com
Mar 113:15 PM
Trial Day 13 — O'Driscoll testimony: Phone calls and text messages between Kouri Richins and her mother Lisa Darden were played in court. In one call, Kouri and Lisa discussed the allegation that Kouri had poisoned a sandwich. Kouri said: 'They are nuts,' characterizing the claim as a lie. Additionally, a text from Kouri to her brother (dated May 24, 2023) was shown, in which Kouri asked her brother if Eric had ever talked about suicide. Her brother responded that he had not.
ksl.com
Mar 113:30 PM
Trial Day 13 — O'Driscoll testimony: The 'Walk the Dog!!' letter was presented to the jury by O'Driscoll, who read the six-page letter aloud in court after a few redactions. The letter, previously framed for the jury as found in Richins' 'personal belongings,' was read in full. O'Driscoll noted the letter instructs Kouri's brother Ronnie to say Eric always wanted Kouri to take the blame if caught and would put his drugs in her bag; that Eric kept his drugs in his work truck but Cody emptied the truck a week after his death; and that Ronnie would have messages from Eric on his phone about Eric getting high. On cross-examination, defense attorney Nester asked O'Driscoll if the letter was ever delivered to Kouri's mother or any family member; O'Driscoll replied 'not to my knowledge.' O'Driscoll also confirmed he never obtained a warrant for Ronnie Darden's phone, and that at least one person he spoke to confirmed knowledge of at least one fight in which Eric put drugs in Kouri's bag before a trip.
abc4.com
Mar 113:45 PM
Trial Day 13 — O'Driscoll cross-examination (Nester): During cross-examination, defense attorney Kathy Nester pressed O'Driscoll on the investigation's limits. O'Driscoll acknowledged: (1) he did not know how the fentanyl got into Eric Richins' system, only that it was orally ingested; (2) he did not know exactly when Eric Richins died; (3) investigators never tested any of the pills that passed from Lauber to Kouri Richins. O'Driscoll also confirmed a Google search from Eric Richins' phone — made shortly before his death — was for the distance of a drive from Utah to Sonora, Mexico. O'Driscoll testified he believed Eric had gone hunting in that area of Mexico. Cross-examination of O'Driscoll was not completed on Day 13; he will return to the stand Thursday (Day 14).
ksl.com
Mar 115:00 PM
Trial Day 13 concludes. Det. Jeff O'Driscoll's cross-examination was not completed; he will return to the stand on Day 14 (Thursday, March 12, 2026). After O'Driscoll's testimony concludes, the state is expected to rest. Defense attorney Kathy Nester indicated she needs to confer with Kouri Richins to make 'some decisions' before the defense presents its case. Defense is expected to motion for acquittal after the state rests. Sources indicate the defense plans to call only approximately three witnesses in its case — significantly fewer than the 35 originally identified.
kmyu.tv
Mar 108:31 AM
Trial Day 12 begins. Before the jury arrived (scheduled for 9:30 a.m.), Judge Mrazik addressed multiple pre-testimony legal issues. Defense attorney Kathryn Nester referenced a transcript of an interview Det. O'Driscoll conducted with Kouri Richins and sought to have several redacted pages admitted into evidence. Prosecutor Bloodworth opposed, arguing the interview was 'peppered with Kouri's self-serving statements.' Judge ruled that information from the interview can come out during trial through questioning, but the interview itself will not be admitted as a whole exhibit. Some portions were unredacted at defense request following further argument.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 109:07 AM
Day 12 pre-jury arguments continued: Prosecution and defense debated which jailhouse calls and text messages should be admitted into trial. Among the messages discussed: one stating Kouri 'thought she would be set for life if he died.' Defense objected to that message; Judge Mrazik ruled it is allowed in. Defense attorney Nester also objected to all jail calls and requested special jury instructions; Judge Mrazik said he would provide them.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 109:19 AM
Day 12: The 'Walk the Dog' letter was discussed by attorneys and Judge Mrazik before the jury arrived. Prosecutor Bloodworth said he could envision the defense arguing the six-page letter was part of a fictional 65-page manuscript and that the context should be understood within a larger volume. Bloodworth stated: 'That is untrue and we can prove that by proving how it was recovered.' Bloodworth proposed his exact wording for how Det. O'Driscoll would introduce the letter.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 109:49 AM
Day 12: Prosecution sought to introduce Carmen Lauber's prior statements to Det. O'Driscoll through O'Driscoll's testimony. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis adamantly objected, arguing the statements should have been addressed when Lauber was on the stand and that the defense would have no ability to cross-examine Lauber on those statements if introduced through O'Driscoll. Judge Mrazik noted Lauber could be recalled by the defense for questioning. Bloodworth stated the prosecution had reached out to Lauber's attorney but had not yet heard back.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1010:29 AM
Day 12: Extended argument over whether Carmen Lauber interview transcripts (approximately 1,000 pages / 7.5 hours of video) should go back to the jury room or be published in open court. Prosecution wanted only narrowly-tailored clips shown; defense responded 'If those 100 pages are going to be published, we want all 1,000 pages published.' Lewis argued publishing all 7.5 hours for the jury to watch would be appropriate given her position that Lauber was unduly influenced by law enforcement. Bloodworth argued: 'The notion of publishing nearly 10 hours of interviews is not productive and a waste of the jury's time.' Lewis also objected to transcripts going to the jury room because jurors could review them repeatedly, unlike live testimony.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1010:50 AM
Day 12: Judge Mrazik ruled that the prosecution can publish specific portions of Lauber's interview statements for the witness on the stand, but the entire transcript should not go to the jury room to avoid undue influence on deliberations. Defense requested a two-day continuance; judge denied it. Defense then requested a one-day continuance; after further argument, Judge granted the one-day continuance on the transcript issue. He told Lewis he needed time to read the material and the state needed time to respond, and indicated he needed time for a video editor to prepare clips for admission. Lewis said she did not believe defense could have their brief ready by 6 p.m. that evening.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1011:12 AM
Day 12: After resolving pre-jury legal arguments, Judge Mrazik told attorneys only one witness would be called and then court would be in recess until the following morning. Jury was brought in at approximately 11:15 a.m. Prosecutor Lindsay Chervenak recalled digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos — the Cellebrite cell phone expert who had previously testified on Day 7 — for brief additional examination. Chervenak asked Kotrodimos about time stamps on text messages from February 14, 2022. Kotrodimos testified the time stamps are provided in UTC; Utah is -7 UTC in standard time and -6 UTC in daylight saving time, with adjustments made in the software to show local time. Defense attorney Alexander Ramos had no questions. Kotrodimos stepped down.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1011:22 AM
Day 12 ends early. Judge Mrazik dismissed jurors for the day and instructed them they do not need to return until 1 p.m. on March 11 (Day 13). Court itself will still begin at 8:30 a.m. on March 11 for attorneys and the judge to address remaining legal issues before the jury arrives. Det. Jeff O'Driscoll — the state's announced final witness — did not take the stand on Day 12.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 1011:00 AM
Trial Day 12 — Court TV ruling clarification on Lauber prior consistent statements: After a short break in pre-jury proceedings, Judge Mrazik ruled against the defense's objection that Lauber's prior statements could only be admitted through Lauber herself, finding no legal authority that would bar a prior consistent statement from being admitted by anyone other than the original witness. This clears the path for Det. O'Driscoll to introduce Lauber interview statements during his testimony. The prosecution also confirmed it had narrowed its request to approximately 100 pages of the transcript (from ~1,000 pages total) and offered to create a video of only those portions to show jurors.
courttv.com
Mar 1011:00 AM
Trial Day 12 — Walk the Dog letter jury presentation framing resolved: In pre-jury proceedings, Prosecutor Bloodworth and the court resolved how O'Driscoll will introduce the Walk the Dog letter to the jury. Because the jury is not supposed to know Richins has been in jail, the state proposed that O'Driscoll testify the letter was recovered from a book found in Richins' personal belongings — without specifying that it was found in her jail cell. This was accepted as the framing for admission.
fox13now.com
Mar 9
Distractify article (published March 9, 2026) confirms that Kouri Richins' three sons — Carter, Ashton, and Weston — are believed to be in the care of one of Eric's sisters (Katie Richins-Benson or Amy Richins) based on Eric's obituary. The article notes it is unlikely a court would place the children with Kouri's mother Lisa Darden given her history as a person of interest in a 2006 suspicious overdose death.
distractify.com
Mar 98:24 AM
Trial Day 11 (Week 3, Day 1) begins. Before jury entered, Judge Mrazik discussed pending jail calls prosecutors want to admit (defense objected). Defense's second mistrial motion (Lauber drug court violation + undisclosed Mainord texts) is pending — Mrazik directed prosecution to file a written response by the following morning. Prosecutor Bloodworth confirmed Det. Jeff O'Driscoll will likely be the state's last witness. Celebration of Life video (with minors' faces blurred) admitted as evidence at the start of session.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 99:10 AM
Trial Day 11: Cody Wright — Eric Richins' business partner and co-founder of C&E Masonry — takes the stand as the first witness. Wright testified about his close friendship with Eric, their 50/50 business partnership since 2010, and Eric's character. In early 2022, C&E employed around 90 people and had 47 active projects. Wright said Eric was motivated to keep growing the company. Wright confirmed he received a call from Eric on Valentine's Day 2022 and described 'fear in his voice and a sense of urgency' — the only other times he heard Eric like that were when Eric's mother died and when Eric was in a serious car accident. Prosecution confirmed that when Eric died, Cody paid the $2 million buy/sell insurance proceeds to the family trust per court instruction.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 99:35 AM
Trial Day 11 — Cody Wright cross-examination (Nester): Wright confirmed Eric went to Mexico in February 2022 for hunting (because Eric couldn't hunt in the U.S. for a while due to wildlife violations). Wright confirmed he and Eric had a falling out because Cody reported Eric's hunting violation to law enforcement — Eric went to jail over the incident involving not having an elk tag; Eric was upset with Cody but the relationship was repaired. Wright confirmed Eric told him he had gone with his son to get an allergy shot on Valentine's Day. Wright also confirmed that Eric and Cody had lunch together at Mirror Lake Cafe on March 3, 2022 — the day before Eric died. Wright said he never saw Eric use over-the-counter, prescription, or illicit drugs, though he acknowledged Eric used THC gummies and admitted Eric shared some personal things as a close friend. Defense attempted to impeach Wright over statements at the preliminary hearing regarding Eric's drug use — Judge Mrazik ruled nothing impeachable had occurred and denied a defense motion to strike all of Wright's testimony.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 910:40 AM
Trial Day 11 — Cody Wright voir dire (jury excused): Outside the jury's presence, defense attorney Nester questioned Wright about 'Red Devils' — pain pills Eric allegedly used in high school. Wright said he was told Eric used them in high school but believed they were Sudafed; he had no knowledge of Eric using illicit drugs after high school. Nester argued she could impeach Wright based on his preliminary hearing testimony vs. trial testimony regarding Eric's drug use; Judge Mrazik disagreed, ruling Wright had not changed his testimony. Wright was released from his subpoena after returning to the stand in front of the jury, with Nester confirming Cody had no idea where Eric got THC gummies.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 911:10 AM
Trial Day 11: Matt Throckmorton — handwriting expert, 30-year forensic document examiner, former Salt Lake City Police crime scene technician of 27 years — testifies for the prosecution. Throckmorton testified he reviewed 86 signatures and 24 sets of initials from Eric Richins, obtained from canceled checks, driver's licenses, tax documents, a trust, a will, and other documents. He was originally hired by the trust attorneys for $900 and is now working for Summit County. After comparing signatures on a questioned insurance document to known samples, Throckmorton concluded: 'There was no evidence that Eric authored the signature and he probably did not. It appeared to be a simulated forgery written by somebody who had access to his writing in an attempt to copy, draw or duplicate his signature.' He could not absolutely eliminate that Eric signed it because he was working from a photocopy, not the original. He also could not identify who wrote the questioned signature. His conclusion was sent to a woman in Colorado for verification. Prosecutor Fred Burmester handled the direct examination.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 912:01 PM
Trial Day 11 — Throckmorton cross-examination (Nester): Defense attorney Nester established that Throckmorton is not certified by national handwriting examiner organizations (he acknowledged 'you pay to become certified'). Nester referenced a national report raising concerns about handwriting analysis conclusions and an error rate of 4 per 100 cases. Nester also elicited that Throckmorton had been subjected to an internal affairs investigation at SLCPD for allegedly falsifying documents — he said he was cleared and 'falsely accused.' Throckmorton acknowledged he cannot say Kouri signed the document, has no personal knowledge Eric gave her permission to sign it, and was working from a PDF copy rather than an original. Throckmorton testified he has testified in court 48 times for forensic handwriting cases.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 91:37 PM
Trial Day 11 (afternoon): The full 911 call recording was played for the jury. In the call, Kouri is heard crying, saying Eric is cold and she doesn't know what happened — 'I was sleeping in with my kids and I just came in our bed and he's cold.' The dispatcher instructed Kouri to attempt CPR; Kouri said Eric was too heavy to move to the floor. A man's voice (likely a first responder or family member) is heard in the background saying 'ambulance is en route' and 'We're in the back bedroom.' The dispatcher counted through CPR compressions with Kouri.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 92:00 PM
Trial Day 11: Detective Jayme Woody — Summit County Sheriff's Office detective and current K9 officer who was the original lead detective in the Eric Richins death investigation — testifies. Woody testified she arrived at the Richins home on March 4, 2022, and was met in the driveway by Amy Richins. Outside the jury's presence, Woody disclosed that Amy told her Eric had said 'Kouri was going to kill him'; in a second conversation, Amy told Woody that Kouri was erratic when drinking, that Eric and Kouri had been fighting a lot, and that Eric said Kouri had threatened to kill him. Woody told Kouri on April 13, 2022 (the day of the search warrant execution) that Eric died of a fentanyl overdose — and that Kouri was upset and detained for approximately 10 minutes. Woody also disclosed that when she asked Kouri her housekeeper's name on March 4, Kouri said she couldn't remember it. Woody confirmed the kitchen garbage cans were empty on March 4 — Kouri said the housekeeper emptied them. Woody began working with a K9 in March 2023; Det. Jeff O'Driscoll then took over as lead detective.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 93:00 PM
Trial Day 11: Todd Gabler — private investigator hired by Eric's family (paid for by Clint and Katie Benson) — testifies as a prosecution witness. Gabler has been a private investigator for 34 years and worked on approximately 100 homicide cases, all previously for the defense. He was hired by the Bensons in April 2022. He analyzed cell phone billing records for Kouri and Eric (obtained from C&E Masonry, which paid the phone bills), finding hundreds of texts between Kouri and Carmen Lauber between January and May 2022 — with only Kouri's mother and Eric having more contact with Kouri than Lauber. Gabler placed GPS tracking devices on Kouri's car, her mother's car, and her brother's car, turning that data over to law enforcement. He also emailed Detective Woody saying 'now would be a really good time to interview Carmen Lauber because she's on the ropes in drug court.' He gave two hard drives to the county attorney's office and met with law enforcement 5-6 times. He first searched the Richins home on May 8, 2023 — the day it was released by the Summit County Sheriff's Office (the same day as Kouri's arrest). He searched for 4-5 days initially, conducting approximately 40-50 interviews overall. He also tracked Carmen Lauber's vehicle and removed the device when he learned it wasn't Carmen driving.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 93:44 PM
Trial Day 11 — Gabler cross-examination (Nester): Defense attorney Nester aggressively cross-examined Gabler, establishing: (1) Gabler removed a safe from the master closet at Clint Benson's request, had it opened with a rubber mallet by a locksmith, and returned it — without law enforcement present; (2) Gabler searched the home on video for hours alone; (3) Gabler found a letter on Eric's side of the bed (described as the 'babycakes letter' from Eric to Kouri) on May 10, 2023, did not consider it relevant, and put it away — but by August 9, 2024, photographed it on the bed; (4) Gabler put a GPS on Kouri's car; (5) Gabler told Woody to interview Lauber while she was 'on the ropes in drug court.' Nester also established that when Gabler called Kouri on January 19, 2023, he stopped the call and contacted her attorney instead. Gabler said even if police told him to stop searching, he would not: 'Police never get anything. Ever. That's true in every case I've ever handled.' Prosecution on redirect confirmed all evidence was removed by the sheriff's office, not Gabler.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 94:40 PM
Trial Day 11 concludes. Court recessed; jury instructed to return at 9:30 a.m. on March 10 (Day 12) because judge and attorneys have legal matters to address at 8:30 a.m. first. State is confirmed to be near resting its case with only a few more witnesses remaining.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 98:30 AM
Trial Day 11 — Celebration of Life video shown BEFORE Cody Wright testified: Fox 13 confirms the Celebration of Life video (showing Kouri celebrating with friends on the day after Eric died) was played for the jury before Cody Wright took the stand — making it the first item presented to the jury on Day 11. Previously the existing record noted it was 'admitted as evidence on Day 11' and played, but the timing relative to witnesses was not specified.
fox13now.com
Mar 99:10 AM
Trial Day 11 — Additional Cody Wright testimony details: Wright told the jury he was informed in January 2022 that the beneficiary on his life insurance policy had been changed — and that he had never observed Eric making those changes himself (consistent with prosecution's theory that Kouri made them). Wright also said he was told Eric used THC edibles and 'popped pills' in high school, but under voir dire said 'Red Devils' referred in his mind to pseudoephedrine (Sudafed) and said 'I don't know what illicit street drugs entail; I know he used some form of drugs; I don't know what they are exactly.' Nester argued this entitled her to show the jury prior inconsistent testimony — Mrazik ruled it was inadmissible hearsay and there was nothing impeachable.
kpcw.org
Mar 910:40 AM
Trial Day 11 — 'Red Devils' evidence ruling: After the defense voir dire of Cody Wright outside the jury's presence, Judge Mrazik ruled that Wright's testimony about Eric's alleged 'Red Devils' high school drug use was inadmissible hearsay. Mrazik then asked the prosecution whether they wanted to proceed with the Red Devils testimony anyway — to insulate the jury's verdict from a likely appeal. Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth conferred with his team and they declined. As a result, evidence regarding Eric Richins' alleged high school drug use will stay out of the trial entirely. The existing record noted only that Mrazik found nothing impeachable and denied motions to strike; this ruling on the Red Devils evidence as a whole is new.
kpcw.org
Mar 92:00 PM
Trial Day 11 — Detective Jayme Woody cross-examination conclusion: Defense attorney Kathy Nester asked Woody whether she had ever asked Kouri how long she was in the bed with Eric before realizing he was cold. Woody said Kouri told her it was 'almost immediately.' Kouri also told Woody that Eric was 'healthy.' Nester had nothing further and told Woody to 'enjoy the dog.' Woody was dismissed from the stand.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 93:00 PM
Trial Day 11 — Additional Todd Gabler testimony details: Gabler confirmed he has spent 936.3 hours on the case. He stated he attempted to interview Kouri's family members about Eric's death, but they refused to speak with him. He also stated: 'Any item that I considered to be evidence was removed by the Sheriff's Office, not me' — pushing back on the defense's implication that he tampered with evidence. He confirmed he filmed with a GoPro the entire time he was in the Richins home, except for one brief instance when he used his cell phone. Nester estimated the Richins family paid Gabler roughly $100,000 for his work.
thenationaldesk.com
Mar 93:44 PM
Trial Day 11 — Additional Gabler cross-examination details (ABC4, Day 11 coverage): Defense attorney Nester showed Gabler a text in which Eric Richins told his best friend Bryce Knudsen that he and Kouri were 'starting an open relationship, so I'm taking you home tonight.' Gabler said he thought that was a joke and did not consider it sexting. On redirect, Gabler confirmed he saw no indication Eric was having an affair with Bryce Knudsen, and he never saw any indication Eric was using illegal drugs. Separately, Gabler testified he was first contacted by Katie Richins-Benson in March 2022 (not April 2022 as originally reported), and he understood he was hired in connection with a civil trust lawsuit — not specifically the criminal investigation. He testified he kept recording devices running during all 45 interviews, with no exceptions, and wrote summaries afterward. He also testified that he removed items belonging to the Richins' sons at the request of CPS, and some personal documents belonging to Katie Richins-Benson. For any items he considered evidence, he contacted the Sheriff's Office, and they came to remove them after obtaining a warrant.
abc4.com
Mar 94:00 PM
Trial Day 11 — Additional Gabler testimony detail: The letter Gabler found in Eric's side of the bed in May 2023 — referred to in existing records as the 'babycakes letter' — is identified by ABC4 as the 'my princess' letter. Gabler testified he found it in May 2023 and initially did not consider it relevant; he later photographed it in August 2024. ABC4's Day 11 coverage also confirmed Gabler created a clone of Eric's phone based on an Apple iCloud backup, giving him access to Eric's text messages. Gabler testified all requests for information he made to the Sheriff's Office were denied, but he continued his investigation nonetheless.
abc4.com
Mar 6
Post-Day 10 Park Record reporting (March 6, 2026) confirmed that the defense has stated its core position at trial: the defense does not contest the timeline of events on the night of March 3–4, 2022, but maintains Kouri did not give Eric fentanyl. Defense attorneys told the court it is 'unknown what happened during the six hours from when Kouri last saw Eric alive to when she found him dead' or how he ingested five times the fatal dose of fentanyl. The defense also confirmed it plans to call its own witnesses and may recall some prosecution witnesses when presenting its case.
parkrecord.com
Mar 6
Post-Day 10 (Park Record, March 6, 2026): Additional detail on Chelsea Barney's financial victimization by Kouri Richins. Barney — who worked as a restaurant manager and saved tip money — wired Kouri $45,000 in two separate wires as a down payment for a home Kouri was flipping. She then paid $2,900 per month in mortgage payments. The deed was never properly recorded with the county. When Kouri was arrested, an unauthorized loan had been taken out on the property without Barney's knowledge. Barney was ultimately evicted in September 2024 when the home was transferred to cover Kouri's debts. Previously in the record only as 'evicted from home Kouri allegedly gave to a lender'; this confirms the $45,000 down payment detail and September 2024 eviction date.
parkrecord.com
Mar 6
Post-Day 10 (Park Record, March 6, 2026): The Celebration of Life held at the Richins home the night after Eric died was described by prosecutors as 'more party-like than grief-stricken.' Prosecutors planned to play a video of the event for the jury with minors' faces blurred. Attendees included Ali Staking, Chelsea Barney, Bryce Knudsen, and Amy Richins (per the photo Lewis admitted into evidence on Day 10). This supplements existing record entries about the Celebration of Life atmosphere.
parkrecord.com
Mar 6
Post-Day 10 (CNN, March 8, 2026): Additional Grossman cross-examination detail not previously captured. When defense attorney Wendy Lewis asked Grossman whether — now looking back — his conversation with Kouri in the Uinta Mountains about killing seemed strange, Grossman's more complete response (per CNN) was that after the private investigator told him Kouri had killed Eric, he was 'blown away' and started 'looking at everything in our past with a different set of goggles on, through different lenses' and was trying to figure out if she did it. This supplements the Day 9 Grossman cross-examination entry.
cnn.com
Mar 6
Post-Day 10 (Allison Wright additional cross-examination detail, from EastIdaho Day 7 live blog): During defense cross-examination of Allison Wright, it emerged that Cody Wright (her husband and Eric's business partner) and Eric Richins had a temporary falling out because Cody's husband had provided information to law enforcement about a hunting violation that Eric may have committed. Nester used this to suggest the Wrights had complicated loyalty dynamics with the Richins family. Wright also confirmed she remained close with Kouri and her family after Eric's death, and that her husband accompanied Kouri to court hearings. This detail was in the Day 7 live blog but not captured in the existing case record.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 58:00 AM
Trial Day 10 scheduling disclosure: During a scheduling discussion at the start of Day 10, Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth announced that the state's last witness will likely be lead detective Jeff O'Driscoll, who he expects to call late Monday (March 9) or early Tuesday (March 10). Cody Wright — Eric's business partner — was identified as among the witnesses expected to testify during the week of March 9.
kpcw.org
Mar 58:30 AM
Trial Day 10 (Thursday, March 5, 2026): Court began with testimony from Marie Bramwell, a domestic relations attorney at Gordon Law Group. Bramwell testified she met with Kouri Richins in person on May 3, 2021 — one meeting only — and that they subsequently exchanged emails (Bramwell emailed Kouri five times; Kouri emailed Bramwell four times) from May 2021 through January 2022. A check from Gordon Law Group paid to Kouri was presented to the court. The defense stressed on cross-examination that Bramwell's practice covers more than just divorce. Bramwell was released from her subpoena. Bramwell was identified as the 34th witness to testify at trial.
abc4.com
Mar 59:00 AM
Trial Day 10: Prosecutors played a redacted jail phone call between Kouri Richins and her brother Ronnie Darden for the jury. Defense attorney Lewis initially objected to playing the call without a live witness; she and Prosecutor Chervenak exited the courtroom to discuss, and the parties agreed certain parts would be redacted. In the played segments, Kouri asks: 'Why is that so bad?' — apparently referring to consulting an attorney — and Ronnie Darden says they might be trying to hold something against her. Kouri says 'Eric did it first' and 'anything she did, Eric did as well, so they cancel each other out.' She expressed being 'annoyed' multiple times and referenced asking someone else to testify. Judge Mrazik instructed jurors they could consider Kouri's statements for any purpose but could only consider other speakers' statements for their effect on Kouri.
abc4.com
Mar 510:30 AM
Trial Day 10: Becky Lloyd — estimator at C&E Stone Masonry and neighbor/friend of Kouri Richins since approximately 2017 — testified for the prosecution. Lloyd testified about a December 17, 2021 conversation in which Kouri told her, while wrapping gifts, that she felt trapped in the marriage and 'in many ways it would be better if Eric was dead.' Lloyd said Kouri was serious, not joking, and was frustrated and struggling. On cross-examination (Nester), an audio recording of Lloyd's interview with a prosecution investigator was played, in which Lloyd said she was 'not confident enough' to make that statement under oath — and was '90% sure she said the comment about him being better dead.' Lloyd acknowledged on the stand that in a first interview she did not recall the statement; she remembered it in a second interview two years later, after speaking with Katie Richins-Benson. Nester established that Kouri had helped Lloyd get her job and was on the C&E payroll until after Eric died. Lloyd was NOT released from her subpoena.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 511:30 AM
Trial Day 10: Gabriel Morin, owner of Mirror Lake Diner in Kamas, testified about a receipt from February 14, 2022 — Valentine's Day — showing a phone order placed under the name 'Corey' at 8:55 a.m. for a Greek omelet and a bagel sandwich, picked up at 9:07 a.m. Prosecutors allege this is the meal Kouri purchased and laced with fentanyl before leaving it in Eric's truck. Defense attorney Nester asked several questions about how orders are packaged. Morin was released from the stand.
abc4.com
Mar 51:00 PM
Trial Day 10 (afternoon): Joshua Kaze — a friend of Eric Richins since 2014, who also worked with him and played recreational sports and hunted with him — testified about a phone call he received from Eric on Valentine's Day 2022. Kaze said Eric seemed uncharacteristically 'somber' and 'sincere' during that call — the same day prosecutors allege Kouri attempted to poison Eric with the breakfast sandwich from Mirror Lake Diner. Per court rules, Kaze was not permitted to repeat Eric's hearsay statements to the jury. Separately, Chelsea Barney — a friend of Kouri's for approximately 20 years who spoke with Kouri 'all of the time' — also testified. Barney recounted that on March 6, 2022 (two days after Eric died), she was at the Richins home and observed Kouri upset because of an argument with her sister-in-law, and trying to get into Eric's safe to find the will — a locksmith was called to open the safe but was stopped. Kouri was described as having 'pure frustration and rage' and was 'shaking' and crying because she couldn't get into the safe. Barney also testified that she purchased a home from Kouri in 2023 but learned the paperwork was never filed; she was later evicted after Kouri allegedly gave the deed to a lender. A recorded three-way phone call between Kouri, Barney, and Bryce Knudsen was played for the jury.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 52:30 PM
Trial Day 10 (late afternoon): Ali (Allie) Staking — Kouri Richins' childhood best friend since junior high — testified as the final witness of the day. Staking and Kouri attended a 'Finding True Self' retreat together in Sedona, Arizona in February 2021, at which both received an assignment to write their life story in the third person. Prosecutors attempted to admit Kouri's 'life story' document into evidence through Staking; after a sidebar, the judge denied its entry as Staking could not confirm the writing was Kouri's. Staking testified about Valentine's Day 2022: after Eric fell ill, the group of friends discussed it as a funny story about an 'allergic reaction,' with friends joking 'Don't eat what Kouri gives you' — and Eric joking along. On cross-examination (Lewis), Staking said she learned of Eric's death from a friend who called her and flew to Utah on March 5. She testified nothing about Kouri's behavior struck her as unusual; an informal Celebration of Life was held at the Richins home the night after Eric died, with alcohol, people talking about memories of Eric, and dancing. Staking also testified that Kouri tried to get into Eric's safe — Kouri 'couldn't believe' all that was happening. Lewis also elicited that on a 2018 Hawaii trip with the Richins family, Eric had secretly put THC gummies in Kouri's suitcase, which made Kouri upset. Staking confirmed THC gummies in the social circle came from one particular person, and she herself had used them with the Richins on prior occasions but not on that Hawaii trip. Court recessed for the weekend at approximately 4:26 p.m., to resume Monday, March 9 at 8:30 a.m.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 58:30 AM
Additional Day 10 detail re: Marie Bramwell testimony (Court TV March 6 coverage): Kouri Richins paid a $5,000 retainer to domestic relations attorney Marie Bramwell (Gordon Law Group) when she consulted her in May 2021. She did not ultimately file for divorce and the bulk of the $5,000 retainer was refunded. This detail was not disclosed in Day 10 real-time coverage but emerged in post-day summaries.
courttv.com
Mar 59:00 AM
Clarification to Kouri-Darden jail call (TownLift March 6 coverage): Kouri's statement 'He did it first' in the recorded jail call with brother Ronnie Darden refers specifically to Eric's meetings with a divorce attorney in October 2020 — Kouri was arguing that Eric's decision to consult a divorce attorney preceded her own meetings with a domestic relations attorney, and that 'anything she did, Eric did as well, so they cancel each other out.' This context was confirmed in TownLift's post-Day 10 report.
townlift.com
Mar 511:30 AM
Additional Day 10 detail from Becky Lloyd redirect examination (EastIdaho/TownLift, March 6 coverage): After defense cross-examination challenged Lloyd's credibility, prosecutors re-examined her. Lloyd told the jury she had previously shared the account of Kouri's 'better if Eric was dead' statement with several friends before testifying, and remained confident Richins had made the remark. Lloyd stated: 'No one has supplied my testimony to me. I know that it happened. I know she said that.' Lloyd added it was 'a very difficult position to be on the stand saying things like this' and 'I don't want to be here.' Defense attorney Nester indicated she wants to recall Lloyd as a witness.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 51:30 PM
Additional Day 10 detail from Chelsea Barney testimony (TownLift/EastIdaho, March 6 coverage): Prosecutors displayed text messages between Kouri Richins and Chelsea Barney. In one message, Kouri wrote: 'If I die, Eric did it.' In additional messages sent after Eric's death in March 2022, Kouri wrote: 'They will not take from me what is mine.' These messages were presented by the prosecution as evidence of Kouri's state of mind and her anticipation of conflict over the estate. Barney also testified that Kouri told her she had to be 'top notch careful' and had taken $250,000 from the house, while worrying Eric might hire a private investigator. Kouri told Barney her investments would pay out within a couple of months.
townlift.com
Mar 53:00 PM
CORRECTION AND UPDATE — Kouri Richins' 'life story' from the Sedona 'Finding True Self' retreat (February 2021) was ultimately admitted into evidence on Day 10, contrary to the existing record that initially indicated it was denied. Prior to trial, Judge Mrazik ruled the document was relevant to how Kouri felt about her marriage and allowed prosecutors to prepare a redacted version; on Day 10, the defense then requested that the jury see the entire (unredacted) journal entry. KPCW's live blog and post-day article confirm 'Prosecutors introduced as evidence a life story Kouri Richins wrote in the third person.' The existing record captured ABC4's live report noting denial through witness Ali Staking; the ultimate admission appears to have occurred through a different evidentiary path. The content revealed: Kouri was born in Oklahoma in 1990, moved to 17 different states; her father went to prison when she was 6 (drunk driving, hit an officer); parents divorced; she and her mother moved to Utah in 2000; her mother is 'a compulsive gambler'; she 'instantly fell for the idea of a marriage with kids and a happy family, a stable family' when she met Eric; she got pregnant sophomore year; she tried to 'chase happiness' through marriage, more kids, and graduate school; her life 'spiraled' after 2018 when she discovered Eric was having an 'emotional affair'; she went to counseling for anxiety and depression; she said Eric 'emotionally exhausted her.'
kpcw.org
Mar 54:00 PM
THIRD MISTRIAL MOTION (previously undisclosed): At a sidebar on Day 10 (March 5, 2026), defense attorney Wendy Lewis filed a third motion for a mistrial after Kouri Richins referred to 'charges' in a recorded phone call that was entered into evidence. Defense attorney Lewis disclosed the existence and withdrawal of this third motion on the morning of Day 11 (March 9), stating that Kouri Richins had now withdrawn it. This is separate from the previously-recorded second mistrial motion (Lauber drug court violation + undisclosed Mainord texts), which remains pending. The motion count now stands at: (1) First mistrial motion — denied March 2 (Gipson 'jail calls'); (2) Second mistrial motion — still pending (Lauber drug court violation + Mainord texts); (3) Third mistrial motion — withdrawn by defense before ruling.
kpcw.org
Mar 49:30 AM
Trial Day 9 (Wednesday, March 4, 2026 — the fourth anniversary of Eric Richins' death): Day started one hour later than usual; Judge Mrazik told jurors: 'I appreciate your patience with my calendar.' The prosecution identified three additional prosecutors at the table: Brad Bloodworth, Lindsay Chervenak, and Fred Burmester. First witness: Lashawnda Rodgers, platinum senior advisor with New York Life Insurance Company. Rodgers testified that on June 2, 2022, she received a call from insurance agent Brian Freckleton about beneficiary changes on Cody Wright's policy. Investigation showed that on January 1, 2022, the beneficiary on the Wright buy/sell policy was changed from Eric Richins to Kouri Richins — and then changed back. All beneficiary changes were made using Eric Richins' login but through Kouri Richins' email address. On cross-examination, defense attorney Ramos established that although Kouri's email was associated with the login activity, this does not definitively mean Kouri herself was behind the screen — and that no actual permanent policy changes were ultimately made.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 410:00 AM
Trial Day 9 — Brian Freckleton (insurance agent) testimony: Freckleton testified he put together the buy/sell life insurance policies for Eric Richins and Cody Wright. He confirmed each partner owned a $2 million policy on the other; in the event of one partner's death, the survivor would receive $2 million tax-free and would be required to buy the deceased's business interest from the estate or trust. In January 2022, Freckleton received an alert that a beneficiary change had been attempted on the Wright policy — changing it from Eric Richins to Kouri Richins. Freckleton was not released from his subpoena at end of testimony.
abc4.com
Mar 410:30 AM
Trial Day 9 — Anne Coates (CMFG Life Insurance Company) testimony: Coates testified that Kouri Richins had called CMFG Life Insurance Company 'numerous times' asking about payments from life insurance policies after Eric's death. Coates was released from her subpoena following brief testimony.
kutv.com
Mar 411:00 AM
Trial Day 9 — SECOND MISTRIAL MOTION (Lauber drug court violation + undisclosed detective texts): Just before noon, defense attorney Wendy Lewis told Judge Mrazik that defense counsel Kathy Nester had received a text from state officials that morning disclosing that star witness Carmen Lauber had violated drug court rules regarding an alcoholic beverage after she began cooperating with investigators. The defense also received text messages between Lauber and Summit County Detective Eric Mainord that had been requested prior to Lauber's trial testimony but not provided. Lewis argued both constituted Giglio material that should have been disclosed earlier and moved for a mistrial. Judge Mrazik said the motion needed to be submitted in writing so prosecutors could respond formally: 'We're not going to do this on oral representations in the moment.' Prosecutor Bloodworth said he was unaware of the detective text messages but stated that information about the drug court violation had been provided to defense three weeks before trial began.
kutv.com
Mar 411:30 AM
Trial Day 9 — Defense misconduct allegation rejected: Between witnesses, defense attorney Kathy Nester told Judge Mrazik she had received reports from viewers watching the trial online claiming that prosecutors were 'making faces' toward the jury during cross-examination. Judge Mrazik replied: 'I have a better view of this than any of the cameras. I haven't seen anything like that. The only faces I've seen are counsel at me, and so I think we're well within the proper bounds of appropriate conduct.'
fox13now.com
Mar 412:00 PM
Trial Day 9 — Christina Miller (divorce attorney) testimony: Miller, a divorce attorney referred to Eric Richins by Clint Benson, testified she met with Eric in late October 2020 for approximately two and a half hours after Benson told her the meeting was 'urgent.' Eric discussed what a divorce would entail and how to protect his finances and children. She also provided custody advice but noted the custody discussion was unusually brief. After the meeting, she gave Eric a 'to-do' list — something she would only give to someone intending to proceed with a divorce. On cross-examination, defense attorney Miller acknowledged that Eric asked her not to contact him directly and said everything should go through his brother-in-law.
abc4.com
Mar 41:00 PM
Trial Day 9 — Kristal Bowman-Carter (estate planning attorney) testimony: Bowman-Carter testified that Eric Richins came to her with concerns about his sons being cared for if anything happened to him. She confirmed Eric did not want to communicate through email because he was worried Kouri would read them. Eric told her he wanted to leave everything to his children and chose his sister as trustee — something Bowman-Carter described as 'unusual for someone who was married' not to choose their spouse. She also confirmed Katie Richins-Benson was named Eric's power of attorney. On the day Eric died, a sheriff's deputy called Katie and asked her to speak with Kouri to explain the estate plan. On cross-examination by Nester, Bowman-Carter acknowledged Eric told her he knew Kouri had made mistakes with his power of attorney (the $250,000 HELOC), but said: 'She's the mother of my children, I know she's made mistakes and she needs more experience.'
fox13now.com
Mar 42:00 PM
Trial Day 9 — Robert Josh Grossman testimony (direct examination): Grossman — Kouri's alleged boyfriend at the time of Eric's death — took the stand in the afternoon, becoming emotional as private text messages were displayed for the courtroom. He made an odd statement when being sworn in; the jury was briefly excused while the judge re-explained the oath and swore him in. Grossman testified he met Kouri in South Carolina approximately a decade ago when he responded to a help-wanted ad for a house-flipping project. He eventually moved to Utah in 2020, living in houses Kouri was flipping; she would occasionally pay him. Their romantic relationship started around the time he moved to Utah. He confirmed he loved her; when asked if she loved him, he hesitated but agreed she did, though 'he probably loved her more.' He testified he described himself in texts as 'head over heels' for her and that it was 'draining to love' her.
abc4.com
Mar 42:30 PM
Trial Day 9 — Grossman testimony — key text message exchanges shown to jury: Prosecutors displayed multiple text exchanges between Kouri and Grossman. A December 2021 message from Kouri read: 'I really enjoy my relationship and love for you... but you're right... we both know this love triangle can't go on forever. You don't deserve it, I don't deserve you. I can't expect you to sit around for the day the trigger gets pulled.' On January 9, 2022, Kouri asked Grossman whether he had done drugs besides marijuana and how recently. On February 19, 2022, Kouri wrote: 'I want you today, every day.' A text from Kouri read: 'I am in love with a man that's not my husband.' Kouri also told Grossman she grew up scrubbing toilets for rich people in Park City and told herself she would one day own those homes. A text from Grossman to Kouri on the evening before Eric died (March 3, 2022) expressed excitement about an upcoming celebration with champagne, balloons, and confetti. Kouri eventually texted back: 'I'm not mad at you, at all. Just haven't had a second to text... give me a few... love you.' They did not text again until the morning of March 4, when Grossman checked in and Kouri informed him: 'Eric passed away' and 'talk later.' She later told him they thought it was an aneurysm. Prosecutors also showed a text from around April 8, 2022, in which Kouri told Grossman she wanted him to be her husband one day.
deseret.com
Mar 43:00 PM
Trial Day 9 — Grossman testimony — Uinta Mountains conversation detail (confirmed): Grossman testified about driving into the Uinta Mountains with Kouri approximately 10–14 days after Eric's death. They spoke for hours on many topics including the Richins children and bowhunting. At some point, Kouri asked Grossman if he had ever killed anyone while serving in the Iraq War, and how it had made him feel. Grossman testified the question was 'not surprising' because she was 'exhausted emotionally' and it may have been a way to switch the conversation to him. He stated that at the time of that conversation, he did not for a moment think Eric was killed, let alone that Kouri was involved: 'Never for a moment did I have a clue, a hint, not a fleeting thought that something intentionally might have happened to him, let alone from her.' The two continued dating for months but things changed; they broke up around the end of 2022 or beginning of 2023. When Grossman later learned Kouri had been arrested, he felt overwhelmed with guilt and sorrow and reached out to Eric's sister Katie, whose husband connected him with the family's private investigator. The investigator indicated he thought Kouri was guilty, which caused Grossman to re-examine past conversations.
parkrecord.com
Mar 44:00 PM
Trial Day 9 — Grossman cross-examination (Wendy Lewis) and release: On cross-examination by defense attorney Wendy Lewis, Grossman confirmed that Kouri seemed to change and appear 'sad' or 'grieving' after Eric's death. He also confirmed it was his first time seeing Kouri since the day they broke up. Lewis elicited that Grossman had no impression from Kouri's texts or conversations before Eric's death that Eric would 'be out of the picture by Friday.' Grossman was released from the stand at 4:37 p.m. Court recessed until 9:30 a.m. the next day (March 5).
kpcw.org
Mar 38:30 AM
Trial Day 8 (Tuesday, March 3, 2026): Forensic accountant Brooke Karrington is the sole witness for the entire day. Prosecutors walk jurors through Kouri Richins' bank accounts, loans, tax filings, and real estate transactions from 2019–2022. Karrington testified that K. Richins Realty was registered April 26, 2019 — originally in Eric's name, changed to Kouri four days later — and that K. Richins Realty and Kouri Richins are 'alter egos.' Karrington said the company's funding shifted from Kouri's own cash, to lenders, to investors over time. Karrington also testified that Kouri's aunt Doreen Kouri — who owned 81% of K. Richins Realty — could not be seen providing any of the cash the business needed.
parkrecord.com
Mar 39:00 AM
Trial Day 8 — Karrington financial testimony detail: By October 2021 — five months before Eric died — Kouri's accounts were perpetually negative. In December 2021 alone, she had 77 overdraft/NSF transactions ($91,000 in bounced transactions; $2,000 in fees). Between January 2021 and March 2022, she bounced 236 checks totaling $360,000+ and incurred $5,600 in overdraft fees. By March 2022, Kouri owed approximately $7.5 million in debt and was paying approximately $80,000 per month to lenders. She had four payday lenders she had committed to pay $2,100 toward each day. 'Kouri Richins was in financial distress, and her financial enterprise was collapsing,' Karrington testified. 'Her debts and liabilities outweighed her assets. Even if she sold everything, it would not be enough to get to zero.' Karrington billed the state at least $200,000 for her review.
deseret.com
Mar 310:00 AM
Trial Day 8 — Midway mansion financial detail (Karrington): Karrington testified that Kouri's only real estate purchase in 2022 was the $2.9 million Midway mansion, which Kouri was required to close on by March 4, 2022 — the day Eric died. Kouri borrowed $3.2 million (including a $2.6 million loan from Sierra-West Capital) to close on the $2.9 million home, walking away with only $87,000 at closing. The home was worth $2.9 million on the day it closed. Karrington said Kouri did not have the $3 million needed for renovations. Kouri listed the mansion for sale on March 12, 2022 — one week after acquiring it. Seven or eight offers were made, all fell through; the property eventually went into foreclosure. By the time it foreclosed, Kouri owed $3.8 million on it alone. Defense cross-examination (Nester) raised that the final property Kouri sold went for $3.4 million — more than the purchase price — without rehabbing, and noted that a safe in the home's garage contained a large amount of cash (including possibly $10,000 in a backpack) not accounted for in Karrington's analysis.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 32:00 PM
Trial Day 8 — Life insurance payout detail (Karrington): Karrington testified that Eric had approximately $2.2 million in life insurance policies (separate from the $2 million buy/sell policy with Cody Wright). Kouri received approximately $1.35–1.4 million of that amount following Eric's death; she spent the entire amount within three months. By September 2022, she had approximately $800 left in her accounts after spending the insurance money. Karrington also noted that after closing on the Midway mansion, Kouri's net worth was negative $1.6 million. After 1.5 hours of cross-examination by defense attorney Kathy Nester, Karrington was released from her subpoena.
abc4.com
Mar 28:30 AM
Trial Day 7 (Week 2, Day 1): Court opens with a false start — defense objected that it had not been able to consult with the state's first witness beforehand, violating court rules. Court recessed to allow defense attorney Alexander Ramos to consult with the witness. Attorneys also discussed additional evidence to be presented during the week, including the May 2023 Crozier interview that Chief Prosecutor Bloodworth said rebuts Crozier's trial testimony. Cross-examination of Chris Kotrodimos by defense attorney Alexander Ramos was ongoing as of the end of the day, at which point Judge Mrazik excused the jury, attorneys, and spectators.
kpcw.org
Mar 29:00 AM
Trial Day 7: Lead detective Jeff O'Driscoll briefly took the stand for the first time at trial to testify about the chain of custody of cell phones the state sought to admit into evidence, then stepped down. He has been present in the courtroom for the entire trial.
kpcw.org
Mar 29:30 AM
Trial Day 7: Digital forensics expert Chris Kotrodimos testified for the prosecution about cell phone data and records he reviewed. He showed jurors a map of phone movement data corroborating that Carmen Lauber and Robert Crozier's phones traveled toward and away from the Maverik gas station in Draper on three specific dates: Feb. 11, Feb. 26, and March 9, 2022 — the same dates Lauber testified she made drug purchases. Each time, Kouri Richins' phone was in frequent contact with Lauber's phone. Kotrodimos also testified that Kouri communicated daily with Josh Grossman beginning in November 2021, that she was traveling to Grossman on Valentine's Day 2022 (texting him 'I love you Wanna be one of my valentines'), and that on that same day Eric texted Kouri he was going to lie down and might need to go to the hospital.
ksl.com
Mar 210:00 AM
Trial Day 7: Kotrodimos testified about Kouri Richins' phone deletion activity. Her white iPhone seized April 13, 2022 had many items deleted from early 2022 through mid-March 2022. A replacement phone she subsequently obtained showed fewer deletions. Jurors were shown multiple searches from the replacement phone related to remotely deleting iCloud data or a phone not in one's possession, what police and the FBI do with electronics, prisons, white collar crimes, 'luxury prisons for the rich,' whether life insurance companies pay when a death certificate is still pending, and Kouri Richins' own net worth.
ksl.com
Mar 211:00 AM
Trial Day 7: Dr. Erik Christensen, former chief medical examiner for Utah, testified. Prosecutors played a recorded phone call in which Kouri Richins called the Utah Office of the Medical Examiner and asked about a report showing additional testing on Eric's stomach contents — the same questions prosecutors asked Christensen at trial. In the call, when Kouri asked how much fentanyl was found, Christensen told her 'people die with half that or less in the system.' Kouri also asked about quetiapine (pronouncing it multiple different ways), which was found in Eric's system but was prescribed to Kouri. Christensen also testified he asked Kouri during the call whether her husband appeared to be abusing fentanyl prior to his death; she said no.
ksl.com
Mar 212:00 PM
Trial Day 7: Molly Crosswhite, a real estate professional, testified she purchased a small Midway home from Kouri Richins in January 2022 — prosecutors allege this is the same property where Kouri and Carmen Lauber used as a dead drop for drug money and pills. Crosswhite confirmed she had not changed the locks on the home, that a key was left outside the property, and that her tenants did not move in until the end of March 2022. A juror issue arose: defense attorney Wendy Lewis asked the judge to dismiss a juror who disclosed during Crosswhite's testimony that they had previously done a business transaction with her (apparently recognizing her under a different former name). Judge Mrazik took the matter under advisement, saying he would consider legal standards and precedent before ruling.
kpcw.org
Mar 21:00 PM
Trial Day 7: Allison Wright (wife of Eric's business partner Cody Wright) testified about a February 2019 conversation in Costa Rica with Kouri Richins, in which Kouri said she felt 'trapped' in the marriage — unable to leave easily because she would receive no money under the prenuptial agreement. Defense attorney Kathy Nester cross-examined Wright about whether Eric had an alleged affair around 2019; Wright acknowledged Eric may have had intimate feelings for a female coworker, which Nester framed as a reason for Kouri's marital difficulties.
ksl.com
Mar 21:30 PM
Trial Day 7: Prosecutors played the body camera video of the May 4, 2023 interview with Robert Crozier in which he told investigators he sold Carmen Lauber fentanyl pills and that 'she knew what she was buying.' Judge Mrazik instructed jurors they could only consider Crozier's side of the conversation — not investigators' questions or statements — when rendering a verdict. This video was specifically highlighted by Chief Prosecutor Bloodworth as rebutting Crozier's Day 5 trial testimony that he sold oxycodone.
kpcw.org
Mar 22:00 PM
Trial Day 7: Judge Mrazik formally elaborated on the Week 1 mistrial motion — confirming it was filed by the defense in response to lead crime scene technician Chelsea Gipson's brief comment asking if attorney Nester was referring to 'jail calls' when asking about phone calls between Kouri and her family. Mrazik said the comment was 'improper' but 'relatively innocuous,' 'in passing,' and 'inadvertent,' and that his instruction to the jury to disregard whether Kouri was in custody was sufficient to avoid a mistrial.
ksl.com
Mar 2
A juror sent a written note to Judge Mrazik on March 2 disclosing they recognized prosecution witness Molly Crosswhite. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis moved to excuse the juror, arguing that had this prior business relationship been known during jury selection, the juror would have been removed. Prosecution opposed dismissal, seeing no sufficient basis. Mrazik declined to rule immediately; additional discussion — including potential questioning of the juror — was expected. It remains unclear whether the juror is a primary juror or alternate.
kpcw.org
Mar 29:30 AM
Additional Day 7 Kotrodimos testimony detail: The 'Idiots. Idiots everywhere' animated GIF accessed on Kouri's phone the morning of Eric's death features actor Kevin Spacey — not simply 'a man' as previously reported. All three GIFs (including the Donald Trump 'I'm really rich' GIF and the woman wiping eyes with money) were accessed as part of a text message thread; Kotrodimos testified 'the source of these images was deleted from the phone — it no longer exists,' describing them as 'ghost' or 'orphaned' images. It is not clear who sent or received the message containing the GIFs.
kpcw.org
Mar 29:30 AM
Additional Day 7 Kotrodimos testimony: Granular phone activity data around Eric's death — Kouri's phone last moved 35 feet on the night of March 3, 2022, and then went inactive. Eric's phone received an unread work text before also going inactive. At 3:06 a.m. on March 4, Kouri's phone was unlocked; 14 seconds later the speaker was activated; at 3:08 a.m. the phone moved 243 feet. It was then unlocked several more times before Kouri called 911 at 3:21 a.m. Prosecutors may use this data to challenge Kouri's account that she was asleep in her son's room before finding Eric unresponsive.
kpcw.org
Mar 210:00 AM
Additional Day 7 Kotrodimos cross-examination detail: Defense attorney Alexander Ramos raised Jen Shah — a former cast member of Bravo's Real Housewives of Salt Lake City who was facing federal charges in April 2022 and changed her plea to guilty in July 2022 — as a possible innocent explanation for Kouri's internet search for 'luxury prisons for the rich in America.' Ramos asked Kotrodimos if he was aware of Shah's case around that time frame. Kotrodimos also acknowledged under cross that cell phone location data shows what a phone was doing and where it was, but cannot confirm who was holding the phone at any given time.
kpcw.org
Feb 288:30 AM
Trial Day 6 (Saturday session): Multiple witnesses testify in a special Saturday court session. Carmen Lauber does not return to the stand. Witnesses testify about how Kouri Richins could have obtained drugs. Robert Crozier's testimony from Day 5 is confirmed final — he met Lauber once or twice (not three times as Lauber stated) at the Maverik in Draper, and said he knew his pills were not fentanyl because 'everybody was scared of fentanyl' in early 2022 — it was hard to get and people were dying from it. Anna Isbell's full testimony clarified: she overheard the Jan. 22, 2022 call and heard Kouri ask for the 'Michael Jackson drug,' which Isbell thought was a muscle relaxer — she did NOT hear Kouri ask for fentanyl. Isbell was 'livid' when a detective told her she would need to appear every day of the trial after she declined to be prepped for her testimony.
ksl.com
Feb 278:30 AM
Trial Day 5: Carmen Lauber retakes the stand for continued defense cross-examination by Wendy Lewis. Lewis presents transcripts from seven jail interviews (April-May 2023), highlighting inconsistencies including: changing number of drug purchases reported, differing accounts of where pills were left, and whether Kouri ever specifically asked for fentanyl. Prosecutors attempt to rehabilitate Lauber's credibility. Audio recordings played of phone calls between Lauber and Nick Von Savage. Judge rules some transcript portions inadmissible wholesale due to hearsay issues.
eastidahonews.com
Feb 2711:11 AM
Trial Day 5 (afternoon): Carmen Lauber's cross-examination concludes. Under questioning by Wendy Lewis, Lauber admitted: Kouri never specifically asked her for fentanyl; she has no direct knowledge of what killed Eric Richins; she initially told investigators she made only three drug purchases (not four); and she did not know what type of pills she received from Crozier. Prosecutor Bloodworth conducted redirect, noting Lauber had been sober since her 2023 arrest and that her memory improved as she got clean. Lauber stepped down, with attorneys noting she may be recalled.
parkrecord.com
Feb 2712:37 PM
Trial Day 5: Anna Isbell — longtime girlfriend of deceased handyman Hayden Jeffs — testifies briefly. She was with Jeffs on Jan. 22, 2022 when Kouri called and asked if he had 'something for a client.' Jeffs declined. Defense attorneys pointed to a text exchange in which a detective allegedly threatened Isbell with a warrant and a 'catch pole' for her dog during the investigation — used to support the defense's witness intimidation narrative.
kutv.com
Feb 271:37 PM
Trial Day 5: Robert Crozier takes the stand for the first time, testifying under a grant of immunity. He testifies that he sold Carmen Lauber 'M30s' and 'blues,' which he understood in early 2022 to be oxycodone — not fentanyl. He says he met Lauber at a Maverik in Draper and those were the only times they met. He does not remember much of his 2023 interview with the Summit County Sheriff's Office because he was in Davis County Jail detoxing. When asked whether Lauber requested blues or fentanyl, he says he does not remember the conversation. Defense attorney Wendy Lewis begins cross-examination. Trial concludes Week 1.
kpcw.org
Feb 272:55 PM
Trial Day 5 (late afternoon): Sgt. Eric Haskell of the Salt Lake City Police Department testifies about street-level drug dealing. Judge Mrazik orders Court TV to stop recording and transmitting during Haskell's testimony, indicating he is an undercover officer. Cameras remain off until he concludes.
eastidahonews.com
Feb 273:49 PM
Trial Day 5 (late afternoon): Marcos Garaycochea of the Salt Lake County District Attorney's Special Investigations Unit testifies. He was asked by the Summit County Sheriff's Office to perform phone downloads on four iPhones. Testifies he uses a forensic machine to retrieve data that cannot be modified or deleted after extraction. One phone required a screen replacement before data could be extracted.
abc4.com
Feb 274:00 PM
Trial Day 5 conclusion: After court recessed just after 4 p.m., Judge Mrazik briefly disclosed that a mistrial motion was filed at some point during Week 1 — it is unclear who filed it — and that he denied it. He indicated he may elaborate on the motion and his ruling the following week. Court to resume Monday at 8:30 a.m.
kpcw.org
Feb 27
During Day 5, the jury sent Judge Mrazik a written note expressing concern about a person sitting in the gallery who was drawing them. This prompted action; the spectator was removed. Previously recorded only as 'a spectator was removed for sketching jurors' — the jury-note mechanism is now confirmed.
kpcw.org
Feb 268:30 AM
Trial Day 4: Continued cross-examination of Chelsea Gipson. Dr. Brianna Peterson (forensic toxicologist) testifies fentanyl was 15 nanograms/mL — five times lethal dose. Acetylfentanyl indicates illicit source. Detective Frank Root testifies about collecting phones from Robert Josh Grossman. Bryan Holden (Utah State Crime Lab) tested 19 items — no fentanyl found on any. Carmen Lauber takes the stand in the afternoon, testifying she bought drugs for Kouri four times. Defense cross-examination begins. Spectator removed for sketching jurors and identifying them by number.
eastidahonews.com
Feb 26
Additional Day 4 Lauber testimony detail: Carmen Lauber testified that after each of her drug purchases for Kouri Richins, she deleted the text messages between herself and her source so as not to create evidence that she violated drug court rules. In one instance, Lauber had been sanctioned to community service after being late to a court-ordered group therapy session — and Kouri wrote her a letter falsely claiming she had volunteered at a horse rescue cleaning stalls, which was submitted to drug court.
parkrecord.com
Feb 26
Additional Day 4 detail: During Carmen Lauber's testimony, investigators' statements about Susan Kohler were disclosed — detectives told Lauber they needed to talk with Kohler and warned that Kohler could be charged with murder if her pills led to someone's death. This was revealed during cross-examination by defense attorney Lewis.
eastidahonews.com
Feb 268:30 AM
Day 4 Gipson testimony additional detail: CSI technician Chelsea Gipson confirmed that investigators retrieved a hard drive from Cody Wright, Eric Richins' business partner in C&E Stone Masonry. Gipson did not personally retrieve it — other investigators brought it to her. A green jacket was also found in the southeast corner of a closet with gummies in a pocket (separate from the black Under Armour jacket collected November 2024).
eastidahonews.com
Feb 26
Additional Day 4 detail on pressure applied to Carmen Lauber: ABC4 reported that after Lauber's initial arrest, investigators returned with a DEA agent and told her she could face federal prison if the fentanyl she provided had led to Eric Richins' death. Lauber confirmed she then told investigators about obtaining drugs for Kouri Richins.
abc4.com
Feb 26
Additional Day 4 detail — Gipson cross-examination: Defense attorney Nester established that on the night of March 4, 2022, CSI technician Chelsea Gipson did not enter, photograph, or collect evidence from the kitchen or the basement of the Richins home. Gipson acknowledged she had no search warrant or probable cause on that initial visit and agreed with Nester's suggestion that the Richins family stored liquor in the basement.
courttv.com
Feb 258:30 AM
Trial Day 3: Defense cross-examination of Chelsea Gipson begins at 8:40 a.m. but is halted after one hour when Judge Mrazik calls a recess for a scheduling conflict. Court dismissed early for the day citing 'unforeseen emergency circumstances unrelated to the case.' Defense highlights empty hydrocodone bottle never tested for fentanyl.
parkrecord.com
Feb 25
Defense attorneys request a mistrial during a private sidebar with Judge Mrazik and prosecutors — triggered by CSI technician Chelsea Gipson's reference to 'jail calls' during cross-examination. Defense attorney Kathy Nester argued the comment prejudiced the jury against Richins and implicated her Sixth Amendment right to a fair trial. Mrazik did not rule immediately; he formally denied the mistrial motion on March 2, ruling the comment was improper but inadvertent and made in passing.
kpcw.org
Feb 248:30 AM
Trial Day 2: Law enforcement and first responders testify. Dr. Pamela Ulmer (medical examiner) describes autopsy findings — fentanyl at five times lethal dose, no natural cause of death, manner listed as 'undetermined.' EMT Margaret Offret testifies Eric's body was at the foot of the bed, lying unusually straight and cold. Chelsea Gipson (CSI technician) begins testimony.
parkrecord.com
Feb 24
Additional Day 2 detail: A K9 officer testified he never found THC gummies at the Richins home despite his drug-detection training during a search. However, packs of THC gummies were subsequently recovered from the home in a later search — stored in places out of reach of children, per defense attorney Nester's framing.
courttv.com
Feb 248:30 AM
Day 2 additional detail: During cross-examination of Katie Richins-Benson, defense attorney Nester elicited that Eric had previously been prescribed hydrocodone, occasionally used THC, drank alcohol socially, and took testosterone. Katie also acknowledged that Kouri sued to challenge the trust after Eric's death. Separately, a U.S. Postal Service agent was among law enforcement involved in the May 8, 2023 search of the Richins home, investigating whether drugs or drug paraphernalia could have been mailed to the residence.
newsnationnow.com
Feb 248:30 AM
Additional Day 2 bodycam detail: Body camera footage from Deputy Nguyen showed Kouri Richins standing with her hands on either side of her head in the doorway to the master bathroom, watching as emergency responders attempted to revive Eric. Defense attorney Ramos cross-examined Nguyen on the death investigation checklist — noting he did not enter the kitchen (where the prosecution alleges the Moscow mule was made) even though it might have contained evidence. Nguyen acknowledged the home was 'semi-secured' while he was there.
parkrecord.com
Feb 24
Additional Day 2 bodycam detail: In Deputy Nguyen's body camera footage played for the jury, Kouri Richins told Nguyen that Eric had mentioned 'chest pain' before bed. She also stated: 'He was active, he didn't just die in his sleep, this is insane.' She said that although she was sleeping in another room with their son, she would have heard any yell and that Eric had not made a sound.
ksltv.com
Feb 24
Additional Day 2 defense cross-examination detail: Defense attorneys pressed first responders about areas the body cameras didn't capture. They asked whether responders had looked on top of a medicine cabinet, checked trash cans in other areas of the home, or tested 'white specks' visible on Eric Richins' nightstand. Dr. Ulmer testified she tested for bacterial, fungal, and tuberculosis infections — finding nothing else that would have contributed to Eric's lung problems.
ksltv.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Trial Day 1: Opening statements. Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth accuses Kouri of murdering Eric for his money and to start a new life with her boyfriend. Defense attorney Kathy Nester plays the 911 call and argues the evidence is circumstantial. First witnesses: Gene Richins (father), Katie Richins-Benson (sister), Clint Benson (brother-in-law), Deputy Vincent Nguyen. Body camera footage from March 4, 2022 shown to jury. Members of public lined up from 4 a.m.
parkrecord.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Defense opening statement additional details (Day 1): Attorney Kathy Nester did not deny Kouri sought drugs, but argued she purchased oxycodone at Eric's request — not fentanyl. Nester argued Eric had recently returned from a trip to Mexico and suffered from chronic back and knee pain and Lyme disease, implying he could have obtained fentanyl himself. 'Guess where the fentanyl comes into this country from — Mexico,' Nester told jurors. Defense also told jurors a close friend of Eric would testify the couple were 'the happiest together he'd ever seen them' in the weeks before Eric died. Defense did not contest that Kouri signed a $100,000 life insurance policy. Prosecution opening statement additional detail: Kouri had booked an all-inclusive Caribbean trip for herself and Grossman to check in one month after Eric died; and she asked Grossman, days after Eric's death, 'How did that make you feel?' after he mentioned having killed someone.
abcnews.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Jury composition established on Day 1: The seated jury of 12 consists of six men and six women, described as all white and predominantly older.
parkrecord.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Defense opening additional visual detail: Attorney Kathy Nester showed jurors an optical illusion drawing that, viewed one way, depicts a young woman in a fur coat and, viewed another way, depicts a witch. 'There's going to be times in this case where the state is going to discuss facts and certain witnesses and they're going to show you the witch. And I'm going to take those same facts and those same witnesses, and I'm going to show you a widow,' she told jurors.
ksl.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Additional Day 1 detail: Judge Mrazik placed an unusual pre-trial ban on media filming or photography in areas outside the courthouse normally considered public, ostensibly to protect witness and family privacy. The Salt Lake Tribune sent the judge a letter Friday Feb. 20 noting the 'unprecedented' restriction conflicts with general state guidance. After a discussion early Monday, the judge agreed to amend the order to allow recording and photography from the courthouse parking lot before 7 a.m. and after 6 p.m.
sltrib.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Additional Day 1 detail: Judge Mrazik ruled that Katie Richins-Benson could be designated as a family victim representative and remain in the courtroom throughout the trial, despite having already testified. The judge noted the defense never listed her as a witness and that she likely already knew all evidence in the case, so there was likely no prejudice. Two other Richins family members — identified only as DJ and Ronnie — were ordered excluded from the courtroom under the exclusionary rule and ordered not to be exposed to testimony or discuss the case.
eastidahonews.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Additional Day 1 jury composition detail: There are 12 seated jurors plus 4 alternates (16 total), all of whom will hear the evidence. Previously reported as '12 jurors' only.
kpcw.org
Feb 239:14 AM
Additional prosecution opening statement detail: Prosecutor Bloodworth stated that Eric Richins' estate was worth over $4 million when he died, and that Kouri believed she would inherit the full amount — because the prenuptial agreement would have prevented her from receiving it in a divorce, but if Eric died while they were married, she believed she would get it all. Bloodworth also stated Kouri owed more than $4.5 million to over 20 different lenders on the day Eric died.
eastidahonews.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Additional Day 1 procedural detail: Judge Mrazik swore jurors in with an incorrect oath before opening arguments; the jurors were re-sworn after a short recess following opening arguments. Defense attorney Kathy Nester indicated it would not pose an issue since opening arguments are not evidence.
kpcw.org
Feb 238:30 AM
Additional Day 1 defense opening framing: Defense attorney Kathy Nester framed Kouri as 'the target of vindictive in-laws who went to great lengths to implicate her in her husband's death, refusing to accept that Eric may have been treating chronic pain with illicit drugs that he may have obtained on a trip to Mexico.' Nester also told jurors: 'You're going to hear that Eric Richins' family simply could not accept that' Kouri did not know what happened to Eric.
courttv.com
Feb 238:30 AM
Additional Day 1 opening statement detail (Boston Herald/AP): Defense attorney Kathy Nester showed jurors a photo of the empty pill bottle sitting on Eric Richins' bedside table the night of his death, along with bags of THC gummies he was known to use regularly — as part of the defense theory that Eric had asked Kouri to procure opioids for him. Nester also argued Eric Richins had Lyme disease and was 'addicted to painkillers,' suggesting he may have overdosed. Additionally, Katie Richins-Benson testified on Day 1 that their mother was a drug and alcohol counselor who had instilled in the siblings from an early age the dangers of drug use — presented as rebuttal to the defense's narrative of Eric as a drug user. Previously captured Day 1 entries did not include these specific details.
bostonherald.com
Feb 21
Defense team issues pre-trial public statement: 'Kouri has waited nearly three years for this moment: the opportunity to have the facts of this case heard by a jury, free from the prosecution's narrative that has dominated headlines since her arrest. What the public has been told bears little resemblance to the truth.' The statement was attributed to attorneys Wendy Lewis, Kathy Nester, and Alex Ramos.
abcnews.com
Feb 11
Jury selection concluded in 2 days rather than the 5 days set aside by the court — with the majority of potential jurors passed by Judge Mrazik on the first day (February 10). Prospective jurors completed a 23-page questionnaire containing 99 questions in advance, covering media consumption, prior knowledge of the case, interactions with law enforcement, civic involvement, marital history, and other background information. Jurors not immediately selected were instructed not to discuss the case.
townlift.com
Feb 10
Jury selection begins in the Kouri Richins murder trial. Approximately 40 prospective jurors are called each day for voir dire in morning and afternoon sessions. Selection is expected to last up to six days, with eight primary jurors and four alternates to be chosen.
parkrecord.com
Feb 6
Judge Mrazik denies second defense motion for change of venue. Jury selection proceeds in Summit County.
kpcw.org
Feb 2
Pre-trial hearing: Judge Mrazik meets with prosecutors and defense to determine which potential jurors to summon. Original pool of 449 Summit County residents narrowed to approximately 250 to be notified. Defense again moves to change venue to Salt Lake County; Mrazik denies it the same day. Defense attorney Kathy Nester warns the trial may not finish by March 27 and raises the possibility of a mistrial if the timeline forces an early end — noting one financial expert alone could take three days given 70 exhibits, and that prosecutors identified more than 10 experts and 100 other witnesses while the defense has 35 of its own.
parkrecord.com
Feb 1
Pre-trial evidentiary hearing: Judge Mrazik rules on defense motions to exclude three prosecution expert witnesses. (1) Molly Amman, former FBI profiler specializing in behavioral threat assessment: Amman may NOT testify as to guilt or innocence or rebut case-specific assertions about why Richins did or did not commit the alleged acts; she IS qualified and her testimony on retrospective studies is sufficiently reliable for a blind expert opinion. (2) Matt Throckmorton, handwriting analyst: Motion to exclude DENIED — Throckmorton is qualified, his methods are reliable, he does not ignore uncontroverted facts, and he believes there is a strong probability that Eric's signature on at least one insurance document was forged by Kouri. (3) Dr. Sheri Vanino, domestic abuse expert: Motion to exclude CONDITIONALLY GRANTED — at that time, her testimony was not relevant; however, if prosecutors can lay a sufficient foundation to draw a nonspeculative inference that Eric knew Kouri tried to hurt him on Feb. 14, 2022 (Valentine's Day), her testimony may be allowed. Defense expert Dr. Bryanna Fox (University of Florida criminology professor) argued the 'pathway to violence' model used by Amman is not based on data analysis and cannot be applied after an offense has occurred.
newsnationnow.com
Jan 8
Judge Mrazik makes decisions on what evidence to allow into the trial at a pre-trial hearing.
deseret.com
Nov 17
Judge Mrazik denies Kouri Richins' request for yet another bail hearing.
deseret.com
Oct 16
Summit County prosecutors file formal written response to defense motion for exculpatory evidence disclosure, contending Crozier's assertion that he sold Lauber OxyContin (not fentanyl) does not constitute a material change in circumstance. Prosecution also files affidavits from Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth and Chief Investigator Travis Hopper and seeks a court order classifying those affidavits as private documents. Defense motion had argued the prosecution learned of Crozier's reversal in April 2025 and concealed it; prosecution states it possesses no exculpatory evidence from that meeting to disclose.
kutv.com
Oct 8
Prosecutors remove charges for drug distribution from Kouri Richins' case, narrowing the charges to be considered by the jury.
ksl.com
Jun 27
Deseret News reporting confirms the separate financial crimes case against Kouri Richins was filed on June 27, 2025 (previously recorded only as 'June 2025'). The case includes mortgage fraud counts moved over from her other case plus new charges.
deseret.com
Jun 13
A new jury trial date is set for Kouri Richins in February and March 2026.
ksl.com
Jun 6
The Utah Supreme Court declines to consider the defense's appeal of the decision to keep the jury trial in Summit County rather than Salt Lake County.
ksl.com
Apr 7
Judge Mrazik grants a defense request to delay the trial — previously scheduled to begin in April 2025 — after denying a request to move the trial to Salt Lake County.
ksl.com
Mar 28
Chief Prosecutor Brad Bloodworth and Chief Investigator Travis Hopper meet with Robert Crozier on March 28, 2025 to prepare him to testify. Crozier's signed affidavit states that in a subsequent April 2025 meeting at a Starbucks in downtown Salt Lake City (which Crozier believed included lead prosecutor Bloodworth and another man), he told prosecutors he was certain he had sold Carmen Lauber OxyContin 30 mg pills, not fentanyl — telling them multiple times when pressed. Prosecution acknowledged the coffee shop meeting but denied possessing exculpatory evidence arising from it.
kutv.com
Mar 17
Defense attorneys file first request to move Kouri Richins' trial to Salt Lake County, citing pre-trial publicity concerns in Summit County.
ksl.com
Feb 3
Court wrestles with questions on the jury questionnaire, with concerns raised about how questions are phrased in relation to jurors' recollection of media coverage of the case.
ksl.com
Jan 23
Officers testify about their investigation into Eric Richins' death at an evidentiary hearing as Richins' attorneys contest which evidence may be brought into trial.
ksl.com
Nov 12
At a bail reconsideration hearing, Judge Mrazik denies Kouri Richins' request for pre-trial release. Mrazik acknowledged Kouri's efforts to use her time in jail 'productively,' but ruled the charges are too serious given potential sentences that could result in her 'dying in prison' — creating incentive to harm herself, threaten witnesses, or flee. Mrazik also denied the defense's request to seat only 8 jurors; the jury count will stand at the standard number. Prosecutors had also filed to dismiss two counts of distribution of a controlled substance before the hearing.
townlift.com
Nov 7
Search of Richins home on November 7, 2024 — prompted by private investigator's tip — results in collection of a letter found at the foot of the bed (not found in any of the first seven searches) and a black Under Armour jacket containing tweezers and a small piece of plastic.
courttv.com
Aug 27
Following testimony at a preliminary hearing, Judge Mrazik orders Kouri Richins to stand trial.
ksl.com
May 24
Kouri Richins proclaims her innocence in voice recordings sent to national media. New defense attorneys — Kathryn Nester, Wendy Lewis, and Alexander Ramos — are subsequently appointed to represent her.
ksl.com
May 20
Judge Mrazik allows Kouri Richins' prior defense attorney Skye Lazaro to withdraw after her firm reported an ethical issue in representing her. The withdrawal led to a delayed preliminary hearing.
ksl.com
May 19
A newly unsealed search warrant reveals that Kouri Richins' mother, Lisa Darden, had a romantic partner who died of a 'suspicious overdose' in April 2006. An autopsy found the immediate cause of death was drug poisoning from an overdose of oxycodone. Lead detective Jeff O'Driscoll noted that Darden had been named the beneficiary of her partner's estate shortly before the death, and that the partner 'was not in a state of recovery from addiction at the time of her death,' making him rule out accidental overdose. O'Driscoll wrote: 'Based on Lisa Darden's proximity to her partner's suspicious overdose death, and her relationship with Kouri, it is possible she was involved in planning and orchestrating Eric's death.' Investigators also found conversations on Kouri's phone showing Darden expressed 'disdain' for Eric. Darden has not been charged with any crime. The search warrant for Darden's electronic devices was executed May 4, 2023.
kutv.com
May 13
Kouri Richins is found guilty in the assault case (class B misdemeanor) after not following plea-in-abeyance conditions within the agreed-upon time period. The assault charge stemmed from a June 2022 altercation at her home involving her sister-in-law.
ksl.com
Mar 25
Amended charges are filed adding attempted aggravated murder in connection with the Valentine's Day 2022 alleged poisoning — the allegation that Kouri attempted to kill Eric with a fentanyl-laced sandwich on February 14, 2022, weeks before his death.
ksl.com
Jan 4
Court documents reveal that Eric Richins' autopsy found medications prescribed to Kouri Richins — in addition to fentanyl — in his system. This publicly surfaces the quetiapine finding.
ksl.com
Dec 18
The jail phone call between Kouri Richins and her brother Ronnie Darden that was played for the jury on Day 10 (March 5, 2026) was specifically dated December 18, 2023 — clarifying a previously undated entry. In the call, Kouri says she went in 'for a consultation' and 'He did it first' (referencing Eric's earlier divorce attorney meetings). The jury was instructed they could not consider whether Kouri is or has ever been in jail.
kpcw.org
Nov 24
Investigators return to the Richins home on November 24, 2023. During this search, CSI technician Chelsea Gipson testified that a letter was found at the foot of the master bed. This is consistent with but distinct from the November 7, 2024 search (prompted by a private investigator's tip) on which the letter was formally collected into evidence. It appears the letter was photographed/observed in the November 2023 search but was not formally collected until November 2024.
abc4.com
Nov 3
Judge Mrazik denies three motions: (1) a defense motion to dismiss charges based on allegations that prosecutors breached professional conduct rules by publishing the 'Walk the Dog' jail letter; (2) a prosecution motion to restrict Kouri Richins' contact with her family; and (3) a defense motion to remove Summit County prosecutors from the case.
ksl.com
Oct 31
Investigators return to the Richins home on October 31, 2023, to collect additional electronics. (A separate October 24, 2023 visit also occurred for electronics.) CSI technician Chelsea Gipson confirmed these searches in her trial testimony.
abc4.com
Jun 12
Judge Mrazik denies Kouri Richins' first request for bail, ruling she will remain in jail as charges proceed through court.
ksl.com
May 18
Amended charges are filed against Kouri Richins, adding insurance fraud — accusing her of taking out approximately $2 million in life insurance policies against her husband without his knowledge.
ksl.com
May 8
Kouri Richins is arrested and charged with aggravated murder in the death of her husband. Search of the home conducted the same day.
biography.com
May 8
During the May 8, 2023 search of the Richins home (the day of Kouri's arrest), CSI technician Chelsea Gipson collected an orange notebook and a blue iPhone from the master bedroom, along with documents from a cabinet. Investigators also seized a cell phone from a cleaner who worked at the house.
abc4.com
May 4
Body camera video of a May 4, 2023 interview with Robert Crozier — conducted by Summit County Sheriff's Office detectives — was played in court. In the video, Crozier tells investigators he sold Carmen Lauber fentanyl pills and that 'she knew what she was buying.' This directly contradicts Crozier's Day 5 trial testimony that he sold oxycodone. Crozier testified at trial he did not remember this May 2023 interview even after being provided the transcript, as he was in Davis County Jail detoxing at the time.
kpcw.org
Apr 26
Carmen Lauber is arrested while on probation in drug court. Investigators discover a firearm under her bed. Two detectives visit her in jail the following day to discuss the Richins investigation, informing her that Eric Richins died of a fentanyl overdose.
parkrecord.com
Mar 5
Kouri Richins publishes children's book 'Are You With Me?' — illustrated picture book about a child coping with the loss of his father, dedicated to Eric. She promotes it on TV program 'Good Things Utah' on local ABC affiliate KTVX.
goodmorningamerica.com
Jun 9
Kouri Richins is charged with assault, a class B misdemeanor, in connection with an altercation at her home involving her sister-in-law.
ksl.com
Jun 6
On June 6, 2022, Kouri Richins texted Chelsea Barney that she was running to get the death certificate before Eric's sister could. Shortly after, she sent Barney a photo of the death certificate and wrote that 'there was a trace of fentanyl and his lungs were shot.' This text exchange was admitted as evidence during Chelsea Barney's Day 10 testimony. This is a distinct exchange from the previously captured 'June 2022' Kouri-Barney texts about family accusations of Kouri's involvement.
eastidahonews.com
Jun 6
Additional detail from Kouri's June 6, 2022 death certificate text to Chelsea Barney (confirmed via post-Day 10 Hidden Killers Substack summary of trial testimony): After sending Barney a photo of Eric's death certificate and noting 'there was a trace of fentanyl and his lungs were shot,' Kouri also wrote that she thought it was 'finally over' and that she was 'relieved.' Prosecutors presented this wording — 'relieved' rather than shattered — as evidence of Kouri's state of mind upon learning the cause of death was confirmed.
hiddenkillers.substack.com
Jun 1
In June 2022, Kouri Richins and Chelsea Barney exchanged text messages about accusations from Eric Richins' family members that Kouri was involved in his death. This text exchange was referenced during Barney's Day 10 testimony and covered in KSL's post-Day 10 reporting, providing additional context for the friction between Kouri and the Richins family in the months following Eric's death.
ksl.com
Jun 1
In a June 2022 text exchange between Chelsea Barney and Kouri Richins — admitted as evidence during Chelsea Barney's Day 10 testimony — Barney asked Kouri: 'What would you have put in the sandwich for him to break out in hives?' Kouri responded that she didn't make the sandwiches. Prosecutors presented Kouri's non-denial deflection as significant. This is a distinct June 2022 Kouri-Barney exchange from the previously captured family-accusations texts and the June 6 death certificate exchange.
hiddenkillers.substack.com
Apr 14
K9 drug search of the Richins home conducted on April 14, 2023 (one day after the April 13, 2023 search warrant execution). CSI Gipson testified the K9 dog's search of vehicles at the property was not confirmed. A detached garage with vehicles belonging to Eric Richins was reportedly not searched.
eastidahonews.com
Apr 13
Summit County Sheriff's Office executes search warrant at the Richins home. Collects phones, documents, and other items.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 20
Sixteen days after Eric's death, Kouri sends Grossman a link to a Caribbean resort with the message 'Are we there yet?'
foxnews.com
Mar 19
A recorded phone call from March 19, 2022 between Bryce Knudsen (Eric's close friend) and Kouri Richins — with Chelsea Barney also on the call — was played for the jury on Day 10. In the recording, Kouri tells Knudsen she understands his loyalty is 100% to the Richins family. She says she doesn't care about money, wants life insurance proceeds to go to her children's trust, but insists the house is hers. Kouri also mentions the money she took from Eric, saying he never 'gave me a f— chance' after that. She becomes emotional as she discusses the trust taking her house. Knudsen says he knew 'things were going to get bad' and chose to be neutral. The court limited what jurors could consider: only Kouri's statements can be used as evidence; the other speakers' words can only be considered for the effect they had on Kouri as a listener.
abc4.com
Mar 19
Additional detail from the March 19, 2022 recorded Kouri-Barney-Knudsen call (confirmed from EastIdaho Day 10 live blog): Kouri told Knudsen she had three million dollars in life insurance and said 'I don't care about money. It's not a big f---ing deal to me. I want it all to go to the trust for my kids.' She also said 'Bryce, I am not a bad mom!' In the same call, Kouri mentioned that Katie and Amy (Eric's sisters) were attacking her 'for no reason' and that she was being charged with assault. Bloodworth objected and the defense approached the bench at that moment. The call also showed Chelsea Barney telling Bryce Knudsen that Kouri 'isn't allowed to attend' the Celebration of Life because 'his family will make her look bad.' These additional quotes were not captured in earlier record entries for this call.
eastidahonews.com
Mar 9
Fourth drug purchase: Lauber deposits Kouri's $1,300 check and uses cash to make another drug purchase from Crozier. Puts pills in the closet of the Midway home.
parkrecord.com
Mar 6
Three days after Eric's death, Kouri texts Carmen Lauber: 'Still have your hookup?' Kouri writes a $1,300 check to Lauber with memo 'construction clean Midway.'
parkrecord.com
Mar 6
Clarification of the March 6, 2022 safe incident from post-Day 10 coverage: It was specifically Amy Richins — Eric's sister (separate from Katie Richins-Benson) — who ran into the garage and physically stopped the locksmith from opening Eric's safe. According to Ali Staking's Day 10 testimony, Kouri was unable to get into the safe because she didn't know the code and had not asked Eric's father for the code before calling the locksmith. Amy's physical intervention to stop the locksmith was a distinct action from the safe confrontation involving Katie Richins-Benson. Note: Previously the record captured only 'a sister-in-law' stopping the locksmith and a description of Amy as 'Eric's sister Amy' in general — this clarifies Amy's specific role.
ksl.com
Mar 57:30 AM
Dr. Pamela Ulmer performs autopsy on Eric Richins. Finds no natural cause of death. Sends toxicology samples to NMS Labs.
parkrecord.com
Mar 5
Additional detail from Day 10 testimony (Bowman-Carter, confirmed): Estate planning attorney Kristal Bowman-Carter testified that after Kouri was put on the phone with her on March 5, 2022 (the day after Eric's death) to be told about the trust, Kouri responded: 'She was livid. She was upset. And she said, "What is wrong with you people?" and handed the phone back to the officer.' Defense disputed that this was when Kouri first learned about the trust. Note: This event date is already in the timeline but this specific quote was not previously captured.
kpcw.org
Mar 43:06 AM
Prosecutors say Kouri first accessed her phone at 3:06 a.m. — approximately 15 minutes before calling 911.
foxnews.com
Mar 43:21 AM
Kouri calls 911 reporting her husband was not breathing and was cold to the touch. She tells the dispatcher she doesn't know CPR but is willing to try.
kpcw.org
Mar 43:58 AM
Eric Richins pronounced dead at the scene at 3:58 a.m. by paramedics. He was found at the foot of the bed, lying very straight. EMT Offret noted his body was 'cold to the touch' and his heart was flatlined.
parkrecord.com
Mar 44:00 AM
Kouri's mother, Lisa Darden, was among the first family members to arrive at the Richins home after the 911 call on March 4, 2022. Darden arrived before Katie Richins-Benson and other family. Body cam footage showed her at the scene. She also told Kouri that her sons had already been informed of their father's death by a police officer.
kpcw.org
Mar 39:00 PM
Evening of March 3: Kouri and Eric celebrate closing on a Midway mansion property deal with drinks. Kouri makes Eric a Moscow mule in the kitchen and brings it to their bedroom. Kouri texts Grossman, who sent her an image of two people kissing; she replies 'Love you' before making the drink. Both sides agree drinks were consumed around 9 p.m.
nbcnews.com
Mar 39:30 PM
Kouri leaves the master bedroom around 9:30 p.m. to sleep with a son who was having night terrors.
parkrecord.com
Mar 310:00 PM
Eric Richins speaks by phone with a friend; sounded fine according to defense.
ksl.com
Feb 28
Third drug purchase (approximate date, late February 2022): Kouri asks Lauber for 'the Michael Jackson stuff' — propofol. Lauber Googles it, then contacts Crozier again and obtains a baggie of light blue pills. Lauber picks up $1,000 from Midway home. Kouri picks up pills from Lauber's home in Heber City.
parkrecord.com
Feb 15
The day after Valentine's Day, Kouri texts her alleged lover: 'If he could just go away ... life would be so perfect.'
apnews.com
Feb 14
Valentine's Day: Eric Richins allegedly falls ill after eating one bite of a sandwich Kouri brought him. He broke out in hives, blacked out, injected himself with his son's EpiPen, took Benadryl, and later told a friend 'I think my wife tried to poison me.' Prosecutors allege this was a failed poisoning attempt. Defense characterizes it as an allergic reaction.
apnews.com
Feb 14
Additional detail on the Valentine's Day alleged poisoning: Prosecutors allege Kouri left the fentanyl-laced sandwich in Eric's truck along with a Valentine's Day note, framing it as a gift. Eric fell ill after eating one bite.
newsnationnow.com
Feb 14
Additional Valentine's Day detail established via Day 10 testimony: Gabriel Morin, owner of Mirror Lake Diner in Kamas, testified that on February 14, 2022, a phone order was placed under the name 'Corey' at 8:55 a.m. and picked up at 9:07 a.m. The order included a Greek omelet and a bagel sandwich. Prosecutors allege this is the breakfast Kouri purchased and poisoned before placing it in Eric's truck. Separately, Eric's friend Joshua Kaze testified that he spoke with Eric by phone on Valentine's Day 2022, and that Eric seemed uncharacteristically 'somber' and 'sincere' during the call — consistent with the prosecution's theory that Eric had just been made ill. Additionally, Ali (Allie) Staking — Kouri's childhood best friend — testified that after Valentine's Day 2022 and before Eric's death, the group of friends discussed Eric having an allergic reaction and needing an EpiPen after eating something Kouri gave him; friends were joking, saying 'Don't eat what Kouri gives you,' and Eric was joking along and did not seem upset.
abc4.com
Feb 11
Second drug purchase: Lauber picks up $1,000 cash from Kouri's Midway property and meets Robert Crozier at a Maverik gas station in Draper, Utah. Receives a clear baggie of approximately 15-20 light green pills containing fentanyl. Lauber buries pills in the fire pit at the Midway home.
parkrecord.com
Feb 5
Carmen Lauber sends Facebook Messenger message to a contact to arrange a second drug purchase after Kouri requested 'something stronger.'
eastidahonews.com
Feb 4
A life insurance policy for Eric Richins goes into effect on February 4, 2022. Prosecutors allege Kouri Richins signed the application for this policy in late January 2022 — weeks before Eric's death.
ksl.com
Feb 1
Early February: Carmen Lauber makes the first drug purchase for Kouri Richins — an envelope of opiate pain pills from co-worker Susan Kohler for approximately $600. Pills are delivered to Kouri in Lauber's driveway.
parkrecord.com
Jan 22
Kouri Richins calls handyman Hayden Jeffs while he is with Anna Isbell, asking if he 'had something for a client.' Jeffs reportedly told Kouri he did not. Prosecutors allege this shows Kouri sought fentanyl and propofol from multiple sources before Eric's death. Jeffs later told investigators Kouri asked him for fentanyl and propofol; he died in a motorcycle accident in September 2024 before trial.
eastidahonews.com
Jan 22
Additional detail from Anna Isbell's Day 5 testimony: When Kouri called Hayden Jeffs (with Isbell present), Isbell overheard Kouri ask for the 'Michael Jackson drug' — which Isbell thought was a muscle relaxer. Isbell testified she did NOT hear Richins ask about fentanyl specifically during that call.
ksl.com
Jan 1
In January 2022, Kouri Richins secretly logged into Eric's life insurance account and changed the beneficiary from his business partner Cody Wright to herself. Eric was alerted to the change and changed it back to Wright's name. This detail was revealed in the probate case petition and is consistent with the broader insurance fraud narrative presented at trial.
sltrib.com
Jan 1
When Molly Crosswhite purchased the Midway home from Kouri Richins in January 2022, she turned the key over to contractors (not simply left it unattended outside). Tenants did not move in until end of March 2022. This clarifies earlier reporting that described only 'a key left outside the property.'
kpcw.org
Dec 17
On December 17, 2021, Becky Lloyd and Kouri Richins were wrapping gifts together as part of a C&E Stone Masonry secret Santa project. Kouri told Lloyd that she and Eric had fought that day — he had booked a family sleigh ride that conflicted with a work gala she wanted to attend. Kouri told Lloyd she felt 'trapped,' that there was no easy way forward out of the marriage, that she was worried about losing her children, and that Eric's family would turn the community against her. Lloyd testified: 'Kouri said in many ways, it would be better if Eric was dead.' Lloyd described the conversation as serious and heartfelt — 'We weren't joking.' This testimony was elicited on Day 10 (March 5, 2026). On cross-examination, defense attorney Nester played an audio recording of Lloyd speaking with an investigator in which Lloyd said she could not say for certain Kouri had made the comment. Lloyd maintained on the stand that she remembered it later because it was 'memorable,' and that she was '90% sure she said the comment about him being better dead.' Nester also established that Kouri had helped Lloyd get her job at C&E Stone Masonry, and that after Eric died, Kouri asked Lloyd to remove Kouri from the C&E payroll.
abc4.com
Oct 14
A text exchange dated October 14, 2020 was presented to the jury during Chelsea Barney's Day 10 testimony. In the exchange, Kouri told Barney that the HELOC loan she took out was $250,000 and that the disagreement with Eric over it was 'getting out of hand.' In the same exchange, Kouri also wrote to Barney: 'If I die, Eric did it.' This confirms the date of the 'If I die, Eric did it' message previously in evidence without a date.
abc4.com
Oct 1
Eric Richins meets with a divorce attorney and an estate planner, one month after discovering Kouri had made major financial decisions without his knowledge, including having a negative bank account, owing $1.8 million+ to lenders, and being sued by a creditor. Without Kouri's knowledge, he changed his will, formed a living trust naming his sister Katie as trustee, transferred business interest to the trust, and changed life insurance beneficiary to his business partner.
apnews.com
Oct 1
Additional detail from Chelsea Barney's Day 10 testimony (confirmed via TownLift/EastIdaho coverage): Barney testified that she and a group of friends, including Kouri Richins, were on a vacation in Sun Valley, Idaho in October 2020 when she first learned Kouri had obtained a $250,000 home equity line of credit on the family home. In a conversation recounted by Barney, Kouri said Eric was angry and had turned off her credit cards after discovering the HELOC. Kouri asked her friends to cover the costs of the trip and said she would reimburse them. Kouri also told Barney at that time she had to be 'top notch careful' and asked her to let attorneys handle the money matters.
eastidahonews.com
Feb 1
Allison Wright (wife of Eric's business partner Cody Wright) testified she had a conversation with Kouri Richins while on vacation in Costa Rica in February 2019, in which Kouri said she felt 'trapped' in the marriage — she was frustrated but knew she would not receive money under the prenuptial agreement if she divorced Eric. Wright also noted Kouri discussed her drive to become financially independent as she pursued a master's degree and real estate license. In cross-examination, defense attorney Nester pressed Wright about whether Eric had intimate feelings for a female coworker around 2019, which Wright acknowledged.
ksl.com
Jan 1
Kouri allegedly used a power of attorney to obtain a $250,000 home equity line of credit on a home Eric owned before their marriage, without his knowledge, and invested it in her real estate business. (Part of a separate financial crimes case.)
newsnationnow.com
Jan 1
Kouri Richins began purchasing life insurance policies on Eric Richins without his knowledge. Policies were purchased between approximately 2015 and 2017, totaling nearly $2 million in benefits.
nbcnews.com
Key People · 79 Identified
KR
Kouri Richins
SuspectER
Eric Richins
VictimCL
Carmen Lauber
WitnessRG
Robert Josh Grossman
WitnessRC
Robert Crozier
WitnessSK
Susan Kohler
WitnessKR
Katie Richins-Benson
FamilyGR
Gene (Eugene) Richins
FamilyCB
Clint Benson
FamilyBB
Brad Bloodworth
Law EnforcementKN
Kathryn (Kathy) Nester
Law EnforcementWL
Wendy Lewis
Law EnforcementAR
Alexander Ramos
Law EnforcementJM
Judge Richard Mrazik
Law EnforcementDU
Dr. Pamela Sue Ulmer
WitnessDP
Dr. Brianna Peterson
WitnessCG
Chelsea Gipson
Law EnforcementDR
Detective Frank Root
Law EnforcementDN
Deputy Vincent Nguyen
Law EnforcementMO
Margaret (Maggie) Offret
WitnessAI
Anna Isbell
WitnessHJ
Hayden Jeffs
WitnessNB
Nick Bonsavage
WitnessCE
Cheney Eng-Tow
WitnessDM
Detective Eric Mainord
Law EnforcementSH
Sgt. Eric Haskell
WitnessMG
Marcos Garaycochea
WitnessSC
Sgt. Andrew Crnich
WitnessDP
Deputy David Pimentel
WitnessCL
Camrynn Larson
WitnessNC
Nicole Cummings
WitnessCW
Cody Wright
WitnessLD
Lisa Darden
WitnessMA
Molly Amman
WitnessDF
Dr. Bryanna Fox
WitnessMT
Matt Throckmorton
WitnessDV
Dr. Sheri Vanino
WitnessDO
Detective Jeff O'Driscoll
Law EnforcementTH
Travis Hopper
Law EnforcementRD
Ronald Darden
WitnessDK
Doreen Kouri
WitnessDW
Detective Whistler
Law EnforcementCK
Chris Kotrodimos
WitnessDC
Dr. Erik Christensen
WitnessMC
Molly Crosswhite
WitnessAW
Allison Wright
WitnessSL
Skye Lazaro
Law EnforcementJS
Jen Shah
WitnessBK
Brooke Karrington
WitnessLR
Lashawnda Rodgers
WitnessBF
Brian Freckleton
WitnessAC
Anne Coates
WitnessCM
Christina Miller
WitnessKB
Kristal Bowman-Carter
WitnessDM
Detective Maynard
Law EnforcementMB
Marie Bramwell
WitnessBL
Becky Lloyd
WitnessGM
Gabriel Morin
WitnessJK
Joshua Kaze
WitnessCB
Chelsea Barney
WitnessAS
Ali (Allie) Staking
WitnessBK
Bryce Knudsen
WitnessCB
Chris Bertram
WitnessAR
Amy Richins
FamilyTG
Todd Gabler
WitnessDW
Detective Jayme Woody
Law EnforcementDN
David Norris
WitnessSA
Selena Armithee
WitnessL2
Laura (Juror No. 2)
WitnessRH
Ron Hershon
Law EnforcementLF
Laura (Juror No. 2 / Foreperson)
WitnessJC
Jean Casarez
WitnessC3
Christie (Juror No. 3)
WitnessL2
Laura (Foreperson / Juror No. 2)
WitnessC#
Christie (Juror #3)
WitnessLF
Laura (Juror #2, Foreperson)
WitnessLF
Laura (Juror #2 / Foreperson)
WitnessL(
Laura (juror)
WitnessSH
Steve Hershon
WitnessVictim Information
Confirmed Facts
• Eric Richins, 39, died March 4, 2022, at the couple's home in Francis/Kamas area, Utah
• Cause of death: fentanyl intoxication — 15 ng/mL (5x lethal dose); fentanyl ORALLY INGESTED per ME
• Acetylfentanyl present — consistent with illicit (not pharmaceutical) fentanyl
• No hydrocodone or other opioids found in Eric's toxicology; manner of death officially 'undetermined'
• Eric's estate was worth over $4 million when he died (prosecution opening)
• Kouri called 911 at 3:21 a.m. on March 4, 2022; Eric found at foot of bed, cold to the touch
• GRANULAR PHONE DATA: Kouri's phone locked at 9:32 p.m. March 3; moved 35 feet around 10:30 p.m.; at 3:06 a.m. phone unlocked; 14 sec later speaker activated; 3:08 a.m. phone moved 243 feet; 3:21 a.m. 911 call
• Kouri published children's book 'Are You With Me?' March 2023 — WRITTEN BY GHOSTWRITER 'Book Writing Lane'; Kouri paid $2,500
• Kouri arrested May 8, 2023; held without bail since; three prior bail requests denied
• Trial began February 23, 2026 in Park City, Utah; CONCLUDED March 16, 2026 (early — was scheduled through March 27)
• FINAL JURY: 8 deliberating jurors (6 men, 2 women); all white; predominantly older
• FORENSIC ACCOUNTING: By March 2022, Kouri owed ~$7.5M in total debt; paid ~$80K/month to lenders; negative $1.6M net worth; received ~$1.4M in insurance proceeds; had ~$800 left by September 2022
• Prosecution displayed text from Kouri to Barney: 'If I die, Eric did it' — DATED October 14, 2020
• Prosecution displayed text from Kouri to Barney (March 2022): 'They will not take from me what is mine'
• June 6, 2022: Kouri texted Barney she was racing to get the death certificate; ALSO wrote 'finally over' and was 'RELIEVED'
• CODY WRIGHT CONFIRMED: Eric went to Mexico in FEBRUARY 2022 for hunting
• DET. WOODY CONFIRMED: Amy Richins told Woody Eric said 'Kouri was going to kill him'
• THROCKMORTON CONCLUDED: 'Simulated forgery' on questioned insurance document
• WALK THE DOG LETTER: Read aloud in court by O'Driscoll; instructs Ronnie to blame Eric for Mexico fentanyl; closes 'Bring me home'
• GHOSTWRITER CONFIRMED: 'Book Writing Lane' wrote 'Are You With Me?'; Kouri paid $2,500
• ANONYMOUS BOOK PACKAGE: Sent to SCSO by Lisa Darden — confirmed via Amazon subpoena
• KOURI TEXTED BROTHER (May 24, 2023): Did Eric ever talk about suicide? Brother: NO
• O'DRISCOLL CONFIRMED: 'Boatload of fentanyl in his stomach'; no fentanyl on any tested home item
• PROSECUTION RESTED (Day 14): 42 individual witnesses
• DEFENSE RESTED (Day 14): 0 witnesses called in defense case-in-chief
• KOURI RICHINS FORMALLY WAIVED right to testify (first time she addressed court during entire trial)
• JURY INSTRUCTION CONFERENCE (March 13): Motive instruction REMOVED; DV/cohabitation REMOVED; Lauber/Crozier = 'INFORMANT' instruction; Hydrocodone bottle 'lost evidence' instruction DENIED
🆕 FOURTH MISTRIAL MOTION (Day 15, March 16): DENIED — 'black widow' comment/demeanor
🆕 CLOSING ARGUMENT — PROSECUTION NEW THEORY: Both Moscow mule AND lemon drop shot may have been delivery vehicles for fentanyl
🆕 VERDICT REACHED: March 16, 2026 after ~3 hours of deliberation
🆕 VERDICT: GUILTY ON ALL 5 COUNTS
• Count 1 — Aggravated Murder: GUILTY
• Count 2 — Attempted Aggravated Murder: GUILTY
• Counts 3 & 4 — Insurance Fraud: GUILTY
• Count 5 — Forgery: GUILTY
🆕 VERDICT FORM: Jurors unanimously agreed FINANCIAL BENEFIT was aggravating circumstance on both homicide counts
🆕 JUROR FOREPERSON: 'There was never a not guilty check with anything, with any element, nothing'
🆕 SENTENCING: May 13, 2026 at 9:30 a.m. (Eric's 44th birthday)
🆕 FACES: 25 years to life in prison (aggravated murder alone)
🆕 DEATH PENALTY: Not sought — decision made in consultation with Eric's father and sisters
🆕 CIVIL: Family pursuing 'slayer statute' claims
🆕 SEPARATE CASE: 26-count financial crimes case — status unclear
🆕 APPEALS: Defense expected to begin after sentencing; likely ~1 year to prepare
Key People
VICTIM: Eric Richins, 39 — stone mason (C&E Stone Masonry), father of 3 sons (Carter, Ashton, Weston); estate worth $4M+ at death; chronic back/knee pain, Lyme disease; traveled to Mexico in FEBRUARY 2022 for hunting; GOOGLE SEARCHED distance from Utah to Sonora, Mexico shortly before death; prescribed hydrocodone, used THC/alcohol, took testosterone; treated for SEASONAL ALLERGIES (trees, grass) — EpiPens in fridge; consulted divorce attorney Oct. 2020; set up living trust; told sister Amy 'Kouri was going to kill him'; Valentine's Day 2022: called both Joshua Kaze AND Cody Wright — both described Eric as distressed/fearful; had lunch with Cody at Mirror Lake Cafe on March 3, 2022; Eric's phone cloned from iCloud backup by Gabler
DEFENDANT: Kouri Richins, 35 — realtor, children's book author (ghostwritten by 'Book Writing Lane' for $2,500); convicted of aggravated murder and 4 other felony counts on March 16, 2026; faces 25 years to life; sentencing May 13, 2026; by March 2022 owed ~$7.5M; received ~$1.4M in insurance proceeds; had ~$800 by September 2022; jailhouse message 'thought she would be set for life if he died'; formally waived right to testify (Day 14); defense rested without calling any witnesses; was VISIBLY TREMBLING at verdict reading; stared at floor and took deep breaths as verdict was read
STAR WITNESS: Carmen Lauber — housekeeper for Kouri's aunt DOREEN KOURI; testifying under immunity; RECALLED Day 13; THREE drug court violations (firearm, alcohol, curfew); in interview clip said Eric 'didn't deserve that'
ALLEGED BOYFRIEND: Robert Josh Grossman — testified Day 9; received ~$25K of Kouri's insurance proceeds; confirmed 'love triangle' texts; appeared 'devastated' per juror Christie
DRUG DEALER (alleged): Robert Crozier — Day 5: sold oxycodone; BUT May 4, 2023 video: told investigators he sold FENTANYL
DECEASED HANDYMAN: Hayden Jeffs — told investigators Kouri asked him for fentanyl; died Sept. 2024
JEFFS' GIRLFRIEND: Anna Isbell — heard 'Michael Jackson drug' on Jan. 22, 2022
ERIC'S BUSINESS PARTNER: Cody Wright — testified Day 11; RELEASED
ERIC'S SISTER (TRUSTEE): Katie Richins-Benson — testified Day 1; designated family victim representative
ERIC'S SISTER (ASSAULT VICTIM): Amy Richins — told Det. Woody on March 4, 2022 Eric said 'Kouri was going to kill him'; 🆕 spoke outside courthouse after verdict: 'Honestly I feel like we're all in shock. It's been a long time coming. Just very happy that we got justice for my brother.'
LEAD DETECTIVE: Jeff O'Driscoll (SCSO) — COMPLETED testimony Day 14; 42 total prosecution witnesses
ORIGINAL LEAD DETECTIVE: Jayme Woody (SCSO) — testified Day 11; investigation 'all but stalled' by fall 2022
KOURI'S MOTHER: Lisa Darden — CONFIRMED via Amazon subpoena as sender of anonymous book package to SCSO; at scene March 4, 2022; investigated re: 2006 suspicious overdose; NOT charged; 🆕 defense had filed SEALED motions requesting court-appointed counsel for Darden prior to trial; those motions and prosecution's objections remain sealed
KOURI'S BROTHER: Ronald Darden — named in 'Walk the Dog!!' letter; jail call (Dec. 18, 2023) played Day 10
PRIVATE INVESTIGATOR (Richins family): Todd Gabler — testified Day 11; 936.3 hours; cloned Eric's iPhone; found 'my princess'/'babycakes' letter; removed safe without law enforcement
🆕 JUROR FOREPERSON 'LAURA' (Juror No. 2) — gave ABC GMA exclusive post-verdict interview; said 'there was never a not guilty check with anything'; cellphone data 'blew her out of the water'; deliberations took ~3 hours
🆕 JUROR No. 3 'CHRISTIE' — gave EastIdahoNews exclusive post-verdict interview; 'utter shock' at defense resting without witnesses; most powerful testimony: Sgt. Haskell (undercover narcotics officer)
🆕 ALI STAKING — testified at trial; gave 20/20 exclusive post-verdict interview; described Eric as 'dedicated dad' and 'goofy cowboy dude who loved to dance'
FORENSIC ACCOUNTANT: Brooke Karrington — testified Day 8; RELEASED
DIGITAL FORENSICS EXPERT: Chris Kotrodimos — testified Days 7 and 12
HANDWRITING EXPERT: Matt Throckmorton — testified Day 11; 'simulated forgery' conclusion
FBI PROFILER: Molly Amman (prosecution) — partially admitted; NEVER TESTIFIED
DOMESTIC ABUSE EXPERT: Dr. Sheri Vanino (prosecution) — conditionally excluded; NEVER ADMITTED
UNDERCOVER OFFICER: Sgt. Eric Haskell (SLCPD) — testified Day 5; MOST POWERFUL TESTIMONY per Juror Christie
PROSECUTOR: Brad Bloodworth (Chief), Lindsay Chervenak, Fred Burmester
DEFENSE: Kathryn Nester (lead), Wendy Lewis, Alexander Ramos
JUDGE: Richard Mrazik
Key Questions
NOTE: These involve interpretation (AI analysis).
🆕 POST-CONVICTION QUESTIONS:
1. SENTENCING (May 13, 2026): Will Kouri receive life without parole or a sentence with the possibility of parole? How will Judge Mrazik weigh the aggravating factors (financial benefit, premeditation, multiple victims) against any mitigating factors?
2. WILL KOURI SPEAK AT SENTENCING? Analysts say unlikely, but she has maintained her innocence throughout.
3. APPEALS: What are the strongest grounds for appeal? The venue argument (denied change of venue motions) has been flagged — how strong is it? Could the four mistrial motions, evidentiary rulings, or the 'high-stakes poker' Norris decision become appellate arguments?
4. SEPARATE FINANCIAL CRIMES CASE (26 counts): Will prosecutors pursue a second trial? Is there appetite in Summit County for the additional cost given the conviction?
5. LISA DARDEN: Will the sealed defense motions regarding court-appointed counsel ever become public? Will Darden face any investigation or charges in connection with the 2006 suspicious overdose or the Richins case?
6. CIVIL 'SLAYER STATUTE' CASE: How will this litigation proceed given Kouri has no assets? Can the family recover anything meaningful?
7. ERIC'S SONS (Carter, Ashton, Weston): What is the custody/guardianship arrangement? Will they ever see their mother again?
8. JUROR INSIGHTS: Juror foreperson said cellphone data was pivotal — does this suggest the Walk the Dog letter and Lauber's testimony alone might not have been sufficient for conviction?
9. LAUBER IMMUNITY: What happens to Carmen Lauber's immunity deal now that the trial has concluded with a conviction? Will she face any remaining legal consequences?
10. CROZIER CONTRADICTION: Crozier testified he sold oxycodone at trial but told investigators in 2023 he sold fentanyl. Will any perjury charges follow?
11. GHOSTWRITER MANUSCRIPT: Kouri discussed a larger 65-page (or 130-250 page) ghostwritten manuscript with her brother. Was the 'Walk the Dog' letter actually part of a fictional story? This question — never resolved at trial — may become relevant on appeal.
12. GROSSMAN: Now that Kouri is convicted, does he have any ongoing legal or civil exposure related to his role in the relationship or any evidence he may have withheld or destroyed (two broken iPhones)?
13. TODD GABLER: Was his removal of the safe without law enforcement present, and possible movement of the 'my princess' letter, ever investigated further? Could it affect any appeal?
14. What is the status of the property litigation between Kouri's estate and Eric's family? Does the criminal conviction resolve any civil property disputes under the slayer statute?
15. CHILDREN'S BOOK: Will 'Are You With Me?' remain available for purchase? The book was described as removed from Amazon as of trial. What legal or civil implications follow?
Gallery · 68 Images
Latest Updates · 6 Reports
Mar 18, 2026
Kouri Richins Juror Reveals: 'Never a Not Guilty' on Any Count
1,160 words · 40 views
Mar 17, 2026
Kouri Richins: What Happens Next After Guilty Verdict
1,169 words · 54 views
Mar 16, 2026
Kouri Richins Found Guilty on All Counts in Husband's Fentanyl Murder
1,289 words · 1,610 views
Mar 12, 2026
Kouri Richins Trial: Defense Rests Without Calling a Single Witness
1,171 words · 86 views
Mar 9, 2026
Kouri Richins Trial Day 11: 911 Call Played, Detectives and PI Testify
1,304 words · 122 views
Mar 2, 2026
Kouri Richins Trial Day 7: Mistrial Denied, Damning Phone Data Presented
1,161 words · 157 views
Media Coverage · 50 Sources
www.msn.com
Juror speaks after delivering guilty verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
www.detpress.com
JUST DAYS AFTER UTAH MOM AND AUTHOR KOURI RICHINS IS FOUND GUILTY OF FATALLY POISONING HER HUSBAND, ‘IMPACT X NIGHTLINE’ AND ‘20/20’ REPORT ON THE DEADLY PLOT THAT LED TO HER CONVICTION
www.msn.com
Juror speaks after delivering guilty verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
www.msn.com
Juror speaks after delivering guilty verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
www.eastidahonews.com
COURTROOM INSIDER | Juror #3 Christie breaks her silence about the Kouri Richins murder trial
www.primetimer.com
Where is Kouri Richins now? Details explored ahead of 20/20 on ABC
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.eastidahonews.com
Juror describes pivotal moments that led to guilty verdict in Kouri Richins trial
abcnews.com
Friend speaks out after Kouri Richins found guilty of fatally poisoning husband with fentanyl: Exclusive
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.dailymail.co.uk
Grief author mom Kouri Richins found guilty of murdering husband by poisoning his Moscow Mule
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.foxnews.com
Juror says Kouri Richins sympathy flipped after trial exposed kids’ book author’s plot to kill husband: report
kmyu.tv
Family of Eric Richins reacts with relief after verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
southernillinoisnow.com
‘Family torn apart’: Kouri Richins juror describes emotional murder deliberations ahead of guilty verdict
nypost.com
Here’s what happens next for Kouri Richins, the black widow children’s book author
www.yahoo.com
Juror speaks after delivering guilty verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
www.npr.org
A mom wrote a kids' book on grief. She was just convicted of her husband's murder
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
abcnews.com
'Family torn apart': Kouri Richins juror describes emotional murder deliberations ahead of guilty verdict
www.whmi.com
WHMI 93.5 FM Radio Station — Livingston County Michigan
www.cnn.com
Prosecutors in Kouri Richins’ murder trial couldn’t prove how she poisoned her husband. They didn’t need to
www.wsjm.com
'Family torn apart': Kouri Richins juror describes emotional murder deliberations ahead of guilty verdict
www.abc4.com
Juror speaks after delivering guilty verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.ibtimes.co.uk
Children's Book Author Kouri Richins Convicted in Husband's Murder — What the Jury Heard
www.today.com
Utah Jury Finds Kouri Richins Guilty in Husband’s Murder
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.usatoday.com
Utah 'black widow' Kouri Richins found guilty of fatally poisoning husband
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
m.economictimes.com
Children’s book author who wrote about grief, now convicted of murder: Kouri Richins case ends in guilty v
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.bbc.com
Utah bereavement author Kouri Richins found guilty of fatally poisoning husband
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.goodmorningamerica.com
Verdict reached in Kouri Richins murder trial
kjzz.com
Family of Eric Richins reacts with relief after verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.msn.com
Grief author murder trial: Watch the verdict!
www.newsnationnow.com
Here’s what happens next for convicted murderer Kouri Richins
usaherald.com
Kouri Richins Convicted of Poisoning Husband in Chilling Utah Murder Case
www.scrippsnews.com
Kouri Richins found guilty on all counts in husband's murder
nationaltoday.com
Jury reaches verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
ksltv.com
Video: COURT: Verdict read in Kouri Richin’s jury trial
kjzz.com
Family of Eric Richins reacts with relief after verdict in Kouri Richins murder trial
freedomforallamericans.org
Court Delivers Guilty Verdict for Kouri Richins in Husband’s Murder by Poisoning